DOCSLIB.ORG

Programme, Through the Rigorous Examination of Existing Studies

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Programme, Through the Rigorous Examination of Existing Studies 2014 CAMPBELL COLLABORATION COLLOQUIUM BETTER EVIDENCE FOR A BETTER WORLD 16–19 JUNE QUEEN’S UNIVERSITY BELFAST #C2Belfast www.campbellcollaboration.org/next_colloquium Welcome We are delighted to welcome you to the Campbell Colloquium, held this year on the campus of Queen’s University Belfast. The Campbell Collaboration is an idealistic network with a straightforward mission: to improve lives. The path to that goal is far from straightforward, however. Our primary role is to provide better evidence of the impact of a given intervention or programme, through the rigorous examination of existing studies. We see this as an important step towards better informed decisions, which in turn can deliver better outcomes to people relying on services. The Lancet has called our Colloquium “a radical and impressive gathering that promised new ways to address urgent issues in health and social care.” We feel that this week’s programme lives up to that billing. Plenary sessions address how to identify the questions that need to be addressed; how to build global capacity for evidence-based approaches; how to use science and research to improve social care, policing and education; and how to tackle poverty more effectively. Workshops and panels are designed to allow discussion of many parts of the evidence cycle, including problem formulation, user engagement and the perennial challenge of bringing findings to those who need them. As in previous years, we place a special emphasis on the methods of research synthesis, an area in which the Collaboration can point to high-level international expertise. The members of the Scientific Programme Committee, chaired by Gary Ritter and coordinated by Sean Grant, had a key role in putting this together, and we owe a special thanks for their work. We are excited to come to Belfast, a vibrant city with a rich and sometimes difficult history that in recent decades has seen a major transformation. The origins of this change are complex, but it also owes something to a shared desire to build a better future, and to the ability to talk about divisions and differences. In this sense, the story of Belfast can also be an inspiration for our own gathering. We are extremely grateful to the Centre for Effective Education at Queen’s University Belfast for hosting the Colloquium this year (HYPERLINK www.qub.ac.uk/cee). We are particularly grateful to Paul Connolly and his local organising committee from the Centre, Kelly Gaw, Laura Dunne, and Sarah Miller, for all of their support and hard work in making the Colloquium possible. Arild Bjørndal Julia Littell Eamonn Noonan Co-Chair Co-Chair CEO Conference Programme Queen’s University Belfast, Northern Ireland 1 Contents 4 Conference at a Glance 13 Map of Belfast 14 Queens University Map 15 2014 Colloquium Workshops 17 Colloquium Plenary Speakers 19 Panel Abstracts 49 Poster Presentations 53 Poster Abstracts 92 List of Exhibitors Conference Programme Queen’s University Belfast, Northern Ireland 3 Conference at a Glance Monday 16th June 8.00-9.00 Registration with Breakfast 9.00-10.15 Training Session 1 10.15-10.45 Coffee/Tea 10.45-11.45 Opening Plenary: Mona Nasser Research Priority Setting 11.45-12.45 Lunch 13.00-14.15 Training Session 2 14.15-14.45 Coffee/Tea 14.45-16.00 Training Session 3 16.15 – 16.45 Graduate Student Reception 17.00 – 18.00 Poster Session 1 and Cocktails 18.00 – 19.00 Poster Session 2 and Cocktails Tuesday 17th June 8.00-9.00 Breakfast 9.00-10.15 Training Session 4 10.15-10.45 Coffee/Tea Plenary 2: Sandy Oliver Global Capacity for Systematic Reviews. 10.45-11.45 Howard White Are Systematic Reviews Relevant to Policy Makers? 