DOCSLIB.ORG

Open Mfsmith - Dissertation - FINAL

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Open Mfsmith - Dissertation - FINAL The Pennsylvania State University The Graduate School EXAMINING THE ROLE OF NARRATIVES IN POLICY AGENDA SETTING AMID A “MANUFACTURED CRISIS” A Dissertation in Public Administration by Michael Smith Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy December 2020 ii The dissertation of Michael Smith was reviewed and approved by the following: Bing Ran Associate Professor of Public Administration, School of Public Affairs Professor-in-Charge, Doctor of Philosophy in Public Administration Professor-in-Charge, Master of Public Administration Professor-in-Charge, Juris Doctor and Master of Public Administration Professor-in-Charge, Certificate Program in Public Sector Human Resource Management Dissertation Advisor Chair of Committee Beverly Cigler Distinguished Professor Emerita of Public Policy and Administration Younhee Kim Associate Professor of Public Administration Steven Peterson Professor Emeritus of Politics and Public Affairs Elizabeth Tisdell Professor of Lifelong Learning and Adult Education, School of Behavioral Sciences and Education iii ABSTRACT Narrative elements and strategies have long been recognized as significant inputs into policymaking, but little research has occurred to date linking the use of these tools directly to agenda setting. Using the Narrative Policy Framework and Multiple Streams Framework as theoretical foundations, this exploratory research examines through qualitative content analysis narratives policymakers employed amidst a partial shutdown of the United States government from late December 2018 through January 2019. Using a typological map of news media accuracy and bias from Ad Fontes Media, a sample of 100 articles from seven programs on four different broadcast networks were coded using a coding worksheet inspired by that used in Shanahan et al.’s study of a Cape Cod, MA, wind farm project. The worksheet tracked codes developed a priori based on narrative elements and strategies as conceptualized in the Narrative Policy Framework, as well as emergent codes identified in a grounded-theory-like manner. Interview transcripts were coded on two separate occasions and coefficients of agreement were calculated for each code. Only those codes demonstrating agreement were analyzed. The data reveal new story lines that expand the Narrative Policy Framework’s plot element and reinforce existing literature on the importance of group cohesion, suggesting shared messaging among political actors and coalitions is important for determining a narrative’s efficacy at advancing or blocking an issue from the decision agenda. The research also suggests narratives play an important role in constructing the legitimacy of problem definitions, focusing events, the political environment, and policy alternatives. The paper offers a new model for conceptualizing the role of narratives in agenda setting as theorized through the Multiple Streams Framework, including the introduction of four legitimacy checkpoints at which evaluations are made and are theorized to influence an issue’s prospects of reaching the decision agenda. iv TABLE OF CONTENTS LIST OF FIGURES ........................................................................................................... vi LIST OF TABLES ........................................................................................................... viii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ................................................................................................ x Chapter 1 Introduction ....................................................................................................... 1 Statement of the problem .................................................................................................3 Research questions ...........................................................................................................5 Significance of the study ..................................................................................................7 Chapter 2 Literature Review ............................................................................................ 11 Crises and organizational change ...................................................................................12 Framing ..........................................................................................................................16 Agenda setting ................................................................................................................22 Narrative policy framework ...........................................................................................28 Integrating theoretical perspectives ................................................................................31 Problem definitions and focusing events ................................................................... 33 Narrative cognition and information processing ....................................................... 35 Narratives as framing tools ........................................................................................ 36 Building discourse coalitions..................................................................................... 37 Modeling narratives in the Multiple Streams Framework ......................................... 38 Critiques of NPF and MSF .............................................................................................40 Power ..............................................................................................................................45 Chapter 3 Research Design and Methods ........................................................................ 47 Philosophical assumptions and role of the researcher ....................................................48 Theoretical framework ...................................................................................................51 Research design ..............................................................................................................52 Jansick’s three-stage model ....................................................................................... 52 Use of content analysis .............................................................................................. 55 A qualitative approach ............................................................................................... 57 Sample selection .............................................................................................................59 Sample selection criteria ............................................................................................ 59 Sample size and breakdown ...................................................................................... 65 Data collection ................................................................................................................67 Coding ....................................................................................................................... 68 Data analysis .............................................................................................................. 71 Validity, reliability and trustworthiness strategies .........................................................74 v Chapter 4 Findings ........................................................................................................... 78 Round 1 vs. round 2 with coefficients of agreement ......................................................79 Republicans vs. Democrats ............................................................................................86 Codes by week................................................................................................................93 Interview counts ........................................................................................................ 93 Narrative elements and strategies .............................................................................. 95 Emergent codes ............................................................................................................106 Chapter 5 Contextual Data Analysis .............................................................................. 111 Setting the stage............................................................................................................112 Presidential controversies ........................................................................................ 112 November 2018 election consequences ................................................................... 114 The Oval Office meeting ......................................................................................... 115 The narratives: elements and strategies ........................................................................120 Heroes ...................................................................................................................... 120 Villains..................................................................................................................... 123 Victims..................................................................................................................... 130 Plot ........................................................................................................................... 133 Morals of the story ................................................................................................... 138 Narrative strategies .................................................................................................
