Gananath Obeyesekere. Imagining Karma: Ethical Transformation in Amerindian, Buddhist, and Greek Rebirth. Berkeley and London: University of California Press, 2002. xxix + 448 pp. $60.00, cloth, ISBN 978-0-520-23220-4.

Reviewed by Nick Allen

Published on H-Buddhism (October, 2003)

Reincarnation west America, on the Inuit and on the Trobrian‐ Although the word does not appear in the ti‐ ders. In the south Asian tradition we read not only tle, this is a book about reincarnation. The ap‐ about Theravada Buddhists but also about the proach is explicitly likened to that of early Levi- Vedic/Upanishadic Hindu background from which Strauss: a model or ideal type is set up analogous Buddhism emerged, and about other reincarna‐ to an elementary structure of , and empiri‐ tion doctrines, notably Jain, Ajivika, and Balinese. cal materials from a good number of are From the Greek world, with admirable intrepidity, presented as transformations of the model. Since the author explores the fragmentary texts that the approach is primarily structuralist, the trans‐ survive from a number of sources: Empedocles, formations are seen more as typological than his‐ Pythagoras, Pindar, Plato, and the Orphics, then torical although, as in Levi-Strauss, questions of Plotinus the neo-Platonist, with his curious of‐ origin and world history cannot be altogether shoots on the fringes of Islam--the Druze and re‐ eliminated. Thus in the small-scale the lated Ismaili groups. tendency is for a deceased individual to reincar‐ A useful conceptual tool is the distinction be‐ nate as a new-born member of the same kin tween two modes of "ethicization" (the author's group, while in the larger-scale archaic literate word). In stage 1 it is the other world that is split civilizations one's next birth tends to be a func‐ or polarized so that in the simplest case one's tion of moral behavior in the present life. The cen‐ good or bad behavior sends one at death to heav‐ tral instance of this is the doctrine of karma, fa‐ en or hell. In stage 2 it is the locus of rebirth that miliar to the author not only from his own cultur‐ is afected: the fruits of behavior in a previous life al roots in Sri Lankan Buddhism but also from his carry one to a more desirable or less desirable previous studies of that religion. reincarnation. Using the basic scheme and these Among the small-scale societies, attention is two transformations, humanity has devised innu‐ focused on several from West Africa and North‐ merable variations. These can bear, for instance, H-Net Reviews on the nature of the other world, the process of or classifcatory, and it is interesting how often reaching it, the soul or whatever it is that cycles to ethnographers mention that ego reincarnates a and fro between the worlds, the mechanisms or member of the grandparental generation. A more divinities that govern the process, the possibility contentious issue is how to explain the similari‐ of escaping from it (to nirvana or the like), and ties between ancient Greece and India. The usual methods of gaining knowledge about past or fu‐ answer is by a combination of independent paral‐ ture reincarnations. One important variation con‐ lel invention and infuences of the East on the cerns the range of beings into which one can rein‐ West. However, evidence is beginning to accumu‐ carnate--the kin group, the , animals (in‐ late from comparative studies on Greek and Indi‐ cluding insects), and even plants. Considerable at‐ an epic that some similarities are due to common tention is given to the relation between reincarna‐ origin--the negative evidence from the early tion in animals and vegetarianism (ahimsa in In‐ Vedas does not rule this out. If so, it is possible dia)--as well as to "endoanthropophagy" (i.e., en‐ that the history of reincarnation beliefs in the docannibalism). Indo-European world is longer than has been sup‐ Like any study, this one has its limitations. posed. It is certainly an open question how far More attention might have been given to the his‐ one can go in understanding early Indian and tory of reincarnation studies. Thus Marcel Mauss Greek world views without taking account of the commented in 1906: "There exists an enormous light that can be shed on them by Indo-European group of societies, Negro, Malayo-Polynesian, cultural comparativism (mentioned here only Amerindian (Sioux, Algonquin, Iroquois, Pueblo, obliquely, in a quotation from Nietzsche). North-Western), Eskimo, Australian, where the Another line of thought comes from Obeye‐ system of reincarnation of the deceased and in‐ sekere's basic model, whose essence has not heritance of the individual name within the fami‐ changed since 1980.[4] The path of the soul is ly or clan is the rule."[1] Obeyesekere makes it shown in the model as a circle bisected by a hori‐ clear that he is not aiming for a thorough sam‐ zontal line separating this world from the other pling of societies with reincarnation beliefs, but world; the circle is traced anticlockwise, passing the passage (cited by Levy-Bruhl in his best- from birth on the left to death on the right, so that known book, as well as in recent Anglophone the other world forms the upper half of the dia‐ work on Mauss),[2] shows that the phenomenon is gram. This choice of orientation is not discussed, even more widely distributed, and hence more but it could perhaps introduce bias or close of important, than is here made apparent (moreover useful insights. For instance, it would be just as the list should certainly include South American logical to draw the circle clockwise, thereby Amerindians). Similarly as regards ethicisation: putting this world above the horizontal line and brief references are made to Axial Age theory, but the other world below (i.e., showing it as Hades the idea can be traced back at least to Tylor, and rather than Heaven). The diagram could then Hocart talks in the same vein of "spiritualiz‐ serve to show not only the path of the soul but ing."[3] also that of the sun: the soul's invisible passage Since he disavows interest in origins, the au‐ through the other world from death to rebirth thor naturally avoids questions about the link be‐ would correspond to the sun's invisible nocturnal tween reincarnation and tribal kinship systems. passage behind or under the world, from its set‐ However, it can be argued that the simplest logi‐ ting in the west to its rising in the east. Such cally possible kinship systems make ego the suc‐ macrocosm-microcosm thinking, which would cessor not of a parent but of a grandparent, real correlate or put in parallel the sun's course from day to day and the soul's course from life to life,

