GOLD STANDARD PASSPORT
GOLD STANDARD PASSPORT
CONTENTS
A. Project title
B. Project description
C. Proof of project eligibility
D. Unique Project Identification
E. Outcome stakeholder consultation process
F. Outcome sustainability assessment
G. Sustainability monitoring plan
H. Additionality and conservativeness deviations
Annex 1 ODA declarations Annex 2 Supporting documentation for feedback round
1
GOLD STANDARD PASSPORT
Version of Document: 3.2 Date of Document: 10 July 2012
SECTION A. Project Title
Project title: Energy Efficient Cook Stoves for Siaya Communities, Kenya Project ID: GS 879
SECTION B. Project description
The project aims to construct energy efficient cook stoves for rural communities in the Siaya County in Nyanza Province, Kenya.
As in many rural regions in developing countries the supply of modern energy carriers such as electricity and fossil fuels is very limited and expensive. In Siaya County only 1.4% of the population uses electricity for lighting and only 0.1% for cooking purpose. To meet their basic energy needs households rely on locally available biomass fuels such as firewood and also occasionally charcoal: almost 90% of households use firewood for cooking and 9% use charcoal for preparing their meals. Households in Siaya County traditionally cook on open fires consisting of 3 stones, in this way burning large amounts of fuel wood in a very inefficient way. This has severe impacts at the social (e.g. health) and environmental levels (e.g. deforestation, CO2- emissions). This project aims to mitigate these impacts by introducing energy efficient cook stoves to Siaya communities in Kenya.
Children collecting fuelwood Baseline cook stove: 3-stone fire The efficient cook stove is a biomass rocket stove designed for burning wood and consisting of two cooking units that can be separately fired. The stove is fixed and installed in households. This efficient cook stove brings multiple benefits to the stove users: it reduces firewood consumption by approximately 48%, thus reducing the burden of firewood collection on women and children or relieving the household’s budget for fuel purchase; moreover, through the cleaner and more efficient combustion harmful smoke emissions are reduced and indoor air quality is considerably improved; the reduction in firewood consumption helps to conserve forest vegetation and to reduce CO2-emissions, which are responsible for climate change.
2
GOLD STANDARD PASSPORT
Project cook stove: fix installed efficient rocket stove The efficient cook stoves are constructed using locally available materials, such as mud, bricks and sawdust. Local artisans are identified in the villages and trained in stove construction and household mobilization. An innovative village based group savings and loaning approach will be integrated to enhance affordability and access to efficient cook stoves through soft loans. Moreover, regular energy education and demonstrations will be conducted to enhance awareness, adoption and utility. The project is developed by the Swiss non-profit foundation myclimate (Zurich, Switzerland) and is coordinated and implemented by the Kenyan Tembea Youth Centre for Sustainable Development (Ugunja, Kenya).
Estimated start date of construction: Project implementation started in October 2010 with the construction of the first efficient stove on 04 October 2010.
3
GOLD STANDARD PASSPORT
SECTION C. Proof of project eligibility
C.1. Scale of the Project
Please tick where applicable: Project Type Large Small
x
C.2. Host Country
Republic of Kenya,
4
GOLD STANDARD PASSPORT
C.3. Project Type
Please tick where applicable: Project type Yes No
Does your project activity classify as a Renewable Energy project? x
Does your project activity classify as an End-use Energy Efficiency Improvement x project?
Please justify the eligibility of your project activity: The proposed project activity meets the Gold Standard eligibility criteria as follows:
The project is the distribution of efficient biomass cook stoves to rural households in Kenya, and therefore classifies as an End-use Energy Efficiency Improvement project.
The project surpasses the threshold of 60 GWh (electric) or 180Gwh (thermal) for small-scale projects and thus the project classifies as a large scale.
The project is located in Kenya, which has ratified the Kyoto protocol and is listed as a Non-Annex I country with no cap on GHG emissions.
Transfer of credits ownership is guaranteed from stove user to project owner by the signed Stove Purchase and Sale Agreement and a VERPA between Tembea Youth Center for Sustainable Development and myclimate.
No ODA money is used to finance this project.
The proposed project activity has not been announced previously without mentioning that it will be conducted as a carbon offset project.
The project reduces CO2, CH4 and N20 emissions by reducing the consumption of non-renewable firewood for cooking.
