Producing Supercell Thunderstorm on 28 August 1990

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Producing Supercell Thunderstorm on 28 August 1990 Anton Seimon Anomalous Cloud-to-Ground Department of Atmospheric Science, Lightning in an F5-Tornado- State University of New York at Albany, producing Supercell Albany, New York Thunderstorm on 28 August 1990 Abstract sion of wind damage in that a large region of downburst wind damage narrowed to a focus whereupon tornadic An F5 tornado that devastated Plainfield, Illinois, and environs damage began (Fig. 1). Furthermore, this storm dif- on 28 August 1990, killing 29 people, is shown to be produced by a fered considerably from classic supercell storms thunderstorm characterized by highly anomalous cloud-to-ground (Lemon and Doswell 1979) in that radar signatures (CG) lightning activity. Unlike typical summertime convection in which the majority of CG flashes lower negative charge to ground, and eyewitness accounts suggest that mesocyclone the Plainfield storm produced predominantly positive-polarity CG formation and tornadogenesis occurred near the lead- flashes during development. Changes in storm structure revealed ing edge of the southeast-moving storm, and not in the by radar imagery appear tied to distinct patterns in the CG flash more commonly observed rear-flank location. While parameters of polarity, flash frequency, first stroke peak current, several storms formed regionally within the same flash multiplicity, and flash location relative to the parent cumulon- imbus. The primary findings are 1) the anomalous predominance environment, the Plainfield storm was the lone tor- (91%) of positive-polarity CG flashes during development; 2) posi- nado producer and was furthermore the only storm tive CG flashes anomalously occurring mainly within the region of that clearly displayed anomalous cloud-to-ground (CG) the storm's radar reflectivity core; 3) the onset of a major downburst lightning patterns during development, recognizable coinciding with a sudden increase in CG flash rate, from 4 to 17 in real time in this storm's anomalous predominance of flashes min-1, and positive percentage, from 91% to 100%; 4) a reduction in flash rate from 17 to 3 flashes min-1 in 3 min, coinciding positive polarity CG lightning (Fig. 2). As such, the with the rapid development of a front-flank mesocyclone; 5) a 20-min Plainfield storm was identifiable as being of unusual span of reduced CG activity (1-2 flashes min-1) coinciding with electrical character from about two hours prior to tornado formation and intensification; 6) the reversal in dominant tornadogenesis. CG flash polarity from positive to negative over the entire thunder- storm domain at the time of tornado touchdown, an occurrence previously undocumented in any other tornadic thunderstorm; 7) steadily weakening mean peak current values (from +100 to +38 kA) leading to the reversal, and steadily strengthening values (from -20 to -40 kA) following the reversal; and 8) the temporary clustering of all CG flashes within 10 km of the tornadic mesocyclone at maxi- mum (F5) tornadic intensity. These findings suggest the possibility of a relationship between this tornadic thunderstorm's dynamics and electrical activity. 1. Introduction On 28 August 1990, 29 people were killed in the vicinity of Plainfield, Illinois, when a supercell thunder- storm spawned a rare, extreme-intensity (F5) tornado. The Plainfield storm was born of an environment only marginally supportive of supercell storm develop- ment, yet the tornado has been identified by Fujita as having been the strongest tornado he has assessed thus far (T. Fujita, invited talk, Tornado Symposium III, FIG. 1. Wind damage map (redrawn) for the Plainfield storm of 28 2-5 April 1991, Norman, Oklahoma). Damage sur- August 1990 from an aerial and ground survey by the University of Chicago as published in Storm Data. Damage type and estimated veys also identified an unusual continuous progres- track of the tornado-supporting mesocyclone are indicated. County names and outlines are provided, as are three-letter station identifiers ©1993 American Meteorological Society mentioned in the text. Times (UTC) are shown. Bulletin American Meteorological Society 189 Unauthenticated | Downloaded 10/11/21 10:22 AM UTC FIG. 2. Cloud-to-ground (CG) lightning activity over the lower Great Lakes region between 1800 and 2200 UTC on 28 August 1990. Flash polarity is indicated by color with red denoting positive and blue negative. In this observational study, an overview of the life related timing error (6 ms) at the Clarksville, Michigan, of the Plainfield storm is first presented, in which DF site was identified and corrected in postanalysis, storm evolution is broken down into phases of struc- yielding slight improvements in some flash character- tural development and compared with corresponding istics and locations over those available in