Ecotoxicology and Environmental Safety 133 (2016) 176–187
Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Ecotoxicology and Environmental Safety
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/ecoenv
Multi-level biological responses in Ucides cordatus (Linnaeus, 1763) (Brachyura, Ucididae) as indicators of conservation status in mangrove areas from the western atlantic
Luis Felipe de Almeida Duarte a,n, Caroline Araújo de Souza a, Caio Rodrigues Nobre b, Camilo Dias Seabra Pereira c, Marcelo Antonio Amaro Pinheiro a a UNESP - Univ Estadual Paulista, Instituto de Biociências (IB), Campus do Litoral Paulista (CLP), Laboratório de Biologia de Crustáceos/CRUSTA, Praça Infante Dom Henrique, s/n, Par - Grupo de Pesquisa em Biologia Laboratório de Biologia de Crustáceos-Praça, Infante D. Henrique, Campus Experimental do Litoral Paulista (CLP), s/n, Parque Bitaru, 11330-900 São Vicente, São Paulo, Brazil b UNISANTA - Univ Santa Cecília, Laboratório de Ecotoxicologia, Oswaldo Cruz 266, 11045-907 Santos, SP, Brazil c UNIFESP - Univ Federal de São Paulo, Departamento de Ciências do Mar, Campus Baixada Santista, Avenida Almirante Saldanha da Gama 89, Ponta da Praia, 11030400 Santos, SP, Brasil article info abstract
Article history: There is a global lack of knowledge on tropical ecotoxicology, particularly in terms of mangrove areas. Received 19 April 2016 These areas often serve as nurseries or homes for several animal species, including Ucides cordatus (the Received in revised form uçá crab). This species is widely distributed, is part of the diet of human coastal communities, and is 12 July 2016 considered to be a sentinel species due to its sensitivity to toxic xenobiotics in natural environments. Accepted 13 July 2016 Sublethal damages to benthic populations reveal pre-pathological conditions, but discussions of the Available online 22 July 2016 implications are scarce in the literature. In Brazil, the state of São Paulo offers an interesting scenario for Keywords: ecotoxicology and population studies: it is easy to distinguish between mangroves that are well pre- Environmental safety served and those which are significantly impacted by human activity. The objectives of this study were to Cytotoxicity provide the normal baseline values for the frequency of Micronucleated cells (MN‰) and for neutral red Density retention time (NRRT) in U. cordatus at pristine locations, as well to indicate the conservation status of Genotoxicity Mangrove different mangrove areas using a multi-level biological response approach in which these biomarkers Ucides cordatus and population indicators (condition factor and crab density) are applied in relation to environmental quality indicators (determined via information in the literature and solid waste volume). A mangrove area with no effects of impact (areas of reference or pristine areas) presented a mean value of MN‰o3 and NRRT4120 min, values which were assumed as baseline values representing genetic and physio- logical normality. A significant correlation was found between NRRT and MN, with both showing similar and effective results for distinguishing between different mangrove areas according to conservation status. Furthermore, crab density was lower in more impacted mangrove areas, a finding which also reflects the effects of sublethal damage; this finding was not determined by condition factor measure- ments. Multi-level biological responses were able to reflect the conservation status of the mangrove areas studied using information on guideline values of MN‰, NRRT, and density of the uçá crab in order to categorize three levels of human impacts in mangrove areas: PNI (probable null impact); PLI (probable low impact); and PHI (probable high impact). Results confirm the success of U. cordatus species’ multi- level biological responses in diagnosing threats to mangrove areas. Therefore, this species represents an effective tool in studies on mangrove conservation statuses in the Western Atlantic. & 2016 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction biodiversity and generate approximately 60% of the primary pro- ductivity of the planet, ecotoxicological studies have been con- Although tropical ecosystems house 75% of the world’s ducted almost exclusively in temperate ecosystems (Peters et al., 1997; Lacher and Goldstein, 1997; Sueitt et al., 2015). Such limited knowledge contrasts with current increasing human impacts in n Corresponding author. the tropics, impacts which are generally the result of unsustain- E-mail addresses: [email protected] (L.F.d.A. Duarte), [email protected] (C.A.d. Souza), [email protected] (C.R. Nobre), able activities and the release of xenobiotics into