Playing with Teaching Techniques: Gamelan As a Learning Tool Amongst Children with Learning Impairments in Northern Ireland
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Playing with Teaching Techniques: Gamelan as a Learning Tool Amongst Children with Learning Impairments in Northern Ireland Jonathan McIntosh ABSTRACT: This article examines gamelan as a community musical tool in Northern Ire- land, United Kingdom. In particular, the article demonstrates how traditional peda- gogic practices are changed in order to suit the needs of those who learn gamelan. A gamelan is an orchestra that includes metallophones (large glockenspiel-like instru- ments), gongs and drums. Originating from Southeast Asia, particularly from the In- donesian islands of Java and Bali, gamelan ensembles have long been used in the teaching of ethnomusicology in academic institutions and for purposes of applied eth- nomusicology, as a musical tool, in the wider community. In these contexts, a gamelan instructor acts as a ‘mediator’ (Naughton 1996: 16) in the transmission of gamelan knowledge; mediating not only between the music and the learners, but also between the role of gamelan in its original sociocultural context and its newly adopted milieu. Drawing upon my experiences as a gamelan instructor, in particular, teaching children with visual and hearing impairments, I demonstrate how traditional teaching tech- niques are adapted to facilitate the learning of gamelan in the Northern Irish context. KEYWORDS: teaching and learning; gamelan; applied ethnomusicology Introduction tices from Indonesia and how they are applied to the learning of gamelan in academia; next, it Gamelan in Northern Ireland is constrained by sketches a framework for the teaching of gam- its setting within short intensive periods of tu- elan as a musical tool in the wider community ition after which there is little or no subsequent with able-bodied students; finally, it demon- follow up. As a result, in order to learn more strates how this framework is adapted to suit than the rudimentary techniques of gamelan the needs of physically challenged students in playing, traditional methods of instruction must a school for children with visual and hearing be extended to incorporate the musical bound- impairments. It concludes by highlighting the aries and limitations of its newfound context. fact that the teaching of gamelan in such con- Wiggins (1996: 29) observes that ‘this process texts must be sensitive to, and creative with, of mediation and translation is a delicate one traditional teaching practices. However, before and it is the individual teacher who must make moving on to discuss the specific case of gam- most of the decisions’, according to specific elan in Northern Ireland, it will briefly be ex- pedagogic situations. This article discusses the plained how gamelan came to be used as a tool teaching of gamelan in three contexts: first, it in the teaching of ethnomusicology in academia outlines traditional gamelan pedagogic prac- and then in wider community contexts. Anthropology in Action, Volume 12, Issue 2 (2005): 12–27 © Berghahn Books and the Association for Anthropology in Action Playing with Teaching Techniques: Gamelan | AiA Gamelan in Western Academia has been published concerning the teaching and Beyond of gamelan in the wider community context. Research published in this area includes work The teaching of gamelan in higher education concerning the use gamelan for crosscultural institutions stems from the work of the US eth- musical learning purposes (Diamond 1983), nomusicologist Ki Mantle Hood. In 1954, Hood gamelan as a sociotherapeutic musical tool for purchased a Javanese gamelan for the Univer- music making with physically challenged indi- sity of California, Los Angeles (UCLA), which, viduals (Sanger and Kippen 1987; MacDonald along with other world music ensembles, was and Meill 2002), a study of Javanese gamelan utilised in the teaching of ethnomusicology at in the United Kingdom (Mendonça 2002) and, UCLA. The reason for the purchase of various most recently, the applied use of gamelan in world music ensembles developed from Hood’s prisons in England (Eastburn 2003). In turn, premise that in order to study the music of other these researchers owe a debt to the work of cultures it is necessary to try and comprehend Hood, without whom the use of gamelan as a such music in its own terms (Hood 1982: 32). tool for the teaching and dissemination of a As a result, Hood developed a performance- form of world music would perhaps not have practice approach to the study of ethnomusicol- occurred. ogy, called ‘bi-musicality’ (1960). It was hoped that bi-musicality would provide ethnomusi- cology students not only with the opportunity Gamelan in Northern Ireland to play the music they studied in lectures but also to develop a certain