2 H-Net Reviews seems to me the sort of phenomenon one might well look for in India, especially given that Vedic Vivasvat, the Sun, last-born of the goddess Aditi, is father of Yama, the frst mortal. But my main point (familiar to kinship theorists) is that the choices embodied in a diagram may be far from trivial. So there is plenty here that can be built on. This is a serious and useful comparative study of just the sort that needs to undertake in order to fulfl its vocation and justify its grander claims. Notes [1]. Marcel Mauss, "Review of A. Dieterich, Mutter Erde," reprinted in Mauss's Oeuvres, vol. 2 (Paris: Minuit, 1969), pp. 135-139. [2]. Lucien Levy-Bruhl, How Natives Think, trans. Lilian A. Clare (Princeton and Guildford: Press, 1985; orig. 1910), pp. 338-339; and N. J. Allen, Categories and Classifca‐ tions: Maussian Refections on the Social (Oxford: Berghahn, 2000), p. 26. [3]. Edward Burnett Tylor, Primitive , vol. 2 (London: Murray, 1873), p. 187; and A. M. Hocart, Kings and Councillors (Chicago and Lon‐ don: Chicago University Press, 1970; orig. 1936), p. 78. [4]. Gananath Obeyesekere, "The Rebirth Es‐ chatology and Its Transformations: A Contribu‐ tion to the Sociology of Early Buddhism," in Kar‐ ma and Rebirth in Classical Indian Traditions, ed. Wendy Doniger O'Flaherty (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1980), p. 144.

If there is additional discussion of this review, you may access it through the network, at https://networks.h-net.org/h-buddhism

Citation: Nick Allen. Review of Obeyesekere, Gananath. Imagining Karma: Ethical Transformation in Amerindian, Buddhist, and Greek Rebirth. H-Buddhism, H-Net Reviews. October, 2003.

URL: https://www.h-net.org/reviews/showrev.php?id=8301

3 H-Net Reviews

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 3.0 United States License.

4