water bodies. [email protected] (C.D.S. Pereira), [email protected] (M.A.A. Pinheiro). These activities ultimately have negative effects on the aquatic http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ecoenv.2016.07.018 0147-6513/& 2016 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Please cite this article as: Duarte, L.F.d.A., et al., Multi-level biological responses in Ucides cordatus (Linnaeus, 1763) (Brachyura, Ucididae) as indicators of conservation status in mangrove areas from the western atlantic. Ecotoxicol. Environ. Saf. (2016), http://dx.doi. org/10.1016/j.ecoenv.2016.07.018i L.F.d.A. Duarte et al. / Ecotoxicology and Environmental Safety 133 (2016) 176–187 177 biota (Peters et al., 1997; Harford et al., 2015). between this bioaccumulation and the genetic impacts observed Different approaches, which consider information ranging from (Pinheiro et al., 2012, 2013). As a result, these xenobiotics are data at the population-community level to sentinel species’ sub- magnified by the trophic chain of the mangrove (Fiscarelli and lethal responses, are the current basis for most biomonitoring Pinheiro, 2002). This species also has a close relationship with programs (Marine Strategy Framework Directive EU - MSFD, 2008/ three environmental compartments of mangroves with which it 56/EC). Short-term responses among lower levels of biological interacts and where it absorbs pollutants: (1) water, via contact, organization have been used to detect the first signs of impair- ingestion, the respiration process, and metabolite excretion; ment caused by xenobiotics (Amiard-Triquet et al., 2013; Pereira (2) sediment, via contact when digging burrows and mud feeding; et al., 2014). These responses have generally been referred to as and (3) trees, through their feeding on the senescent leaves and “biomarkers,” which are defined herein as genetic, biochemical, seedlings (Fiscarelli and Pinheiro, 2002; Pinheiro et al., 2013; cellular, physiological, or behavioral variations that can be mea- Christofoletti et al., 2013). sured in tissue or body fluid samples or at the level of the whole A multi-level biological response approach must include not organism and which provide evidence of exposure to and/or ef- only the most ideal biological model – the area selected for study fects of one or more chemical pollutants and/or radiations (De- must also present a wide regional environmental impact gradient pledge et al., 1993). so that the investigation will be more effective and meaningful. Genetic and physiological changes are therefore of particular Therefore, it is important to highlight the high anthropic impact importance, since they are conspicuous in organisms that inhabit observed in southeastern Brazil, particularly in coastal areas. impacted areas (Adams, 1990; Dailianis et al., 2003; Otomo and However, pristine mangroves also exist and are represented by Reinecke, 2010; Amiard-Triquet et al., 2013; Toufexia et al., 2013). protected areas (Cetesb, 2001, 2007). It is, therefore, a contrasting Because of their effectiveness and ecological relevance (Bonassi scenario that has been mentioned and studied by several authors et al., 2000; Dailianis et al., 2003; Neri et al., 2003), two biomarker (Silva et al., 2002; Abessa and Ambrozevicius, 2008; Cordeiro and assays are widely used. The first is the micronucleus test (MN‰), Costa, 2010; Martins et al., 2011; Pereira et al., 2011; Torres et al., which quantifies the frequency of micronucleated cells and which 2012; Pinheiro et al., 2008, 2012, 2013). measures genotoxicity. Genotoxicity is higher in more highly im- Given both the contamination gradient of the mangroves in the pacted areas (Brunetti et al., 1988; Burgeot et al., 1995; Collier region and the possible biological responses at the cellular, phy- et al., 2013; Pinheiro et al., 2013). The second is the neutral red siological, and population levels of a sentinel species (U. cordatus), retention time (NRRT) assay, which evaluates lysosomal mem- this study aims to: (1) provide normal baseline values for the brane stability as a diagnostic biomarker of individual health sta- micronucleated cell frequency (MN ‰) and neutral red retention tus (Buratti et al., 2012, Ospar, 2013). time (NRRT) in U. cordatus at pristine locations; and (2) perform a Genetic and physiological changes are considered pre-patho- multi-level assessment using this species as a biological model by logical indicators (Tsarpali and Dailianis, 2012) that can detect analyzing the effectiveness and ecological relevance of two bio- biological dysfunction in response to a stressor before population markers (genetic via MN ‰ and physiological via NRRT), their problems