University of Wollongong Research Online Faculty of Engineering and Information Sciences - Faculty of Engineering and Information Sciences Papers: Part A
2013 Electroactive polymers as soft obr otic actuators: electromechanical modeling and identification Rahim Mutlu University of Wollongong, [email protected]
Gursel Alici University of Wollongong, [email protected]
Weihua Li University of Wollongong, [email protected]
Publication Details Mutlu, R., Alici, G. & Li, W. (2013). Electroactive polymers as soft or botic actuators: electromechanical modeling and identification. 2013 IEEE/ASME International Conference on Advanced Intelligent Mechatronics (AIM) (pp. 1096-1101). United States: IEEE.
Research Online is the open access institutional repository for the University of Wollongong. For further information contact the UOW Library: [email protected] Electroactive polymers as soft obr otic actuators: electromechanical modeling and identification
Abstract Biologically inspired robotic applications have recently received significant attention due to developments in novel materials and actuators with an operation principle similar to the natural muscles’. Electroactive polymer (EAP) actuators, also known as artificial muscles, possess extraordinary properties such as low efficiency consumption, compliance, bio-compatibility and ability to be miniaturized. Although several methodologies have been proposed for modeling and identification of their quasi-static bending behavior, a negligibly small attention has been given to their dynamic behavior. In this paper, we, therefore, report on their electromechanical modeling and parameter identification. We model the tri-layer EAP actuators as a soft robotic actuator consisting of a significant number of rigid links connected with compliant revolute joints. The experimental and numerical results presented suggest that the soft or botics approach is an effective way to model the EAP actuator and subsequently identify its dynamic parameters accurately. We have previously employed the same soft or botic approach to estimate the whole shape of the EAP actuator as a function of time.
Keywords soft, electromechanical, polymers, modeling, electroactive, actuators, robotic, identification
Disciplines Engineering | Science and Technology Studies
Publication Details Mutlu, R., Alici, G. & Li, W. (2013). Electroactive polymers as soft or botic actuators: electromechanical modeling and identification. 2013 IEEE/ASME International Conference on Advanced Intelligent Mechatronics (AIM) (pp. 1096-1101). United States: IEEE.
This conference paper is available at Research Online: http://ro.uow.edu.au/eispapers/1258
Electroactive Polymers as Soft Robotic Actuators: Electromechanical Modeling and Identification
Rahim Mutlu, Gursel Alici and Weihua Li
biologically-inspired robotics –thanks to their natural muscle Abstract—Biologically inspired robotic applications have like working principles. Inspired from fish swimming, the recently received significant attention due to developments in EAP actuators were employed to establish swimming robots novel materials and actuators with an operation principle powered through their caudal fin for a nautical motion [6, 7]. similar to their natural counterparts, i.e. muscles. Electroactive polymer (EAP) actuators, also known as artificial muscles, Mutlu et al. [12] first time proposed the EAP actuators possess extraordinary properties such as low efficiency forming a helical shape from a planar spiral that is inspired consumption, compliance, bio-compatibility and ability to be from bacteria (i.e. E. coli) forming its flagella into a helical miniaturized. Although several methodologies have been shape to swim. Sareh and Rossiter [13] have reported on bio- proposed for modeling and identification of their quasi-static inspired devices powered by ionic polymer metal composite bending behavior, a negligibly small attention has been given to (IPMC) actuators with which an atrioventricular cuspid their dynamic behavior. In this paper, we, therefore, report on their electromechanical modeling and parameter identification. valve and Vorticella campanula’s retracting stalk motions We model the tri-layer EAP actuators as a soft robotic actuator are replicated. consisting of a significant number of rigid links connected with compliant revolute joints. The experimental and numerical A number of methodologies have been followed in the results presented suggest that the soft robotics approach is an literature in order to model and analyze the EAP actuators’ effective way to model the EAP actuator and subsequently bending behaviors based on their chemical, electrical, identify its dynamic parameters accurately. We have previously mechanical properties and parameters. In most of these employed the same soft robotic approach to estimate the whole studies, the EAP actuators’ bending behavior is analyzed shape of the EAP actuator as a function of time. using a cantilever-beam-bending approach in which an I. INTRODUCTION electrical stimulus is applied at the