11.45-12.45 Lunch 13.00-14.15 Training Session 5 14.15-14.45 Coffee/Tea 14.45-15.45 Plenary 3: Paul Connolly The Advance of Evidence-Based Approaches in Ireland 16.00-17.00 Campbell Coordinating Group Meetings 18.30 -19.30 Belfast City Hall Reception 18.30 – 19.30 Civic Reception 4 Queen’s University Belfast, Northern Ireland Conference Programme Conference at a Glance Wednesday 18th June 8.00-9.00 Breakfast 9.00-10.15 Panel Session 1 10.15-10.45 Coffee/Tea Plenary 4: Tony Hunter Prospects for Evidence-Based Approaches in 10.45-11.45 Social Care 11.45-12.45 Lunch 13.00-14.15 Panel Session 2 14.15-14.45 Coffee/Tea 14.45-16.00 Panel Session 3 16.00-16.30 Coffee/Tea 16.30-17.30 C2 Business Meeting 19.00 19.30 Drinks Reception 19.30-23.00 Gala Dinner Thursday 19th June 8.00-9.00 Breakfast 9.00-10.15 Panel Session 4 10.15-10.45 Coffee/Tea 10.45-11.45 Plenary 5: Kitty Stewart and Kerris Cooper: Combatting Poverty 11.45-12.45 Lunch 13.00-14.15 Panel Session 5 14.15-15.00 Coffee/Tea 15.00-16.00 Closing Plenary Peter Neyroud: Using Science to Improve Policing. 16.00 - 16.15 Closing remarks from C2 Conference Programme Queen’s University Belfast, Northern Ireland 5 Full Conference Schedule Monday 16 June Time Agenda Details Location 8.00-9.00 Registration with Whitla Hall Breakfast 9.00-10.15 Training Session 1 Introductory Level: Problem Formulation (Sean Grant) College Park 01/026 Applied Level: Moderator Analysis LAN 01/052 Lanyon (Jeffrey Valentine) Building 1st Floor 10.15-10.45 Coffee/Tea Whitla Hall 10.45-11.45 Opening Plenary Mona Nasser, Research Priority Setting Whitla Hall 11.45-12.45 Lunch Whitla Hall 13.00-14.15 Introductory Level: Literature Searching (Karianne LAN 01/052 Lanyon Training Session 2 Hammerstrøm) Building 1st Floor Applied Level: Robust Variance Estimation (Emily College Park 01/026 Tanner-Smith) 14.15-14.45 Coffee/Tea South Dining Room 14.45-16.00 Introductory Level: Coding College Park 01/026 Training Session 3 (Sandra Wilson) Advanced Level: Network Meta-Analyses (Dimitris LAN 01/052 Lanyon Mavridis) Building 1st Floor 16.15 – 16.45 Graduate Student Whitla Hall Reception 17.00 – 18.00 Poster Session and Poster session 1 South Dining Room Cocktails 18.00 – 19.00 Poster Session and Poster session 2 South Dining Room Cocktails 6 Queen’s University Belfast, Northern Ireland Conference Programme 2014 Campbell Collaboration Colloquium 16-19 June 2014 Tuesday 17 June Time Agenda Details Location 8.00-9.00 Breakfast Whitla Hall 9.00-10.15 Training Session 4 Introductory Level: Calculating Effect Sizes LAN 01/052 (David Wilson) Lanyon Building 1st Floor Applied Level: Individual Participant Data Meta- College Park 01/026 Analysis (Terri Pigott) Knowledge Translation and Implementation College Park 01/035 Workshop Part 1 10.15-10.45 Coffee/Tea Whitla Hall 10.45-11.45 Plenary 2 Sandy Oliver: Global Capacity for Systematic Reviews Whitla Hall 11.45-12.45 Lunch Whitla Hall 13.00-14.15 Training Session 5 Introductory Level: Introduction to Meta-Analysis LAN 01/052 (Jeffrey Valentine) Lanyon Building 1st Floor Advanced Level: Multilevel Meta-Analysis College Park 01/026 (Joshua Polanin) Knowledge Translation and Implementation College Park 01/035 Workshop Part 2 14.15-14.45 Coffee/Tea Whitla Hall 14.45-15.45 Plenary 3 Paul Connolly: The advance of evidence-based Whitla Hall approaches in Ireland 16.00-17.00 Campbell ED Meeting College Park 01/026 Coordinating Group SW Meeting 01/035 Meetings ID Meeting 01/037 KTI Meeting 6 University Square LAN 01/052 CJ Meeting Lanyon Building 1st Floor Methods Meeting LAN 0G/049 Lanyon Building Ground Floor 18.30 - 19.30 Civic Reception Belfast City Hall, hosted by Lord Mayor Conference Programme Queen’s University Belfast, Northern Ireland 7 Full Conference Schedule Wednesday 18 June Time Details Location 8.00-9.00 Breakfast Whitla Hall 9.00-10.15 Sub Panel Session 1 No: Session 1a User Engagement and User-Centered Design and Delivery College Park 01/035 Chair: Aron 25 Does User Involvement Produce Higher Quality Reviews? Mike Fisher. Shlonsky 94 Engaging Stakeholdersi n the Development of an Economic Analysis of Domestic Violence Interventions for Nice Public Health Guidance. Jacque Mallender. 