Atherton overcharged building fees; builders may be entitled to refunds. Page 9
Online. Anyplace. Anytime.
TheAlmanacOnline.com THE HOMETOWN NEWSPAPER FOR MENLO PARK, ATHERTON, PORTOLA VALLEY AND WOODSIDE SEPTEMBER 26, 2007 www.TheAlmanacOnline.com | VOVOL.L 4433 NONO. 4
Waiting for backup
Menlo Park’s policepolice forcef is understaffedunderstaffed anda nd overworked,o oveve and more cops are on their way out. —Page 12 apr.com
REDEFINING QUALITY SINCE 1990 Reading between the emotional line makes the difference between finding a house and a home.
ATHERTON Presiding on a 1.03+/-acre lot, this superb home, guesthouse and parklike grounds combine to create an estate property of unparalleled distinction. The finest materials, including honed limestone, marble and cherry have been applied with a discriminating eye. Formal rooms and everyday areas feature every amenity and use of the latest technology. Outside evokes a resort-like atmosphere with vast lawns, pool, spa, fireplace, entertainment cooking area and a stunning 1-bedroom guest house. $9,200,000
ATHERTON This 2-years new, elegant 4bd/4.5ba villa celebrates European artisanship. Grandly appointed rooms, casual living areas, hand painted tiles and Murano glass embellish the home. Private setting. $3,295,000
PORTOLA VALLEY Private cul-de-sac setting offering pristine, tranquil views. 4bd/3ba + office with built-in workstation, chef’s kitchen plus extensive great room. Outstanding community amenities. Excellent Portola Valley schools. $2,445,000
apr.com | WOODSIDE OFFICE 2930 WOODSIDE ROAD 650.529.1111
APR COUNTIES | Santa Clara | San Mateo | San Francisco | Alameda | Contra Costa | Monterey | Santa Cruz
2 ■ The Almanac ■ September 26, 2007 Low Cost Divorce/Living Trust DOCUMENT PREPARATION SERVICE INCLUDES: This week’s news, features and community events. • Divorce $449 • Living Trusts $399/$499 FIRST SHOT • Incorporations/LLC $399 • Non-Profit $399 • Probate (Free Quote) • And much more! Kyle & Koko
We The People® 800-579-0009
Form and Service Center since 1985. We are not attorneys. We provide only self-help services at your specific discretion. LDA#72 Santa Clara County
TECHSHOP?AD? PDF 0-
Gourmet Italian Foods OPEN 7 DAYS -ON 3AT AM PM s 3UN AM PM (650) 369-4235 WEEKLY SPECIALS
Photo by Howie Rosen #AMBAZOLA Toma 4IGER 6IRGIN Geared up "LUE "RIE 0IEMONTESE /LIVE /IL Getting ready to hit the road for the second annual Tour for Woodside bike ride are, from left, Nicolas $ 99 $ 99 $ 95 Fenzi, Bob Page, Susan Doherty, Christopher Fenzi, Deborah Gordon and Millo Fenzi. The ride, held on 9 lb. 9 lb. 19 3 Ltr Sept. 23, drew 800 participants and raised an estimated $100,000 for Woodside High School, said Exp. 10/2/07 Exp. 10/2/07 Exp. 10/2/07 Ms. Doherty. At the end of the ride, cyclists chowed down on a barbecued chicken lunch donated by Draeger’s, one of a number of local businesses sponsoring the ride. 7OODSIDE 2OAD 2EDWOOD #ITY .EXT TO 'RAYS 0AINT
Atherton Schools You Can Come In and Use Our... MILLING MACHINES ■ Town overcharged building fees; builders may ■ Building starts at Encinal: Classroom wing will be entitled to refunds. Page 9 be expanded for kindergarten classes. Page 15 METAL LATHES ■ Holbrook-Palmer Park: Some adults fear kids LASER CUTTERS are taking it over. Page 5 METAL WELDING People TechShop is a membership-based workshop that lets you drop in and PLASMA CUTTER ■ use our facilities, tools and equipment to work on your metal, plastic, Portola Valley’s Jon Silver to take a break after wood and electronics projects at your own pace in a supportive and 3D PRINTERS Portola Valley 28 years of public service. Page 7 creative environment! Membership is only $100 a month. SEWING MACHINES ■ Roberts market likely to open in Portola Valley Classes at TechShop are typically $30 and about an hour long, and VINYL CUTTER in January. Page 5 cover lots of great topics including machining, welding, fabricating, Community CNC, laser cutting, 3D CAD design, and lots more! Classes fill up PLASTIC CASTING ■ Town and school officials to meet on Phillips ■ Le Tour de Menlo rolls out at M-A High. Page 9 very quickly...visit our web site for our class list and to sign up. CNC MACHINES Brooks plans. Page 5 TechShop is open 7 days a week from 9 AM until midnight. SHEET METAL FAB ■ Matching grant could add $1 million to coffers for Town Center project. Page 11 PenStyle N 84 Visit TechShop Today! CONSTITUTION DR 120 Independence Dr ■ Eyeglasses are so stylish that even those with 101 INDEPENDENCE DR Menlo Park, CA 94025 perfect vision covet a pair. Cover, Section 2 MARSH RD www.techshop.ws 1 (800) 640-1975 Also Inside On the cover Births ...... 20 Menlo Park cop Chris Sample gets his car ready Calendar ...... 31 for evening patrol. Following a flood of resigna- 10 reasons why Burgess Park pools Editorial ...... 22 tions, the department is understaffed and inexpe- Letters ...... 22 rienced, forcing Mr. Sample and other officers to are the center of Menlo Park’s Obituaries ...... 21 work overtime to keep the streets patrolled. Photo Rain report ...... 21 by Veronica Weber. The story starts on Page 12. active community Town Square ...... 23 1. Open & Lap Swim 2. Masters Swim CALLING ON THE ALMANAC 3. Masters Water Polo 4. Youth Swim Teams The Almanac offices are at 3525 Alameda de las Pulgas, Menlo Park, CA 94025. THE ALMANAC (ISSN 1097-3095 and USPS 459370) is published every Wednesday by Embarcadero Publishing 5. Triathlon Teams For Classified ads, call 854-0858 ■ E-mail news to (no photos please): Co., 3525 Alameda de las Pulgas, Menlo Park, CA 94025- 6. Swim School [email protected] 4455. Periodicals Postage Paid at Menlo Park, CA and at For all other calls, phone 854-2626 additional mailing offices. Adjudicated a newspaper of general 7. Summer Aquatics Camps News: Ext. 213 ■ E-mail news photos with captions to: circulation for San Mateo County, the Almanac is delivered free to homes in Menlo Park, Atherton, Portola Valley and 8. Adult Aqua Fitness Display advertising: Ext. 233 [email protected] ■ Woodside. Voluntary subscriptions for $30 per year or $50 per Fax: 854-0677 E-mail letters to the editor to: 2 years are welcome from residents of the above circulation 9. Snack Bar and Pro Shop [email protected] area. Subscription rates for businesses and for residents of 10. Family Picnics and Parties other communities is $50 per year and $80 for two years. POSTMASTER: Send address changes to the Almanac, P.O. Menlo Swim and Sport To request free delivery, or stop delivery, of The Almanac in zip code 94025, 94027, Box 7008, Menlo Park, CA 94026-7008. Copyright ©2006 by Information and registration 501 Laurel St., Menlo Park, CA 94025 94028 and the Woodside portion of 94062, call 854-2626. Embarcadero Publishing Co., All rights reserved. Reproduction without permission is strictly prohibited. Burgess Park Pools • 650-328-SWIM (7946) www.menloswim.com
September 26, 2007 ■ The Almanac ■ 3 ! Pumpkin Time ! A TOWN MARKET PLACE 3015 WOODSIDE ROAD Pumpkin Chocolate Pumpkin Pie Pumpkin Drop WOODSIDE, CA 94062 Chip Cake Bar Cookie 650-851-1511 Extra moist cake Just the Thick moist cookies Open 6:30AM - 8PM sold by the pound perfect size! with frosting Sale Dates: Sept. 26, 27, 28, 29 $ 39 $ 49 $ 39 SUSHI 6 lb. 2 ea. 2 ea. NOW www.robertsmarket.com at Roberts Upper Crust Pumpkin Pie John & Jill's New York 8" Pie Pumpkin Swirl Cheesecake
New Crop $ 99 $ 59 $ 16 ea. 3 ea. BARTLETT PEARS 1.69 lb. New Crop Washington $ FUJI APPLES 1.99 lb. Red Diane ¢ YAMS 99 lb. Fresh & Crisp ¢ ROMAINE LETTUCE 99 ea.
