DOCSLIB.ORG

A Quantitative Approach to Linguistic Model Validation

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
A Quantitative Approach to Linguistic Model Validation A Quantitative Approach to Linguistic Model Validation Ph.D. Thesis by LEE PICK PANG INSTITUTE OF EDUCATION UNIVERSITY OF LONDON 1989 DECLARATION I hereby declare that this thesis represents my own work and that it has not been previously submitted to this university or other institutions in application for a degree, diploma or other qualification. Table of Contents Table of Contents Abstract Acknowledgements iii Initial Influences, Objectives & The Methodology of The Study 1.1 Introduction 1 1.2 Current state of linguistics and applied linguistics . 1 1.3 The domain of the research 3 1.4 Objectives of the present research project . 4 1.5 Delimitations of the study 5 1.5.1 Text and discourse 5 1.5.2 Text structure 7 1.5.3 The reading process 8 1.5.4 Scope of the Study . 8 Alternative Models of Text Analysis 2.1 Introduction . .. .10 2.2 The Tagmemic approach . 11 2.2.1 Overview . .11 2.2.2 Meyer (1975) . 14 2.2.3 Clements (1979) . 15 2.3 Schema Theory .. 16 2.3.1 Overview .. 16 2.3.2 Schema 17 2.3.3 Script . .18 2.3.4 Frame . 18 2.3.5 Observations .19 Table of Contents 2.4 Text Linguistics 20 2.4.1 van Dijk 20 2.4.2 de Beaugrande & Dressler 21 2.4.3 Specimen text analysis 22 2.4.4 Observations 23 2.5 Text Signalling Approach . ..... 24 2.5.1 Clause relation & signalling devices . 24 2.5.2 Discourse pattern 26 The Text Analysis Approach Adopted 3.1 Introduction 28 3.2 Criteria for choice 29 3.2.1 Being text-based . .. 29 3.2.2 Being codable . .. 29 3.2.3 Surface textual features . 30 3.3 Evaluation of the text analysis approaches 30 3.3.1 The Schema approach . 30 3.3.2 Text Linguistics . .. 32 3.3.3 The Tagmemic approach . 33 3.3.4 Text Signalling approach 34 3.4 Conclusion .... 34 Statistical Discussion: An Introduction to the Research Methods 4.1 Introduction 36 4.2 The nature of the data to be collected and the method of analysis 36 4.2.1 Scientific research 36 4.2.2 Quantitative and qualitative research 38 4.3 Sources of behavioural data 44 Table of Contents 4.4 Relevance to the present research . 46 4.5 Repertory Grid Analysis • .... 47 4.5.1 Personal Construct Psychology and Repertory Grid Analysis 47 4.5.2 Characteristics of Repertory Grid Analysis . 48 4.6 The general characteristics of Repertory Grid Analysis . 50 4.6.1 General outline . 50 4.6.2 Repertory Grid Analysis and linguistics . 51 4.6.3 Identification of the Elements 51 4.6.4 Specification of the Constructs 52 4.6.5 Configuration of the constructs 53 4.7 Comparison of repertory grid analysis methods 53 4.7.1 Introduction . 53 4.7.2 Repertory grid analysis methods 54 4.7.3 Theoretical and statistical considerations 56 4.8 An Empirical Investigation . 59 4.8.1 The text ..... 59 4.8.2 Methods of analysis . 59 4.9 Generating the Theoretical Grid . 59 4.9.1 The constructs . 59 4.9.2 The grid .. 60 4.10 Analysis Using FOCUS . 60 4.10.1 Cluster Analysis . 60 4.10.2 Data display . 62 4.10.3 The Spaced Focus grid . 62 4.10.4 Comments on FOCUS . 65 4.11 Analysis using INGRID . 66 4.11.1 Principal component analysis . 66 4.11.2 Observations . .69 4.12 Conclusion 70 Table of Contents Implementing Repertory Grid Analysis 5.1 Introduction 72 5.2 The implementation of repertory grid analysis 72 5.2.1 Elicitation of the grid 73 5.2.1.a Identification of elements 73 5.2.1.b Specification of constructs 73 5.2.2 Repertory grid analysis using INGRID 74 5.2.3 INGRID 75 5.2.4 The other programs 76 5.3 The Pre-pilot study 77 5.3.1 Introduction 77 5.3.2 The Study 78 5.3.2.a The Experimental Subjects 78 5.3.2.b The Grid . 78 5.3.2.c The Experiment 80 5.3.2.d The Results 81 5.3.3 Observations 82 5.4 The Pilot Study .... 84 5.4.1 Objectives . . 84 5.4.2 The design . . 84 5.4.3 The sample . . 85 5.4.4 The texts . .... 85 5.4.5 The constructs ... 86 5.4.6 The theoretical grids . 87 5.4.7 The triads . . 88 5.4.8 The experiment ... 88 5.4.8.a Organizing the experimental sessions . 88 5.4.8.b Conducting the experimental sessions . 