135 Systematic Review Summaries on Child Welfare Services. Hege Kornør. Session 1b Question Formulation and Prioritization LAN 01/052 Lanyon Building 1st Chair: Brandy 100 Mapping the Intervention Literature in Military Social Work. Floor Maynard David L. Albright. 92 Improving The Utility and Practice Of Evidence Synthesis: Views and Experiences of Public Health Decision Makers and Review Authors in the Uk. Hilary Thomson. Session 1C A Spectrum of Methods: Choosing Appropriate Synthesis and College Park 01/026 Chair: Emily Evaluation Methods Tanner Smith 37 Development of a Quality Scoring System for Autism Reviews. Melissa McPheeters. Impacts Of Water, Sanitation and Hygiene Interventions: An Evidence Gap Discussant: 95 Map and Systematic Review. Terri Pigott Hugh Waddington 110 Theory-Based Evaluation of Criminal Justice Interventions for Intimate Partner Violence. Karen Schucan Bird. Session 1d Knowledge translation and implementation: moving from evidence to College Park 01/037 Chair: Warren recommendations Cann 88 “Why is the U.S. So Bad at Knowledge Transfer and Implementation of Evidence-based Practices in Education and How Can It Do Better?” John ‘Jack’ States. Discussant: Introducing the Collaboration for Environmental Evidence Robyn Mildon 16 Andrew Pullin and Ruth Stewart. 76 The Role of Campbell Collaboration in Promoting Access to Evidence In Africa: Better Evidence for Better Africa. Aweh Annih Akofu. 10.15-10.45 Coffee/Tea Whitla Hall 10.45-11.45 Plenary 4 Whitla Hall Tony Hunter: Prospects for Evidence-Based Approaches in Social Care 11.45-12.45 Lunch Whitla Hall 8 Queen’s University Belfast, Northern Ireland Conference Programme 2014 Campbell Collaboration Colloquium 16-19 June 2014 Wednesday 18 June (continued) Time Details Location 13.00-14.15 Sub Panel Session 2 No: Session 2a A Spectrum of Methods: Using Appropriate Evidence Synthesis and College Park 01/035 Chair: Emily Evaluation Methods for Quantitative Research Tanner Smith 22 How to Use R for Meta-Analysis.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • The Party's Over?
    The Party’s Over? 63rd Annual International Conference 25 - 27 March 2013 City Hall, Cardiff, Wales Cover images: courtesy of www.visitcardiff.com Stay informed of Routledge Politics journal news and book highlights Explore Routledge Politics journals with your 14 days’ free access voucher, available at the Routledge stand throughout the conference. Sign up at the To discover future news and offers, Routledge stand and make sure you subscribe to the Politics we’ll enter you into our & International Relations Bulletin. exclusive prize draw to win a Kindle! explore.tandfonline.com/pair BIG_4664_PSA_A4 advert_final.indd 1 27/02/2013 11:38 Croeso i Gaerdydd! Welcome to Cardiff! Dear Conference delegate, I’d like to welcome you to this 63rd Conference of the Political Studies Association, held in Cardiff for the first time and hosted by the University of Cardiff. We are expecting over 600 delegates, representing over 80 different countries, to join us at Cardiff’s historic City Hall. The conference theme is ‘The Party’s Over?’; are the assumptions that have underpinned political life and political analysis sustainable? This subject will most certainly be explored during our Plenary Session ‘Leveson and the Future of Political Journalism’, a debate that has enormous ramifications for the future of UK politics. We will bring together some of the most passionate and eloquent voices on this topic; Chris Bryant MP, Trevor Kavanagh, Mick Hume and Professor Brian Cathcart. This year’s Government and Opposition- sponsored Leonard Schapiro lecture will be given by Professor Donatella Della Porta, who will consider the issue of political violence, the new editor of the American Political Science Review, Professor John Ishiyama, will discuss ‘The Future of Political Science’ and the First Minister of Wales, Carwyn Jones AM, will address attendees at the conference dinner.