Suiting Different Tastes MARIAMARIA - DELIDELI wine tasting party is a great way to get to know new friends and new wines. The easiest approach involves selecting representative examples of the same grape variety from different A areas. For instance, a "varietal tasting" may showcase Chardonnays from California, Burgundy, Washington State, Australia, New Zealand, northern Italy, Spain, and Chile. This type of comparative tasting of similarly aged wines lead to a better appreciation of how Noble Syrah different regions contribute their own distinctive character to the same variety of grape. More experienced wine drinkers may want Syrah is truly a noble grape, capable of producing wines of tremendous to engage in a "horizontal tasting" of wines from a single category power and grace. Best known for the great northern Rhone Hermitage and a single vintage for a more rigorous debate of subtle distinc- and Cote-Rotie, the new world has embraced this grape and now produces tions. Either approach ensures a fun gathering. wines to rival those from France. The following are limited production wines that represent the best CA has to offer. ine tasting parties are really a fantastic opportunity for you and your guest to enjoy quality 2005 A Donky and Goat, Vieilles Vignes ...... $36.99 wines in a great atmosphere. At ROBERTS MARKET, we can cater to your vision of the $ perfect wine tasting event. We offer a wide variety of foods from all over the world, and our 2004 Travieso "Amarante", Kirk's Vineyard ...... 38.99 W 2005 Failla Phoenix Ranch, Napa Valley...... $44.99 wine department is the most extensive in the area, more than most liquor stores. This means that if 2003 Ojai White Hawk Vineyard, Santa Barbara County ...... $44.99 you are going to a party with wine, we can provide you with everything you need. 2004 Peay "Les Titans", Sonoma Coast ...... $46.99 HINT: At a wine tasting, keep a wine journal of the labels from the wines you sample and your 2005 Radio-Coteau "Las Colinas", Sonoma Coast ...... $59.99 evaluation of each. 2004 Sanguis "The Last Dance", Santa Maria ...... $59.99 2004 Shafer "Relentless", Napa Valley ...... $65.99 2004 Sanguis "The Wedding", Santa Maria ...... $69.99 2004 Joshua Stagecoach Vineyard, Napa Valley ...... $89.99 NOTE: The above wines assort for a 10% case discount CLOVER ORGANIC LOWFAT YOGURT ¢ 6 oz. 75 LA BALEINE FINE SEA SALT CRYSTALS $ 26 oz. – Also Course 2.39 — Special This Week at Roberts — PEPPERIDGE FARMS APPLE TURNOVERS $ $ 12 oz. – Also Raspberry 1.99 CHILEAN SEABASS 27.98 lb. QUACKER OATS OLD FASHION CEREAL $ $ 18 oz. – Also 1-minute Quick 1.99 COUNTRY STYLE BACON 3.98 lb. PEPSI-DR.PEPPER-MOUNTAIN DEW $ $ lb. 12 oz. – 6 Pack Cans – Plus Calif. Redeem Value 2.29 CRAB CAKE 3.50 PEDIGREE CHOICE CUTS CHICKEN DOG FOOD $ BEEF SHORT RIBS $ lb. 22 oz. – Also Beef – Liver – Lamb 1.09 4.98
4 ■ The Almanac ■ September 26, 2007 M ENLO PARK | ATHERTON | WOODSIDE | PORTOLA V ALLEY Officials to meet on Phillips Brooks School plans ■ Letter confirms that the school bought 10 acres, Steve Toben said he met on Sept. The school has no immediate Toben, Mr. Vlasic and two Phil- likely for a new campus. 19 with 25 concerned Santa Clara plans for the Santa Clara County lips Brooks trustees. County neighbors of the site at site, Portola Valley deputy town Mayor Driscoll would not con- By David Boyce parking lot of the Alpine Inn in their invitation. “We’re interested planner Tom Vlasic said he was firm plans to meet and said he Almanac Staff Writer Portola Valley. in all learning together,” he said. told. did not want publicity about the In a letter to parents dated Aug. “This is a big deal.” School officials have not meeting, in part to avoid residents fficials from Portola Val- 30, Phillips Brooks officials say As for the planned meeting responded to numerous Almanac showing up outside the school- ley and Phillips Brooks the school purchased the property with Phillips Brooks trustees, Mr. requests for comment. house to protest. “We’re trying to OSchool, a private ele- and add: “The Board of Trustees Toben said the point was to be do this in a friendly manner here,” mentary school now extensively believes this property could be the cordial and give the trustees “the Meeting he said. rebuilding its campus on Avy site of a permanent home for The benefit of the doubt.” The meeting of Portola Valley Without a quorum — if just two Avenue in Menlo Park, plan to Phillips Brooks School.” The preschool-to-grade-5 and school officials could take of the five council members are meet this week to discuss why the That prospect worries neighbors school has leased its Avy Avenue place as early as Tuesday morn- present — the council would not school bought 10 acres of undevel- and Portola Valley officials because campus from the Las Lomitas ing, Sept. 25, at the town’s Historic have to open the meeting to the oped land near Arastradero Road of potential environmental impacts Elementary School District since Schoolhouse. public. in unincorporated Santa Clara on the area, including increasing 1978. The lease expires in 2017 Among those likely to par- County. The land is along Los traffic through Portola Valley. and has an option for one five- ticipate are Portola Valley Mayor See SCHOOL, page 8 Trancos Creek and opposite the Portola Valley Councilman year extension. Ted Driscoll, Councilman Steve Roberts market likely to open in Portola Valley in January By David Boyce town’s plan-check consultant for Almanac Staff Writer another round of analysis, mostly concerning structural and load- t will likely be January before bearing elements, said Town Plan- the Portola Valley grocery store ning Manager Leslie Lambert. Ionce known as John’s Valley Plan-check is complete and a Foods reopens as Roberts market building permit should be issued at the corner of Alpine and Portola this week, Ms. Lambert told the roads. Almanac on Friday. Owner George Roberts said he “This one is important,” Mr. is used to Portola Valley-related Roberts said. With a building questions from customers who permit, he can go ahead with patronize his Woodside store. electrical work, heating and cool- “They’re always asking about ing, plumbing and a mezzanine. when it’s going to happen,” he This interior work will establish said. the store’s personality, Mr. Roberts Bureaucratic processes have said. delayed a planned November The 2,000-square-foot mezza- opening in Portola Valley of a nine, a new feature, would house new version of what has become the store offices and an employee a Woodside institution. “The lounge, Ms. Lambert said. systems that are set up to wind The architectural design team your way through are the biggest includes grocery store design The Almanac/Veronica Weber problem,” Mr. Roberts told the specialist Sutti Associates, based Timber! Almanac. “It just takes so long to in Burlingame. Asked if planning San Mateo County public works employees contemplate how to remove a tree that toppled on to Perry Avenue do.” staff had been in unfamiliar ter- near Vine street in unincorporated Menlo Park on Sept. 19, taking out power lines on the way down. The amended building plans have been in the hands of the See ROBERTS MARKET, page 8 Atherton’s Holbrook-Palmer Park: Some fear kids are taking it over ■ Little League wins from playing ball at the park and for any accidents or misuse of the to open it up to youth sports have turns a temporary ballfield into a bid to keep backstop up to restore the field’s open space backstop. usually met with stiff resistance. permanent baseball field, depriv- all winter. appearance for half the year. “Don’t we have ing other park visitors of using the Despite the objections of mem- enough in the park area, Ms. Carlson said. By Andrea Gemmet ber of the Atherton Park and for children?” asked M-A Little League officials Almanac Staff Writer Recreation Committee and the ‘Don’t we have enough in the Park and Recreation argued that the backstop was ill the crack of the bat Holbrook-Palmer Park Founda- park for children? Could we not Commissioner Shir- getting damaged as a result of the be heard year-round in tion, the Atherton City Council ley Carlson. “We annual deconstruction and recon- WAtherton’s Holbrook- voted to allow the league’s back- leave something for the adults have the preschool, struction, and that it was an added Palmer Park? stop to remain up all year, on a trial in this community?’ a playground, Eas- expense that a nonprofit organiza- Under an eight-year-old agree- basis. The vote was 4-1, with Kathy ter and Christmas tion could do without. Boys and ment with the town, Menlo- McKeithen opposed, at the Sept. 19 SHIRLEY CARLSON, RECREATION COMMISSIONER (events). There’s girls should be able to go there to Atherton Little League officials council meeting. plenty for children. practice baseball in the off-season have had to remove the backstop In exchange, Little League will Holbrook-Palmer has never been Could we not leave something for or have pick-up games with friends at the end of the season in July, have to take out a larger insurance a typical municipal park geared the adults in this community?” to discourage rowdy adult groups policy and assume the liability toward children, and past attempts Leaving the backstop in place See PARK, page 8