degree of ability in other It was John Blacking, the late professor of Social musical systems. Today, performance-practice Anthropology and Ethnomusicology at Queen’s learning, involving the teaching of world mu- University Belfast (QUB) who, in 1982, insti- sic ensembles, is an important element in the gated the purchase of a gamelan for QUB. At teaching of ethnomusicology (see Ramnarine first, the procurement of a gamelan did not 2004). However, I do not wish to imply that all meet with wide-ranging approval because it students who participate in gamelan, or other was thought that a gamelan might not be rele- world music ensembles, in the university con- vant in the Northern Irish context.2 Nonethe- text necessarily become bi-musical. Only a few less, Blacking, realised that the purchase of a students go on to study a musical tradition in gamelan would not only further the teaching more depth and do fieldwork. The majority take possibilities of QUB, but he also saw the poten- a gamelan (or Andean, Brazilian or Korean tial for using gamelan as a recreational tool in music) course only for a semester or two. the wider community outside of the academic However, because of Hood’s concept of bi- context. Blacking asked Annette Sanger, one of musicality, the opportunity to learn gamelan is his research students at that time, to find a gam- now commonplace in many academic institu- elan for purchase. Sanger was already conduct- tions where ethnomusicology is included in the ing fieldwork in Bali during 1981–1982. The curriculum.1 Moreover, the teaching of game- gamelan chosen for QUB was a twentieth-cen- lan in these institutions has become the subject tury genre of gamelan, Gamelan Gong Kebyar. In of recent debate amongst ethnomusicologists a strange twist to this story, Hood also tried to (cf. contributors in Solís 2004). Outside of the purchase the same gamelan at the same time as realm of academia, gamelan has actively been Blacking. Hood, who was by this time teaching used as a community musical tool for the wider at the University of Maryland, Baltimore, like ‘public practice of ethnomusicology’ (Titon Blacking, wanted to purchase a Balinese gam- 1992: 315). But despite this fact, little research elan to increase the teaching possibilities of the | 13 AiA | Jonathan McIntosh Music Department at the University. However, Open Arts’s mission is to provide access to Blacking secured the purchase of the gamelan music and other art forms for physically chal- for QUB. When the gamelan arrived in Belfast lenged and able-bodied individuals and groups. in 1984, it was given the Balinese name Gam- In spite of the fact that the majority of the com- elan Widya Santi, ‘Gamelan of Knowledge and pany’s outreach involves projects with physi- Peace’. Sanger’s Balinese music teacher, the cally challenged individuals, it does not regard great composer and performer, I Wayan Sinti, this work as music therapy. Moreover, the com- had suggested the name.3 Furthermore, during pany seeks to enable and empower such indi- her subsequent appointment as lecturer in eth- viduals through participation in arts activities. nomusicology at QUB, Sanger earnestly pro- Although other research (Sanger and Kippen moted the newly arrived gamelan not only 1987; MacDonald and Meill 2002) involving within the confines of the university but also physically challenged individuals and game- actively sought to introduce the gamelan into lan has stressed the possible therapeutic val- new community contexts in Northern Ireland ues of gamelan in such circumstances, this (see Sanger 1989a). Outside of its formal, edu- article, in keeping with the policy of Open cational context, the QUB gamelan was used in Arts, does not explore this area. Similarly, be- various workshop forums and as a sociothera- cause musicians, and not music therapists, are peutic tool in areas such as music therapy (see employed by Open Arts, it is not my intention Sanger and Kippen 1987). to engage in debates concerning gamelan and As a direct result of Sanger’s applied ethno- clinical practice. musicological work with the Balinese gamelan at QUB, community arts organisations in North- ern Ireland began to realise the possibilities of Traditional Methods of Teaching using gamelan in their own work. However, and Learning Gamelan due to its role in the ethnomusicology teaching programme, it was difficult to move the en- Gamelan playing involves the holistic practice semble outside of the university to partake in of direct sociomusical participation in an en- other music-making arenas. Consequently, in semble where knowledge is acquired through 1995, Open Arts, a Belfast-based community developed modes of intuitive and experiential arts organisation, brought a Javanese gamelan learning. This assimilated approach is a conse- from Yogyakarta, central Java, to Northern Ire- quence of