occur (Amiard-Triquet et al., 2013). As determined by correlation with population parameters (condition factor and Adams, (1990) and by Fishelson et al. (1999), such sublethal da- density), and their interactions with the conservation status of mages may have more serious effects, such as increases in disease, different mangrove areas (determined via information from the changes to mortality rates, and population decline. According to literature and solid waste volume). The validation of this multi- these authors, other parameters found at higher levels of biolo- level approach will allow for the conservation statuses of the gical organization, such as at the population level, may also be mangroves to be categorized without the need for contaminant relevant bioindicators of environmental impact and quality (Bru- quantification or qualification. High costs are therefore avoided, ner et al., 2001; Barrilli et al., 2015). Therefore, Fulton's condition which will provide more opportunities for diagnosing this eco- factor (K) would be a relevant population parameter in these as- system's conservation status. sessments: it can quantify “well-being” as a ratio of size to in- dividual weight (Lima-Junior et al., 2002), with higher values in- dicating better environmental quality (Viana et al., 2014; Barrilli 2. Materials and methods et al., 2015). Similarly, density is a parameter that can be reduced by contaminants, as seen among crustaceans (Krebs and Valiela, 2.1. Mangrove areas studied and their conservation statuses 1974; Krebs and Burns, 1977), although the reverse effect can also occur, leading to an increase in density due the tolerance of con- The coast of São Paulo State in Brazil is frequently divided into taminants and their indirect effects on the environment (Cannicci three sections referred to as the northern coast, the central coast, et al., 2009). and the southern coast. These sections are distinguished by their There is limited knowledge available on links between sub- coastal plain areas (6000 km2, 3200 km2, and 7800 km2, respec- lethal damages seen in the lower levels of biological organization tively) (Gouveia, 2012), by the extent of river basins (194,800 ha, and those seen in higher levels (at the population or community 281,800 ha, and 1,706,800 ha, respectively; see BRASIL (2006)), level), particularly when a multi-level approach is considered. and by the extent of mangroves (central: 8858 ha; southern: However, in order for the biological model to be effective, it must 15,193 ha; see Cunha-Lignon et al. (2011a, 2011b) and Cunha-Lig- consider a species that is both important to the ecosystem and non (2014)). The present study considered mangroves from only sensitive enough to reveal early environmental disturbances the central coast (8858 ha) and the southern coast (15,193 ha), (Beltrame et al., 2010, 2011; Pereira et al., 2012, 2014). Thus, Pin- which represent the vast majority of the state’s mangrove area heiro et al. (2012) describe characteristics of the uçá crab (Ucides (99%). These sections also have a history of human occupation and cordatus) that reflect its importance as a sentinel species in man- impact dating back to the 1500 s when the first Brazilian city (São groves in the Western Atlantic: endemism and reduced mobility, Vicente) was founded on the central coast of the state (Cunha- bioturbation of sediments, feeding on leaves and sediments (de- Lignon et al., 2011b). Six mangrove areas have been established posit feeding); reduced growth, a relatively long lifespan, higher (Fig. 1), three of which are located on the central coast (Bertioga, or abundance, and increased ease of capture. The uçá crab accumu- BET, Cubatão, or CUB, and São Vicente, or SAV) and the other three lates contaminants in its tissues; there is a high correlation which are located on the southern coast (Iguape, or IGU; Cananéia,
Please cite this article as: Duarte, L.F.d.A., et al., Multi-level biological responses in Ucides cordatus (Linnaeus, 1763) (Brachyura, Ucididae) as indicators of conservation status in mangrove areas from the western atlantic. Ecotoxicol. Environ. Saf. (2016), http://dx.doi. org/10.1016/j.ecoenv.2016.07.018i 178 L.F.d.A. Duarte et al. / Ecotoxicology and Environmental Safety 133 (2016) 176–187