September 26, 2007 ■ The Almanac ■ 5 6 ■ The Almanac ■ September 26, 2007 PEOPLE REAL ESTATE Q&A by Gloria Darke Jon Silver to take break after To Sign or Not to Sign? Q: We are going through a divorce and many a property has been sold to people 28 years of public service do not want to do a lot of explaining to who weren’t even looking to buy a house our neighbors about why we are selling. Is simply by driving by and spotting the sign! He’s leaving the county Planning Commission, where he served 12 years it really necessary to put a “for sale” sign Signs are effective because many poten- in front of our house? tial buyers like to do “drive-bys” in neigh- By David Boyce borhoods they like. It’s human nature to — Mel J. Almanac Staff Writer be curious. When they spot a property A: Dear: Mel J., that attracts their attention, they will either Many sellers do not want the neighbors fter 28 years of volunteer- call the listing brokerage, or contact their to know they are selling for a variety per- agent to make a showing appointment. ing on the public’s behalf, sonal reasons but the fact is “for sale” signs The appeal of seeing a live property is far a rest from the routine is in are the number one form of advertisement A greater than that of a picture in a maga- and the least expensive. Compared with order, says Portola Valley resident zine, virtual tour or a three-line classified Jon Silver, but public issues will the other media, signs attract the highest number of phone responses, in ratio to the ad. Although various advertising media continue to matter to him. are effective in creating interest and inqui- Mr. Silver is leaving the San money invested. On the other hand, sticking a “for sale” ries, nothing beats a sign in the yard. Mateo County Planning Com- I appreciate your desire for privacy. mission after 12 years of meetings sign on your front lawn is not the only marketing tool realtors have. But we try But to effectively market your home there every other Wednesday morning. to use all of the tools at our disposal. With needs to be realtor tours, open houses, vir- Before that, he was on the Portola the internet now posting all of the listings tual tours, etc. And to add insult to injury, Valley Town Council for 16 years, it’s a whole new world. However, there are the whole world knows at the close of including three times as mayor, still buyers who do not use the internet and escrow what you sold the house for! from early 1978 to late 1993. The Planning Commission For answers to any questions you may have on real estate, you may e-mail me at gdarke@apr. oversees development on unin- com or call 462-1111, Alain Pinel Realtors. I also offer a freemarket analysis of your property. corporated county land, most of which lies west of the Coast Range from Pacifica south to the Santa The Almanac/Veronica Weber Cruz County line. Jon Silver with his two poodles at the Chilean woodchoppers house in NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING “It’s a good time to make a Portola Valley. Mr. Silver’s next public service endeavor is to save the change,” Mr. Silver told the Alma- aging house, left over from the Gold Rush era, that served as a refuge CITY OF MENLO PARK nac. His third and last allowable for Chilean prospectors turned woodcutters. CITY COUNCIL term ended in January, but he Planning Commission agreed to stay on until October, turned woodcutters. panied the council on an afford- when county Supervisor Rich The men had been expelled able-housing field trip to Palo Alto NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the Planning Commission of the City Gordon plans to recommend from the gold fields by racist white and came away heartened, Mr. of Menlo Park, California is scheduled to make a recommendation to the City Council on the following item: his successor for District 3. The miners, so the story goes, and had Silver says. Board of Supervisors makes the found work making charcoal from Zoning Ordinance Amendment /City of Menlo Park: Consideration appointment. willow wood, which was abundant A family matter of a Zoning Ordinance Amendment to clarify the definition of Gross Floor “It’s unfortunate,” Mr. Gordon then in Portola Valley. Sailing Being upbraided during a public Area to more specifically identify features of a building that are either says about Mr. Silver’s departure. back to Chile was out of the ques- hearing, and holding one’s tongue, included or excluded from the calculation. Gross floor area is used “He’s been a fantastic planning tion since San Francisco Bay was come with the territory of being a in calculating the floor area ratio (FAR) and parking requirements for developments in all zoning districts except for single-family and R-2 (Low commissioner.” During his tenure, packed tight with idle ships left public official. Decision makers Density Apartment) zoning districts. Floor area ratio equals the gross floor Mr. Silver deftly addressed coastal there by gold seekers. are advised to let everyone speak area of a building divided by the lot area and effectively regulates the protection and found the “right “To me, (the woodchoppers before closing the hearing so that size of a building. In addition, gross floor area is used in determining the places” for new developments, Mr. house) is just as valuable as slave legislators can then discuss and/or applicability of requirements for below market rate (BMR) housing and the Gordon says. housing in Virginia or a house act on the matter before them. preparation of traffic studies. The clarifications to the definition will focus Nonprofits may miss Mr. Silver, along the underground railroad Mr. Silver remembers that dur- on new buildings and attempt to minimize impacts to existing buildings. too. His commissioner’s stipend of in a (Civil War) border state,” Mr. ing a hearing held over several The Zoning Ordinance Amendment will be exempt from the California about $2,300 a year has been going Silver says. It is also a reminder that months on a controversial effort Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) in that the changes are intended to to causes such as the Audubon people of small means once lived to amend San Mateo County’s have no potential to impact the environment. Society, the Greenbelt Alliance and where homes now sell for millions, Coastside master plan, one man Copies of said draft Zoning Ordinance Amendment will be on file for the county hospital. he added. accused him, early on, of knowing review at the City Library and available for distribution at the Community “I’ll miss not having that free nothing about big families and Development Department, Civic Center, 701 Laurel Street, Menlo Park, money to give away,” he says. Small is beautiful? their need for big houses. CA 94025, on Monday, October 1, 2007. Mr. Silver, 54, earns his living The woodchoppers house is not Unable to respond for months, NOTICE IS HEREBY FURTHER GIVEN that said Planning Commission as the owner of the Quicksilver alone as a small dwelling in Portola by which time the moment had will hold a public hearing on these items in the Council Chambers of the Delivery Service (it delivers the Valley today. Second-unit cottages passed, Mr. Silver says he had no City of Menlo Park, located at 701 Laurel Street, Menlo Park, on Monday, Almanac), and he shares his house offer homes for people with lower doubt that his accuser was wrong. October 8, 2007, 7:00 p.m. or as near as possible thereafter, at which with two large poodles. “One’s a incomes. A Town Council in the That’s understandable, given that time and place interested persons may appear and be heard thereon. socialist and one’s an anarchist,” he 1990s that included Mr. Silver his maternal Mormon grandfather If you challenge these items in court, you may be limited to raising only says. In keeping with their uncon- amended the general plan’s hous- had had three wives simultane- those issues you or someone else raised at the public hearing described ventional politics, he says he lets ing element to specify inclusionary ously, and his paternal Mormon in this notice, or in written correspondence delivered to the City of Menlo their coats go natural and avoids zoning, which requires subdivi- grandfather had had four. Park at, or prior to, the public hearing. the “frou-frou” poodle look. “They sions of seven or more homes to “They didn’t get divorces along Documents related to these items may be inspected by the public on look like regular dogs.” reserve 15 percent of the project for the way,” Mr. Silver explains. At weekdays between the hours of 7:30 a.m. and 5:30 p.m. Monday through With his life less regulated, Mr. below-market-rate homes. the time, most of the marriages Thursday and 8:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m. on Friday, with alternate Fridays Silver says he plans to spend his Mr. Silver says he remembers a had been covertly sanctioned by closed, at the Community Development Department, 701 Laurel Street, Menlo Park. Please call Justin Murphy, Development Services Manager, time finding a permanent site in meeting during the zoning delib- the Church of Latter Day Saints, if there are any questions or comments on this item. He may be reached Portola Valley for the small home erations that “resembled a lynch he says. at 650-330-6725 or email at [email protected]. left over from the Gold Rush era mob.” A resident complained that Eventually the church distanced and known as the Chilean wood- she had left South Africa to escape itself by excommunicating his Visit our Web site for City Council public hearing, agenda, and staff choppers house. racial issues, that she’d left Ather- paternal grandfather, Mr. Silver report information: www.menlopark.org The aging little house on Portola ton to escape proximity to East says, adding that his grandfather DATED: September 20, 2007 Deanna Chow Road at the northern edge of the Palo Alto, and now “you want to later redeemed himself by arrang- Senior Planner Jelich Ranch is the only remaining do it here,” he recalls. ing to have three of the marriages PUBLISHED: September 26, 2007 house of five or six that served as The woman may have sounded annulled and getting himself re- If there are any questions, please call the Planning Division at (650) 330-6702. refuges for Chilean prospectors incorrigible, but she later accom- baptized. A Published in THE COUNTRY ALMANAC on September 26, 2007.