EAP actuator’s fixed-end and its displacement is measured from the EAP actuator’s OFT robotic devices based on highly flexible materials free-end as an output using either a finite element method or have gained significant momentum in the last decade S black box approach (i.e. SISO based on a transfer function) due to their favorable characteristics such as compliance, [14-17]. Alici also applied the classical beam theory taking compactness, ease of manufacturability, and being suitable non-linear effects into account to estimate non-linear to miniaturization. Of those materials used to establish bending displacements of the PPy-EAP actuators [18]. artificial muscles exhibit natural muscle like behaviors due However, these studies focus on quasi-static bending to their operation principle similar to real muscles [1, 2]. The behavior of the EAP actuators. A more comprehensive EAP actuators, the most popular of the artificial muscles, model explaining their dynamic behavior will be crucial for have several advantageous over other smart material the EAP actuators if they are to be employed in more actuators such as manufacturability in nano- and micro-size, advanced applications such as medical devices, micro small energy consumption, a high force output to weight robots, artificial organs/muscles and other bio-inspired ratio, biocompatibility, ability to operate in air and aqueous applications. The dynamic model should not only estimate environments, compliance, and silent operation. EAP the EAP actuator’s tip positions, but also be able to predict actuators have been proposed for applications including the whole bending behavior of the EAP actuator as a micro robotic gripping systems, energy converters, function of time. swimming devices, crawling robots, micro manipulators, stiffness regulators, motion converter mechanisms and many One can follow several methods to obtain a dynamic more [3-11]. The EAP actuators are especially suitable for model. In general, two methods are commonly used [19];
R. Mutlu ([email protected]) is with School of Mechanical, i. to identify a transfer function based on the system’s Materials and Mechatronic Engineering, University of Wollongong, NSW, input/output behavior, 2522, Australia G. Alici (Corresponding Author) is with School of Mechanical, Materials ii. to establish a mathematical model using the Newton- and Mechatronic Engineering and ARC Centre of Excellence for Euler method, the Lagrangian or the Hamilton Electromaterials Science, University of Wollongong, NSW, 2522, Australia formulations. (ph: +6142214115, [email protected]) W. Li ([email protected]) is with School of Mechanical, Materials While the first method is more suitable for modeling single and Mechatronic Engineering, University of Wollongong, NSW, 2522, Australia input single output (SISO) systems, we use the second method in this study to model the Polypyrrole based tri-layer
EAP (PPy-EAP) actuator. It is not straightforward to model poositively charged PPy layer and a volume contraction in the and analyze the kinematic and dynamic behaviors of these other PPy layer. This electro-chemo-mechanical process cantilevered-type actuators as their operation principlle based therefore generates a mechanical bending in the PPy-EAP
on the electrical, chemical mechanical parameters is not actuator, as illustrated in Figure 1. fully understood yet. The dynamic model developed in this paper is inspired by a soft robotic actuator or manipulator modeling approach in which the real structure is represented by a curve, known as the backbone curve. We incorporate a voltage-internal moment relation into the dynamic model to obtain an electromechanical model which can be used to understand the dynamic behavior of the PPy-EAP actuator for a given electrical input. After estimating the PPy-EAP actuator’s whole shape configuration as a function of time using its hypeer-redundant inverse kinematic model soolved by an optimization (AngleOPT) method [20, 21], we experimentally identify the dynamic parameters of the PPy- EAP actuatoor. We have experimentally validated the proposed electromechanical model which can be used for (i) identifying the stiffness and damping parameters of the actuator and (ii) controlling the actuator’s whole shape deflection under an electrical stimulus without requirring any position/deflection feedback information. PPy+ (TFSI−) + Li+ + ee− ↔ PPy◦ (Li.TFSI−) oxidized state reduced state HE ABRICATION ND PERATION RINCIPLE F II. T F A O P O EAP Figure 1. Structure and operaation principle of the PPy-EAP actuator. ACTUATORS The tri-layer laminated EAP actuators considered in this III. SOFT ROBOTIC KINEEMMATIC MODEL OF PPY-EAP study are synthesized by following a number of steps. ACTUATOR Pyrrole is used as polymerization monomer. Both sides of a Classical beam theories can be applied to structures with porous layer (i.e. polyvinylidene fluoride, PVDF), as constant material propertiess such as a constant elasticity received (110 µm in thickness), were sputter coated with modulus. Cantilevered