Biological Evaluation for Southern Regional Forester's Sensitive
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Biological Evaluation for Southern Regional Forester’s Sensitive Species NORTH SHENANDOAH MOUNTAIN RESTORATION AND MANAGEMENT PROJECT Rockingham County, Virginia – Pendleton County, WV North River Ranger District, George Washington and Jefferson National Forests INTRODUCTION Forest Service Manual (FSM) Section 2672.41 requires a biological evaluation (BE) and/or biological assessment (BA) for all Forest Service planned, funded, executed, or permitted programs and activities. For this project, the Biological Evaluation (BE) and the Biological Assessment (BA) were completed as separate documents. The objectives of this Biological Evaluation (BE) are to: 1) ensure that Forest Service actions do not contribute to loss of viability of any native or desired non-native species or contribute to trends toward federal listing, 2) comply with the requirements of the Endangered Species Act (ESA) so that federal agencies do not jeopardize or adversely modify critical habitat (as defined in ESA) of federally listed species, and 3) provide a process and standard to ensure that Regional Forester’s Sensitive species receive full consideration in the decision-making process using the best available science. The North River Ranger District supports known occurrences and suitable habitat for several R8 Sensitive species, all of which were considered in this analysis. This BE documents the analysis of potential impacts of the proposed project to Sensitive species and associated habitat. It also serves as biological input into the environmental analysis for project-level decision-making to ensure compliance with the ESA, National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA), and National Forest Management Act (NFMA). PROJECT AREA & EFFECT ANALYSIS AREA The North Shenandoah Mountain Project is located within Rockingham County, Virginia and Pendleton County, West Virginia, approximately 12 miles northwest of Bridgewater, Virginia (see Figure 1). Within the 128,000-acre greater project area of intermingled private and National Forest System (NFS) ownership, approximately 103,000 acres are NFS lands and 25,000 acres are in private land or other ownership. The project area is bounded on the east by State Routes 259 and 763, on the north by the Virginia and West Virginia state boundary, on the west by West Virginia State Route 3, and on the south by US Highway 33, except for one decommissioned road proposal south of US Highway 33. The geographic scope of this biological evaluation for terrestrial plants and animals is the project area (project disturbance area). With regards to impacts to the aquatic ecosystem, the geographic scope of this analysis will be identical to that analyzed for the water quantity and sedimentation aspect of the water resource. The boundary of the analysis will be the watersheds draining the project area down to their confluence with either the South Fork South Branch Potomac River, North Fork Shenandoah River, or the Dry River watershed. This analysis area was chosen because it is estimated that effects below these points would be insignificant and immeasurable. 1 North Shenandoah Mountain Restoration and Management Project Biological Assessment The project area lies within the South Fork South Branch Potomac River (183,440 acres), Shoemaker River – North Fork Shenandoah River (133,155 acres), and Dry River (76,848 acres) 5th level HUC watersheds in Rockingham County, Virginia, and Pendleton and Hardy Counties, West Virginia. PROPOSED MANAGEMENT ACTIONS The Forest Service proposes to harvest timber, conduct prescribed burning, and complete other ancillary resource/habitat improvement projects within the next one to five years. The North Shenandoah Mountain Restoration and Management (NSM) Project is designed to implement the strategic direction described in the 2014 Revised Land and Resource Management Plan (Forest Plan) for the George Washington National Forest (GWNF). More specifically, the proposed action includes the following: • provide early successional habitat through vegetation treatments including timber removal, grassy area enhancements, and prescribed fire; • provide open canopy conditions through timber harvest and prescribed burning; • release desired tree species in previously regenerated stands from competition • provide new and maintain existing wildlife clearings, open grasslands, and open savannah and woodlands habitat; • use herbicides to treat non-native invasive plant species across the project area and native plant competitors to promote release of desired tree species (oak, pine, and hickory, etc.); • decommission about 14 miles of National Forest System (NFS) roads to improve road conditions creating resource impacts, compliant with the Travel