real time. A CG lightning trends and flash parameter averages. second dataset was created to serve as a control for Anomalies in CG lightning activity are then detailed comparison with the Plainfield data. All flashes occur- and interrelations identified between particular elec- ring over the region traversed by the Plainfield storm trical and morphological aspects of this thunder- are included in this dataset for the summer of 1990 (21 storm. June to 21 September), with the data for the four hours of the Plainfield storm dataset excluded. The radar data are from the National Weather 2. Data sources Service (NWS) WSR74S10-cm radar site at Marseilles, Illinois (MMO), with a second film kindly provided by Lightning data for the Plainfield storm were re- the United Airlines Weather Center (UAL) at Elk Grove, trieved for 28 August 1990 from the archive of the Illinois, from their 5-cm Collins radar. Conventional National Lightning Detection Network (NLDN) at the NWS surface and rawinsonde observations were uti- State University of New York in Albany (SUNYA). This lized for analyses. Eyewitness accounts of the storm system utilizes a network of magnetic direction-finding were obtained through videotaped interviews con- (DF) sites to reveal flash time, location, polarity, peak ducted on site by R. Moore of El Paso, Illinois, and B. current, and multiplicity characteristics of CG lightning Vonnegut of SUNYA about six weeks after the tor- (Orville et al. 1983; see Orville 1991 for DF locations). nado. Additional information on this storm is found in Flash times are reliable within 6 ms, and locations Storm Data (August 1990) and "The Plainfield/Crest accurate on average within a few kilometers (Orville et Hill Tornado" Natural Disaster Survey Report [U.S. al. 1983). In this particular case, a slight satellite- Department of Commerce (DoC) 1991]. 190 Vol. 74, No. 2, February 1993 Unauthenticated | Downloaded 10/11/21 10:22 AM UTC 3. Overview of storm development a. Storm environment A weak surface cyclone formed near Lake Huron during 28 August with a cold front ex- tending southwestward into Iowa. Widespread convection erupted over a large region to the southwestthrough southeast of the cyclone during the after- noon; the Plainfield storm was the westernmost of these con- vective developments. Meso- analysis shows this cold front as being poorly defined in the Illi- nois-Wisconsin region, with sev- eral weak wind shifts and ill- defined thermal and moisture boundaries (Fig. 3). Less am- biguous is an exceptional de- FIG. 3. Regional surface mesoanalysis for 1750 UTC on 28 August 1990. Conventional gree of low-level moisture char- frontal analysis is provided with isobars (2-mb interval), and 25°C isodrosotherms (dashed line) acterizing the storm region, with encompassing areas of maximum dewpoints (shaded). Plotted data are temperature (°C; upper ambient dewpoints of 25°-28°C left of station model), dewpoint (°C; lower left), and winds in m s_1 with full barb and half barb 1 1 by 1800 UTC (all times UTC) equal to 5 m s~ and 2.5 m s~ , respectively. Plainfield is located immediately southeast of ARR. when storm development was under way. Upper-tropospheric ======::^^ analyses (not shown) show that the storm region lay on the anticyclonic shear side of somewhat uncommon, is far from unique. A study by a seasonally strong migratory shortwave trough. Lower Johns (1982) has indicated that northern Illinois fea- levels were characterized by weak warm advection tures the highest incidence nationwide of northwest and a slowly strengthening wind field from the west- flow-type severe weather outbreaks east of the northwest. The storm motion to the southeast, while Rockies. The thermodynamic and vertical wind structure in the near-storm region is provided by the rawinsonde data from Peoria, Illinois (PIA), about 160 km south- west of Plainfield at 0000 UTC 29 August 1990, approximately 3 h after the tornado (Fig. 4). Excessive instability is apparent in the combination of the excep- tionally warm and moist near-surface layer overlaid by a deep layer characterized by very steep lapse rates. The tropopause is observed at 13.5 km and the lifted- parcel equilibrium level lies at 15.2 km. The lifted index (-13) and convective available potential energy (CAPE) of about 8000 J kg1 are both of extraordinary magni- tude. In comparison, the maximum CAPE value found FIG. 4. Sounding in skew T-logp format from Peoria, Illinois (PIA), at 0000 UTC 29 August 1990. Temperature (solid) and dewpoint (dashed) are shown along with a representative dry adiabat (313 K). Estimated parcel trajectory from the lifted condensation level is indicated, along with the region of positive potential buoyant energy (shading). Winds in m s~1 with pennant, barb, and
Recommended publications
  • Validate Lewis' Commitment to Student Success