88 5.4.8.c Analysing the grids .. 89 Table of Contents 5.4.9 Results 89 5.4.9.a Aim of this section . 89 5.4.9.b Construct elicitation through triads . 89 5.4.9.c Comparison with the theoretical grid . 92 5.4.10 Observations 96 5.4.10.a Target element identifications 96 5.4.10.b Comparison with the theoretical grid 97 5.4.10.c Analysis of individual subject grids 97 5.4.11 Conclusion 98 The Experiment and Further Research Design Issues 6.1 Introduction 99 6.2 The Experimental Procedure 99 6.2.1 The population and the sample 99 6.2.2 Grid elicitation . .. 101 6.2.3 The analysis design 102 6.2.3.a The overall approach • 102 6.2.3.b Quantitative analysis • 103 6.2.3.c Qualitative analysis 104 6.2.4 The experimental sessions 105 6.3 The Analysis 107 6.3.1 Introduction . 107 6.3.2 Repertory Grid Analysis 107 6.3.3 Quantitative Analysis 109 6.3.4 Qualitative Analysis 110 Table of Contents RESULTS I - Individual Perception 7.1 Introduction 114 7.1.1 Scope of the presentation 114 7.1.2 Repertory grid analysis 115 7.2 The INGRID output .115 7.3 The Theoretical Grids .116 7.3.1 The Helicopter text • 116 7.3.1.a Overview of the statistics . 116 7.3.1.b Sums of squares . 118 7.3.1.c Descriptive statistics . 119 7.3.1.d Principal component analysis . 120 7.3.1.e Issues relating to principal component analysis . 122 7.3.1.f The Bartlett test . 124 7.3.1.g Principal component analysis for the Helicopter text 125 7.3.1.h Observations . 126 7.3.2 The Computer text 128 7.3.2.a Observations . 133 7.4 Case studies of subject grids .... 136 7.4.1 Introduction ...... 136 7.4.2 Case 1 . 137 7.4.3 Case 2 . 145 7.4.4 Case 3 . 153 7.4.5 Case 4 . 158 7.4.6 Case 5 . 164 7.4.7 Observations ..... 169 Table of Contents 7.5 Qualitative Analysis 171 7.5.1 Introduction 171 7.5.2 Case 1 173 7.5.3 Case 2 174 7.5.4 Case 3 . 175 7.5.5 Case 4 .... 176 7.5.6 Case 5 177 7.5.7 Observations 179 RESULTS 2 - Theoretical & Subject Grid Agreement 8.1 Introduction 182 8.2 Theoretical grid and subject grid agreement 183 8.2.1 Matching the constructs 183 8.2.2 Indices of agreement between constructs Correlation and Angular distances . 184 8.2.3 Statistics on construct correlations & angular distances Introductory remarks . 185 8.2.4 Descriptive statistics . 187 8.2.5 The extent of theory-subject agreement . 190 8.3 Subject consensus . 193 8.3.1 Introduction . 193 8.3.2 Overall results . 194 8.3.3 The Helicopter text .. 196 8.3.4 The Computer text . 201 8.3.5 Observations .... 205 Table of Contents 8.4 ANOVA 206 8.4.1 Introduction 206 8.4.2 The Results 208 8.4.2.a Overall results 208 8.4.2.b Detailed results for main effects 210 8.4.2.c Interaction effects 211 8.4.3 Observations 216 8.5 Observations on theory-subject agreement 216 Conclusions & Implications for Future Research 9.1 Introduction 218 9.2 The methodological investigation 219 9.2.1 Introduction 219 9.2.2 Review of the field of text analysis and the choice of the linguistic model . 220 9.2.3 Discussion and choice of an analytic technique . 221 9.2.4 The pilot studies . .. 222 9.2.4.a The pre-pilot study . 222 9.2.4.b The pilot study . 223 9.2.5 The main study . 224 9.3 Principal findings 226 9.3.1 Introduction 226 9.3.2 Repertory grid analysis 226 9.3.2.a the choice of elements and constructs 227 9.3.2.b The construct elicitation technique 228 9.3.2.c Principal component analysis 229 Table of Contents 9.3.3 The Winter-Hoey model . 231 9.3.3.a What has been validated . 231 9.3.3.b Problems with the Winter-Hoey model . 233 9.3.3.c To what extent is the Winter-Hoey model not validated? . 234 9.3.3.d Conditions for adequacy of linguistic model validation: . 235 9.3.4 Some special issues 236 9.3.4.a Text patterning and text signalling constructs 236 9.3.4.b The text structure as analysed by a quantitative method . 237 9.3.4.c Observations . 238 9.4 Implications for future research . 239 9.4.1 Introduction . 239 9.4.2 Repertory grid analysis . 239 9.4.2.a Element and construct specification . 240 9.4.2.b Construct elicitation technique . 241 9.4.2.c Principal component analysis . 242 9.4.3 The Winter-Hoey model .