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Eric F. Stein Director, Office of Information Programs and Services Building SA-2 515 22Nd Street, NW Washington, DC 20522-8100 (202) 261-8484 [email protected]
    October 4, 2017 VIA ELECTRONIC MAIL Eric F. Stein Director, Office of Information Programs and Services Building SA-2 515 22nd Street, NW Washington, DC 20522-8100 (202) 261-8484 [email protected] Re: Freedom of Information Act Records Request Dear Mr. Stein: Pursuant to the Freedom of Information Act (“FOIA”), 5 U.S.C. § 552 et seq., and Department of ​ ​ State FOIA regulations at 22 C.F.R. Part 171, Democracy Forward Foundation makes the following request for records. Background On October 4, 2017, Secretary of State Rex Tillerson gave an unscheduled press conference [herein “the Press Conference”] to address early morning press reports that he openly disparaged President Trump and had been on the verge of resigning this past summer amid clashes with the White House.1 The press conference was held despite an already scheduled press briefing led by Department Spokesperson Heather Nauert.2 During the press conference, Secretary Tillerson stated he did not speak with the President ahead of his unscheduled appearance. Secretary Tillerson also refused to refute reports that he “openly disparaged the president, referring to him as a ‘moron,’ after a July 20 meeting at the Pentagon with members of Trump’s national security team and Cabinet officials”:3 “REPORTER: Can you address the main headline of this story that you called the president a moron, and if not, where do you think these reports — “TILLERSON: I’m not going to deal with petty stuff like that. This is what I don’t understand about Washington. Again, I’m not from this place. But the places I come 1 goo.gl/qm7UV3 ​ 2 https://www.state.gov/r/pa/prs/dpb/ ​ 3 goo.gl/vxK6zL ​ from, we don’t deal with that kind of petty nonsense.
    [Show full text]
  • Trump Administration Allies Have Burrowed Into 24 Critical Civil Service Positions and 187 Last-Minute Appointments
    Trump Administration Allies Have Burrowed Into 24 Critical Civil Service Positions And 187 Last-Minute Appointments SUMMARY: Following the outgoing administration’s “quiet push to salt federal agencies with Trump loyalists,” an Accountable.US review has found that, as of February 22, 2021, at least 24 Trump administration political appointees have “burrowed” into long-term civil service jobs in the new Biden administration. This includes at least four figures in the national security apparatus, nine figures with environmental regulators, three figures in the Department of Justice, two figures in the embattled Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, and at least six other appointees elsewhere who have refused to step down in the transition. Burrowing of this sort is not treated lightly, as officials who transfer from political appointments to career positions must undergo scrutiny by federal personnel overseers for a full five years—and some of these cases have been found to violate federal laws and have drawn congressional scrutiny. However, there is a much wider slate of concerning Trump administration appointments that are not subject to such strict oversight: During the Trump administration’s waning days following the 2020 election, it announced 187 last-minute appointments to various boards, commissions, and councils that don’t require Senate confirmation. While some of these appointments have already drawn alarm for going to campaign staffers, megadonors, and top administration allies, Accountable.US has unearthed even more troubling names in Trump’s outgoing deluge. Similar to how early Trump administration personnel picks were directly conflicted against the offices they served, many of these late Trump appointments are woefully underqualified or have histories directly at odds with the positions to which they were named—and they are likely to stay in long into the Biden administration.
