LISTING OF CITATIONS - MORAY VALUATION APPEAL COMMITTEE

Hearing on 3rd February 2016 at 10.00 am in Registrar's Office, 240 High Street, Elgin

Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

1 23059/50453 PUBLIC HOUSE BELHAVEN BREWERY CO LTD P 16,500 16,500 IONIC BAR BELHAVEN PUBS DIVISION 39 HIGH STREET ELGIN GERALD EVE LLP A

2 23086/50456 PUBLIC HOUSE BELHAVEN BREWERY CO LTD P 16,500 16,500 THE DROUTHY COBBLER BELHAVEN PUBS DIVISION 48A HIGH STREET ELGIN GERALD EVE LLP A

3 23093/50411 PUBLIC HOUSE J D WETHERSPOON PLC P 78,000 78,000 THE MUCKLE CROSS PER BNP PARIBAS REAL ESTATE 36 HIGH STREET ELGIN BNP PARIBAS REAL ESTATE A

4 37096/50451 HOTEL WHITBREAD PLC P 275,000 275,000 LINKWOOD LODGE PER BRIAN OWEN 15 LINKWOOD WAY GERALD EVE ELGIN GERALD EVE LLP A

5 23356/50575 PUBLIC HOUSE HAWTHORN LEISURE LIMITED P 10,000 10,000 CABER FEIDH MAIN STREET NEW ELGIN GERALD EVE LLP A

6 25249/50612 DISTILLERY GLEN TURNER DISTILLERY LTD P 242,000 242,000 GLENMORAY DISTILLERY BRUCELAND ROAD ELGIN GVA JAMES BARR A

7 25249/50613 DISTILLERY GLEN TURNER DISTILLERY LTD P 182,000 182,000 GLENMORAY DISTILLERY BRUCELAND ROAD ELGIN GVA JAMES BARR A

8 25249/50614 DISTILLERY GLEN TURNER DISTILLERY LTD P 265,000 265,000 GLENMORAY DISTILLERY BRUCELAND ROAD ELGIN GVA JAMES BARR A

9 23871/50457 PUBLIC HOUSE BELHAVEN BREWERY CO LTD P 44,800 44,800 THE FOUNDRY BELHAVEN PUBS DIVISION 14 THUNDERTON PLACE ELGIN GERALD EVE LLP A

10 24190/50455 PUBLIC HOUSE BELHAVEN BREWERY CO LTD P 29,500 A 29,500 RED LION HOTEL BELHAVEN PUBS DIVISION 1,000 R 1,000 2-6 TOLBOOTH STREET 28,500 N 28,500 FORRES GERALD EVE LLP A

11 24426/50475 PUBLIC HOUSE SCOTTISH & NEWCASTLE PUB ENTERPRISE P 18,750 A 18,750 THE ABBEY INN 750 R 750 FINDHORN ROAD 18,000 N 18,000 KINLOSS GERALD EVE LLP A

12 24448/50418 HOTEL PUNCH TAVERNS LTD P 23,000 23,000 THE CROWN & ANCHOR INN 44 FINDHORN FORRES GRAHAM & SIBBALD A

13 82438/50561 WORKS DALKIA PLC O 274,000 274,000 ROSEISLE BIOMASS AND AQUEOUS PLANT ROSEISLE ELGIN GVA JAMES BARR A

16/10/2015 Page 1 of 4 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

14 24979/50431 PUBLIC HOUSE TRUST INNS LTD P 13,500 13,500 STEAMBOAT INN 15 PITGAVENY STREET LOSSIEMOUTH RYDEN LLP A

15 25284/50563 DISTILLERY PLC P 105,000 105,000 GLEN ELGIN DISTILLERY PER KENNETH MCCORMACK LONGMORN GVA JAMES BARR ELGIN GVA JAMES BARR A

16 26428/50472 DISTILLERY DIAGEO PLC P 205,000 205,000 INCHGOWER PER KENNETH MCCORMACK BUCKIE GVA JAMES BARR GVA JAMES BARR A

17 31987/50483 PUBLIC HOUSE HIGHLAND TRAVEL INNS T 14,000 14,000 THE PUB IN THE SQUARE 7 CLUNY SQUARE BUCKIE RYDEN LLP A

18 26346/50484 HOTEL HIGHLAND TRAVEL INNS T 12,500 12,500 RED LION INN 67 HIGH STREET FOCHABERS RYDEN LLP A

19 26358/50482 HOTEL HIGHLAND TRAVEL INNS P 28,000 28,000 GORDON ARMS T/A GORDON ARMS HOTEL 80 HIGH STREET FOCHABERS RYDEN LLP A

20 26707/50572 PUBLIC HOUSE HAWTHORN LEISURE LIMITED P 11,000 11,000 CROWN INN 22 REIDHAVEN SQUARE KEITH GERALD EVE LLP A

21 26719/50474 DISTILLERY DIAGEO PLC P 105,000 105,000 DISTILLERY PER KENNETH MCCORMACK STRATHMILL GVA JAMES BARR KEITH GVA JAMES BARR A

22 26719/50560 DISTILLERY DIAGEO PLC P 107,000 107,000 STRATHMILL DISTILLERY PER KENNETH MCCORMACK STRATHMILL GVA JAMES BARR KEITH GVA JAMES BARR A

23 26889/50622 DISTILLERY INVER HOUSE DISTILLERS LTD P 86,500 86,500 KNOCKDHU KNOCK HUNTLY GVA JAMES BARR A

24 86924/50564 DISTILLERY THE CHIVAS & GLENLIVET GROUP P 250,000 250,000 DALMUNACH NORTHERN OPERATIONS CARRON GVA JAMES BARR ABERLOUR GVA JAMES BARR A

25 27381/50405 DISTILLERY INVER HOUSE DISTILLERS LTD P 44,500 44,500 SPEYBURN NORTH STREET ROTHES GVA JAMES BARR A

26 27639/50592 DISTILLERY WILLIAM GRANT & SONS LTD P 2,260,000 2,260,000 BALVENIE/ DUFFTOWN KEITH GVA JAMES BARR A

27 27652/50559 DISTILLERY DIAGEO PLC P 147,000 147,000 GLENDULLAN PER KENNETH MCCORMACK DUFFTOWN GVA JAMES BARR KEITH GVA JAMES BARR A

16/10/2015 Page 2 of 4 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

28 27763/50452 DISTILLERY DIAGEO PLC P 100,000 100,000 MORTLACH PER KENNETH MCCORMACK FIFE STREET GVA JAMES BARR DUFFTOWN GVA JAMES BARR A

29 86866/50562 SITE HUTS DIAGEO PLC P 13,000 13,000 PER KENNETH MCCORMACK FIFE STREET GVA JAMES BARR DUFFTOWN GVA JAMES BARR A

16/10/2015 Page 3 of 4 CASES CONTINUED FROM 30/09/2015 HEARING

Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

8 82165/50479 HEALTH CENTRE LINKWOOD MEDICAL T 82,500 82,500 LINKWOOD MEDICAL THE GLASSGREEN CENTRE 2 THORNHILL DRIVE WILLIAMS YOUNG MCKAIG LIMITED A ELGIN

9 82169/50478 HEALTH CENTRE NHS GRAMPIAN T 102,000 102,000 THE GLASSGREEN CENTRE 2 THORNHILL DRIVE ELGIN WILLIAMS YOUNG MCKAIG LIMITED A

10 23602/50476 HEALTH CENTRE NHS GRAMPIAN P 100,000 100,000 MARYHILL HIGH STREET ELGIN WILLIAMS YOUNG MCKAIG LIMITED A

16/10/2015 Page 4 of 4