September 26, 2007 ■ The Almanac ■ 7 NEWS Residents’ views sought on what city should do about El Camino Real
Sometime in the next several ■ MENLO PARK weeks, Menlo Park residents can expect to see a familiar question show up in their mailboxes: Real corridor and downtown What should the city do about area. The city also intends to hold El Camino Real? a series of community workshops The city is sending out fliers and public meetings, likely start- soliciting public input to help ing in January. decide what should replace abandoned auto lots along the New director at MCC city’s main corridor. Among the questions the city Molly Given, a 10-year veter- is asking: an of childhood education, has ■ What kinds of new busi- been named the new director nesses does the city need? of the Menlo Children’s Center, ■ How tall should new build- which houses the city’s West ings be? Menlo preschool and school- age child care programs. ■ Would you like to see more Almanac photo by David Boyce housing on El Camino Real and Ms. Given has worked in sev- Firefighters direct hose at burning stacks of lumber. near the city’s downtown area? eral teaching posts, and recently Attached to the mailer will be a received her site director permit short survey that residents can fill from the California Department Firefighters battle lumber fire in Menlo Park out and send back to the city. of Education, according to a letter Firefighters from the Menlo Park Fire Protection the piles of lumber until a military-issue forklift City officials say the input will emailed to parents by city staff. District responded in force Sept. 19 to a grass fire — capable of lifting 15 tons — removed the non- be included in the city’s efforts to She is scheduled to start Oct. 1. along the Caltrain railroad tracks in east Menlo burning stacks on top so firefighters could get to design a comprehensive plan for Park that set alight stacks of lumber in an indus- the burning wood underneath. properties along the El Camino — Rory Brown trial parking lot. Such a fast-burning fire might have been The fire moved quickly due to high winds and prevented if officials had cleared the vegetation burned along the backside of Hamilton Avenue to surrounding the abandoned train tracks, Chief SCHOOL Madera Avenue, where it began to spread to piles Schapelhouman said. continued from page 5 ■ Raising that much money of lumber stored behind a wood trim shop, Menlo No structures were damaged, though one busi- would entail a fundraising cam- Park Fire District Chief Harold Schapelhouman ness with a propane tank behind its building was Letter to parents paign over 10 to 15 years. reported. threatened before firefighters secured the scene. The Aug. 30 letter to Phillips The fire closed six city blocks along Hamilton One firefighter sustained minor injuries when Brooks parents says that finding Avy Avenue campus Avenue while fire crews cleared the scene, he said. a piece of equipment was blown over and struck a permanent home is “critical” In the 2005-06 school year, After they doused the grass fire, firefighters him, according to Chief Schapelhouman. to the school’s long-term sustain- Phillips Brooks paid $900,000 in concentrated on hosing down and keeping cool Bay City News Service contributed to this report. ability and the 10-acre purchase is rent to the Las Lomitas district for “part of that continuum.” The site its Avy Avenue campus in Menlo “could be” the school’s permanent Park, about 7 percent of the dis- home, but the letter says the trust- trict’s revenue that year. ROBERTS MARKET amendments will go to the Plan- amendment, Ms. Lambert said. ees must first evaluate its potential In early 2006, Phillips Brooks continued from page 5 ning Commission for preliminary The employee parking lot will also and find a way to “most effectively got the go-ahead from the city of review, then to the ASCC, then have landscaping intended to pro- use this property.” Menlo Park to embark upon a $10 ritory in talking with a firm that back to the Planning Commission tect residential views and dampen The one-page letter is not signed, million upgrade of the campus. specializes in grocery stores, Ms. for a public hearing and a decision, noise, she said. but the two names at the bottom The project is nearing completion. Lambert said that that was not the Ms. Lambert said. The loading dock will have a are Scott Ryles, who chairs the The new buildings will expand case and described the relation- 6-foot-long sleeve to enclose the Phillips Brooks board of trustees, the school’s floor area to 31,000 ship as “a good working balance.” ‘Typical grocery store’ rear end of trucks and damp down and Kristi A. Kerins, the head of square feet from 18,000 square feet The other project hurdle will be Employee hours will be from 6 the noise of goods and produce the school. and alleviate a situation in which amendments to the conditional a.m. to 8 p.m., Mr. Roberts said, being unloaded, Mr. Roberts said. The letter also says: art, music, science and foreign lan- use permit, which can cover the with the last employee prob- Parked trucks will have to have ■ School trustees decided to guage teachers have to share class- impacts of exterior noise, exterior ably gone by 8:30 p.m. Employees their engines and refrigeration buy the property at the last board rooms, the spokeswoman said. lighting and delivery schedules — gathering in parking lots before or units shut down. meeting of the 2006-07 school In the Aug. 30 letter to parents, matters that neighbors may want after hours is unlikely, he added. The trash compactor out back year. The land set the school back Mr. Ryles and Ms. Kerins said they to weigh in on. The use permit “One thing about (store employ- will be enclosed in its own roofed about $5 million. Building a cam- expect students to “thrive in our must be brought up to date and ees) is they don’t hang around.” shed, Mr. Roberts said. pus comparable to the 4.5-acre site new Avy Avenue campus for years geared specifically toward Roberts Employee coming and going “This isn’t going to be any dif- on Avy Avenue would take “greater to come.” A market, Ms. Lambert said. will be discussed in granting ferent than a typical grocery than $30 million.” A staff report on use-permit amendments to the use-permit store,” he said. A
PARK providing an area for children.” brook-Palmer is Atherton’s only larger landscaped playground. honor its contract since the continued from page 5 In all, six people spoke against park. Besides fields and walking Construction of the Little League expense of removing the back- leaving up the backstop and eight paths, it holds tennis courts, sever- field came after multiple attempts stop is minimal. spoke in favor of it. While some al historic buildings, and a pavilion to get the town to provide space “I’m the only member who and family, they said. people complained that the back- that is rented out for weddings and for youth sports at the park. It was was on the council when this was “Our family and many, many stop is ugly, Councilman Charles events. the subject of intense public debate approved,” said Mayor Alan Carl- families support retaining the Marsala said it improves the look Over the years, as more families and its use is governed by a restric- son. “There was a lot of resistance backstop,” said Atherton resident of the park, since it partially blocks with young children moved into tive 10-year contract. The M-A to having kids at the park.” Michelle Dollinger, who spear- views of the rusting fences around Atherton, there’s been increasing Little League paid for the field’s Mr. Carlson said one of his headed the campaign to rebuild the tennis courts. tension over the use of the park. construction and reimburses the proudest accomplishments was the children’s playground at Hol- In 2002, Atherton families raised town for its maintenance. helping broker the compromise brook-Palmer Park. “Not just Tension over use money and replaced the park’s Councilwoman McKeithen that allowed the field to get because of the cost, but because it’s A 22-acre former estate, Hol- aging play structures with a much said that Little League should built. A