Fig. 1. Location of the six mangrove areas sampled in the state of São Paulo (Brazil), represented by 18 subareas located in the central and southern coasts (Source: Satellite images from Google Earths redesigned by Gustavo Pinheiro). or CAN, and Juréia, or JUR, the latter of which is an ecological pentachlorophenol (PCP) into the environment. These three areas station). Each mangrove area includes three subareas (replicas) therefore have a history of more substantial human impact, with that are similar in tree composition (450% Rhizophora mangle), records of contamination by various xenobiotics, including metals vegetation structure (tree height 45 m and diameter at breast (Azevedo et al., 2009; Pinheiro et al., 2012, 2013) and organo- height 410 cm), height of flooding by tides (430 cm) and pro- chlorines (Martins et al., 2011). As a result, some sublethal damage ductivity (leaves available on the sediment 42gm 2). However, has been observed in the local biota, including genetic changes the six areas have experienced different types of human occupa- reflected by an increase in micronucleus frequency and alterations tion and impacts, and different contamination levels. Each area has in the cell nucleus. These changes have been confirmed in fishes, been characterized according to relevant parameters (see Table 1) crabs, and mollusks (Kirschbaum et al., 2009; Caricato et al., 2010; and based on a review of the main pollutants recorded at con- Hagger et al., 2010; Dissanayake et al., 2011; Pinheiro et al., 2013). centrations above legally permitted levels for brackish water The mangrove areas on the southern coast of São Paulo are (Environment Canada, 1999a) and sediment (Environment Canada approximately 80–200 km away from the mangrove areas on the 1999b, FDEP 1994). central coast. The southern coast is comprised of estuaries with Located on the central coast of São Paulo, the Bertioga Estuary more conserved areas, though some of these areas have already (BET) receives domestic untreated sewage and effluents from a exhibited effects of indirect anthropogenic influence. The Estuar- public garbage dump as its main source of pollution. Even so, the ine System that includes Cananéia, Iguape, and Juréia is located estuary is used for ecotourism and sport fishing, including uçá crab within a single environmental protection area (EPA) that also in- fishing (Eichler et al., 2006). Cubatão (CUB) is considered one of cludes the entire state of Paraná. Together, these land masses form the most polluted regions in the world; in recent years, it has the Lagamar Complex, one of the largest estuarine complexes in become the most important Brazilian industrial hub, formed by 23 Brazil. It covers 3287 km2 and includes other interconnected ba- industrial complexes, 111 factories, and more than 300 pollution sins (ISA, 1998). Located in the northeastern most portion of this sources. Home to the largest port in Latin America, it also ex- complex is the area known as Iguape (IGU), which until the early periences large vessel transit in which several types of chemicals 1990s received significant waste discharge from rich heavy metal are imported and exported (Pinheiro et al., 2012, 2013). Located mining in the Ribeira River (approximately 5.5 metric tons per within the same estuarine complex is São Vicente (SAV). This area month of Pb, Zn, Ag, As, Cd, Cu, and Cr, according to Tessler et al. is known for its substantial human activity, low GDP, illegal slums (1987), Eysink et al. (1988) and Cetesb (1988, 2000, 2007). The located within estuarine regions, and a lack of wastewater treat- area known as Cananéia (CAN) is located 50 km to the southwest. ment and solid waste collection (Cetesb, 2007; Kirschbaum et al., It includes preserved mangroves and excellent environmental 2009; Cordeiro and Costa, 2010), the latter of which is intensified quality, and uçá crab capture is substantial there (Duarte et al., by 11 industrial sources of pollution and the long-standing illegal 2014). Therefore, this region is important in analyses of the sub- deposition of organochlorine compounds such as lethal impacts on this species (Mendonça and Miranda, 2008;
Please cite this article as: Duarte, L.F.d.A., et al., Multi-level biological responses in Ucides cordatus (Linnaeus, 1763) (Brachyura, Ucididae) as indicators of conservation status in mangrove areas from the western atlantic. Ecotoxicol. Environ. Saf. (2016), http://dx.doi. org/10.1016/j.ecoenv.2016.07.018i org/10.1016/j.ecoenv.2016.07.018 laect hsatcea:Dat,LFdA,e l,Mlilvlbooia epne in responses biological Multi-level atlantic western al., the from et areas mangrove L.F.d.A., in status Duarte, conservation of as: indicators as article Ucididae) this cite Please
Table 1 Characteristics of the municipalities/areas sampled in the state of São Paulo (Brazil).
i Characteristic of Central Coast Southern Coast Municipality/Area Cubatão São Vicente Bertioga Mean7SD Total ∑ Iguape Cananéia Juréia Mean7SD Total ∑ ....Dat ta./EooiooyadEvrnetlSft 3 21)176 (2016) 133 Safety Environmental and Ecotoxicology / al. et Duarte L.F.d.A.