    [Show full text]
  • Melania and Me: the Rise and Fall of My Friendship with the First Lady
    Thank you for downloading this Simon & Schuster ebook. Get a FREE ebook when you join our mailing list. Plus, get updates on new releases, deals, recommended reads, and more from Simon & Schuster. Click below to sign up and see terms and conditions. CLICK HERE TO SIGN UP Already a subscriber? Provide your email again so we can register this ebook and send you more of what you like to read. You will continue to receive exclusive offers in your inbox. To Melania — Prologue — Just Another Lunch “Grab ’em by the pussy.” The sentence that reverberated around the world on October 7, 2016. The quote was an excerpt from a recording that became forever known as “the Access Hollywood tape,” published by the Washington Post and aired on NBC News, a month before the 2016 presidential election. It had been recorded eleven years earlier, in September 2005, on a bus taking Donald Trump to make a cameo on the NBC soap opera Days of Our Lives. Now infamously, Donald told TV host Billy Bush, “I’m automatically attracted to beautiful. I just start kissing them. It’s like a magnet. Just kiss. I don’t even wait. And when you’re a star, they let you do it. You can do anything. Grab ’em by the pussy.” When the story broke about the tape I was deeply immersed in my oldest son, Zach’s, health problems related to his life-threatening food allergies and other issues that required many doctor’s visits and therapies. My middle son, Tyler, was transferring to a new school, and my daughter, Alexi, was adjusting to hers.
    [Show full text]
  • Is Donald Trump an Outlier Among Recent Presidents?
    FEATURE Contemporary Presidency Presidents Meet Reporters: Is Donald Trump an Outlier among Recent Presidents? MARTHA JOYNT KUMAR Is President Donald Trump an outlier among presidents in the ways in which he meets with the press? Using comparative data for Presidents Ronald Reagan, George H. W. Bush, Bill Clinton, George W. Bush, Barack Obama, and Trump, this article looks at how similar and different Trump is compared to his recent predecessors. While at one time presidents answered reporters’ queries in presidential press conferences, today presidents have more opportunities to meet the press. All six presidents studied used three basic forums: press conferences, informal question-and-answer sessions, and interviews. They did so in ways consistent with their presidential goals and in settings in which they felt comfortable. In their first 32 months, all recent presidents employed strategies similar to ones that brought each to the presidency and then most found additional resources for communicating with the public. Except for President Trump, Presidents Reagan through Obama did so with relatively stable White House leadership teams and coordinated communications organizational structures. In this way as well as in significant others, the five previous presidents had more in common with one another than they did with President Trump. Keywords: president and press, White House press operations, presidential press conferences President Donald Trump is often characterized as bent on destroying the political system as we know it without a relationship to past presidential patterns. Gerald Seib of the Wall Street Journal characterized Trump as “the disrupter-in-chief, the most promi- nent leader to rise to power by proudly taking a wrecking ball to the prevailing political system” (2019).
    [Show full text]
  • Self-Framing of Women in U.S. Politics on Instagram
    Brigham Young University BYU ScholarsArchive Theses and Dissertations 2020-02-24 Self-Framing of Women in U.S. Politics on Instagram Madison Marie Parks Brigham Young University Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarsarchive.byu.edu/etd Part of the Fine Arts Commons BYU ScholarsArchive Citation Parks, Madison Marie, "Self-Framing of Women in U.S. Politics on Instagram" (2020). Theses and Dissertations. 9044. https://scholarsarchive.byu.edu/etd/9044 This Thesis is brought to you for free and open access by BYU ScholarsArchive. It has been accepted for inclusion in Theses and Dissertations by an authorized administrator of BYU ScholarsArchive. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Self-Framing of Women in U.S. Politics on Instagram Madison Marie Parks A thesis submitted to the faculty of Brigham Young University in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts Pamela J. Brubaker, Chair Scott Church Kris Boyle School of Communications Brigham Young University Copyright © 2020 Madison Marie Parks All Rights Reserved ABSTRACT Self-Framing of Women in U.S. Politics on Instagram Madison Marie Parks School of Communications, BYU Master of Arts This study explored how women involved in U.S. politics visually framed themselves on their Instagram pages. While recent research in political communications examined the use of Facebook and Twitter, few studies assessed Instagram’s role in the game of politics. Guided by political and visual framing theories, a quantitative content analysis of Instagram posts (N = 1,947) from women involved in U.S. politics was conducted. This examination allowed for an exploration of how these public figures framed themselves on Instagram and the extent to which they shared personal content, despite their varied involvement in U.S.