8 ■ The Almanac ■ September 26, 2007 NEWS FOOTHILL COLLEGE Invites you to join us at our guest location at Stanford Linear Accelerator Center (SLAC) Town overcharged building fees; 2575 Sand Hill Rd., Menlo Park (408) 864-8817 (Just Minutes from either Foothill Expwy or 280) builders may be entitled to refunds A SIX-WEEK By Andrea Gemmet as possible.” ■ ATHERTON Almanac Staff Writer Mr. Cully did not return the Almanac’s phone calls seeking INVESTMENT AND FINANCIAL nyone building a home in manager Jim Robinson was told comment. Atherton who got permits about the fee table when it came to “I can’t think of single project that PLANNING CLASS before December 2006 might light. had a permitted value of $5 million. A Wednesday evenings from 7:00 - 9:00 PM. It is better to register now, but you want to get out a calculator and give “We discussed the matter of pos- That would have been a 20,000- the building permit and plan-check sible overcharges extensively with square-foot house,” Mr. Johns told may also register the first evening of class on Oct. 10th. (Class #255). The cost fees a second look. the former city manager and the the Almanac. is $49. No prior financial knowledge is required. To register call (408) 864-8817, Town officials acknowledged last former building official,” said Mr. When validating building depart- or go online, www.shortcourses.fhda.edu (in the Financial Planning section). week that a mistake in the printed Johns. ment fees, he found variations on fee table used by the Atherton Mr. Robinson agreed that any average ranged from $100-$500, “Outstanding Course!” Building Department caused staff corrections should be done on a go- Mr. Johns said. “I don’t want to exaggerate, but I truly believe this course has to overcharge projects with a valu- forward basis, and that the amount “I considered it to be a tolerable improved my life and my financial well-being. The instructors ation of $1 million or more. of the overcharges was likely to be level of error. Again, we’re talk- had an outstanding command of the material and presented it The errors were quietly fixed, immaterial, based on extensive fee ing about permit fees in the tens thoughtfully and with great humor & insight.” and town staff chose not to inform validations conducted during the of thousands of dollars,” he said. either the City Council or building audit of the building department, A $2 million project would have department clients. Councilman Mr. Johns told the Almanac. been assessed permit fees of about Some of the Topics Are: Charles Marsala raised the issue Mayor Alan Carlson said the $40,000 he said. $ THREE STRATEGIES FOR SUCCESSFULLY BUILDING A and the council is set to discuss it council should have been told about The building department is enti- STOCK PORTFOLIO at its next meeting, on Wednesday, the problem with the fee table. tled to recoup its costs by charging $ THE BEST WAYS OF INVESTING IN REAL ESTATE Oct. 17. fees, but legally, it cannot make a $ ANNUITIES, BONDS & MUTUAL FUNDS According to documents provid- ‘Tolerable level of error’ profit. “This happened at a time ed to the Almanac by Councilman The discovery of the overcharges when the building department had $ RETIREMENT STRATEGIES & PLANNING Marsala, the mistake was discussed is documented in an e-mail dated a net operating loss for the year of $ ACHIEVING TAX-FREE INCOME in November by Finance Director Dec. 1, 2006 between Mr. Cully and $200,000,” Mr. Johns said. “Despite $ PROTECTING WEALTH & ASSETS IN TROUBLED TIMES John Johns and Mike Cully, an out- Finance Director John Johns. any apparent minor overcharges, $ MANAGING YOUR MONEY TO YOUR ADVANTAGE side consultant then serving as the Mr. Cully wrote, “I am troubled the building department wasn’t $ TAX-DEFERRED SAVINGS ACCOUNTS town’s interim building official. by our discussion on Wednesday making a profit.” Mr. Marsala said he heard from wherein you elected to dismiss the The problem with building fees $ WHAT TO DO RIGHT NOW & FINANCIAL PLANNING Mr. Cully this spring about the inaccuracy of the existing printed is the latest revelation in a series of $ HOW TO CHOOSE A TOP-NOTCH ADVISOR overcharges, and filed two public fee tables as insignificant.” unflattering events for Atherton. $ TURNING THE MOST COMMON FINANCIAL MISTAKES INTO PROFIT records requests in order to docu- He goes on to say, “A quick calcu- Atherton’s building department $ IRAs: WHAT WALL STREET WON’T TELL YOU ment them. lation I did on a $2 million project is undergoing a major overhaul fol- $ ECONOMIC HEDGING & ASSET ALLOCATION Anyone who discovers an over- showed it was about $800 (over) on lowing numerous problems turned charge may ask for a refund, as long the permit fee alone. If you did a up during a three-phase internal $ INCREASING INCOME: WHICH CDs OR T-BILLS ARE SUPERIOR as the request is made within 180 quick calculation for a $5 (million) audit led by Mr. Johns last year. $ AND MUCH, MUCH MORE INCLUDING ROLLOVERS days of the error coming to light, project you would discover that Among the issues: sloppy prac- said City Attorney Marc Hynes. we are assessing the permit holder tices, poor record-keeping and lack ABOUT YOUR INSTRUCTOR Steve Lewis is President of Lewis & Mathews Investment Mr. Hynes said it was unclear about $3,300 more than we should. of accountability. One of many Management, Inc., which is a personal financial advisory firm in how many projects might have This is 10.7 percent too much.” changes in its practices is the drop- Menlo Park. He teaches investment courses for various colleges been overcharged, and he did not Mr. Cully ends the e-mail by say- ping of preprinted fee tables in favor and institutions in the area. He is a financial author and has know how long the flawed fee table ing, “I strongly suggest you rethink of using a computer spreadsheet appeared on national radio and television. He is a past officer and has served as a board member of the S. C. International was in use. your position and we make these Association of Financial Planners. He has served on the National Mr. Johns said that then-city corrections as quickly, and quietly, See FEES, page 19 Academy Advisory Board of IAFP and is a member of the Palo Alto Financial Planning Forum. Among others, he has written for Money Magazine and Dow Jones’ Barron’s.