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Developing Competency Model Using Repertory Grid Technique: the Case of Spinning Master
    The Qualitative Report Volume 22 Number 3 Article 14 3-26-2017 Developing Competency Model Using Repertory Grid Technique: The Case of Spinning Master Praveen Kumar Srivastava Pune Institute of Business Management, [email protected] Bhavna Jaiswal IBS Hyderabad, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://nsuworks.nova.edu/tqr Part of the Performance Management Commons, Quantitative, Qualitative, Comparative, and Historical Methodologies Commons, and the Social Statistics Commons Recommended APA Citation Srivastava, P. K., & Jaiswal, B. (2017). Developing Competency Model Using Repertory Grid Technique: The Case of Spinning Master. The Qualitative Report, 22(3), 895-914. https://doi.org/10.46743/ 2160-3715/2017.2530 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the The Qualitative Report at NSUWorks. It has been accepted for inclusion in The Qualitative Report by an authorized administrator of NSUWorks. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Developing Competency Model Using Repertory Grid Technique: The Case of Spinning Master Abstract This paper aims to develop the Competency Model using Repertory Grid Technique. 15 Spinning Master of a large textile company in India were interviewed using repertory grid technique. The study identified 9 competencies in 3 competency clusters that are Interpersonal Relationship, Operational Efficiency and Individual Traits. The study is the first attempt ot develop competency model in any textile company and can be useful in implementing competency based HR practices in the organizations. The Repertory Grid Technique used in the study helps in developing competency model in a quick and comprehensive manner that may reduce the time, labor and cost involved in the same.
    [Show full text]
  • Euclidean Distance in the Repertory Grid Technique: a Study of Distances Between Elements in a Sample of Battered Women
    Jesús Garcia-Martínez, Ángeles Payán-Bravo and Rafael Moreno-Rodríguez EUCLIDEAN DISTANCE IN THE REPERTORY GRID TECHNIQUE: A STUDY OF DISTANCES BETWEEN ELEMENTS IN A SAMPLE OF BATTERED WOMEN Jesús Garcia-Martínez, Ángeles Payán-Bravo and Rafael Moreno-Rodríguez. University of Seville, Spain In this study, Euclidean distance was used to analyse the construct of male-female elements and those supportive or non-supportive in a sample of battered women (N=25). The main aim was to study the differences in subjective similarity (Euclidean distance) according to different structural indexes in the repertory grid. The sample was divided into two groups using the mean as the criterion for dichotomizing groups as high-low. Symptomatology was also used as a factor for distributing the sample. Between-group differences were calculated with the Student’s-t. Women in the high-polarization group considered themselves different from their partner and also from other aggressive men. Women in the low-intensity group considered themselves and their partners as different from cooperative-helpful men. Keywords: Euclidian distances, repertory grid technique, intimate partner violence. INTRODUCTION Whiting (2014) found three different groups, prepared for change, focused on negative symp- On gender violence toms and focused on feelings of guilt and self- blaming, and Garcia-Martínez (2006) establishes The World Health Organization calls gender a similar classification, those that maintain their violence a severe social and public health prob- ability to cope with the situation, those focused lem (WHO, 2005), and according to this organi- on anxious-depressive symptoms and those that zation, one third of the women who have had a need a reconstruction of their identity.