The project implementation did not start before the local stakeholder meeting and therefore the project classifies for the regular project cycle.
Pre Announcement Yes No Was your project previously announced? x
5
GOLD STANDARD PASSPORT
The proposed project activity has not been announced previously without mentioning that it will be conducted as a carbon offset project. Please see the project decision timeline below for clarification.
Project decision timeline: • MoU between Tembea and MyClimate signed on 23 April 2009 • Term sheet between Tembea and MyClimate signed on 28 April 2010 • Local stakeholder meeting was conducted according to Gold Standard guidelines on 05 May 2010 • Stakeholder report uploaded to Gold Standard registry on 18 June 2010 • Project listed in Gold Standard registry on 15 July 2010 • Project implementation started in October 2010 .
6
GOLD STANDARD PASSPORT
C.4. Greenhouse gas
[See Toolkit 1.2.d]
Greenhouse Gas
Carbon dioxide x
Methane x
Nitrous oxide x
C.5. Project Registration Type
[See Toolkit 1.2.f]
Project Registration Type
Regular x
Preliminary evaluation Rejected by Retroactive projects (eg: Large Hydro or UNFCCC Pre-feasibility assessment (T.2.5.1) palm oil-related (T2.5.3) project) (T.2.5.2)
If Retroactive, please indicate Start Date of Construction dd/mm/yyyy:_N/A______
7
GOLD STANDARD PASSPORT
SECTION D. Unique project identification
D.1. GPS-coordinates of project location
Coordinates Latitude 00° 10' 59.88" N Longitude 34° 17' 59.99" E
Explain given coordinates The energy efficient cook stoves will be constructed in the rural communities in the Siaya County in the north of Nyanza Province in Kenya.
The given coordinates correspond to the office of the project owner Tembea Youth Centre for Sustainable Development P.O. Box 313, 40606, Ugunja, KENYA
D.2. Map
Map 1: Nyanza Province in Kenya1
1 Source: http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/6/60/Kenya-Nyanza.png
8
GOLD STANDARD PASSPORT
Map 2: Siaya County in Kenya2
2 Source: http://www.kenyaradarlive.co.ke/?page_id=96
9
GOLD STANDARD PASSPORT
Map 3: Map of Siaya County3
3 Source: Map put together by Tembea Youth for Sustainable Development in conjunction with the University of Nairobi. The relevant government agencies have not yet a Siaya County Map available to the public.
10
GOLD STANDARD PASSPORT
SECTION E. Outcome stakeholder consultation process
E.1. Assessment of stakeholder comments
The local stakeholder consultation was held the 5th of May 2010 in Ugunja, Kenya. 57 people attended the meeting whereof more than 30 participants were local residents, Feedback forms with three questions were handed out and a total of 42 feedback forms returned by the participants. Generally the participants gave a positive feedback about the project. Especially the following benefits of the project were pointed out: • The project considers the poor people • Addresses present day environmental concerns like deforestation • Addresses gender gaps • Can lead to poverty reduction • Can offer employment for the youth • Addresses millennium development goals • Addresses health issues
Table: Overview of 5 representative samples of filled out feedback forms Participant What is your impression of What do you like What do you not like about Name the meeting? about the project? the project? Mary Mbenge • Excellent and thanks for • Linking energy • We should have a your invitation conservation to power point • As stakeholders from gender, MDGs, presentation (LCD) for the Lake Victoria climate change pictorial presentations. catchment we hope to • Starting at Seeing is believing and do our best too! grassroots levels pictorial presentation i.e. Anyiko sub are never forgotten location it will • Create more awareness succeed!!keep it • Organize for field trip up Tembea • Train more women as TOTS (trainers of trainees) for success of the project Mercy Nyakowa • Wish it was done on • Good and timely every village level and project should be schools. taken to all parts • It was too good to be for of the country the few who attended • Hope attendants will disseminate the information Lilian Amollo • I feel that the • The project is • The only problem with Oluoch stakeholders should really good the project especially sensitize and mobilize because it is going this energy efficient
11
GOLD STANDARD PASSPORT
the community on the to change the Jikos is just that it is benefits of the energy lives of many from expensive such that efficient cook stoves poverty to better some other people lives and also might not afford enable people to know the importance of natural resources Richard Tony • I am impressed that the • This project if • Am not sure if women Ogolla community resources implemented will will actively participate persons e.g. save our world as much as they are o DO, youth leaders and greatly in many represented others are involved ways: social, directly. A clear economic, indication that environmentally something constructive etc. on environmental • It manipulates an conservation will be act of man that will done. surely make a big change • The most innovative if implemented Bianca Louisa • Educative and • It’s a good • Enhance the adoption Ochollah informative initiative for of the technology at a conservation as cost, even if it’s in kind. well as meeting the MDGs
E.2. Stakeholder Feedback Round Please describe report how the feedback round was organised, what the outcomes were and how you followed up on the feedback.