    [Show full text]
  • Nicola Mary Brewer
    Nicola Mary Brewer (Taplow, United Kingdom, 1957) PROFESSIONAL PROFILE AND BIOGRAPHICAL DATA Type: independent director. Committees: member of the Sustainable Development Committee. Date of appointment as a director of Iberdrola, S.A.: 2 April 2020. Interest in the share capital of Iberdrola, S.A.: 1,000 shares (0.0%). Other current positions and professional activities Non-executive director of Aggreko plc. Academic training Was educated at the Belfast Royal Academy and read English at the University of Leeds, graduating with a BA in 1980, then taking a Doctorate in linguistics in 1988. Granted an Honorary Doctorate of Laws from the University of Leeds in 2009. Noteworthy experience in the energy and industrial engineering sector Held the position of independent director at Scottish Power Ltd., the country subholding company of the energy businesses in the United Kingdom. While holding this position, she has obtained a first-hand understanding of the operation of the Iberdrola group and the main challenges and opportunities of the energy sector in a key market. Noteworthy experience in other industries She was a diplomat until 2014, having been the Founding Director of the Diplomatic Academy of the Foreign and Commonwealth Office (“FCO”) of the British government. In 2009, she succeeded Mr Paul Boateng as British High Commissioner to South Africa, Swaziland and Lesotho, completing her mission in September 2013. In December 2006, she was appointed by open competition as the first Chief Executive of the newly established Equality and Human Rights Commission, the successor body to the Commission for Racial Equality, the Disability Rights Commission and the Equal Opportunities Commission, taking up her new position in 2007 and standing down in 2009.
    [Show full text]
  • British Security in the 2020S"
    "British Security in the 2020s" Professor Michael Clarke Former Director-General RUSI (Royal United Services Institute) Professor Michael Clarke was Director General of the Royal United Services Institute (RUSI) from 2007 to 2015. Until 2001 he was Deputy Vice-Principal and Director for Research Development at King’s College London, where he remains a Visiting Professor. From 1990 to 2001 he was the founding Director of the Centre for Defence Studies at King's. He is now a Fellow of King’s College London and of the Universities of Aberystwyth and Exeter. He has previously taught at Aberystwyth, Manchester and Newcastle-upon-Tyne, New Brunswick, and the Open University. He has been a Guest Fellow at the Brookings Institution, and a Fellow in Foreign Policy Studies at the Royal Institute of International Affairs. Michael has been a specialist adviser to the House of Commons Defence Committee since 1997. In 2004 he was appointed as the UK’s member of the UN Secretary General’s Advisory Board on Disarmament Matters. In 2009 he was appointed to the Prime Minister’s National Security Forum and in 2010 to the Chief of Defence Staff’s Strategic Advisory Group. In January 2016 he was appointed a specialist adviser to the Joint National Committee on Security Strategy for the period of the current Parliament. Michael is an Hon Member of the Keele World Affairs Advisory Panel. " The Great War and Today's World" Professor Sir Hew Strachan Professor of International Relations, University of St Andrews Hew Strachan read History at Corpus Christi College, Cambridge (MA, PhD) and is now a Life Fellow.
    [Show full text]
  • Annual Corporate Governance Report
    Annual Corporate Governance Report Financial Year 2020 NOTICE. This document is a translation of a duly approved Spanish-language document, and is provided for informational purposes only. In the event of any discrepancy between the text of this translation and the text of the original Spanish-language docum ent that this translation is intended to reflect, the text of the original Spanish-language document shall prevail. ANNUAL CORPORATE GOVERNANCE REPORT OF LISTED PUBLIC LIMITED COMPANIES ISSUER IDENTIFICATION DETAILS YEAR-END DATE 31/12/2020 TAX IDENTIFICATION CODE (C.I.F.) A-48010615 Company Name: IBERDROLA, S.A. Registered Office: Plaza Euskadi número 5 48009 Bilbao - Biscay - Spain 1 ANNUAL CORPORATE GOVERNANCE REPORT OF LISTED PUBLIC LIMITED COMPANIES A OWNERSHIP STRUCTURE A.1 Complete the table below with details of the company's share capital: Number of voting Date of last change Share capital (euros) Number of shares rights 29/07/2020 4,762,545,750 6,350,061,000 6,350,061,000 Indicate whether there are different classes of shares with different associated rights: Yes No X Remarks On 2 February 2021, the share capital was increased to 4,813,617,000 euros, represented by 6,418,156,000 ordinary shares having a nominal value of 0.75 euro each, belonging to a single class and series, which are fully subscribed and paid up. A.2 List the company’s significant direct and indirect shareholders at year end, excluding directors: Name or % of voting rights attached to the % of voting rights through % of total company name shares financial instruments voting rights of shareholder Direct Indirect Direct Indirect BLACKROCK, INC.