EAPP actuators have been modeled gold to produce a conductive surface for polymerization. and analyzed using a constant elasticity modulus assumption Lithium triflouromethanesulfonimide (Li.TFSI) is used as [14-17]. The constant elasticcity modulus assumption can be the electrolytic ions, Li+TFSI−, which are stored in the PVDF applied to the EAP actuator bending in a linear range. This layer. Polymerization solution was prepared containing assumption amputates the apppplicability of the EAP actuators 0.1M pyrrole monomer, Li+TFSI− (0.1 M) and 1% water in due their highly non-linear strain or deflection. Further, the propylene carbonate (PC). The gold coated PVDF was classical beam theories assume that the beam deflection or placed in the polymerization solution. Polypyrrole (PPy) the displacement output is less than 15% of the actuator layers were galvanostatically grown from the solutiion at a beeam length. As reported before, the cantilevered EAP current density of 0.1 mA cm−2 for 12 hours on the gold actuators can generate tip deflections as high as 50 % of coated PVDF. 12-hr polymerization process provides ~30 their length [22]. With this in mind, one should follow a µm thickness of a PPy layer on each side of the gold coated different methodology taking active material properties into PVDF. The PPy based EAP actuator was cut from the bulk account rather than using a constant property assumption, sheet fabricated which we call the PPy-EAP actuator and linear actuator deflection output. We use soft robotic throughout the paper unless otherwise stated. The PPy-EAP structure modeling approach which assumes an imaginary actuator’s laminated structure and operation principle are curve (i.e. so called backbone curve) passing through the depicted in Figure 1. geometric centers of the discrretized cross-sections of the real The PPy-EAP actuator’s operation principle is based on soft robotic structure. In our previous papers [12, 20, 21], we the energy conversion from an electrochemical process to a demonstrated that the soft rrobotic modeling approach can mechanical output. An electrical input applied to thhe PPy accurately estimate the hiigghly non-linear whole shape layers stimulates counter-ions to move in and out of the PPy beending behavior of the PPy--EAP actuators. The soft robotic layers. Whille the positively charged polymer layer is modeling approach has been reported on some bio-inspired oxidized, the negatively charged polymer layer is reduced. robotic manipulators including snake-like robot [23], The TFSI− anions move from electrolyte into the positively octopus arm [24] and elephant trunk robot [25, 26]. charged PPy layer and an opposite reaction happens in the Mathematically expressing tthe backbone curve of the soft other PPy layer in order to neutralize the charge in the PPy robotic structure, which becomes its kinematic model, is layers. This ion transfer causes a volume expansion in the straightforward. However, obtaining solutions to this soft
robotic kinematic model can be problematic. Conventional r σ ,t methods such as differential kinematics based on the min ƒ min 2 r σ ,t Jacobian matrix cannot be employed due to numerical instabilities close to kinematically singular configurations and inversion problems associated with non-square Jacobian matrix of the soft robotic kinematic model [27]. Modde shape and optimization methods can serve well to solve inverse kinematics of the soft robotic structure modeled using the backbone curve approach [23, 28-30]. Mode shape method is limited to the case in which movements of the soft robotic structure are predetermined for certain modes whichh should be matched by the backbone curvature of the soft robotic structure. These mode shapes are then incorporated into the forward kinematic model. Mode shape method is more suitable for soft robotic structures where feedback control from joints is possible. However, the purpose of the soft robotic kinematic modeling in this study is to estimate the Figure 2. An EAP actuator ‘s cconfiguration and its soft robotic model shape that the real soft robotic structure (i.e. PPy-EAP representation defined by its backbone curve, . actuator in this case) forms. Optimization methods are therefore morre suitable to solve inverse kinematics of the As the PPy-EAP actuatorr’s actuation configuration is PPy-EAP actuator using the backbone curve toppology. cantilevered, the models are developed in 2D. The shape Further, optimization based approaches do not require estimation problem (Eq.2) baased on the kinematic model is subjected to physical constraaiints of the PPy-EAP actuator in mathematical manipulations, provided that appropriate joint operation. r σ ,t and r σ ,t are the position coordinates constraints are imposed on the inverse kinematic soolutions. We construct an inverse kinematic model of the PPy-EAP of each section of the PPy-EEAAP actuator, t is time, and n is actuator and then solve this inverse kinematic model by the number of links. employing a non-linear constraint optimization method, IV. SOFT