Tembea undertook a feedback round as per the requirement and provision of the Gold standards rules for VER project. The feedback round had duration of 60 days; it started on 12th October 2011 and ended on 12th December 2011. The feedback round provided an opportunity for the stakeholders to give their input on project progress and perceived impacts as well as evaluate how their input at the local stakeholders consultation meeting (held in May 2010) was included in project documents and design. All stakeholders invited to the local stakeholder meeting were invited during the feedback round to give feedback on the project. For this a “Call for Stakeholder Feedback Round” (see Annex 2) was sent out and latest versions of the PDD, the GS Passport and the stakeholder report were published on myclimate’s website to make them accessible to all stakeholders. See Annex 2 for invitation tracking table for the feedback round.
Dissemination of project documents:
12
GOLD STANDARD PASSPORT
Hard copies of PDD, Gold Standard Passport and Local Stakeholder Report were used during the feedback round (see picture below). The copies of the documents were distributed to various strategic resource centres and libraries for stakeholders to read through and present their feedback. They were also used during feedback meeting.
The project documentation including the local stakeholder consultation report, project design document and GS passport were to be availed for public review. In this regards Tembea has made available hard copies of the same documents in the following locations; 1. Tembea Youth centre for sustainable development resource center (Ugunja) 2. District commissioner office (Siaya) 3. NEMA Siaya office 4. District information and documentation center (DIDC, Siaya) 5. Ugunja community resource center
Consultative feedback round meeting A consultative feedback round meeting was held on 21.10.2011 at the Camunya Hotel in Ugunja, Kenya. The consultative feedback meeting took place during validation site visit, which allowed the validation team to participate in the meeting and talk to the stakeholders.
Mode of Stakeholders selection: The participants for the feedback round were selected from the list of attendees during the local stakeholder’s consultation meeting held in May 2010. All participants were contacted to check on their availability and willingness to engage in the feedback round. A number of the phone contacts given were no longer in use and this applied to over 15 participants. The remaining participants were contacted to check on their availability and willingness to participate. Seventeen stakeholders were available to participate in the feedback round consultative meeting held in Ugunja in October 2011. The rest cited work or travel reason for not participating.
Mode of Stakeholders invitation: The participants were invited via phone call, public gathering announcements, email and hard copy letters. In one particular case a letter was needed to enable the participants get permission from their superior to attend the consultative
13
GOLD STANDARD PASSPORT meeting. One participant shared his feedback through email.
List of participants: NO. NAMES ORGANIZATION CONTACT ID NO 1. GEORGE ALUOCH SPECOOP 0722154808 21693175 2. JAMILA OCHIENG UCRC 0722674747 10820285 3. EUNICE A. ONYANGO SIAYA COUNTY 0714843495 23667299 COUNCIL (CDA) 4. CHARLES L. OWUOR ASST. CHIEF 0720058071 4081402 5. JOANES N. ODUNDO ASST. CHIEF 0720994196 13786374 LIGEGA 6. WILLIAM O. LALA ASST. CHIEF 0722959819 4802983 7. GEORGE O. OMOLLO BROSYC 0715554522 21189841 8. RICHARD ODHIAMBO OGOT COTTAGE 0722265097 22540553 9. GEORGE WAMBIA URDI 0720919931 22216169 10. LILIAN A. OLUOCH TEACHER GEM 0729934798 25256022 11. ODIERO CHARLES OTIT - SIAYA 0720102394 10972288 12. ALLAN WAYODI REMOYOG 0717199297 26110363 13. JANET OMONDI SYG 0718247123 28129727 14. BERNARD OMONDI SIAYA 0729892223 27010136 15. DAVID OMOLLO PAMOJA 0715197450 27834563 16. DORCAS OKETCH REMOYOG 0714578222 23656661 17. NICHOLUS ONYANGO FARMER 0724072074 213239081 18. SARAH ATIENO TEMBEA 0725273573 234580022 19. JOB ORINA TEMBEA 0725273573 2415551730 20. NICHOLUS NGESA TEMBEA 0727649967 24773335
Discussion approach-description of discussion The participants had a chance to review the project since inception using the methods discussed below.
