Wilderness Litigation State Wilderness in US Wilderness Restoration Mexico, Europe INTERNATIONAL Journal of Wilderness APRIL 2008 VOLUME 14, NUMBER 1
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Wilderness Litigation State Wilderness in US Wilderness Restoration Mexico, Europe INTERNATIONAL Journal of Wilderness APRIL 2008 VOLUME 14, NUMBER 1 FEATURES SCIENCE AND RESEARCH, continued EDITORIAL PERSPECTIVES PERSPECTIVES FROM THE ALDO LEOPOLD 3 Wilderness Is on the Move! WILDERNESS RESEARCH INSTITUTE BY VANCE G. MARTIN 32 Wilderness Restoration From Philosophical Questions about Naturalness to SOUL OF THE WILDERNESS Tests of Practical Techniques 4 The Need for Wilderness Litigation BY DAVID N. COLE BY JON DETTMANN EDUCATION AND COMMUNICATION STEWARDSHIP 33 El Triunfo RAVE: Rapid Assessment Visual Expedition 7 U.S. Forest Service Litigation BY JAIME ROJO The Wilderness Act and Wild and Scenic Rivers Act: 1989–2004 BY ROBERT W. MALMSHEIMER, CORALINE FALCO, INTERNATIONAL PERSPECTIVES AMANDA M. ANDERSON, DENISE M. KEELE, and 38 PAN Parks Perspectives for a Wilder Europe DONALD W. FLOYD BY VLADO VANCURA, ZOLTÁN KUN, and MYLÈNE VAN DER DONK 15 Wilderness and Accessibility BY JANET A. ZELLER WILDERNESS DIGEST 19 State-designated Wilderness in the United States: 43 Announcements A National Review BY BLAKE M. PROPST and CHAD P. DAWSON 47 Book Reviews 47 American Wilderness: A New History 25 Searching for Solitude in the Wilderness EDITED BY MICHAEL LEWIS of Southeast Alaska Reviewed by John Shultis BY MARY EMERICK and DAVID N. COLE 48 Rebel on the Road: And Why I Was Never Neutral BY MICHAEL FROME Reviewed by John Shultis SCIENCE AND RESEARCH 28 Risk Factors for Coliform Bacteria in Sierra Nevada Mountain Wilderness Lakes and Streams BY ROBERT W. DERLET, JAMES R. CARLSON, and JOHN R. RICHARDS On the Cover FRONT: Resplendent Quetzal (Pharomachrus DISCLAIMER mocinno) male at nest hole—Rapid Assessment The Soul of the Wilderness column and all invited and fea- Visual Expedition (RAVE), El Triunfo Biosphere tured articles in IJW, are a forum for controversial, inspiring, or Reserve, Sierra Madre range, Chiapas, Mexico. especially informative articles to renew thinking and dialogue Photo © Thomas Mangelsen among our readers. The views expressed in these articles are those of the authors. IJW neither endorses nor rejects them, but invites comments from our readers. INSET: Coffee worker in Ejido Santa Rita, El Triunfo Biosphere Reserve. Photo © Patricio Robles Gil —John C. Hendee IJW Editor-in-Chief International Journal of Wilderness The International Journal of Wilderness links wilderness professionals, scientists, educators, environmentalists, and interested citizens worldwide with a forum for reporting and discussing wilderness ideas and events; inspirational ideas; planning, management, and allocation strategies; education; and research and policy aspects of wilderness stewardship. EDITORIAL BOARD Perry Brown, University of Montana, Missoula, Mont., USA H. Ken Cordell, Southern Research Station, U.S. Forest Service, Athens, Ga., USA Troy Hall, University of Idaho, Moscow, Idaho, USA Vance G. Martin, WILD Foundation, Boulder, Colo., USA Rebecca Oreskes, White Mountain National Forest, Gorham, N.H., USA John Shultis, University of Northern British Columbia, Prince George, B.C., Canada Alan Watson, Aldo Leopold Wilderness Research Institute, Missoula, Mont., USA EDITOR-IN-CHIEF John C. Hendee, Professor Emeritus, University of Idaho Wilderness Research Center, Moscow, Idaho, USA MANAGING EDITOR Chad P. Dawson, SUNY College of Environmental Science and Forestry, Syracuse, N.Y., USA ASSOCIATE EDITORS—INTERNATIONAL Gordon Cessford, Department of Conservation, Wellington, New Zealand; Karen Fox, University of Alberta, Edmonton, Alberta, Canada; Andrew Muir, Wilderness Foundation Eastern Cape, South Africa; Ian Player, South Africa National Parks Board and The Wilderness Foundation, Howick, Natal, Republic of South Africa; Vicki A. M. Sahanatien, Fundy National Park, Alma, Canada; Won Sop Shin, Chungbuk National University, Chungbuk, Korea; Anna-Liisa Sippola, University of Lapland, Rovaniemi, Finland; Franco Zunino, Associazione Italiana per la Wilderness, Murialdo, Italy. ASSOCIATE EDITORS—UNITED STATES Greg Aplet, The Wilderness Society, Denver, Colo.; David Cole, Aldo Leopold Wilderness Research Institute, Missoula, Mont.; John Daigle, University of Maine, Orono, Maine; Lisa Eidson, University of Montana, Missoula, Mont.; Joseph Flood, East Carolina University, Greenville, N.C.; Lewis Glenn, Outward Bound USA, Garrison, N.Y.; Gary Green, University of Georgia, Athens, Ga.; Glenn Haas, Colorado State University, Fort Collins, Colo.; William Hammit, Clemson University, Clemson, S.C.; Dave Harmon, Bureau of Land Management, Portland, Oreg.; Bill Hendricks, California Polytechnic State University, San Luis Obispo, Calif.; Greg Kroll, El