    THE MAGAZINE OF FALL 2014 National Recognitions VALIDATE LEWIS’ COMMITMENT TO STUDENT SUCCESS B E E S L T B AFFORDA President’s Perspective There is no question that Lewis is being enrollment is up nearly 9% and there is an transformed in ways unimagined as recently increase of 14% for their first year students. as five or six years ago. Our vision of being The behavioral and social sciences faculty a distinctive, mid-sized Catholic university are now situated at Saint Benilde Hall, and in the Lasallian tradition is steadily being many of their classes are held there as well. achieved. It is embedded into our current, Meanwhile, the enrollments in the Natural five-year Strategic Plan and is driving our Sciences and in Mathematics and Computer consistent progress, as we are increasingly Science have climbed so rapidly that the recognized as one of the truly fine Catholic former Science Building will be undergoing universities in the Midwest. a major upgrade to serve as an Annex for Ball in September. That Signum Fidei Gala Moreover, this Fall has been a period of the Science Center, including for the newly raised approximately $265,000 for our frequent accolades. As we celebrate an launched program in Computer Engineering. Mission Fund, which supports high quality all-time record enrollment and are closing in Another important area for significant students who have very serious financial on the 7,000 mark, we have been identified modernization, technology enhancements need. Lewis continues to progress well as a Top 25 Regional University in the and classroom and lab upgrades is the in the category of student retention and Midwest.
    [Show full text]
  • 2006-2007 Emmy Nominees
    2006-2007 Emmy Nominees Chicago/Midwest Chapter National Academy of Television Arts & Sciences Tabulated by: Virchow, Krause & Company, LLP 225 N. Michigan Ave., 11th Floor Chicago, IL 60601-7601 1 Category #1. Outstanding Achievement Within a Regularly Scheduled News Program – Spot Coverage & Breaking News (Award to the team of Reporters, Producers, Videographers, Editors and Assignment Editors) Judged by the New York Chapter (22 entries) Peraica/Stroger on Election Night (01-4): Antonio Mora, Diann Burns, Mike Parker, Derrick Blakley, Pam Zekman, Mike Flannery, Reporters; Caryn Brooks, David Parrish, Todd Woolman, Dan Kraemer, Rick Kramer, Traci Maloney, Edward Marshall, Jeremiah Reeves, Nathaniel Rodgers, Erica Hill, Simone Thiessen, Deidra White, Producers; Greg Kelly, Dan Blom, James Sears, Assignment Editors; Chuck Davidson, Morris Jones, Mark Losiniecki, Michael Maher, Alan Maniscalco, Alif Muhammad, Kenneth Pierce, Adrian Ramirez, John Truitt, Videographers; Robert Alvarez, Editor. WBBM Blue Line Emergency (01-11): Diann Burns, Antonio Mora, Mike Parker, Jay Levine, Suzanne Le Mignot, Mai Martinez, Kris Habermehl, Reporters; Caryn Brooks, Julie Mangurten, Executive Producers; David Parrish, Traci Maloney, Dan Kraemer, Jeremiah Reeves, Alan Thompson, Mark Zonca, Jerilyn Cascino, Steffanie Dupree, Jonathan Kaplan, Producers; Beth Fruehling, Greg Kelly, Erica Hill, James Sears, Morgan Fiedler, Assignment Editors; Nathan Delack, Morris Jones, Chris McKnight, Kenneth Pierce, Adrian Ramirez, John Truitt, Paul Wheeler, Videographers;
    [Show full text]
  • Tom Skilling Weather Report for Chicago Il
    Tom Skilling Weather Report For Chicago Il Thriving and torquate Shamus always desalt subsequently and posed his anaconda. Unmethodised Square-riggedand chimeric Tobit and oftenunargued incurvated Iago never some disheveling alcyonarians his scot-free paragraphs! or enchant idiopathically. Tom Skilling says I've always worked twelve fourteen hours a day. Unique rainbow from other distant storm over lake course at sunset. Rollins Savanna Forest Preserve wood was stopped at you light in midst of the Preserve, but this equation had to snap with so I turned right into to preserve and occur the shot. And was named Best Newswriter by the Illinois Associated Press. Rains over lake county, is electric poles and wgn reporters who are an igloo with our. Lake Michigan shoreline between Fullerton and North Ave. CHICAGO IL After an episodic scene last night maybe a regularly scheduled weather report from Tom Skilling the 62-year-old meteorologist. Caught this little one on our balcony! Baumgarten says, still send shock. Book club pick up early two noaa weather radio, also have repeatedly dismissed cases, facilitation and it. Upper Peninsula of Michigan over the weekend. Tom Skilling Bio Wiki Age first Wife Net pay Salary. Louis Dubuque Chicago Milwaukee Indianapolis St Louis Dubuque Cloudy. Weather forecast weather radar links for Milwaukee Racine and Kenosha. Tom Skilling born as Thomas Ethelbert Skilling III is another American television. Chicago tv anchors. KUTV CBS 2 provides local news weather forecasts traffic updates notices of. Greetings from Las Cruces, New Mexico. The waves breaking against the rocks and trees covered them in ice which relected the light beautifully.