Le Tour de Menlo rolls out at M-A High Other instructors include Deborah Peri and Jim Curran. The instructors have taught Elite cyclists who are ready to to the King will head north from the start test their mettle on some of the and Queen to Redwood City, San Carlos, over 30,000 Northern Californians their Peninsula’s steepest terrain will of the Hill Belmont and Hillsborough in a money managing techniques. have an opportunity on Sunday, for the best series of hills that will include the Oct. 14, when the fourth annual combined two timed climbs. TAXES • FINANCIAL PLANNING • REAL ESTATE le Tour de Menlo rolls out begin- times on The ride will be fully supported, STOCKS • MUTUAL FUNDS • TRUSTS ning at 7 a.m. at Menlo-Atherton the two with a major rest stop at the half- SOME COMMENTS FROM PAST CLASS MEMBERS: High School. hills. way point in Belmont. Drinks “This course has been excellent, very informative and enlightening.” The Tour offers two courses, an Riders can register at www. and snacks will be available all “...Very objective in presentation of material...” extreme hills version with 5,000 TourdeMenlo.com through Fri- morning, as well as SAG services. “I have looked forward to each class like opening a new package each week.” feet of climbing in 50 miles for day, Oct. 12, or on the day of Route maps and instructions on “The course exceeded my expectations.” hardy riders, and a tamer, 30-mile the ride from 7 a.m. to 9 a.m. at how the climbs will be timed will “...I personally benefited a great deal from the subject covered.” route with fewer hills that offers a Menlo-Atherton High School, be available at the start. challenging course for beginning 555 Middlefield Road in Ather- Sponsors of the ride are the “... A very helpful, well thought out, well presented course. I have and intermediate riders. ton. Mailed entries should be Rotary Club of Menlo Park and recommended it to many people.” All proceeds from the event will post-marked no later than Oct. the Almanac. The ride’s $40 “Well done, informative, stimulating.” be used to support tutoring and 5 and sent to Tour de Menlo, entry fee includes a T-shirt. Late “Terrific! Loved the course.” scholarship projects of the Rotary 3525 Alameda de las Pulgas, registration will be available “ Your ability to take subject matter to which I have never been exposed and Club of Menlo Park. Menlo Park, CA 94025, with for $45 on the day of the event. make it understandable commands my highest respect.” Another important feature of check or credit card information Students 16 and under are $30 “Extremely informative.” the 50-miler is an opportunity for enclosed. or $35 on ride day. Call Tom at riders to be timed on two hills in Riders will be able to start as 650-854-2626, ext. 222, for more THIS IS THE ONLY AD THAT WILL APPEAR FOR THIS the event. Prizes will be awarded soon as they are registered. They information. COURSE. PLEASE CUT OUT AND BRING TO CLASS (This space donated to Foothill College. Not paid with tax dollars.)
September 26, 2007 ■ The Almanac ■ 9 NEWS Woodside knocks report on Huddart, Wunderlich parks
■ such a lack of analysis to support on its dreadful inadequacies,” cilwoman Deborah Gordon. Draft environmental impact report ignores their assumptions,” Mayor Sue said Councilwoman Carroll Ann “You read this and it’s clear that town concerns, council says. Boynton said. Hodges. they didn’t hear us. They didn’t Residents of Greer Road are wor- One such error is the statement pay attention to any of these con- By Andrea Gemmet report is a state-mandated analysis ried that the access road to Hud- that Huddart Park is surrounded cerns,” Ms. Gordon said. “That’s Almanac Staff Writer of the project’s potential impacts. entirely by public lands, ignoring the thing that bothers me the housands of extra visitors? Woodsiders are concerned about the fact that it shares a half-mile most about this.” A wedding reception every traffic, noise and other effects, boundary with private property By consensus, the council agreed day of the year? Parked especially those from the proposed ‘You read this and it’s owned by Elizabeth Flood, said to incorporate residents’ com- T community building at Huddart cars clogging the roads near park clear they didn’t hear Mr. Susk, who is Ms. Flood’s attor- ments and concerns into an offi- entrances? A master plan for that could host weddings year- ney. The report also refers to a plan cial response letter from the town future development at Huddart round. The EIR says the park us. That’s the thing that to open to the public a permissive that will be become part of the and Wunderlich County parks in currently hosts two or three wed- bothers me the most.’ horse trail on Ms. Flood’s property, record in the final environmental Woodside has town officials and dings a week over the summer at something Mr. Susk said will not impact report. residents deeply concerned about its outdoor facility, said Virginia COUNCILWOMAN DEBORAH GORDON happen and should be removed “I think we have our work cut the development’s impact. Dare, chair of the town’s open from the EIR. out for us,” said Councilman Dave Huddart and Wunderlich parks space committee. dart at the end of their narrow lane Almost all of the concerns raised Tanner. “We need to go to San offer almost 2,000 acres of for- “If it’s used 100 days a year by will turn into a second entrance to at the meeting had been raised Mateo (County) in a bigger force 250 people, that’s 250,000 people,” est and meadow threaded with the park, overwhelming them with before with the county, said Coun- to make sure they hear us.” A trails and dotted with picnic and Ms. Dare said. She said the park traffic. They’ve already seen a big group camp sites. The master currently draws about 90,000 visi- increase in county park vehicles plan includes constructing two tors a year. using the road, and they report Castilleja celebrates a century new buildings at Huddart Park: a “It’s a potentially significant ongoing problems with the large visitors’ center and a community increase in use,” Ms. Dare said. numbers of recreational bicyclists. The Castilleja community is and varsity, a “decade parade” building at the Zwierlein group “It’s being shoved under the mat, “This is a call to action to the having a 100th birthday party will be held at 5 p.m. picnic area. It also details improve- being ignored, and it needs to be council to protect Greer Road from 3 to 8 p.m. Friday, Sept. 28, There will be a picnic din- ments to restrooms, roads, parking addressed.” residents,” said resident Bob Susk. at the Palo Alto school, 1310 Bry- ner, live music, dancing and lots and group camp areas, as well The proposed closure of park Residents and Woodside town ant St. roving entertainment at 6 p.m. as some trails and trail bridges. trail creek crossings for horses has staff also said they found a num- Events include a parade, alum- The birthday celebration, centen- A crowd of people showed up local equestrians upset, and the ber of errors from the master nae water polo game, dinner and nial show and closing ceremonies at the Woodside Town Council’s potential impact of cars parking on plan that had been repeated or a birthday celebration. The after- begin at 7:30 p.m. Parking will be Sept. 11 meeting to raise concerns the road rather than in the parking exacerbated in the environmental noon begins with carnival games, available at El Camino Grove lot that they said were not adequately lots has town officials worried. impact report. concession stands, student exhib- 2 at Stanford University. Shuttle addressed in the plan’s draft envi- “I’m amazed at this draft “Our citizens reviewed the draft its and music. After the water polo service will be provided. For more ronmental impact report. The (report) mostly because there is EIR in detail and picked up game at 4 p.m. between alumnae information, call 470-7749. 3FDZDMF#BUUFSJFT $FMM1IPOFTBU UIF$VSC
(OW TO PARTICPATE
$PMMFDUBMMUZQFTPGIPVTFIPME CBUUFSJFTBOEDFMMQIPOFT T T T T T
'PSTBGFUZSFBTPOT QMFBTF )PVTFIPMECBUUFSJFTJODMVEF 8SBQDFMMQIPOFTJOQBQFS 1VUMPPTFC HBUIFSBMMMJUIJVNiCVUUPOw BMMSFDIBSHFBCMFBOE UPQSPUFDUUIFN"OZLJOEPG MJUIJVNCBU CBUUFSJFTBOEQMBDFBQJFDF EJTQPTBCMFBMLBMJOFUZQFT QQQBQFSJTPLB ZZ XSBQQFEDF /0BVUPNPUJWFCBUUFSJFT PGEVDUPSFMFDUSJDBMUBQF $-&"3QMBT BSPVOEFBDIPOF ;JQUZQFCB
4FSWJDFBWBJMBCMFGPSTJOHMFGBNJMZSFTJEFOUTJO"UIFSUPO #FMNPOU #VSMJOHBNF &BTU1BMP"MUP 'PTUFS$JUZ )JMMTCPSPVHI.FOMP1BSL3FEXPPE$JUZ 4BO$BSMPT 4BO.BUFP 8FTU#BZ4BOJUBSZ%JTUSJDUBOETPNFBSFBTPGVOJODPSQPSBUFE4BO.BUFP$PVOUZ'PSNPSFJOGPSNBUJPO DPOUBDU"MMJFE8BTUFBU