Rito, N.M.; Ed Krumpe, University of Idaho, Moscow, Idaho; Yu-Fai Leung, North Carolina State University, Raleigh, N.C.; Jim Mahoney, Bureau of Land Management, Sierra Vista, Ariz.; Bob Manning, University of Vermont, Burlington, Vt.; Jeffrey Marion, Virginia Polytechnic Institute, Blacksburg, Va.; Leo McAvoy, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, Minn.; Michael McCloskey, Sierra Club; Christopher Monz, St. Lawrence University, Canton, N.Y.; Connie Myers, Arthur Carhart Wilderness Training Center, Missoula, Mont.; Roderick Nash, University of California, Santa Barbara, Calif.; David Ostergren, Northern Arizona University, Flagstaff, Ariz.; Joe Roggenbuck, Virginia Polytechnic Institute, Blacksburg, Va.; Holmes Rolston III, Colorado State University, Ft. Collins, Colo.; Keith Russell, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, Minn.; Tod Schimelpfenig, National Outdoor Leadership School, Lander, Wyo.; Rudy Schuster, SUNY-ESF, Syracuse, N.Y.; Michael Tarrant, University of Georgia, Athens, Ga.; Elizabeth Thorndike, Cornell University, Ithaca, N.Y.; Dave White, Arizona State University, Tempe, Ariz. International Journal of Wilderness (IJW) publishes three issues per year Submissions: Contributions pertinent to wilderness worldwide are (April, August, and December). IJW is a not-for-profit publication. solicited, including articles on wilderness planning, management, and allocation strategies; wilderness education, including descriptions of Manuscripts to: Chad P. Dawson, SUNY-ESF, 320 Bray Hall, One Forestry key programs using wilderness for personal growth, therapy, and envi- Drive, Syracuse, NY 13210, USA. Telephone: (315) 470-6567. Fax: (315) ronmental education; wilderness-related science and research from all 470-6535. E-mail: [email protected]. disciplines addressing physical, biological, and social aspects of wilder- ness; and international perspectives describing wilderness worldwide. Business Management and Subscriptions: The WILD Foundation, Articles, commentaries, letters to the editor, photos, book reviews, P.O. Box 20527, Boulder, CO 80308, USA. Telephone: (303) 442-8811. Fax: announcements, and information for the wilderness digest are encour- (303) 442-8877. E-mail: [email protected]. aged. A complete list of manuscript submission guidelines is available from the website: www.ijw.org. Subscription rates (per volume calendar year): Subscription costs are in U.S. dollars only—$35 for individuals and $55 for organizations/ libraries. Artwork: Submission of artwork and photographs with captions are Subscriptions from Canada and Mexico, add $10; outside North America, encouraged. Photo credits will appear in a byline; artwork may be add $20. Back issues are available for $15. signed by the author. All materials printed in the International Journal of Wilderness, copyright Website: www.ijw.org. © 2008 by the International Wilderness Leadership (WILD) Foundation. Individuals, and nonprofit libraries acting for them, are permitted to make Printed on recycled paper. fair use of material from the journal. ISSN # 1086-5519. SPONSORING ORGANIZATIONS Aldo Leopold Wilderness Research Institute • Conservation International • National Outdoor Leadership School (NOLS) • Outward Bound™ • SUNY College of Environmental Science and Forestry • The WILD® Foundation • The Wilderness Society • University of Idaho Wilderness Research Center • University of Montana, School of Forestry and Wilderness Institute • USDA Forest Service • USDI Bureau of Land Management • USDI Fish and Wildlife Service • USDI National Park Service • Wilderness Foundation (South Africa) • Wilderness Leadership School (South Africa) FEATURES EDITORIAL PERSPECTIVES Wilderness Is on the Move! BY VANCE G. MARTIN he year 2008 holds exciting prospects for wilder- Nahanni National Park to ness internationally, with progress already protect mountains and karst- Thappening or imminent in many countries. lands totalling about 33,000 The U.S. presidential race is the most diverse and sq km; a new national park exciting in decades. Because of the many domestic wilder- on the East Arm of Great ness bills held in abeyance during the past eight years, or Slave Lake of 33,000 sq km; others simply in process, if the voters opt for change we Ramparts National Wildlfe may well see significant progress on U.S. wilderness in the Area, 15,000 sq km to pro- next few years. tect wetlands for migratory The potential for wilderness in the United States and birds; and the sacred lands of elsewhere is also driven by the increased attention to cli- Sahoue Edacho peninsulas mate change and global warming. Large wilderness areas in Great Bear Lake of 8,500 have an important place in this debate, because of their sq km. Designated wilder- Vance G. Martin key role in stabilizing, moderating, and regulating plane- ness in a matrix of protected tary climate. One of the best examples