Main economic Industry Commerce and Tourism and Tourism, fish- Fishing Ecotourism and activity services commerce ing and sustainable commerce extraction
1 (km ) 142,879 147,893 490,148 – 780,920 1,977,957 1,239,376 7924 – 3,225,257 Área Number of 118,72 332,445 47,645 – 391,962 28,841 12,226 1285* – 42,352 inhabitants 1 Demographic 83,091 224,788 9721 105,8667109 317,600 1458 986 162 8687655 2606 1 2 density (hab./km ) HDI1 0.737 0.768 0.730 0.74570.20 – 0.726 0.720 – 0.72370.04 – GDP2 ( R$ 1000.00) 63,481.45 38,358.00 8855.89 36,898727,342 110,695.34 324.77 1347.06 – 835.917722.86 1671.83 GDP per capita 2 (R$) 52,772.36 11,388.65 17,604.74 27,255722,315 81,765.75 11,177.76 11,027.28 – 11,102 710,640 22,205.04 HPI3 (%) 21.30 15.00 25.00 20.4375.05 61.30 33.30 37.30 – 35.30728.28 70.60 Sanitation 4 (%) 75.14 87.08 30.81 64.34729.64 –––––– Drainage basin5 24,394 8581** 61,291 – 94,266 ––– – 17,068 (km2) Metals (water and As 6,Cd6,12 ,Pb6,11,14 ,Cu6,Cr6,11 ,Hg6,11 , Pb6,Cu6,7,13 ,Hg6,11 , As6,Cr6,11 , – 8 Contaminants Pb 9, 12 ,Cu12 Cd10 ––3 Contaminants sediment) Ni6,11 ,Zn6,11 Ni6,7 ,Cr7,11 ,Zn7,Cd12 Ni6,11 ,Cd11 Organochlorine pes- Alpha-BHC6, Delta-BHC 6, Gamma- Alpha-BHC 6, Beta- –– 4 Contaminants – DDT 8, DDE 8, ––4 Contaminants 6 6 6 8 8 ticides (water andBHC BHC , Delta-BHC , DDD , HCB 6 sediment) Gamma-BHC cdscordatus Ucides 6 ––– ––– – – ctxcl nio.Sf (2016), Saf. Environ. Ecotoxicol. . PCBs (Sediment) PCBs totais 1 Contaminant PAHs (Sediment)6 Acenaphthene, Acenaphthylene, An- Acenaphthylene, An- –– 12 Contaminants ––– – – thracene, Benzo-a-Anthracene, Ben- thracene, Benzo-a-
zo-a-Pyrene, Chrysene, Dibenzo-a- Anthracene – Anthracene, Phenanthrene, Fluor- 187 anthene, Fluorene, Naphthalene, Pyrene Lnau,16)(Brachyura, 1763) (Linnaeus,
HDI: Human Development Index, GDP: Gross Domestic Product, GDP per capita: GDP/number of inhabitants, HPI: Human Poverty Index, PCB: Polychlorinated Biphenyl and PAH: Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbon. References in 1 2 3 4 5 fi 6 Table 2: IBGE BRASIL (2010); IBGE BRASIL (2012); IBGE BRASIL (2000);*Nunes (2003), AGEM, Agência Metropolitana da Baixada Santista (2010), CBH Comitês de Bacias Hidrográ cas (2016), **To São Vicente Island, Cetesb 7(2001)Carmo, et al. (2011), 8Reigada et al. (2014), 9Sant’anna et al. (2014), 10 Mahiques et al. (2013), 11 Semensatto-Jr. et al. (2007), 12 Abessa and Ambrozevicius (2008), 13 Mahiques et al. (2009), 14 Cesar et al. (2006) and 15 Pinheiro et al. (2013). The use of a hyphen (-) represents information that is not available. http://dx.doi. 179 180 L.F.d.A. Duarte et al. / Ecotoxicology and Environmental Safety 133 (2016) 176–187
Pinheiro et al., 2012, 2013). The mangroves in Juréia (JUR) are lo- of the previously prepared slides, which were kept in a humidified cated approximately 50 km northeast of Iguape, and this area is in dark chamber (an acrylic box with paper moistened with distilled an ecological station known as the Juréia-Itatins Ecological Station water) for 15 min so that the cells would better adhere to the (EEJI). The human population is more limited in the region and is slides. In addition, 40 μL of working solution was dripped on the based on traditional extractive activities that are free of con- hemocytes on each slide, and these slides were then kept in the taminants (Marques and Duleba, 2004; Pinheiro et al., 2013). The humidified dark chamber for 15 min. Slides were covered using station is therefore considered effective in protecting local biodi- coverslips, and excess liquid was carefully removed using a filter versity (Bruner et al., 2001). In summary, Cananéia and Juréia are paper. In the first hour, the slides were examined every 15 min considered pristine estuarine regions of São Paulo State (Azevedo under an optical microscope (400x) and, if necessary, after the et al., 2009) where some cytological and hematological analyses in second hour, every 30 min. In contrast with micronucleus test, sea bass fish have not shown any sublethal damage (Kirschbaum only granulocytes and semi-granulocytes were evaluated (Hose et al., 2009; Seriani et al., 2013). et al., 1990; Martinez et al., 1999; Matozzo and Marin, 2010). Ly- sosome size