    [Show full text]
  • A Study of Impact of Learners' Personal Constructs on Reading
    International Journal on Studies in English Language and Literature (IJSELL) Volume 3, Issue 2, February 2015, PP 87-109 ISSN 2347-3126 (Print) & ISSN 2347-3134 (Online) www.arcjournals.org A Study of Impact of Learners’ Personal Constructs on Reading Comprehension through Induction-Deduction Strategies Dr. Mohammad Zohrabi, Dr. Farahman Farrokhi English Department Faculty of Persian Literature and Foreign Languages University of Tabriz, Tabriz, Iran Monir Alizade Aras International Campus University of Tabriz, Tabriz, Iran Abstract: This study is an attempt to investigate the role of personal constructs through Induction- Deduction strategies on Iranian EFL learners' reading comprehension. People cannot understand the world except through their own constructs. Therefore, in order to understand a person's response to events, we have to understand the constructs through which he or she has perceived those events. Also the intended meaning is communicatively successful only if the speaker’s illocutionary intention is recognized by the hearer. These intentions are essentially communicative because the fulfillment of illocutionary intentions consists in hearer’s understanding. Not only are such intentions reflexive, their fulfillment consists in their recognition. The purpose of this study was to inspect the Iranian English learners to see how individuals vary in the perception of reading texts from their personal constructs point of view. It also serves to explain why individuals have different kinds of perception. Therefore, a quantitative approach was used to carry out this study. The assessment program involved Oxford Placement Test (OPT), Eysenck Personality Questionnaire (EPQ), Comprehension Reading Test (CRT) and Repertory Grid Technique (RGT) which were administered to 60 upper-intermediate EFL learners.
    [Show full text]
  • Bridging the Cross-Cultural Gap with Personal Construct Repertory Grids
    BRIDGING THE CROSS-CULTURAL GAP WITH PERSONAL CONSTRUCT REPERTORY GRIDS By GREGORY STUART HADLEY A Dissertation Submitted to the Faculty of English of The University of Birmingham for the degree of MASTER OF ARTS TEFL/TESL This dissertation consists of 14,302 words School of English Centre for English Language Studies University of Birmingham Westmere, Edgbaston Birmingham B15 2TT England December 1996 ABSTRACT Personal Construct Repertory Grids, often referred to as "rep grids," have a long and distinguished history as a research instrument in psychological, educational and cross- cultural studies. However, they have seen only limited use in EFL-based research. This paper presents the background, theory and terminology associated with Repertory Grids. The research tradition, reliability and validity of repertory grids will also be discussed. For EFL teachers unfamiliar with the procedure, a step-by-step description is provided on one way to use repertory grids for cross-cultural research in the second language classroom. The remainder of this paper covers the first documented use of repertory grids in a Japanese EFL setting. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS Many thanks to the following: Dr. Chris Evans, Senior Lecturer in Psychiatry at the University of London and expert in the field of PCP, for his invaluable help with analyzing the data for this study. Professor A. Charles Muller of Toyo Gakuen University in Chiba, Japan, an internationally known Confucian scholar, for graciously allowing the use of his recent translation of Confucius' "Five Books" (Muller, forthcoming, Five Chinese Classics). Professor Yukihiko Ushiyama of Niigata University, whose help with Internet access was vital for the completion of this research.
    [Show full text]
  • A Sentence Completion Task for Eliciting Personal Constructs in Specific Domains
    A Sentence Completion Task for Eliciting Personal Constructs in Specific Domains A SENTENCE COMPLETION TASK FOR ELICITING PERSONAL CONSTRUCTS IN SPECIFIC DOMAINS James W. Grice1, Edward Burkley III2, Melissa Burkley2, Sara Wright3, Jennifer Slaby4 1 Oklahoma State University , 2University of North Carolina Chapel Hill, 3University of Iowa, 4Nevada Missouri A novel sentence completion task was developed to assess how individuals view themselves and others in differ- ent domains of experience. This task was incorp orated into a repertory grid and evaluated in two studies. In the first study, ratings obtained from the grid procedure were shown to be internally consistent and reliable over time in two distinct domains of experience: mathematics and athletics. Moreover, ratings for oneself in the grids for each domain were found to be highly correlated with corresponding subscale scores from a popular multidi- mensional measure of self-concept. In the second study, the repertory grid ratings were again shown to be inter- nally consistent and to yield information that was truly distinct across the domains of mathematics and athletics. Positive ratings for oneself in the grids were again shown to correlate highly with corresponding subscale scores from the same multidimensional measure of self-concept. The theoretical and methodological implications of these results and new procedures were discussed. Keywords: sentence completion, self-concept, idiographic INTRODUCTION studying how individuals construe themselves and their surroundings. From the perspective of Personal Since the 1980s self-concept researchers have devel- Construct Theory (PCT, Kelly, 1955), the elements oped and promoted hierarchical and multidimensional (people, places, things, etc.) that comprise a given models of the self (see Byrne, 1996).
