The Planning Inspectorate Appendix 3

______An Ererutite .•I ç’z,ir m~’DrpzV77nem~ufTh& ~EiIVhUII)??rl?! am! the Welsh Office )~ :Z≥\ Vi Ruom 1405 Line 0272-878902

C ToIh!ale Ilotise r ~. - Swhehhourd 0272—878811

- Hotiltt~n Street Fax N” 0272-878769

Bristol 13S2 QflI . 1374-8q02

County Planning Officer Your REf: YGBLP 4.2 MFS/MO

North Yorkshire County Cou~cil . .

County Hall . Our Ref: PINSM/D2700/429/3

Northallerton . - DL7 SAC Date: .10 November 1994

Dear Sir

YORK GREEN BELT LOCAL PLAN - LAND TO THE NORTH WEST OF EASTWICK VILLAGE

Thank you for you letter of 12 october requesting clarification of an aspect of Inspector’s report into objections to the above Local Plan.

The matter has been raised with the Inspector and we have now received his observations. The following answers on the points raised by your letter are based on comments received from the Inspector.

The Green Belt Local Plan included the whole of the existing village in the Green Belt, whereas the Southern Local Plan excluded it. Both Plans excluded the area to the North of the Village at Fosslands Farm in order to allow new developemnt there.

In essence the Inspectors recommendations to both Council’s were that both the existing village and the area of proposed new development should be omitted from the Green Belt. The Inspector also recommended that the boundaries shown in the Deposit Plans should be modified in respect of the area shown for new development.

As far as the land to the north west of the existing village is concerned, there was an objection to the exclusion of the village as a whole from the Green Belt in the Southern Ryedale Local Plan, but not the exclusion of this specific site. The Inspectors recommendation in respect of the village as a whole was that the village should continue to be excluded from the Green Belt (Paragraph 529.4). As far as the Green Belt Local Plan is concerned, a Proposed Change was published (No 16) by the County Council to “insert Earswick within the Green Belt”. The Inspectors recommendation was that the Plan should be modified as set out in that Proposed Change. He was unaware that a plan accompanied the advertised Proposed Changes showing the precise boundaries referred to and differing from the boundaries shown in the Southern Ryedale Local Plan. He therefore expressed no opinion as to whether Llz~ idild in question should be included in the Green Belt or the village inset as he was unaware of any dispute relating to this point.

As the Inspector indicated in the introductory letters to each Report, if the Green Belt is to continue to be shown in both Local Plans this must be done in a consistent manner. Under these circumstances, and bearing in mind the planning permission recently granted by Ryedale District Council, he recommends that the Modification to the Green Belt Local Plan should exclude from the Green Belt the area of the existing village as shown on the Deposit version of the Southern Ryedale Local Plan.

