Volume XXVII, No. 2 Spring 2007 Table of Contents
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Psychologist– ψ Official Publication of Division 39 of the American Psychoanalyst Psychological Association VOLUME XXVII, NO. 2 SPRING 2007 TABLE OF CONTENTs FROM THE PRESIDENT HAYDEE FAIMBERG’S TELESCOPING OF ARTICLES POLITICS AND BEDFELLOWS GENERATIONS: LISTENING TO THE NARCISSISTIC AN INVITATION TO JOIN THE ACADEMY OF NANCY MCWILLIAMS.....................................1 LINKS BETWEEN GENERATIONS PSYCHOANALYSIS OF THE AMERICAN BOARD OF IN MEMORIAM CHRISTINE KIEFFER................................... 35 PROFESSIONAL PSYCHOLOGY TONI BERNAY..............................................5 ROBERT WASKA’S REAL PEOPLE, REAL JOSEPH REPPEN.........................................59 FROM THE EDITOR PROBLEMS, REAL SOLUTIONS: THE KLEINIAN IMPRESSION AND REFLECTION ON THE 2007 BILL MACGILLIVRAY...................................... 5 PSYCHOANALYTIC APPROACH WITH DIFFICULT MULTICULTURAL CONFERENCE AND SUMMIT IN PSYCHOANALYTIC RESEARCH PATIENTS SEATTLE TAI KATZENSTEIN AND CALEB SEIFERT...............7 CHARLES MOST....................................... 37 MING-HUI DANIEL HSU...............................60 HOPE FOR PSYCHOTHERAPY MATTHEW VON UNWERTH’S FREUD’S REQUIEM: ANNUAL REPORT OF DIVISION 39 TO APA HAL SHOREY............................................ 7 MOURNING, MEMORY, AND THE INVISIBLE MARILYN JACOBS...................................... 61 SPECIAL SECTION: ON MentAL HISTORY OF A SUMMER’S WALK AFTERMATH OF CONFLICT: UNDERSTANDING AND HEAlthcAre JEFFREY GOLLAND.................................... 40 TREATING TRAUMATIC STRESS SYNDROMES THE QUICK FIX: THE CRISIS IN CANADIAN CARLO STRENGER’S THE DESIGNED SELF: MARILYN JACOBS AND JAINE DARWIN............... 66 MENTAL HEALTHCARE PSYCHOANALYSIS AND CONTEMPORARY IDENTITIES TASK FORCE ON LIAISON TO APA’S COMMITTEE ON JON MILLS.............................................12 MARILYN METZL...................................... 42 INTERNATIONAL RELATIONS IN PSYCHOLOGY CANARY IN THE COAL MINE: PSYCHOANALYSIS AND SHELDON BACH’S GETTING FROM HERE TO MARILYN JACOBS....................................... 67 HEALTH THERE: ANALYTIC LOVE, ANALYTIC PROCESS LOCAL CHAPTER REPORTS PRUDENCE GOURGUECHON.......................... 19 JAY FRANKEL............................................44 CHICAGO ASSOCIATION FOR PSYCHOANALYTIC INVITED ARTICLES ABBY STEIN’S PROLOGUE TO VIOLENCE: CHILD PSYCHOLOGY MAKING STRIDES AGAINST TERRORISM IN THE ABUSE, DISSOCIATION AND CRIME BERNADETTE BERARDI-COLETTA.....................69 CAUCASUS RONALD NASO......................................... 52 OKLAHOMA SOCIETY FOR PSYCHOANALYTIC STUDIES NINA CERFOLIO........................................24 JEROME WINER, JAMES ANDERSON AND ELIZABETH MICHAEL KAMPSCHAEFER..............................70 ON THE PLEASURE IN PLAY DANZE’S PSYCHOANALYSIS AND ARCHITECTURE SECTION REPORT HENRY SEIDEN........................................27 SUZANNE OUELLETTE AND PSYCHOLOGIST PSYCHOANALYST CLINICIANS SEAN AKERMAN........................................ 54 JOHANNA TABIN.........................................70 PSYCHOANALYTIC BOOKS CLAYTON ROWE’S TREATING THE BASIC SELF: BOARD MEETING MINUTES IVAN MILLER’S BALANCED CHOICE: A COMMON UNDERSTANDING ADDICTIVE, SUICIDAL, JANUARY 2007..........................................71 SENSE CURE FOR THE US HEALTH CARE SYSTEMS COMPULSIVE AND ATTENTION DEFICIT/ DIRECTORY KEITH COOK............................................ 30 HYPERACTIVITY BEHAVIOR COMMITTEE MEMBERS.................................74 OWEN RENIK’S PRACTICAL PSYCHOANALYSIS FOR DAVID MACISAAC..................................... 56 BOARD OF DIRECTORS.................................75 THERAPISTS AND PATIENTS DANIEL ARAOZ..........................................33 Psychologist– ψ Official Publication of Division 39 of the American Psychoanalyst Psychological Association Volume XXVII, No. 2 Spring 2007 POLITICS AND BEDFELLOWS FROM THE PRESIDENT: Nancy McWilliams PhD n this column I THE PSYCHOANALYTIC CONSORTIUM Iexpand on the second One ongoing undertaking that has paved the way for presidential initiative more far-reaching collaboration among psychoanalytic I mentioned in the organizations is the involvement of Division 39 in the previous newsletter: my Psychoanalytic Consortium. The other Consortium hope to join forces with members include the American Psychoanalytic other psychoanalytic Association (APsaA, or “the American”), the Academy for groups in pursuit of Psychoanalysis and Dynamic Psychiatry (“the Academy”), common goals. Given and the American Association for Psychoanalysis in the political, economic, Clinical Social Work (AAPCSW, formerly NMCOP, the and ideological pressures National Membership Committee on Psychoanalysis in that are threatening Clinical Social