and color were determined to assess stress level ab- 2.2. Multi-level biological responses exhibited by U. cordatus normalities, as was cell shape (irregular¼healthy; circular¼ stressed), these characteristics may also be altered by con- 2.2.1. Genotoxicity via micronucleus Test (MN‰): molecular level taminants (Collier et al., 2013). Details of the criteria used to define During the winter of 2013, adult male U. cordatus specimens granulocytes and semi-granulocytes as healthy or under stress are (carapace width or CW 460 mm) were captured by hand (see described by Lowe et al. (1995). Pinheiro and Fiscarelli (2001)). They were in the intermolt stage and free of parasites. Five specimens per subarea were obtained 2.2.3. Condition factor and crab density: population level (n¼15/area), for a total of 90 specimens for the genotoxicity Fulton's condition factor (K) was measured in mature males analysis. The animals collected underwent biometric procedures, from each area. It was calculated using on the following equation: including body size (CW) measurement using precision calipers b (0.01 mm) and total wet weight (WW) measurement using a KWWCWiii= /() precision scale (0.01 g). A hemolymph sample was obtained from where WW is the wet weight of the i-nth individual, recorded each crab in order to conduct the micronucleus test following a i using a digital precision balance (0.01 g), CWi is the carapace modified version of the protocol offered by Scarpato et al. (1990) width of the i-nth individual, measured using precision calipers and successfully employed by Nudi et al. (2010) and Pinheiro et al. (0.05 mm), and b is the constant growth in weight, determined (2013). The number of hemocytes (hyalinocytes) that contained fi micronuclei was recorded in relation to every 1000 cells analyzed using the t of the empirical points of the WW CW relation for ¼ b (MN‰), thus avoiding possible errors if granulocyte and semi- each area based on the power function (WW aCW ), as indicated granulocyte hemocytes were used (Hose et al., 1990; Martinez by Lima-Junior et al. (2002) and Pinheiro and Fiscarelli (2009). et al., 1999; and Matozzo and Marin, 2010). Micronucleated cells Therefore, the mean condition factor was calculated for each were identified according to the descriptions offered by Country- mangrove area and the differences were analyzed. The U. cordatus man and Heddle (1976), and were confirmed by the presence of density of each mangrove subarea was estimated using the pro- cytoplasmic corpuscles less than 1/3 of size of the nucleus (which tocol established by Pinheiro and Almeida (2015). In this case, the 2 were not connected to the micronuclei and which needed to ex- areas were comprised of four squares of 5 5 m (25 m ) to which hibit similar staining results). Cells with more than three micro- random sampling was applied. Two sites were near the margins of nuclei were not considered. the estuary (approximately 15 m away from the estuary water) with 50 m between them, and the other two were positioned 2.2.2. Cytotoxicity according to neutral red retention time (NRRT): more deeply inside the forest (about 30 m away from the banks of 2 physiological level the estuary). The total was therefore 100 m per subarea. The 2 Hemolymph samples were obtained from 10 specimens per density (ind m ) of each sample square was determined using subarea (n¼30/area), for a total of 180 samples for the cytotoxicity the indirect method based on the number of open and closed assay. First, the NRRT assay was applied to U. cordatus, with an burrows with biogenic activities (Pinheiro and Almeida, 2015)in adaptation to the protocol originally created by Lowe et al. (1995) which the presence of one crab per burrow is assumed (Wun- for bivalve mollusks and subsequently adapted to crabs (Buratti derlich et al., 2008). U. cordatus density was represented as the et al., 2012). The slides were decontaminated with nitric acid (5%) average obtained in each mangrove area from twelve sampling 2 and then washed, air dried, and treated with a diluted poly-L-ly- units (300 m ). sine solution (1:10 in distilled water) using 10 μL per slide for hemocyte adhesion. The four following solutions