Yours fa C~rn

C N Pritchard Developments Plans Appendix 4

MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC COMMENTING ON SITE D50 LAND AT REAR OF SOUTHFIELDS, STRENSALL

REF NO SURNAME MRJMRSIMISS INITIALS

0011 WOODALL MRS R.J. 0012 DOBSON F.P. 0013 NAYLOR MR&MRS D. 0014 THOMPSON MRMRS R. 0015 SIMPSON MR&MRS J.& G. 0016 SPAYNE MR M. 0017 COLES MR&MRS T.& .J. 0018 DARLINGTON B. 0019 THOMPSON MR&MRS J.M. 0020 THOMPSON MRS R.R. 0021 BEAN MR M.C. 0022 CLARK MR F.D. 0023 HOPWOOD MR&MRS P.R. 0024 ROBINSON MRS S. 0025 LOCKWOOD C. 0026 HART E.M. 0029 LEFF PROF. G. 0030 ALDERSON MRS M. 0031 MILNER MRS S. 0034 PICKARD S. 0035 RICHARDSON S.J. 0036 BERRY MR&MRS P. 0037 SCOTT MRS J.Y. 0038 MANLEY B.& P. 0039 WATSON MR T.C. 0040 LEEDHAM MRS P. 0041 BARRETT MRS M..J. 0042 HALEY MR&MRS R.& M. 0043 STAUNTON S. 0044 STUBBS MR K. 0045 BIRD DR L.M. 0046 SHARPE MR&MRS G. 0047 RILEY MR M. 0048 DOLLING MR N. 0049 PRIESTLY A.V. 0050 SLATER DR C.A. 0051 NURSE MRS R. 0052 CLARKE MRS R.M. 0053 ROBERTSON MR K.D. 0054 SCOTT MR&MRS J. 0055 LITTLE REV D. 0056 CALVERT MR&MRS G.O. 0057 LEWIS MAJ. E.W. 0058 GREER MRS M. 0059 WELLBURN MR K. 0060 WRAGG MR&MRS D. 0061 GOWTHORPE MRS M. 0062 HAMPSHIRE MRS J.M. 0065 BRIGGS J. 0066 BIRCH MRS D.M. 0074 PLANT R. 0077 WILSON MISS I.E. 0082 REID J.M. 0083 REEDER R. 0084 HEARLD MR&MRS G.E. 0091 WILLIAMSON MRS J.E. REF NO SURNAME MRIMRSIMISS INITIALS

0092 BOYES MRS J.F. 0093 SIIUTT MRS M. 0094 BUCKLAND MRS J. 0095 BUCKLAND MR D.L. 0096 CLARKE MRS A.E. 0097 DAVISON MRS M. 0098 METCALFE MRS R.M. 0099 CUNNINGHAM MR&MRS M.& R. 0100 SHOUKSMITH MRS R.P. 0101 WILEMAN MR&MRS B.& W. 0102 BEAN MR&MRS A.& B. 0103 BOWLBY MR J.

0104 CURTIS . MRS D. 0106 BENSON MR M. 0122 HOBSON J. 0123 HALL C.H. 0124 THORPE MISS C. 0125 BAXTER D. 0126 BAXANDALL G.A. 0127 BAXANDALL A.J. 0128 THORPE MRS W. 0129 THORPE MR P. :‘~ SELBY ~VALE~

Selby District Council CMC centre, rodhotifle goad, Selby, North yorishire, VOS aSS. Tui: 01Th7 705101. DX 27408 Salby

please ask sort MR T BESELTON your Ret: Dial Direct No: 01757 292091 Our Raft TRH/CBB/S0/C~ 12/10 - Fax No: 01757 292090 sp2/1

30 March 1995 C0bWY ~~

N’ J 0 Renflhl~°~ county planning Of ficer North Yorkshire county Council D~.SS TO CountY flail 4 N0RTB~LERTO~ North Yorkshire

Dear Mr ReflflilSQfl

STRUCT~ PLAN THIRD P1flRATION -~ YORE GREEN BELT LOOP1 PLAN ~01iOWing the special meeting of the Planning co~±tte8 on 23 March 1995 I am writing to draw your attefltl0fl. to t~ specific resolutions prior to the CountY planning ~eeting on 3’ March 1995• These are as fo1loWS~ istrict L0ca1 P18fl “That the District council proceed with full consultatbOfl and progress the plan, as it relates to the ~~jstiflg adwin15t~t~~ area of SeTh)’ District, to deposit prior to i April 1996. ~oca1Pla

That the attention of the County planning Officer be drawn to the dIffi0ult~eS of 6doptiflg the York Green Belt Local plan in view of the advice contained within ppG2 and that he be advised that council considers the needs of the area would be best senred if final adopti0fl of the Plan was undertaken by the new

- Greater York Council.”

continued 0—03—95 10:40 SL)C tnglneers ~ o. ~O~~jO~J A

30 March 1995 Cant! 2

I would be grateful if these resolutions can be drawn to Members attention. Both resolutions are subject to consideration by special Policy and Finance Committee on 30 March~ 4995 and Full Council on 13 April 1995.

Yours sincerely

Department Services