Work). Organized originally to address the everyone identified with ill-fated Clinton health care reforms, the Consortium went psychoanalysis (and, on to articulate consensual standards of its component arguably, everyone within the broader humanistic tradition groups for psychoanalytic training and to foster the in which the examined life is valued), we cannot dissipate establishment and incorporation of the Accreditation our energies fighting with each other when we could be Council for Psychoanalytic Education (ACPE). It has addressing together the threats to our common survival. also defined membership criteria for other psychoanalytic Irrespective of the differences in our professional settings, organizations interested in becoming part of the orienting theories, philosophies of education, and standards Consortium. for training, and notwithstanding our painfully checkered I am told that the early meetings included history as a movement whose in–groups have repeatedly considerable acrimony and frustration, but the current treated out-groups with unconscionable arrogance, all tone—not surprising when people with vital interests in of us are currently under siege and need to find ways to common slowly get used to each other and try to work in cooperate. good faith—is notably cooperative. Relationships built Psychotherapy is rapidly being swallowed up by during the Consortium discussions have paved the way a mass, technocratic culture from which we once were for, among other accomplishments, the international able to preserve some potential space, some room for collaboration that produced the Psychodynamic Diagnostic the uniqueness of the individual sufferer and the sanctity Manual and the recent ecumenical celebrations of Freud’s of the therapeutic relationship. The industrialization 150th birthday at the Austrian Embassy in Washington, DC. of therapy reflects the power of pharmaceutical and insurance companies, abetted by an ostensible public JOINT VENTURES WITH THE AMERICAN PSYCHOANALYTIC indifference to issues like privacy, attachment needs, and ASSOCIATION the complexity of change. These social forces are much It is twenty years now since the settling of the lawsuit bigger than we are, but there is some strength in numbers, that opened the institutes of the American to nonmedical and some value in trying to speak truth to power with one practitioners and made affiliation with the International voice. Psychoanalytical Association possible for non–APsaA PSYCHOLOGIST-PSYCHOANALYST, SPRING 2007 groups. The current leaders of the American include From our end, I have asked Lynne Moritz, the people trained with nonphysicians on an equal basis. The current President of the American, for APsaA support for a President–Elect, Prudy Gourguechon (see her disturbing joint Division 39/APsaA conference highlighting the work and timely article in this issue), began her analytic training of psychoanalytic scientists, providing invited researchers in the first post-lawsuit class and tells me she has no time to work together on issues of mutual concern, and professional memory of the “bad old days.” perhaps ultimately producing a consensus statement about Although there is ongoing competition between “evidence” and psychoanalysis. institutes of the American and other psychoanalytic She has obtained agreement from the relevant training centers, and although many of us have legitimate boards of the American that our respective organizations can complaints about how members and organizations of the co-sponsor two meetings in 2008, one connected with the American have behaved in specific instances, there is no Division 39 Spring Meeting in New York, the other attached longer much evidence of the systematic discrimination to the APsaA meetings the following June. Sidney Blatt and that once poisoned relationships between ApsaA and most Glen Gabbard are working together on this project, with psychologist-psychoanalysts. It is time to work together the help of Mark Hilsenroth and Andrew Gerber. They are where we can. currently at the brainstorming state, and many creative ideas One reason for collaboration is to avoid diffusing are being considered. We can assume that the considerable our energies by duplicating each other’s efforts. Several public relations skills of Dottie Jeffries of the American will projects recently inaugurated by the American could be applied to publicizing these events. have just as easily been spearheaded by Division 39, and APsaA leaders have enthusiastically sought our members’ COLLABORATIONS WITH OTHER PSYCHOANALYTIC involvement in them. For example, Prudy Gourguechon ORGANIZATIONS has launched the “10,000 Minds Project,” an effort to Division 39 has also agreed to join a dizzying number of get psychoanalytic ideas back into university (especially cosponsors for