Draft Protocol for Cabinet Reports
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Author/Lead Officer of Report: Andrew Marwood Senior Engineer - Strategic Traffic and Infrastructure, City Growth Department Tel: 0114 2736170 Report of: Executive Director, Place Report to: Executive Member for Climate Change, Environment and Transport Date of Decision: 24th June 2021 Subject: Grey to Green Phase 2 - Angel Street - Proposed Scheme and Associated Traffic Regulation Orders. Is this a Key Decision? If Yes, reason Key Decision:- Yes x No - Expenditure and/or savings over £500,000 x - Affects 2 or more Wards Which Executive Member Portfolio does this relate to? Climate Change, Environment and Transport Which Scrutiny and Policy Development Committee does this relate to? Overview and Scrutiny Management Committee Has an Equality Impact Assessment (EIA) been undertaken? Yes x No If YES, what EIA reference number has it been given? 258 Does the report contain confidential or exempt information? Yes No x If YES, give details as to whether the exemption applies to the full report / part of the report and/or appendices and complete below: - Purpose of Report: To seek approval for the Angel Street scheme as shown in appendix ‘A’ and to proceed with the implementation of the traffic regulation measures (included those in the associated Traffic Regulation Order (TRO)) shown in appendix ‘B’, subject to authorisation of the project through the capital gateway process. The report sets out the background to the scheme, consultation comments and officer recommendations. Form 2 – Executive Report June 2021 Recommendations: That the scheme is approved as shown in Appendix ‘A’. That the associated traffic regulation measures (including those in the associated TRO) as shown in Appendix ‘B’ to facilitate the Angel Street project are implemented, subject to authorisation of the project through the capital gateway process. Background Papers: Appendix ‘A’ – Scheme Concept Design Appendix ‘B’ – Traffic Regulation Order Changes Plan Appendix ‘C’ – Consultation Letter Appendix ‘D’ – Further Analysis of the Consultation Results Lead Officer to complete:- 1 I have consulted the relevant departments Finance: Damian Watkinson in respect of any relevant implications indicated on the Statutory and Council Policy Checklist, and comments have Legal: Richard Cannon been incorporated / additional forms completed / EIA completed, where Equalities: Annemarie Johnston required. Legal, financial/commercial and equalities implications must be included within the report and the name of the officer consulted must be included above. 2 EMT member who approved Edward Highfield submission: 3 Executive Member consulted: Cllr Douglas Johnson 4 I confirm that all necessary approval has been obtained in respect of the implications indicated on the Statutory and Council Policy Checklist and that the report has been approved for submission to the Decision Maker by the EMT member indicated at 2. In addition, any additional forms have been completed and signed off as required at 1. Lead Officer Name: Job Title: Andrew Marwood Senior Engineer - Strategic Traffic and Infrastructure, City Growth Department Date: 22/06/2021 Page 2 of 21 1.0 PROPOSAL 1.1 The multi-functional Grey to Green Phase 2 scheme around Castlegate, Exchange St/ Blonk St and Snig Hill was completed in September 2020. It links a pedestrianised Castlegate to the ‘hidden jewel’ of Victoria Quays and has transformed the almost redundant former Inner Ring Road into a green corridor with sustainable drainage, floral meadows, segregated cycle lanes and public art. 1.2 As part of the completed improvements to Snig Hill, an additional segregated cycle lane has been provided, which has enhanced the approach to Angel St. Angel St has a number of important buildings, such as Castle House (an important Listed Building in the area which now houses popular food hall Kommune and tech workspace Kollider), the National Video Games Museum and other shops, hotels, offices and residential areas leading to Commercial St, Fitzalan Square and High St. 1.3 Additional funding has now been secured from the European Regional Development Fund, Sheffield City Council and Yorkshire Water to extend the Grey to Green 2 improvements to Angel St, which remains a key link of the gateway into the City Centre. 1.4 The proposals shown as a concept design in appendix ‘A’ include: High quality new shrub and perennial flower planting as well as retention of existing trees. Improvements to the public open space outside Castle House, including additional seating, the replacement of the existing planted area with a new one at the junction of Angel St and Castle St, a new reconstructed wall and wider path. Better pedestrian connectivity between ‘Grey to Green’ phase one (West Bar), Snig Hill and the Future High Streets scheme proposed for High Street. Enhanced public spaces with perennial meadow planting, tree planting, quality materials and public art. Providing areas where water run-off can be collected and gradually released, resulting in reduced pressure on already overburdened waterways and therefore reducing the risk of future flooding. Segregated two-way cycle lane to connect Angel St to other riverside / local and national cycle routes with at least a 50mm level difference to the footway as agreed with the Access Liaison Group. Reduction of road width to a single carriageway to allow for the extended cycle lane and planting. Page 3 of 21 Wide and repaved footpaths in the same quality paving as Snig Hill. New Street furniture (cycle stands and bins). Two ‘bug hotels’ located within the planting (similar to those on Exchange Place). 