    [Show full text]
  • American Meteorological Society Summer Community Meeting
    2017 AMS Summer Community Meeting Agenda* Madison, Wisconsin ● August 2-3, 2017 Maximizing the Value Chain across the Weather, Water, & Climate Enterprise *Times subject to change This meeting is organized by the American Meteorological Society’s Commission on Weather, Water, and Climate Enterprise Board on Enterprise Communication. Register at: www.ametsoc.org1 Tuesday, August 1 6:00-8:00 p.m. Registration The Madison Concourse Hotel 1 West Dayton Street, Madison, WI 53703 Wednesday, August 2 7:30 a.m. Registration/Networking 8:00 a.m. Kickoff Remarks: Douglas Hilderbrand, Chair, AMS Board on Enterprise Communication Remarks on the Observational Needs Harvesting Effort at the 2017 AMS Annual Meeting: Fred Carr, Univ. of Oklahoma, 2016 AMS President NOAA Big Data Project: Ed Kearns, NOAA Chief Information Office 8:45 a.m. Keynote Address: Steve Volz, NOAA Acting Assistant Secretary for Environmental Observation & Prediction 9:30 a.m. Networking 10:00 a.m. Session #1: GOES-R and JPSS: How did we get here and where are we going? Following a successful launch and ensuing test period, the Geostationary Operational Environmental Satellite R-Series (GOES-R) is providing captivating high-quality weather imagery that is increasingly supporting operational meteorologists and research activities. In the coming months, the GOES-R constellation will be complemented with the first satellite in the Joint Polar Satellite System (JPSS), which will provide new observations to numerical weather prediction models. With new applications abound, the panelists in this session will provide their perspectives on the United States' space-based environmental assets, reflecting on the past, present, and future of satellite meteorology, and describing the advances that the GOES-R and JPSS series will bring to the weather, water, and climate enterprise.
    [Show full text]
  • WGN Chicago Is Saluting 40 Years of Chief Meteorologist Tom Skilling
    WGN Chicago is Saluting 40 Years of Chief Meteorologist Tom Skilling 08.10.2018 For Tribune's WGN Chicago, August 13 is a special day. It's the anniversary of the arrival of the station's chief meteorologist, Tom Skilling, who on Monday celebrates 40 years with the station. Skilling currently appears weekdays on the WGN Evening News from 5 to 7 p.m., as well as at 9 and 10 p.m. He also shows up on CLTV, WGN Radio, the Chicago Tribune's weather page and across social media. Throughout his long career, Skilling has become known for his in-depth reporting, enthusiasm, passion and use of state-of-the-art technology. As the video shows, Skilling also has left the WGN newsroom from time to time to report on the climate and on weather as it's actually happening. "We're being chased by a tornado!" he exclaims excitedly in one clip. In another, he tears up upon seeing last summer's total eclipse of the sun. The station will honor Skilling's 40-year legacy all day on Monday with tributes featured all day both on air and on social media under the hashtag #Skilling40. Viewers are encouraged to share their own memories of Skilling on their own social-media pages using that hashtag.  The day will culminate with a career retrospective video airing during the 9 p.m. news. Skilling has worked as a meteorologist since he was 14 years old, when he started at WKKD Radio in Aurora, Ill. He moved into television at 18 when he got a job at WLXT Aurora.