Analysis Plan; • construct, reconstruct, and maintain several Forest System Roads (FSR) and temporary roads (about 2.15 miles new system roads; 19.1 miles reconstruction; 25-30 miles maintenance; and 15 miles temporary, respectively); • protect riparian habitat for aquatic species by buffering certain streams from recreation impacts; • replace up to about 15 culverts with aquatic organism passage structures; • establish new prescribed-fire burn blocks to restore fire-dependent plant communities; • restore yellow pine species and habitat via planting, a combination of thinning and regeneration treatments, and prescribed fire; • provide waterholes habitat for wildlife and amphibians; • provide additional wood turtle nesting habitat and instream large woody debris (LWD) for overwintering habitat; • plant American chestnut that is resistant to the Asian chestnut blight; • provide patch openings nested in thinning prescriptions for grouse habitat. NOTE: Proposed Actions and associated acreages detailed below and summarized in Table 1. Need For The Proposed Action(s) This proposed action is located on the North River Ranger District of the George Washington National Forest (GWNF) and is designed to meet the direction set forth in the 2014 Revised Land and Resource Management Plan for the George Washington National Forest (Forest Plan). The proposed treatments 2 North Shenandoah Mountain Restoration and Management Project Biological Assessment follow the Forest-wide vision for the desired condition for forested ecological systems with an emphasis to forested structural diversity. As stated in the Forest Plan, an appropriate balance of vertical structure within forested communities provides habitat for associated terrestrial species that require various forest age/structural stages. Departure from the desired vegetation structure and composition is influencing the ecological sustainability within the project area. The current conditions do not reflect the desired biological, physical, and watershed conditions as described in Forest Plan. If left unaddressed, they will decrease the health, diversity, and productivity of the forest. The Forest Plan’s Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) page E-19 defines forested structural classes as follows: • Early Successional or Regenerating Forest: Forest stands developing after a major disturbance (such as a regeneration harvest) generally less than 11 years in age. • Late Successional Open Canopy Forest: Forest stands reaching older ages of mature trees (50- 100 years or greater) and more lasting structural conditions with an overall open canopy (canopy closure of 25-60 percent: typical of thinned forests). Fire, wind, and ice damage were previous disturbance regime drivers that affected about 10% of the landscape and typically occurred in 5-20-acre blocks. These mosaics increase biodiversity in the area, and early seral species can increase the carrying capacity of species that benefit from open habitat or early-seral habitat types (Harper et.al., 2016). Fire was an important system driver that has been removed from the landscape for some time (Delcourt et.al., 1998; Vander Yacht et.al., 2017). Additionally, invasive species are a more recent threat to habitat biodiversity and landscape resilience. Under climate change conditions and current stand trajectories, these risks are likely to persist. Therefore, active management, including commercial, non-commercial, and prescribed fire vegetation treatments are required in order to address conditions in the planning area. To move toward the desired ecological systems diversity and species diversity, there is a considerable need to establish additional early-successional habitat, younger forest habitat, and to improve stand health, vigor and diversity via thinning. There also is a need to create additional open habitat that is lacking for certain species. This, in turn, would provide forest products to the local economy. To move toward the desired conditions for watersheds, there is need to replace impassible culverts with structures that are passable for aquatic organisms, and to decommission several Forest System roads that are no longer needed, or that are causing stream sedimentation. 3 North Shenandoah Mountain Restoration and Management Project Biological Assessment Figure 1. North Shenandoah Mountain Restoration and Management Project planning area and location of working areas 4 North Shenandoah Mountain Restoration and Management Project Biological Assessment Activities such as timber harvest, prescribed burns, wildlife clearings and other applicable habitat management techniques would primarily promote ecological restoration by: 1) promoting desired structural conditions for ecological systems, 2) promoting oak and pine reproduction, 3) enhancing habitat conditions for declining early