    [Show full text]
  • In the United States District Court for the District of Columbia
    Case 1:18-cv-01005-RC Document 5 Filed 06/20/18 Page 1 of 34 IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA SAMIR HAMEL, c/o DEMOCRACY FORWARD FOUNDATION P.O. Box 34553 Washington, D.C. 20043 and Case No. 1:18-cv-1005 (RC) WILLIAM FISCHER, c/o DEMOCRACY FORWARD FOUNDATION P.O. Box 34553 Washington, D.C. 20043 Plaintiffs, v. U.S. DEPARTMENT OF VETERANS AFFAIRS, 810 Vermont Avenue Washington, DC 20420 and PETER O’ROURKE, in his capacity as the person claiming to be the acting Secretary of Veterans Affairs, 810 Vermont Avenue Washington, DC 20420 Defendants. Case 1:18-cv-01005-RC Document 5 Filed 06/20/18 Page 2 of 34 AMENDED COMPLAINT 1. Plaintiffs Samir Hamel and William Fischer bring this action against Defendants the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs (the “Department” or the “VA”) and Peter O’Rourke, in his capacity as the person claiming to be the acting Secretary of Veterans Affairs, seeking a declaration that O’Rourke is not the lawful acting Secretary, and an injunction barring O’Rourke and the Department from continuing to represent that O’Rourke is the acting Secretary and from taking any action in reliance on O’Rourke’s purported authority. 2. According to press reports, the Trump administration and its allies in Congress seek to privatize essential VA services, turning veterans’ health care over to a network of private providers rather than the facilities and physicians that veterans have come to count on. But this case is not about whether privatization is a good idea or a bad idea.
    [Show full text]
  • Trump Base DA
    Notes The Base DA — by Dana Randall, Director of Debate at Carrollton Sacred Heart. General Argument The Base DA is a “politics disadvantage” — it’s about the political consequences of the plan. This DA argues that there is a core group of Trump supporters, known as his “base,” who support the president primarily because of his stance on immigration. This base consists of people who are worried about economic competition with immigrants (they took our jobs), people who have safety/security concerns about immigration (build the wall), and people who oppose immigration for other reasons like nationalism/xenophobia. The disad argues that while Trump is/has become very unpopular with a lot of people because of other policy actions (tax cuts, Paris withdrawal, environmental deregulation etc) the base is primarily (or exclusively) concerned about immigration policy and thus these other issues have not “thumped” the disad. The link relies on characterizing the affirmative as “soft” on immigration, which is straightforward but slightly different for each case: • Open Borders — the easiest to argue the link. This aff removes ALL immigration restrictions, so links like “DACA” or “chain migration” obviously apply as does any other link. This case would trigger all of the base anxieties about immigration. • High Skilled Immigrants — while traditional, pro-business segments of the GOP would be in favor of high skilled immigration the base generally views any such policy as job competition. This is why Trump recently made H1-B visa applications far more cumbersome. • Refugees — since Trump recently had sessions change refugee policy, this affirmative can be cast as a “flip flop”, which is when a politician changes their stance on something.