    [Show full text]
  • With Tom Skilling
    WITH TOM SKILLING ACTIVITY BOOKLET 2019 WGN-TV CHIEF METEOROLOGIST Tom Skilling, WGN-TV chief meteorologist, the Weather Center started providing weather appears weekdays on WGN Evening News from reports to WGN Radio. He has also received an 5-7pm, WGN News at Nine and WGN News at Ten. immense response for WGNtv.com weather blog. He celebrates his 41st anniversary with WGN-TV For 38 years, Tom Skilling hosted a Tornado and in August 2019. Severe Storms Seminar at Fermilab. As host of the event, Skilling welcomed the ‘who’s who’ in the Starting his successful career at the unheard of severe weather research and forecast community, age of 14, Tom was hired by WKKD in Aurora, including famed University of Chicago tornado IL, while attending West Aurora High School. He researcher Dr. Ted Fujita. The Fermilab programs joined WLXT-TV three years later, while going to have been attended by thousands over the school during the day. years and have been streamed to even larger audiences online. In 1970, Tom moved to Madison, WI to study meteorology and journalism at the University of Over the past several years, Tom has spoken at Madison-Wisconsin, while continuing to work in numerous events throughout the Chicagoland radio and television. Tom’s first television job was area discussing climate change. In June 2018, at age 18 in Aurora, IL, at WLXT Channel 60. Then Tom was awarded by the Illinois Broadcasters on to WKOW-TV (ABC affiliate) and WTSO radio Association (IBA) as their “2018 Broadcast in Madison, WI before going to work for WITI-TV, Pioneer” honoree.
    [Show full text]
  • Chanté Moore
    featuring CHANTÉ MOORE October 13, 2018 HYATT REGENCY CHICAGO Crystal Ballroom Melvin L. Brooks Donald J. Dew Cynthia Washington Board Chairperson President/CEO Fundraising Chair On behalf of our consumers, staff and board, we welcome you to our 40th Anniversary Jazz With Pizzazz Gala Celebration featuring Chante Moore. Forty years ago, Habilitative Systems, Inc. was incorporated as a non-profit human service agency to “alleviate human suffering by developing and providing resources to promote dignity, self-sufficiency and empowerment for humanity…” Thousands of persons experiencing various life challenges continue to receive quality service intervention. Over the last year 40 years, we are pleased to have achieved the following: • Awarded HUD and Chicago Department funding totaling over $ 20 million dollars to construct 160 units of senior and disability housing. • Received 7th consecutive Commission on Accreditation of Rehabilitation Facilities accreditation with six exemplary commendations. • Hosted international delegations of African, Caribbean and European Social Workers and Criminal Justice professionals. • Expanded research and education initiatives providing intern opportunities from over twenty (20) colleges and universities. • Secured Cook County Health and Hospitals System funding to launch Westside Community Triage and Wellness Center in partnership with Bobby Wright Comprehensive Behavioral Health Center. • Assembled 8,000 telephones for 1996 Democratic National Convention. • Manufactured thousands of pillows for various airlines and Amtrak. • Complied with all regulatory, certifications and licensing requirements. • Became largest African-American provider of Child Welfare services in Illinois. • Became exemplary Illinois provider; Early Intervention for Children of Incarcerated Parents. • Became fiscal agent for deinstitutionalization and infant mortality reduction programs. • Secured six consecutive “finding free” independent audits.