ROBOTIC ELECTROMECHANICAL MODEL OF PPY- which we call the AngleOPT, to estimate all configurations EAP ACTUATOR of the actuator throughout its movement under an electrical The electromechanical model of the PPy-EAP actuator is input. While details of the soft robotic kinematic moodel and obtained by incorporating its input voltage – internal solving its inverse kinematics can be found in [20, 21], we moment relation into its dynamic model. The dynamic provide some brief information here for the sake of model of the PPy-EAP actuattor is obtained by employing the completeness. Lagrange equations to the soft robotic structure. The kinetic The backbone curve of the PPy-EAP actuator operating energy of i-th link on the backbone curve is in planar conditions (the actuator operates in horizontal , (3) plane) can be defined as, with respect to the fixed-end of the actuator, as shown in Figure 2, where m is the mass and J is the inertia tensor of the r σ, t r σ, t r σ,t (1) discretized section measuredd from the center of mass of the where r σ, t : 0, L → R2 assigns a position vector in the section which is described as Euclidean space to each link (i.e. discretized section of the I I J (4) backbone curve of the soft robotic structure) parameeter, σ ∈ I I 0, L in an instant time, t [12, 31]. L is the overall length of the backbone curve. The total kinetic energy is given by Inverse kineematic solutions of the PPy-EAP actuator’s t ≜ K θ, t 5 hyper-redundant kinematic model are obtained by converting its kinematic model into a non-linear constrained optimization problem with an adaptive boundary-coonstraint The potential energy of the PPy-EAP actuator consists of approach. In other words, the PPy-EAP actuator’s shape two components; elastic pottential energy and gravitational variation during its operation becomes a shape estiimation pootential energy. The elastic potential energy of i-th problem solved by optimization. The objective function discretized section on the backbone curve is given below is based on the tip coordinates, , of the P θ, t k θ θ (6) PPy-EAP actuator;
where k is the stiffness constant for each generalized coordinate, . Elastic bending property of the PPy-EAP
actuator is represented by the stiffness constants. The total where is the blocking force measured elastic potential energy is given by experimentally, and are the overall length and each link length of the EAP actuator, respectively. The t ≜ P θ, t 7 electromechanical equations can be written in a matrix- vector form by employing Eqs. 11-14; where P θ, φ, t is the elastic energy of the i-th discretized section on the backbone curve of the EAP actuator. The t D q t q t H q t ,q t C q t (15) gravitational potential energy of each discretized section is given by V. EXPERIMENTAL RESULTS AND DISCUSSION P θ, t m g z θ, φ, t (8) The PPy-EAP actuator used in the experiments was cut into the dimensions of 20x3x0.17mm, length, width and where g is the gravitational acceleration, z θ,φ,t is the vertical distance between the centre of mass of i-th thickness, respectively. Although there is no restriction on discretized section and the base plane. The total gravitational the number of links in the soft robotic actuator model potential energy is obtained as development, the kinematic and dynamic models are developed as 16-Dof hyper-redundant actuator (i.e. 16 serially connected rigid links with compliant and damped t ≜ P θ, φ, t 9 joints). The higher is the number of the links in the soft robotic actuator model; the better is the shape If the EAP actuator operates in horizontal plane where correspondence between the real EAP actuator and the vertical distance of discretized sections along the backbone model. Of course, the computational cost will increase as the curve do not change, the potential energy of the EAP number of links increases in the models. actuator depends only on its elastic bending property. The The EAP actuator’s elastic behaviors are condition- Lagrangian is therefore given in the following form [32] dependent; electrical input, ion diffusion, the geometry, t t t (10) porosity in the tri-layers, and conductivity of the active layers, electrolyte conductivity and its molarity change the where t is the total kinetic energy and t is the total EAP actuator’s elastic behavior. Joint stiffness and damping potential energy of the EAP actuator. Using the Lagrangian, parameters should be estimated dynamically [33-35]. Joint the motion equations are obtained from stiffness and damping values are obtained by employing a direct dynamic parameter identification method in which the bq , i 1,2,…,n (11) identification is performed using experimental data. We where q represents generalized coordinates at each joint. employ a non-linear least-square formulation to identify the is the torque (i.e. internal bending moment) at i-th joint. b joint stiffness and damping parameters by minimizing the indicates the damping coefficient in the rotational error between experimental and simulation results as generalized coordinates. formulated below;