    [Show full text]
  • This Week Chicago Reader | September   | Volume  Number 
    FREEANDFREAKYSINCE | SEPTEMBER THIS WEEK CHICAGOREADER | SEPTEMBER | VOLUME NUMBER IN THIS ISSUE TR - ortwoaboutcorruption 26 StreamingSplitscreentheater 36 RecordsofNoteApandemic @ tearsdownthedigitalbox can’tstopthefl owofgreatmusic HOUSING andthisweektheReaderreviews PTB 12 Isaacs|CultureAbooklooks currentreleasesbyBillCallahan ECS K KH beyondskyscraperstoaneglected PhewUniformtheJuJuExchange CLR H MEP M bountyofsinglefamilyhouses andmore TDKR 14 Dukmasova|WitnessExcops 41 EarlyWarningsRescheduled CEBW attemptedtothrowoutaRogers concertsandotherupdated AEJL SWMD LG ParktenantatgunpointThe listings DI BJ MS policereporttellsadiff erentstory 41 GossipWolfHyperpop EAS N L 18 LandlordsAnewdatabase newcomerFraxiompackstwo GD AH CITYLIFE L CSC-J 03 TransportationAchallenging matchesrentalpropertieswith albums’worthofsoundintoanew SJR andmemorablebikeridearound ownerswhethertheylikeitornot EPheavymusiczineDistort/ F AM R Chicago’sexactcitylimits 22 Photography TheFoldedMap Delayreturnsa erafouryear CEBN B L C M DLCM Projectshowsasegregatedcity FILM hiatusandSundayseriesVibes C NLC J F S FOOD&DRINK 28 SmallScreenHousingand onLoganhostsvinylDJsonthe F JH IH B 06 FeatureAsPasserottocloses thehauntingofsegregationin boulevard J C MJ M KSKND LM itschefreimaginesthefutureby Lovecra Country MAM -K J R N J preservingthepast 29 MoviesofNoteTheBabysitter OPINION N M OAP- KillerQueenisahorrorcomedy 42 NationalStageInpoliticsthe AK S CS thatholdsitsownTheBroken fi ghtsarefakebutthefolkspulling ----------------------------------------------------------------
    [Show full text]
  • Police: Girl's Death Accidental
    SPORTS Keith West returns to coaching staff at alma mater SHS FRIDAY, JUNE 7, 2019 | Serving South Carolina since October 15, 1894 75 cents B1 Police: Girl’s death accidental Gilmore was “very outdoing, surveillance video footage and the child when it was discov- Sumter department funny” and a “loving person. the initial autopsy results de- ered something was wrong, says no charges as She is the child when you’re termined the incident was the although she remained above having a bad day, she would “result of a tragic accident, water.” of now after child give you a hug.” and no charges are forthcom- McGirt said everyone who The child was unresponsive ing,” according to Tonyia Mc- was at the pool was associated drowned at hotel when she was pulled from the Girt, public information offi- or acquainted with each other. BY KAYLA ROBINS pool at the Econo Lodge on cer for the department. Initial autopsy results found [email protected] North Washington Street “Anywhere from 20 to 30 or there was no physical trauma, about 5 p.m. Saturday, accord- more children and adults and toxicology results are The aunt of the 5-year-old ing to the Sumter Police De- were in and around the pool pending. girl who died from a likely ac- partment, and transported to leading up to the incident,” “Members of the Sumter cidental drowning at a hotel Prisma Health Tuomey Hospi- McGirt said. “The video foot- Police Department are deeply PHOTO PROVIDED pool in Sumter said she miss- tal, where she later died.
    [Show full text]
  • Euharlee Names New Police Chief
    FRIDAY June 7, 2019 BARTOW COUNTY’S ONLY DAILY NEWSPAPER 75 cents Euharlee names new police chief BY JAMES SWIFT cil meeting. “We went through thews,” Worthington said. agenda concerned the purchase [email protected] some great candidates, and I Matthews served on the Pow- of a four-wheeler — a carry- tell you what, it just amazes me der Springs Police Department over item from the council’s A member of the Powder the talent’s that’s out there and for about 17 years. He is set to last meeting. Springs Police Department has the education some of the peo- be sworn in at a city council “We had some bids and there been named the new chief of ple has put into it.” work session meeting slated for was a thought we might get a police for the City of Euharlee. The council narrowed down 7 p.m. at 30 Burge’s Mill Road better bid, but I don’t think that Lieutenant Jody Matthews its list to two candidates fol- on June 18. matured,” Worthington said. came out on top of a field of lowing a lengthy executive “I’m glad to be here and “It is a used vehicle, but it’s almost two dozen applicants in session discussion at a May 21 thank you for this opportuni- supposed to be top-notch.” the wake of former Euharlee council meeting. Euharlee’s ty,” Matthews said at Tuesday The council opted for the Police Chief Lee New’s retire- Deputy Chief of Police Wil- evening’s public meeting.