10 ■ The Almanac ■ September 26, 2007 NEWS FEATURED AUTHORS Matching grant could add World Without End The Book Thief Ken Follett Marcus Zusak $1 million to coffers for Monday, October 22 Tuesday, October 30 Tow n Center project 7:30 p.m. 7:00 p.m. Ken Follett has 90 million The Book Thief affects By David Boyce ■ PORTOLA VALLEY readers worldwide. everyone who reads it. Almanac Staff Writer The Pillars of the Earth is his bestselling book Zusak’s complex and sophisticated narrative has he passing of the com- 355 donors, up from 335 in April of all time. Now, 18 years after its publication, taken the young adult novel to another level, munity hat continues in and including 86 of $5,000 or Follett has written the most anticipated sequel of forever raising the bar for his successors. TPortola Valley in a “final more and five of at least $1 mil- the year – World Without End. fundraising drive” for the $20 lion. The 2000 census lists about million project to build a new 1,770 families in Portola Valley. Don’t miss these other exciting author events! library, Town Hall and com- Adding to, but separate from, munity hall and redo several the overall cost of the new com- Featuring Paola Gianturco Author à la Carte Event: recreational facilities. plex is a Sept. 12 decision by The Global Fund for Women Presents: The Hearty Boys: Dan Smith and Steve McDonagh This latest fundraising push the Town Council that is likely Women Who Light the Dark Tuesday, October 2, 7:30 p.m. Talk With Your Mouth Full got a kick-start Sept. 12 with an to lead to the spending of an Friday, October 12, 6:30 p.m. anonymous $500,000 dollar- additional $1 million to open Sultana Restaurant, for-dollar matching grant that up — or daylight — about 280 Robert Draper 1149 El Camino Real, Menlo Park runs until Dec. 15, according feet of Sausal Creek. Dead Certain: The Presidency of George W. Bush Michael Krasny to a statement from the Portola Finding the money to pay for Wednesday, October 3, 7:30 p.m. Off Mike: A Memoir of Talk Radio off mik mikee A Memoir of Talk Radio Valley Community Fund. Gifts the creek element will be a sepa- and Literary Life michael krasny and Literary Life may be of any size and may be rate fundraising effort. Monday, October 15, 7:30 p.m. earmarked for any part of the For decades, the seasonal project. creek has been buried in a cul- Jennifer Ackerman The new complex is tentatively vert. In deciding to open up part Sex Sleep Eat Drink Dream: set to open in late 2008. The of the creek, the council also Gail Tsukiyama A Day in the Life of Your Body environmentally green elements directed the project architects to The Street of a Thousand Blossoms Wednesday, October 24, 7:30 p.m. of the buildings and grounds are cap the existing culvert and Tuesday, October 9, 7:30 p.m. expected to win a high, and pos- keep it underground as storage Tom Perrotta sibly the highest, classification for rainwater runoff. A Haven Kimmel The Abstinence Teacher for environmentally conscious The Used World Friday, October 26, 7:30 p.m. design. ■ INFORMATION Thursday, October 11, 7:30 p.m. With the town aligned along the infamous San Andreas fault, To make a donation to the Town the new Town Hall will also Center fund, go to www.pvtown- GO-GREEN Event house an earthquake-resistant center.com or contact Community Michael Shellenberger/ Vijay Vaitheeswaran Ted Nordhaus Break Through: emergency operations center. Fund volunteers Beth Rabuczewski at 529-9541 or Ms. Reiss at 529- ZOOM:The Global Race to Fuel the From the Death of Environmentalism The fundraising has attracted Car of the Future to the Politics of Possibility 0829. Send e-mail to pvcommu- about $17.5 million in tax- Wednesday, October 10, 7:30 p.m. Monday, October 29, 7:30 p.m. [email protected]. Checks deductible gifts since early 2004, may be sent to SVCF/For the the great majority from Portola Benefit of the Portola Valley Com- Special Family Events! Valley residents, said Commu- munity Fund, 4540 Alpine Road, nity Fund co-chair SallyAnn Portola Valley CA 94028. Diva Night 2007 Explore the World of Books for Kids Reiss. The fund’s Web site lists Tuesday, October 2 DIVA NIGHT Nick Hornby 5:00 p.m. – Drinks, food and mingling 2007 Slam Rodney Smith to be honored by council 6:00 p.m. – Presentations begin Tuesday, October 23, 7:30 p.m. A proclamation to honor Portola the corner of Alpine and Portola Kepler’s and the Menlo Park Library Present: Youth Author Speaker Series at the Menlo Park Library Valley resident Rodney Smith will roads where John’s Valley Foods Youth Writer’s Workshop with Deborah Davis [Ages 13 and up] start off the 8 p.m. Town Council used to be. Warriors Tour with Author Creating Memorable Characters meeting on Wednesday, Sept. 26, The council will also consider a Erin Hunter (aka Victoria Holmes) Thursday, October 25, 7:00 p.m. at the Historic Schoolhouse. resolution approving an agreement Warrior’s Super Edition: Firestar’s Quest With his wife Mary, Mr. Smith with San Francisco-based stream Monday, October 15, 7:00 p.m. was a major donor to the preserva- consultant Phillip Williams & Spook Night with Dave Keane tion of open space in the town. He Associates to come up with a plan Nancy Farmer Saturday, October 27, 6:00 p.m. died May 25, 2007, at the age of 67 to open up about 280 feet of Sausal In the Land of Silver Apples All ages are welcome and costumes Friday, October 19, 7:00 p.m. while cycling on Sand Hill Road Creek at Town Center. are encouraged! after colliding with a car. The council will also engage in The council is also set to hear a discussion on how to raise the a progress report on the Roberts necessary $1 million to pay for the market grocery store planned for creek “daylighting” project. Kepler’s Story Time every Sunday at 11:30 a.m.
October 6th Story Time with Rosemary Wells Creator of the October 21st GO-GREEN Story Time with Madeleine Dunphy Max and Ruby characters, and illustrator for the popular Here Is the Coral Reef Dunphy's books are full of lush, highly Simitian holds ‘town hall’ meetings Mother Goose collections with Iona Opie, she will read from detailed illustrations that bring ecosystems to life and are their newest collaborative effort. must-reads for budding nature lovers. State Sen. Joe Simitian, D-Palo City, 1017 Middlefield Road. ■ October 7th Max and Ruby Story Time Additional Rosemary October 28th Story Time with Jon Agee Alto, will hold “Town Hall” Saturday, Sept. 29, from Wells-themed reading with guest reader Chelsea McNeel. Nothing Don’t be fooled by the title! meetings in Redwood City, Palo 10 a.m. to noon, Palo Alto City This book really is something! San- Alto and Los Altos this week Hall, 250 Hamilton Ave. October 14th Story Time with Chuck Ashton Redwood City Francisco resident and ALA Notable ■ Children’s Librarian, Chuck Ashton will lead our Story Time Book author Jon Agee will read his and next. He invites residents of Thursday, Oct. 4, from 7 to crowd in a romp through classics. latest picture book tale. the 11th Senate District to bring 8:30 p.m., Los Altos City Hall, 1010 El Camino Real, Menlo Park questions, comments, and con- One North San Antonio Road. All events are at Kepler’s unless otherwise noted. www.keplers.com cerns about state government. For more information, call Meeting dates and places: Sen. Simitian’s district office at ■ Thursday, Sept. 27, from 6 (650) 688-6384 or go to www. to 7:30 p.m., City Hall, Redwood senatorsimitian.com . Follow me to Kepler’s. It’s our bookstore.
September 26, 2007 ■ The Almanac ■ 11 Menlo Park’s police force is understaffed and overworked . . .
wirling a cup of coffee in the break room of the Menlo Park Police Department on Sa September afternoon, Felicia Byars is exhausted. A patrol officer on the Menlo Park force for five years, Ms. Byars is nearing the end of her fifth straight day of at least 12 hours on the job. She’s been up since 4:30 a.m., is running on about four hours of sleep, and still has an hour- long drive back to her home in the East Bay. And her week still isn’t over: She picked up a couple of extra shifts, and still has two 12-hour days ahead of her. ➙
Special Report WAITING FOR BACKUP
Report by Rory Brown Almanac Staff Writer
ABOVE: Menlo Park officers, from left, Burke Bruttig, Alan Swanson, Chris Sample and Nick Douglas talk about a motorist pulled over for speeding near Marsh Road and U.S. 101. RIGHT: Officer Douglas pats down the car’s passenger.