1.5 Some of the road layout changes and traffic regulation measures that the scheme proposes can only be introduced following the making and implementation of a TRO. The key elements of the TRO plan for Angel Street as seen in appendix ‘B’ are: A proposed new location for the 24-hour taxi rank. Revised loading restrictions to compliment the new road layout. Revised taxi arrangements on a night so that after the last bus leaves the stops, taxis will be able to rank in the bus layby until the first bus in the morning at 5am. In addition, it is proposed that a new speed plateau (implemented via road humps) be introduced to compliment the recently introduced 20mph speed limit throughout the City Centre. 1.6 The main objectives of the scheme are to; Provide walkers and cyclists much easier and more enjoyable access to and from the city centre. Create the opportunity for outdoor events. Attract further investment into the area. Improve resilience to climate change. Increase the city centre’s biodiversity from the previously hard ‘grey’ environment. 2.0 How Does this Decision Contribute? 2.1 The project will contribute directly through its interventions to the overall strategic vision and objectives of Sheffield City Council and the Sheffield City Region. 2.2 The scheme contributes to the Sub Regional Vision which promotes the Sheffield City Region as a place to collaborate, to invest, to innovate and grow a business, live, work, play and study. It will be supported by an unrivalled skills base and quality of life. 2.3 The scheme supports the key actions set out in the City’s Transport Strategy, adopted by Cabinet in March 2019. Page 4 of 21 3.0 Has there been any consultation? 3.1 Consultation Strategy In January 2021, a ‘Concept Design’ drawing was finalised, illustrating the initial ideas and key elements of the scheme for consultation purposes See appendix ‘A’. A questionnaire was also designed. The consultation period ran from 18th January 2021 until 11th February 2021. As some of the road layout changes that the project is proposing could only be introduced following the making of a TRO, both the public/stakeholder and TRO consultations ran concurrently. 163 letters were posted to occupiers of the area within an agreed boundary relevant to the project (which included the TRO proposals). A copy of this letter is attached, see appendix ‘C’. Over 100 emails were sent to relevant groups/ stakeholders. Given the Covid 19 pandemic and the Government’s lockdown, face to face consultation events were not possible. Instead, the project team organised two on-line webinars (via zoom) on two different dates. These events were very well attended with attendants encouraged to submit their comments via the Citizenspace website (part of SCC) or by contacting the project client / consultation lead. The SCC website was also updated with the project information and consultation details. In addition to the above, an on-line questionnaire and all corresponding information was set up using the Council’s consultation platform, Citizenspace, seeking views on both the proposed improvements as well as on the statutory TRO by the deadline of 11th February 2021. A press release was issued to local newspapers. Statutory consultees for the TRO were notified of the proposals and consultation took place directly with the Access Liaison Group as well as the Cycle Forum. 3.2 Consultation Analysis 167 formal responses were received within the consultation period. The breakdown was as follows; 143 questionnaires were received online via the Citizenspace platform and 24 emails were also sent with comments to the client and consultation lead. From the questionnaires received (via Citizenspace), 143 in total, the breakdown is as follows (people may fall into more than one category); 82% were local residents 25% work locally Page 5 of 21 5% own or run a local business/ local property developer 11% were visitors to the area 6% other/ not answered In terms of the gender of those who completed questionnaires; 42.7% were female, 52.5 were male, 1.4% intersex/ other 3.4% did not answer In terms of disability, 84.6% considered themselves not to have a disability. 11.2% considered themselves to have a disability. 4.2% did not answer. The disabilities most prominent were; mobility or physical disability, long term illness, mental health and a hearing impairment.