    [Show full text]
  • Smith, Lauren N. and Mcmenemy, David
    Smith, Lauren N. and McMenemy, David (2017) Young people's conceptions of political information : insights into information experiences and implications for intervention. Journal of Documentation, 73 (5). pp. 877-902. ISSN 0022-0418 , http://dx.doi.org/10.1108/JD-03-2017-0041 This version is available at https://strathprints.strath.ac.uk/60488/ Strathprints is designed to allow users to access the research output of the University of Strathclyde. Unless otherwise explicitly stated on the manuscript, Copyright © and Moral Rights for the papers on this site are retained by the individual authors and/or other copyright owners. Please check the manuscript for details of any other licences that may have been applied. You may not engage in further distribution of the material for any profitmaking activities or any commercial gain. You may freely distribute both the url (https://strathprints.strath.ac.uk/) and the content of this paper for research or private study, educational, or not-for-profit purposes without prior permission or charge. Any correspondence concerning this service should be sent to the Strathprints administrator: [email protected] The Strathprints institutional repository (https://strathprints.strath.ac.uk) is a digital archive of University of Strathclyde research outputs. It has been developed to disseminate open access research outputs, expose data about those outputs, and enable the management and persistent access to Strathclyde's intellectual output. Young people’s conceptions of political information: insights into information experiences and implications for intervention Smith, Lauren N.* and McMenemy, David University of Strathclyde, Department of Computer and Information Sciences, Livingstone Tower, 26 Richmond Street, Glasgow G1 1XH, UK {lauren.n.smith, d.mcmenemy}@strath.ac.uk *Corresponding author Purpose: This paper explores young people’s conceptions of political information.
    [Show full text]
  • Implicative Dilemmas and General Psychological Well-Being
    Implicative Dilemmas IMPLICATIVE DILEMMAS AND GENERAL PSYCHOLOGICAL WELL-BEING Stefanie Dorough, James Grice, Jessica Parker Oklahoma State University, Stillwater, OK, USA This study examined the relationship between psychological well-being and implicative dilemmas (Feixas & Saúl, 2004). Participants completed repertory grids based on a sentence-completion task as well as standardized measures of anxiety, depression, and self-esteem. Zero-order correlations revealed statistically significant relationships between the percentage of dilemmas derived from the repertory grids and the measures of psychological well-being. Hierarchical regression analyses, however, indicated that dilemmas were not generally predictive of psychological well-being after controlling for variability in self-discrepancies. Two archival data sets and two individual cases were also examined, and it was concluded that person-centered studies are needed to effectively address the validity of implicative dilemmas. Keywords: Implicative dilemmas, psychological well-being, sentence-completion task INTRODUCTION (undesired traits). Blocked from casting herself in the role of her ideal self in this aspect due to a cost Cognitive conflicts have long been recognized as she considers too high, she is consequently stuck in potential contributors to negative psychological an unsatisfied state of self-discrepancy. states (Freud, 1923; Festinger, 1957; Festinger and In the past personal construct psychologists have Carlsmith, 1959; Heider, 1958), although the rela- attempted to assess cognitive conflicts using reper- tionship between conflicts and negative emotions, tory grid measures based on construct angular dis- like depression, anxiety and lowered self-esteem has tances, construct content, and ‘imbalance’ within largely been explored only in theory. This is, per- triads (Fransella, 1972; Fransella & Crisp, 1979; haps, due to the perceived difficulty of measuring Ryle, 1979; Slade & Sheehan, 1979; Winter, 1983, cognitive conflicts.