Almanac photos by Veronica Weber
12 ■ The Almanac ■ September 26, 2007 COVER STORY
Police Chief Bruce Goitia said the police department is “running out of bodies,” as officers Felicia Byars has been a police officer in Menlo Park for five years, which makes her one of leave Menlo Park to retire or join other law enforcement agencies. the more experienced cops out on patrol.
. . . and more cops are on their way out
➙ “You can’t just leave the streets empty,” Ms. Byars We’re running out of bodies to fill holes.” patchers with two cities to cover. said. “You get tired, you get depressed, but you sign up He added that when officers have to report to court, or for overtime because you have to.” get sick or injured, other officers are forced to come in More departures Overtime has become a must for Ms. Byars and other on their off days. Response times haven’t been affected, Chief Goitia said the city has hired six new officers officers, as an exodus of officers from Menlo Park has left but non-emergency calls aren’t getting the priority they — three new recruits going through the academy, and the force understaffed, overworked, and inexperienced. have in the past, Chief Goitia said. three from other departments — but with impending Thirty officers have left the force since 2004, some The extra hours put in by officers has also come at a retirements and more resignations, the department is through retirement. But 17 of them resigned to join other cost — in the 2006-07 fiscal year, the department paid still a ways from recovering. police agencies, according to a recent city report. Many officers $1.29 million in overtime — 28 percent more “We’ve had some success finding new officers, but in of them have cited a mix of exhaustion, morale problems than what was projected. the case of Terri Molakides, I don’t know how I’m going to and lack of opportunities as their reasons for leaving. The city should have 30 officers on patrol duty, but replace someone with 30 years of experience,” he said. Although a new aggressi ve recruiting effort is under way there are currently only 23, Chief Goitia said. He noted But Menlo Park and other California cities may have with the support of the City Council, Police Chief Bruce that some special units, such as narcotics, code enforce- to get used to more veteran officers leaving their jobs. Goitia said three more officers are expected to transfer to ment, and traffic enforcement, no longer exist, as those A surge in retirements is expected by the year 2012, as other police departments soon, and three more officers, officers have been reassigned to patrol to compensate baby boomers reach retirement eligibility and can cash including Cmdr. Terri Molakides, will retire. for the staffing shortage. in on their pension plans. The current pension benefit Cmdr. Molakides has been with the department for Mr. Poirier said he has worked back-to-back 17 hour offered by the California Public Employees’ Retirement 29 years, and will retire by next May, Chief Goitia said. days, and Ms. Byars said she once worked 23 hours System allows 30-year veterans of police departments Experience is a key concern. The department has 50 straight — not exactly the ideal situation for people who to receive 90 percent of their annual salary after they sworn officers when fully staffed, but that number has need to be alert at all times. retire — a formula in place in Menlo Park. dropped to the low 40s. About 20 current officers have “I don’t have time to work out, I don’t have time to eat In Cmdr. Molakides’ case, she’ll receive $97,000 to less than two years of law enforcement experience, Chief right, and I don’t have time to do the things I’m sup- $122,000 annually after retiring. Goitia said. posed to do when I’m tired,” Ms. Byars said. By 2010, there will be 11,000 to 13,000 police officer The flood of resignations has made officers such as The city’s dispatch unit is also severely understaffed, as openings statewide, according to a recent report co-au- Ms. Byars, with only five years on the force, one of the a recent merger of operations with the city of San Carlos thored by Cmdr. Lacey Burt and Assistant City Manager more experienced officers out on patrol. — a move that was supposed to make it easier to respond Audrey Seymour. “I like catching the bad guys and I like helping people,” to 911 calls — has actually made things more difficult. Ms. Byars said. “This is my home as a police officer, but All of the dispatchers who came from San Carlos Low pay I’m starting to get really tired.” in the merger have resigned, leaving Menlo Park dis- More vacancies and a smaller pool of cops to choose Jason Poirier, an officer who transferred to Menlo from mean that Menlo Park is in fierce competition Park from Brisbane just over a year ago, said he enjoys with departments all over the state to recruit and the overtime, but the department needs more cops. retain officers — not an easy task considering that the “I’m used to working on just a couple hours of sleep, Police problems city doesn’t offer the pay or opportunities of other law so I’ll take on the extra hours,” said Mr. Poirier, a former enforcement agencies. U.S. Marine. “To an extent, overtime is a good thing … The Menlo Park Police Department: Although Menlo Park provides the state’s top pen- but the more time we spend covering shifts, the less time sion benefit, the city aims to be an average payer when ■ we have to train and get experience in other areas.” Has lost 30 officers since 2004. it comes to base salary, meaning there are always other ■ Has 20 officers — about half the force — with less than departments that offer more. Making it work two years of law enforcement experience. “It’s a dog-eat-dog situation in recruiting cops from Thanks to the willingness of cops such as Ms. Byars ■ Has officers that work as many as 25 hours of overtime other agencies,” said Cmdr. Burt. “There are two things and Mr. Poirier, patrol shifts are covered, reports are in a week. cops look for — pay and opportunities. Right now, we written, and the department has been able to respond to ■ Has a dispatch center that is short four officers, aren’t offering much in those areas compared to most emergencies, but with more departures on the horizon, but required to take 911 calls for two cities. other cities, and we’re trying to get creative.” officers are getting burnt out. City Manager Glen Rojas, in an effort to address the ■ “It’s hard to have a stable environment in the police Has no officers assigned to narcotics, code officer shortage, has created a task force of top city offi- department when you have this amount of turnover,” enforcement, or traffic enforcement. cials and police officers to study surrounding depart- Chief Goitia said. “It takes an officer a very short ■ Has officers that commute to Menlo Park from as ments and their wage packages. amount of time to resign, but it takes us a very long time far away as Tracy, Modesto, and Reno. to get someone trained and ready to be in the field. … Continued on next page
September 26, 2007 ■ The Almanac ■ 13 COVER STORY ALLIED ARTS GUILD Open for ELEGANT SHOPPING LOVELY EVENTS
Mon - Sat, 10:00 – 5:00 75 Arbor Road, Menlo Park – at Cambridge –
www.alliedartsguild.org
In Mountain View
At the 7 p.m. briefing, officers discuss assignments before heading out on the night patrol shift. With the department short on staff, some officers who arrive for the 7 a.m. briefing are still hard at work at 7 p.m. Where in three critical years, girls accelerate accredited academically, strengthen self-confidence, by WASC and become leaders—ready to succeed In 2004, the Western Association of Schools and in high school and beyond. Colleges gave GMS away from East Palo Alto — one mutes, a racial discrimination its highest rating. Waiting of the few cities that pay less than lawsuit had been hanging over Menlo Park, Chief Goitia said. the department’s head since for backup October 2006, until the suit was Housing settled earlier this month. The chief said it’s not just lower Three former black officers, Continued from previous page pay that is prompting officers to Keith Butler, Kenneth Clayton leave Menlo Park; the increased and Joe Hinkston, were suing The starting salary for a line-lev- cost of living in the Bay Area is the city for $2 million, alleging el police officer in Redwood City pushing officers to the East Bay that Sgt. Ron Prickett created (one of the highest-paying employ- and Central Valley. a hostile work environment by ers in the Bay Area), for example, “Some officers want to buy a targeting the former officers is $85,980 a year, compared with home for less than half a mil- because they are black. $70,204 a year in Menlo Park, lion dollars,” he said. “You can’t The city agreed to pay YOU’RE INVITED TO ATTEND AN ADMISSIONS OPEN HOUSE: according to data provided by both do that in Menlo Park, and you $165,000 ($55,000 each) to the Sat., November 10 at 1pm or Thurs., December 13 at 7 pm cities’ personnel departments. can’t really do that on this side three former officers, although 650-968-8338, x115 or [email protected] The base salary for Redwood of the Bay.” the city attorney, council mem- City patrol officers is even higher All but two officers live out- bers, and Chief Goitia stressed www.girlsms.org than the $84,680 annual base side Menlo Park city limits, with the decision was made to cut salary for Menlo Park sergeants. some commuting from as far as legal costs, not because the city “Menlo Park has to offer more Tracy, Modesto, and even Reno. was at fault. )&