were prepared: 2.3. Environmental quality indicator: quantity of solid waste (1) a physiological solution (4.77 g of HEPES, 25.48 g of sodium chloride, 4.36 g of magnesium sulfate, 0.75 g of potassium chlor- In addition to the environmental impacts obtained from a re- ide, 1.92 g of calcium chloride, 1 L of distilled water, and pH 7.36); view of the literature, the quantity of solid waste (g m 2)by (2) a stock neutral red solution (22.8 mg of neutral red and 1 mL of mangrove area or subarea was also used as an indicator of en- DMSO); (3) a working solution (10 μL of the stock solution and vironmental quality. Solid waste is also a source of contamination 5 mL of physiological solution); and (4) an anticoagulant solution for U. cordatus, and it was assumed that many types of con- (2.05 g of glucose, 0.8 g of sodium citrate, 0.42 g of sodium chlor- taminants are higher in places where there is a greater human ide, and 100 mL of distilled water). The anticoagulant and phy- presence (Abessa and Ambrozevicius, 2008; Cordeiro and Costa, siological solutions were mixed (a 3:2 ratio) using a 0.5-mL filled 2010). To achieve this information, waste found in the sediment hypodermic syringe (1 mL, provided with a 21 G needle). These was collected from the same square sample used to estimate crab syringes were used to extract 0.5 mL of hemolymph per crab, and density. These items were placed in plastic bags and transported to the samples were transferred into microtubes (2 mL) that were the laboratory, where they were classified according to type slightly homogenized and then placed onto specific shelves for 15– (processed wood, plastic, glass, etc.), washed to remove mud, and 20 min. Next, 40 μL of a hemolymph, anticoagulant and physio- dried in a forced ventilation oven (60 °C for 72 h), until a constant logical solution were dripped from each microtube on the surface weight was achieved on a digital precision scale (0.01 g). Dry
Please cite this article as: Duarte, L.F.d.A., et al., Multi-level biological responses in Ucides cordatus (Linnaeus, 1763) (Brachyura, Ucididae) as indicators of conservation status in mangrove areas from the western atlantic. Ecotoxicol. Environ. Saf. (2016), http://dx.doi. org/10.1016/j.ecoenv.2016.07.018i L.F.d.A. Duarte et al. / Ecotoxicology and Environmental Safety 133 (2016) 176–187 181 weight average of solid waste by mangrove area was calculated for Vicente mangrove stood out not both solid waste volume and 12 sample squares (300 m2). quantity (375 units), as well as for the variety of items (62.5%). The solid waste from the São Vicente mangrove was represented by 2.4. Statistical analysis 328 pieces of plastic, 38 pieces of processed wood, 7 cloths, 1 piece of glass, and 1 piece of Styrofoam. A similar situation was recorded Excel and R 2.13.0 were used to design the figures and perform in the Cubatão mangrove, which presented an abundance that was the statistical analyses (Ihaka and Gentleman, 1996). Results of the three times lower (123 units) and more diverse (87.5%). The Cu- cytotoxicity tests (neutral red retention time, in minutes), geno- batão waste consisted of 100 pieces of plastic, 6 cloths, 6 pieces of toxicity tests (micronucleated cells per 1000 analyzed cells), solid processed wood, 4 pieces of paper, 4 pieces of Styrofoam, 2 pieces waste volume (g m 2), and the condition factor and density of glass, and 1 piece of rubber. The Bertioga sample totaled only 20 (ind m 2)ofU. cordatus were all represented by their averages solid waste units distributed across five categories (62.5%), with 15 (7standard deviations) for each mangrove area. In all cases, the pieces of plastic, 2 pieces of processed wood, 1 cloth, 1 piece of means were compared using ANOVA and a post hoc multiple Styrofoam, and 1 piece of concrete. comparison with Tukey's range test, confirming a normal dis- The animals used in the sublethal damage assessment had an tribution (Shapiro-Wilk test) and equality of variances, or homo- average carapace width of 77.41 mm (75.53) and an average scedasticity via Levene’s test (Zar, 1999; Faraway, 2002). The weight of 210.7 g (738.92). With the exception of the condition average of each biological parameter (cytotoxicity, genotoxicity, factor (K), which did not differ statistically between the study condition factor, and crab density) were used to determine multi- areas (ranging from Cananéia¼4.62 10 470.42 10 4 to Ig- level biological responses in relation to the contamination in- uape¼4.82 10 4 70.44 10 4), all of the biological responses pre- dicator (solid waste) based on a multifactorial analysis comprised sented statistical differences according to ANOVA. There were of a principal component analysis (PCA), a distances of similarity contrasts between some areas according to Tukey's test (po0.05). analysis, and a cluster analysis based on Euclidean distance Genotoxicity results (MN‰) were found to be in the following (Kaufman and Rousseeuw, 1990). Calculations were executed using mangrove order: SAV (7.472.6)4[CUB (5.271.9)¼BET an R package named FactoMineR (Husson et al., 2012), with a (5.071.3)¼IGU (3.872.5)]4[JUR (0.771.0)¼CAN (0.470.6)] classification of each area clustered by similarity (Q mode). (Fig. 3A). A similar order occurred in the case of the cytotoxicity The NRRT vs. MN association was determined using a Spear- results, which were found to be as follows: CUB (29.5710.0)4 man's rank correlation coefficient and empirical points obtained [BET (51.0718.7)¼SAV (61.5710.7)]ZIGU (71.0714.7)4CAN from all mangrove subareas sampled. The statistical significance (141.0751.8)4JUR (260.0742.7) (Fig. 3B). The average crab was 5% and the association was confirmed using tabulated data density was found to be in accordance with the sublethal re- with n-2 degrees of freedom (Zar, 1999). A power function was sponses observed: lower densities were found in mangrove areas applied to the empirical point of this relationship (Y¼aXb), with that experienced more sublethal damage and human impact: [BET interpretation by the coefficient of determination (R2). (0.7770.83)¼CUB (0.9970.68)¼SAV (1.3270.91)rIGU (1.6570.65)]r[CAN (1.870.78)¼JUR (1.9271.03)] (Fig. 3C). The two biomarkers (NRRT and MN‰) were found to share a 3. Results significant negative correlation (r¼–0.78; Po0.01; Fig. 4). There is therefore evidence that they are antagonistic but that they reflect A total of 517 solid waste samples from the mangrove areas to the same sequence as the conservation status of mangroves studied were divided into eight categories: plastic (85.5%), pro- studied. Empirical points of the NRRT vs. MN‰ correlation were cessed wood (8.9%), cloth (2.7%), Styrofoam (1.0%), paper (0.8%), adjusted by the power function, resulting in the equation 0.424 glass (0.6%), rubber (0.4%), and pieces of concrete (0.2%). At the NRRT¼153.58MN and 61.8% representation of the fitted Juréia and Cananéia sites, there was no solid waste (in g m 2; see empirical points. Fig. 2), while the lowest average was found in Iguape (0.470.9) These indicators show that the mangrove areas of Cubatão, São and the highest was recorded in the central coast mangroves: SAV Vicente, and Bertioga experience greater human impact, while the (34.4732.6)4BET (22.2726.6)4CUB (18.9732.1). The São mangroves of Juréia and Cananéia presented higher environmental quality. The Iguape area, on the other hand, remained in a rela- tively moderate position, regardless of the indicator (Chart 1). It is important to note that, for the first three sites (greatest impact), the fourth site (moderate impact), and the last two sites (minor impact), there were no changes in mangrove areas asso- ciated with the indicators; there was only a change in the hier- archy within these groups, depending on the sensitivity of the indicator employed. These three groups (Group 1, Juréia and Ca- nanéia; Group 2, Iguape; and Group 3, Cubatão, Bertioga, and São Vicente) were confirmed by multifactorial analysis (Fig. 5). The multi-level biological response proved to be compatible with the environmental quality indicator (solid waste). Thus, Group 3 was characterized as the areas experiencing the greatest sublethal damage associated with higher solid waste volumes and lower crab population densities, while the opposite occurred in Group 1. Similar to the information presented in Chart 1, Iguape (Group 2) was found to be between the other two groups.