    [Show full text]
  • Repertory Grid Technique in Adoptive Parent Candidates Counselling
    Repertory Grid Technique in adoptive parent candidate counselling REPERTORY GRID TECHNIQUE IN ADOPTIVE PARENT CANDIDATES COUNSELLING Leonora S. Pechnikova*, Andrey L. Ryzhov* & Ekaterina B. Zhuykova** * Lomonosov Moscow State University, Moscow, Russia ** Psychological Institute, Russian Academy of Education, Moscow, Russia Parental expectations play an important role in the success of adoption or foster placement. We propose a qualitative approach to explore parental expectations based on repertory grid technique with children’s photos as elements. Its main advantage rests on the ability to assess such interrelated aspects of parental expectations as the elaboration of personally important content, the ability to regulate reactions, the presence of stereotypes about adoption, lack of awareness or evasive thinking and specific attitudes towards family members. The article presents rationale, administration and interpretation procedures, the results of an exploratory study of parents from 48 families in order to define preliminary norms for quantitative indexes and a sample of grid analysis to illustrate how the method can be employed in counselling. Keywords: adoption, repertory grids, family counselling, parental expectations INTRODUCTION relevance in the Russian Federation, where the large number of orphans is acknowledged as a Adoptive parents form an idea of their future problem, and active efforts have been made to child long before adoption. They also develop reduce it. This resulted in a decrease in the meanings of desired and undesired behaviours number of orphans in institutional care from and interactions, supposed signs of a successful 120,000 to 52,000 in the period from 2012 to adoption process and anticipate themselves in 20171. To achieve this goal, an extensive the parental role.
    [Show full text]
  • How Does Our Brain Constitute Defense Mechanisms? First-Person Neuroscience and Psychoanalysis
    Innovations Psychother Psychosom 2007;76:141–153 DOI: 10.1159/000099841 How Does Our Brain Constitute Defense Mechanisms? First-Person Neuroscience and Psychoanalysis a, c c b d Georg Northoff Felix Bermpohl Frank Schoeneich Heinz Boeker a Department of Psychiatry, Psychotherapy and Psychosomatics, University of Magdeburg, Magdeburg , and b c Department of Psychosomatics, Humboldt University Charité, Department of Psychiatry and Psychotherapy, d Charité-University Medicine Berlin, Berlin , Germany; Department of Psychiatry, University of Zurich, Zurich , Switzerland Key Words tion in the neural network including the orbitofrontal, the Psychoanalysis Neuroscience Defense mechanisms medial prefrontal and the premotor cortices. In general sen- Neuronal integration Catatonia sorimotor regression and other defense mechanisms are psychoanalytic constructs that are hypothesized to be com- plex emotional-cognitive constellations. In this paper we Abstract suggest that specific functional mechanisms which inte- Current progress in the cognitive and affective neuroscienc- grate neuronal activity across several brain regions (i.e. neu- es is constantly influencing the development of psychoana- ronal integration) are the physiological substrates of defense lytic theory and practice. However, despite the emerging mechanisms. We conclude that first-person neuroscience dialogue between neuroscience and psychoanalysis, the could be an appropriate methodological strategy for open- neuronal processes underlying psychoanalytic constructs ing the door to a better understanding of the neuronal pro- such as defense mechanisms remain unclear. One of the cesses of defense mechanisms and their modulation in psy- main problems in investigating the psychodynamic-neuro- choanalytic psychotherapy. Copyright © 2007 S. Karger AG, Basel nal relationship consists in systematically linking the indi- vidual contents of first-person subjective experience to third-person observation of neuronal states.