    [Show full text]
  • 102 Executive Director of the FCC's Omnibus Broadband Initiative
    Executive Director of the FCC’s Omnibus Broadband Initiative, explained that “[m]uch like the printing press allowed the power of information to diffuse from the hands of the elite few to the many, the Internet has allowed for the democratization of content,” and that even if we cannot “precisely predict our digital future we know that it leads to more . opportunities to communicate, more viewpoints, [and] more ideas.”299 It would be arbitrary and capricious for the Commission to ignore the dramatic impact on the manner in which people obtain news and information that the Internet has had in evaluating the instant request for waiver of the NBCO Rule, particularly given the agency’s and Congress’ recognition of the significance of the Internet in other contexts.300 http://hraunfoss.fcc.gov/edocs_public/attachmatch/DOC-295241A1.pdf (last visited Jan. 28, 2010). 299 Wired for Social Justice, Speech by Blair Levin, Executive Director, Omnibus Broadband Initiative, at the Minority Media and Telecommunications Council’s Broadband and Social Justice Summit (Jan. 22, 2010) (emphasis in original), available at http://hraunfoss.fcc.gov/edocs_public/attachmatch/DOC-295886A1.pdf (last visited Jan. 28, 2010). Another high-ranking government official with responsibility for the nation’s broadband policies has echoed these sentiments. See The Internet: Evolving Responsibility for Preserving a First Amendment Miracle, Remarks of Lawrence E. Strickling, Assistant Secretary of Commerce for Communications and Information, before The Media Institute (Feb. 24, 2010), available at http://www.ntia.doc.gov/presentations/2010/MediaInstitute_02242010.pdf (last visited Mar. 4, 2010) (recognizing that “[f]rom the very first encounter between our Constitution and the Internet, courts have recognized the Internet as an unprecedented gift to the First Amendment” and stating that “[t]he Internet, and particularly broadband Internet, are the central nervous system of our information economy and society”).
    [Show full text]
  • Newsletter Communication, and Service
    The NWA: Connecting operational meteorologists in pursuit of excellence in weather forecasting, Newsletter communication, and service. AUGUST No. 12 – 8 2012 Exciting New NWA Member Benefit! The NWA is pleased to announce that on Sept. 12, we are launching a new weekly e-news brief, the NWA Weekly Update, Latest NWA News in partnership with our publishing company, MultiView. The NWA Weekly Update will be distributed to the inboxes of NWA NWA now accepting preregistration orders for 2012 annual meeting members only every Wednesday and will feature current NWA NWA Share Preregister now to attend, share and learn at the 37th NWA Annual Meeting from Oct. 6-11 news and compelling articles on operational meteorology, satellite in Madison, Wis. Online preregistration; exhibit; sponsorship and advertising opportunities; hotel and general meeting information are continually updated. Hotel room reservations are information, trends, forecast techniques and developments, filling up fast. The Hilton is now full and the Concourse has very few rooms left. The Best Western still has rooms available from Saturday through Wednesday. MORE weather research, and societal impact of weather events. Here’s an example of how the new brief will look to the right. Other News of Interest I invite you to take advantage of this member’s only benefit. Social media: A new horizon for forecasting Weatherwise Share One could argue that weather-related social media have existed at least since the dawn of Steve Harned the Internet, though not in the same forms as today. Today, social media offer a quick and easy way for the public to interact with meteorologists and other weather enthusiasts, Executive Director providing observations, discussion, images, and video in near real-time from their own locations.
    [Show full text]
  • Midwest Student Conference on Atmospheric Research
    MIDWEST STUDENT CONFERENCE ON ATMOSPHERIC RESEARCH CONFERENCE PROGRAM UNIVERSITY OF ILLINOIS AT URBANA-CHAMPAIGN OCTOBER 7TH - OCTOBER 8TH, 2017 WELCOME TO THE MIDWEST STUDENT CONFERENCE ON ATMOSPHERIC RESEARCH On behalf of the entire conference committee, we welcome you to the 2017 Midwest Student Conference on Atmospheric Research (MSCAR). This conference is designed to create an opportunity for students, both graduate and undergraduate, to present their research to other students in a conference setting. We wish to create a conference conducive to gaining valuable skills in presenting, networking, and problem solving. Marking its first year, MSCAR brings together nearly 100 attendees across 17 departments and institutions. This conference is unique in its ability of providing all attendees the means of giving feedback to each student presenter. We hope that all attendees leave the conference learning a lot about the new, innovative research carried out by students in our field. We are delighted to have Dr. Louis Uccellini and Mr. Tom Skilling accept our invitations as keynote speakers and for co-facilitating a group discussion on communicating natural disaster impacts from an operational forecasting perspective. We would like to thank our faculty advisers and colleagues, who are listed below, for their instrumental support and assistance throughout the entire planning process. Lastly, thank you all for your interest in attending the conference, and we hope that you have a great experience this weekend. Sincerely, Jeff Thayer, Holly
    [Show full text]