Breaking Barriers to Novel Analgesic Drug Development
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
REVIEWS Breaking barriers to novel analgesic drug development Ajay S. Yekkirala1–3, David P. Roberson1–3, Bruce P. Bean1 and Clifford J. Woolf1,2 Abstract | Acute and chronic pain complaints, although common, are generally poorly served by existing therapies. This unmet clinical need reflects a failure to develop novel classes of analgesics with superior efficacy, diminished adverse effects and a lower abuse liability than those currently available. Reasons for this include the heterogeneity of clinical pain conditions, the complexity and diversity of underlying pathophysiological mechanisms, and the unreliability of some preclinical pain models. However, recent advances in our understanding of the neurobiology of pain are beginning to offer opportunities for developing novel therapeutic strategies and revisiting existing targets, including modulating ion channels, enzymes and G-protein-coupled receptors. Pain is the primary reason why people seek medical blockbuster model of one treatment for all pain condi- Analgesics 12 Pharmacological agents or care: more than 40% of the US population is affected tions is not tenable . The poor predictability of preclin- 1 ligands that produce analgesia. by chronic pain . In the United States alone in 2013, the ical ‘pain’ models can result in candidates being selected overall cost of treating certain chronic pain conditions that do not have activity in the conditions suffered by Tolerance amounted to more than US$130 billion2. Currently avail- patients13 (BOX 1). Conversely, difficulty in ensuring A state in which the drug no analgesics longer produces the same able — nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs target engagement, lack of sensitivity of clinical trials effect and a higher dose is (NSAIDs), amine reuptake inhibitors, anti epileptic and distortions induced by placebos increase the risk therefore needed. drugs and opioids — have varying but typically low that potentially effective compounds or targets may levels of analgesic efficacy, which is generally coupled be prematurely abandoned14,15. These issues have led Dependence with deleterious effects2. Indeed, opioids, which are the to most drug developmental efforts being devoted to An adaptive state that develops when a pharmacological agent most commonly used (with ~240 million prescriptions reformulations of existing validated analgesic classes — 3 is used repeatedly and leads to in 2014 in the United States) and often the most effec- opioids, NSAIDs, antiepileptic agents and amine reuptake withdrawal on cessation of the tive class of analgesics, produce tolerance, dependence inhibitors — despite their well-known limitations16. drug regimen. and constipation, and are associated with major abuse Given the prevalence of opioid diversion and over- 1Department of liabilities. Furthermore, the respiratory depression asso- dose, there is an urgent need to develop effective and Neurobiology, Harvard ciated with high doses has led to a catastrophic increase safe analgesics without a liability for abuse. Work from a Medical School, Boston in the number of drug overdose deaths in the United large number of laboratories has shed light on the mech- Children’s Hospital, 300 States3 (see the US Centers for Disease Control and anisms and pathways that mediate specific aspects of the Longwood Avenue, Boston, 8,10,11,17–19 Massachusetts 02115, USA. Prevention website). nociceptive nexus (FIG. 1), revealing the poten- 2FM Kirby Neurobiology Diverse pathological situations at different anato- tial for more fine-tuned targeting of acute and chronic Center Boston Children’s mical sites can lead to pain. Causes of pain include pain in different clinical conditions. Completely new Hospital, 300 Longwood cancer, inflammation or tissue injury, as well as injury therapeutic strategies targeting ion channels, enzymes Avenue, Boston, 4–8 Massachusetts 02115, USA. or lesions of the nervous system . Diverse chronic and G-protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs), often with 3Blue Therapeutics, Harvard widespread pain syndromes may also occur owing to human genetic validation, are emerging. In this Review, Innovation Launch Lab, 114 abnormal amplification states in the central nervous sys- we present these emerging mechanisms and assess tar- Western Avenue, Allston, tem (CNS)9–11. All of these can lead, through abnormal gets and agents in preclinical and early clinical stages of Massachusetts 02134, USA. Correspondence to A.S.Y. activity in nociceptive systems, to pain in the absence development that show promise for the development and C.J.W. of a stimulus (spontaneous pain), exaggerated responses of innovative analgesics (TABLES 1,2). [email protected]; to noxious stimuli (hyperalgesia) and pain evoked by Clifford.Woolf@childrens. normally innocuous stimuli (allodynia). Neurobiology of pain harvard.edu The heterogeneity of clinical pain conditions and The mechanisms that sustain and drive chronic pain doi:10.1038/nrd.2017.87 the complexity and multiplicity of underlying patho- (FIG. 1) have been exhaustively reviewed elsewhere7,10,17,20–23. Published online 9 Jun 2017 Corrected online 23 Jun 2017 physiological mechanisms has made it difficult to iden- In physiological situations, pain is a necessary protective and 6 Oct 2017 tify tractable targets with broad involvement — the response that is initiated by high-threshold peripheral NATURE REVIEWS | DRUG DISCOVERY VOLUME 16 | AUGUST 2017 | 545 ©2017 Mac millan Publishers Li mited, part of Spri nger Nature. All ri ghts reserved. REVIEWS Box 1 | The challenges of preclinical models of pain Another driver for spontaneous pain in the absence of a peripheral stimulus is the ectopic activity of primary 255,256 Preclinical rodent efficacy models are essential for analgesic development , but sensory neurons (FIG. 1). Several voltage-gated sodium their predictive validity has been questioned owing to several high-profile programmes channels (Nav1.3 (REFS 27,28), Nav1.7 and Nav1.8 in which rodent behavioural readouts predicted analgesic effects that were absent in (REFS 29–34)), potassium channels (KCNQ), calcium humans. For example, fatty acid amide hydrolase (FAAH) inhibitors were found to be antinociceptive in a range of animal models, but compounds such as PF-04457845 channels (Cav2.2) and hyperpolarization-activated produced no analgesic effect in people with osteoarthritis despite lowering FAAH cyclic nucleotide-modulated channel (HCN) have been activity by >96%244. Similarly, NK1 (substance P) antagonists were shown to robustly implicated in the modulation of ectopic activity and reverse rodent nociceptive responses in the context of inflammation and nerve injury membrane excitability in sensory neurons, especially but failed to produce analgesia in subsequent clinical trials257. Nonetheless, many after peripheral nerve injury35–38. However, a direct rela- clinically used analgesics, such as nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) and tionship between such ectopic activity of primary sen- opioids, produce antinociceptive effects in rodents256, albeit typically at much higher sory neurons with spontaneous pain is yet to be proven, doses than those used in patients. mainly due to inconsistent results and the paucity of reli- Using animal models of pain to detect putative analgesics faces several challenges. able preclinical models, although live-cell imaging with First, how do you measure pain, a conscious subjective report of an unpleasant sensory genetically encoded activity reporters should change this. experience, when you have no access to how an animal feels? Second, are the models true surrogates for the conditions or diseases that commonly produce pain in patients? One major consequence of peripheral inflamma- Third, how do you eliminate the confounders of bias, observer-induced changes and tion is the hyperfunction of nociceptive transduction lack of reproducibility? And last, it is possible that drugs that target human proteins ion channels on the peripheral terminals of sensory may not be active on their rodent homologues. neurons. These channels are responsible for converting Effectively measuring pain is perhaps the most difficult challenge, as we can only noxious stimuli into inward currents. The peripheral measure outcomes that may correlate with some aspect of pain, such as withdrawal sensitization of these transducers and ion channels from a stimulus or learned avoidance from a situation that may be painful. For involved in membrane excitability leads to a reduction reflexive measures of pain, typically a brief stimulus lasting for seconds is applied to in the threshold for activation and hyperexcitability of 5,6 a part of an animal’s body and a response measured . This clearly bears little nociceptor sensory neurons17. However, peripheral sen- correspondence to the clinical situation of ongoing spontaneous pain. Attempts have sitization alone does not fully account for the prolonged been made to develop outcome measures that may reflect the presence of discomfort, but these require more effort and validation to make them robust and presence of pain, dynamic tactile allodynia, temporal useful255. Some classes of analgesics, such as opiates, can reduce nociceptive reflexes summation of pain and the spread of pain hypersensi- 26 at high doses; however, this does not mean that such reflexes have predictive validity tivity to non- injured tissue (secondary hyper algesia) . for all classes of analgesics. These features of pain hypersensitivity are the conse- Some disease surrogates, such