    [Show full text]
  • Qualitative Analysis of Repertory Grids: Interpretive Clustering 1
    Qualitative analysis of repertory grids: Interpretive clustering DISCUSSION PAPER QUALITATIVE ANALYSIS OF REPERTORY GRIDS: INTERPRETIVE CLUSTERING Viv Burr and Nigel King Department of Psychology, University of Huddersfield, UK In this discussion paper, we present a new form of qualitative analysis of repertory grid data that we have called ‘Interpretive Clustering’. Although numerous existing publications report having performed qualitative analyses of repertory grid data, upon inspection this is usually a content analysis of constructs. In our research, used as an illustrative example here, we explored people’s constructions of nature through images of outdoor spaces using repertory grids. Through visual in- spection we used patterns of responses across constructs in each participant’s grid to identify con- struct ‘clusters’; these clusters are therefore constituted by constructs that hold implications for each other and are examples of ‘constellatory construing’. We would like to invite comments from academics and practitioners on both the process and potential usefulness of Interpretive Clustering. Key words: repertory grid, clustering, qualitative analysis, interpretive analysis. At the EPCA (European Personal Construct As- describes a process for performing such a con- sociation) conference in Edinburgh, 2018, we tent analysis and this has been adopted in previ- presented material from our ongoing research ous research reporting qualitative analyses of project using Repertory Grid interviews to ex- repertory grids; for example, Kreber & Klampf- plore peoples’ construal of outdoor spaces. In leitner (2013) used this method to derive themes analysing our data, we have been developing a in constructs elicited in relation to teacher effec- method for qualitatively analysing Grids. Grids tiveness as perceived by lecturers and students, are predominantly analysed quantitatively, using and Home, Bauer & Hunziker (2007) used it to computer software, but in this paper we will analyse constructs around urban green spaces.
    [Show full text]
  • Studying Empirically Religious Development: Interview, Repertory 1 Grid, and Specific Questionnaire Techniques
    Studying empirically religious development: Interview, Repertory Grid, and specific Questionnaire Techniques Author(s): Stefan Huber, K. Helmut Reich and Dominik Schenker First published: Archiv für Religionspsychologie / Archive for the Psychology of Religion, Vol. 24 (2002), pp. 180-201. First published by: Brill | downloaded: 30.9.2021 https://doi.org/10.7892/boris.73908 source: Studying empirically religious development: Interview, Repertory 1 Grid, and specific Questionnaire Techniques BY STEFAN HUBER, K. HELMUT REICH, AND DOMINIK SCHENKER Introduction Before going into the methodological issues, we state our basic assumptions about human nature and the ensuing conceptualisations in the psychology of religion. The state of the human psyche, human behaviour and related developments are thought to be co- determined by four types of factors (Dennett, 1996, pp. 83-101; Overton, 1999): (1) the biological substrate (body, genetic endowment, central nervous system, - cf. Reich, 2000a); (2) the psychic makeup and its workings (cognition, emotions, conation, etc. but also the unconscious); (3) the proximate and distal human surroundings (significant others, society at large, culture); and (4) the bio-physical environment (climate, geography ...). A complete review of research methodologies and methods would have to go into all four areas. However, the present considerations focus on point (2), with point (3) also getting some attention. Having delineated the research area, the next question is the status of the research envisaged. In the case of basic research, is the issue at hand (a) beginning in uncharted territory, (b) testing tentative hypotheses, or (c) using and possibly improving on an extant theory? The differences in these three cases as to the best methodology will be illustrated for interview techniques.
    [Show full text]
  • 1 Towards a Shared Understanding
    Towards a Shared Understanding - Using Personal Construct Psychology to differentiate in-session interventions in Arts Psychotherapies Abstract This study aims to answer the question, ‘How do arts psychotherapists describe their practice in sessions with clients who have severe mental illness?’ The authors explore the use of personal construct psychology (PCP) methods to gather and build consensus about how arts psychotherapists describe in-session therapeutic interventions (constructs) in adult mental health services, working with patients diagnosed with severe mental illnesses. We used PCP techniques to interview seven arts psychotherapists (art, music, drama and dance movement psychotherapists) about in-session constructs relating to clinically significant events. PCP assumes that the interviewee holds personal perspectives and makes decisions based on their system of personal constructs. The results showed that there were overarching categories for the in-session constructs elicited from arts psychotherapists during interviews. These constructs were subjected to an intensive categorising process that produced a final set of 14 bipolar constructs describing 28 alternative therapeutic constructs. The in-session constructs cover a wide range of interventions from empathic attunement to narrative reconstruction. Key Words: Arts Therapies, Personal Construct Psychology, Consensus, Interventions, constructs Introduction Arts psychotherapies (APs) is a term which covers a number of creative therapies which have a strong non-verbal component, such as art therapy, music therapy, dance 1 movement psychotherapy and drama therapy. In the UK, art psychotherapy, dramatherapy and music therapy are legally regulated by the Health and Care Professions Council (HCPC) (Health & Care Professions Council, 2014) . Body movement and dance movement psychotherapy is regulated by the National Association of Dance Movement Psychotherapy (ADMP).
    [Show full text]