    [Show full text]
  • Informational Materials
    Received by NSD/FARA Registration Unit 11/20/2020 11:38:22 AM Thursday 11/19/20 This material is distributed by Ghebi LLC on behalf of Federal State Unitary Enterprise Rossiya Segodnya International Information Agency, and additional information is on file with the Department of Justice, Washington, District of Columbia. Pentagon Praises Record UK Defense Budget Hike, Urges Other 'Free Nations' to Follow Suit by Morgan Artvukhina The British military is Washington’s primary partner in some of its most important missions around the globe, and London’s planned exit from the European Union is likely to push the two nations even closer. The new acting Pentagon chief hailed London’s decision to "significantly increase defense spending", saying it sets an example for other US allies. The United Kingdom is already the second-highest defense spender in the NATO alliance, after the United States. “The UK is our most stalwart and capable ally, and this increase in spending is indicative of their commitment to NATO and our shared security. With this increase, the UK military will continue to be one of the finest fighting forces in the world. Their commitment to increased defense funding should be a message to all free nations that the most capable among us can - and must - do more to counter emerging threats to our shared freedoms and security,” acting Pentagon chief Christopher C. Miller said in a statement Wednesday. The development comes as UK Prime Minister Boris Johnson announced on Wednesday a defense spending increase, the largest for the island nation since the end of Cold War.
    [Show full text]
  • Wednesday, February 26Th, 2020 Chesapeake 4-6 3:00PM
    CPAC International Training: Wednesday, February 26th, 2020 Chesapeake 4-6 3:00PM- What We Believe: What Conservatism is and What it is Not ​ David Azerrad, PhD, Hillsdale College ​ Matthew Spalding, PhD, Hillsdale College ​ 3:20PM- 3 CPACs & Counting: Lessons Learned through Trial and Error ​ Jay Aeba, Japanese Conservative Union ​ 3:40PM- Tales from the Trail: Lessons Learned through Trial and Error ​ Jay Aeba & Micchi Watanabe, CPAC Japan ​ Eduardo Bolsonaro & Elias Macedo, CPAC Brazil ​ Annie Chan & Patrick Kang, CPAC Korea ​ Andrew Cooper & Lyndal Maloney, CPAC Australia ​ 4:10PM- Getting the Logistics Right ​ Robert Clark, Legend House ​ Peter Green, ConferenceDirect ​ ​ Ryan Meerstein, Targeted Victory ​ Ana Carbonell, Hispanic Nexo, LLC ​ Chris Price, TradeShow Logic ​ Dave Mohel, BlueSkin Solutions ​ Dan Schneider, American Conservative Union ​ CPAC Direct Action Training: Wednesday, February 26th, 2020 Sponsored by WinRed Prince George’s Exhibit Hall E 3:00PM- Welcome to CPAC Direct Action Training 2020 ​ Matt Schlapp, American Conservative Union Chairman ​ Katrina Pierson, Donald J. Trump for President, Inc. ​ 3:30PM- Weaponize Social Media with WinRed Team Pages ​ Gerrit Lansing, WinRed ​ 4:00PM- The Fate of Our Culture and Our Nation Hangs in the Balance ​ Rep. Dan Crenshaw (TX-2) 4:20PM- Celebrate (App) Adoption! ​ Chris Turner, Stampede Consulting ​ 4:30 PM- "No Time" is No Excuse! The Necessary Discipline to Free Up Time for Activism ​ Mark Geist, Client Response ​ Interviewed by Amber Smith, Former Defense Official, Combat Veteran, Author ​ 5:05PM- Don't Just Talk, Be Persuasive: Learn How and How Not to Communicate with ​ Undecided Voters Kayleigh McEnany, Donald J. Trump for President, Inc. ​ Tim Murtaugh, Donald J.
    [Show full text]