    [Show full text]
  • Programme for Website.Pub (Read-Only)
    CAISTOR GRAMMAR SCHOOL School Year 2013-2014 PRESENTATION OF AWARDS on Thursday 18th September 2014 at Caistor Parish Church by Sir David Bell, KCB Vice Chancellor University of Reading Mr Roger Hale Headmaster 28 Mr John Colley Chair of Governors Senior Prefect Team: Head Boy: Ben Stacey Head Girl: Kate Pattison Sir David Bell, KCB Deputy Head Boy: Marcus Polledri Deputy Head Girl: May Al Moasseb Sir David Bell took up the post of Vice-Chancellor of the University of Reading on 1st January 2012. Since then he has Secretary to School Council: Sheehan Quirke spearheaded the University’s development of a campus in Secretary to School Council: Annie May Malaysia (due to open in 2015) as part of the University’s ambitious internationalism strategy. A key priority for Sir David is to maintain the University’s position as one of the top 1% in the House Officials: world. Ayscough Born in Glasgow, Sir David studied History and Philosophy at House Captains: Sree Ghosh, George Kirkby Glasgow University and obtained his PGCE from Jordanhill Sports Captains: Olivia Sowerby, Aidan Watts College of Education. He has a Master of Education degree in Performing Arts: Katherine Briggs, Christopher Allan Management and Administration from Glasgow University. Sir David held teaching posts in primary schools in Glasgow before becoming a deputy head and then head in a school in Essex. Hansard House Captains: Sophie Botham, Matthew Hoare Sir David went on to become Chief Education Officer of Sports Captains: Lucy Walker, Harry Capstick Newcastle City Council, Chief Executive of Bedfordshire County Performing Arts: Bethany Laverick, Noah Phillips Council, HMCI (that is Head of Ofsted) and most recently, Permanent Secretary at the Department of Education.
    [Show full text]
  • Academy Awards 2011
    News Summer 2011 President’s column 2 News of Fellows 3 Policy and public affairs 4 Research 5 International 6 Development 8 Events and awards 9 Education 10 Public engagement 11 Obituaries 12 Academy Awards 2011 On 6 June 2011, more than 350 Fellows, representatives from leading companies and their guests, award finalists and prize winners once again filled London’s historic Guildhall for the Academy’s annual awards evening. The compère for the ceremony was Radio 4 Today programme presenter Sarah Montague, who introduced Academy President Lord Browne of Madingley FREng FRS and guest of honour the Rt Hon Vince Cable MP, Secretary of State for Business, Innovation and Skills. The UK’s most valuable engineering innovation prize, the £50,000 MacRobert Award, was presented to a Cambridge-based team from Microsoft Research for their work in helping to create Microsoft Kinect for Xbox 360, the world’s first truly hands-free gaming system, which holds the Guinness World Record as the fastest-selling consumer electronics device in history. The five winning engineers, Professor Andrew Blake FREng FRS, Mat Cook, Dr Andrew Fitzgibbon, Toby Sharp and Dr Jamie Shotton, won the 42nd annual MacRobert Award for cracking the problem of motion-capture in real time, giving Kinect its unique functionality and opening up a new world of possibility in the IT world. It is anticipated that such hands-free computer control devices could revolutionise the way surgery is performed around the world. The second annual Rooke Medal for the Public Promotion of Engineering, named after former Academy President Sir Denis Rooke OM CBE FRS FREng, went to Professor Chris Bishop FREng FRSE, also of Microsoft Research, for his ongoing work in engaging members of the public in the work of engineers and their contribution to society.
    [Show full text]
  • Nicola Brewer
    (United Kingdom, 1957) NICOLA BREWER PROFESSIONAL PROFILE AND BIOGRAPHICAL DATA Member of the Scottish Power Limited Board of Directors. Non-executive director. Dame Nicola Mary Brewer DCMG is a British diplomat and university administrator. In May 2014 she was appointed Vice-Provost (International) at University College London. She is a non-executive director of Aggreko. Brewer was British High Commissioner to South Africa from 2009 to 2013. Brewer joined the Foreign and Commonwealth Office (FCO) in 1983, completing overseas postings in South Africa, India, France and Mexico. She served as the FCO's Director for Global Issues from 2001 to 2002, and then as Director-General for Regional Programmes at the Department for International Development (DfID), the DfID board member supervising the UK's overseas bilateral aid programmes. In 2004, she was appointed Director-General for Europe at the FCO, leading the FCO's contribution to the UK's 2005 Presidency of the European Union, advising the Foreign Secretary and the Minister for Europe on European Union and other European policy issues. In December 2006, Brewer was appointed by open competition as the first Chief Executive of the newly established Equality and Human Rights Commission, the successor body to the Commission for Racial Equality, the Disability Rights Commission and the Equal Opportunities Commission. She took up her new position in March 2007, standing down in May 2009 to succeed Paul Boateng as British High Commissioner to South Africa, Swaziland and Lesotho, completing her mission in September 2013. On her return to the UK, she became the Founding Director of the FCO Diplomatic Academy.
    [Show full text]