Presentation The program coordinator made a presentation that involved the following items; • Project non technical summary • Project targets and progress • Introduction to project documents, the local stakeholders consultative report, PDD and project passport • The feedback round
Plenary The participants had a chance to ask questions and get answers as well as always raise any issues relevant for project progress.
14
GOLD STANDARD PASSPORT
Stakeholders at the consultative feedback round meeting held on 21.10.2011 in Ugunja, Kenya.
The validators getting feedback from one of the stakeholder – Assistant Chief- Ligega Sublocation.
Feedback/comments received during feedback round No feedback was received from GS Supporters contacted via email. One local stakeholders handed in feedback via email. However, comprehensive feedback was received from the participants of the consultative feedback round meeting held on 21.10.2011, see tabulated summary below:
Name Overall impression on Likes about project What don’t Consideration of Any other project you like LSC in PDD issues about project George Aluoch –Siaya -Job creation to youths -job creation Nothing Yes -consider the peasant community outreach of both genders -energy conservation entire Siaya project Willian .O. Lala Good impression on the -offered employment Nothing Yes -need for reports community savings and -made people busy to the local loaning (CSL). with development administration on artisans and CSL
15
GOLD STANDARD PASSPORT
Joanes .N. Odundo – -a well timed project -created employment -being a new Yes -more artisans to assistant chief when there is global to the youth as project I be recruited warming and climate artisans and other haven’t seen -creation of a tree change which has great grow while its demerits nursery in every impacts on the understanding their sub location environment and trees environment supported by in specific -it has reduced tree Tembea cutting and diseases Benard omondi -impressive -includes youth Nothing Yes Employ more -has impact on climate -run by youth youth change -employs youth Richard Odhiambo Ogola- -Positive impact on the -acceptable to Project Yes -need for more COTTAGE environment that community concentration technical extends to the whole -income generating in Ugunja trainings planet activity to the workers especially in -incorporation of CSL Wagai division -competency of Tembea staff Eunice .A. Onyango –Siaya -the project has already -created some Let the Yes -more county council department of picked up and it is employment to the project not be sensitization community development going to help youth like artisans confined in -employ more community to conserve -the project considers one area of youth their environment by gender Ugenya using the stoves constituency Lilian Oluoch -make more stoves in -stakeholder Nothing Yes -consider others Gem consultations districts with -project is necessary stoves and training of the youth Charles Odiero -improved livelihoods -environmental(natural Nothing Yes -soil health and income resource conservation issues need to initiative and health be brought out integration) clear to the community as an added advantage Allan Wayodi -good -employing the youth Nothing Yes None -will help our -reducing climate community change Dorcas Oketch-REMOYOG -eye opener project -conserves Nothing Yes None environment -creates employment Nicholas Onyango -good and relevant to -efficient jikos Nothing Yes None the community George Ouma-BROSYC -smart project design -creating jobs to the -the project Yes -awareness which can help the youth in siaya county should creation of the nation -environmental capture project should be conservation everyone not done even where leaving the the constructions old age hasn’t started Jamila -UCRC -Good project -working with schools Nothing Yes -include tree planting Nicholas Ngesa -TYCSD -impressed with project -involvement of Nothing Yes -more education design requirements stakeholders and capacity
16
GOLD STANDARD PASSPORT
and thresholds -achievement of the building sessions projected project on climate goals change Job orina -TYCSD -positive impact on -it has opportunity to Nothing Yes None community reduce the carbon -good impact on GHG footprint of the local reduction communities -overall impact on -it improves the social clmate change economic status of the mitigation is big local communities P.K.Otieno- RECONCILE -impressive -mainstreaming of Nothing Yes -need for -led to attitude change livelihood and social continued project -enhanced awareness elements in the evaluation at community level project -need for -enhanced -use of local language geographical environmental and consideration of consideration in compliance local contexts planning exercises Sarah Atieno-TYCSD -Good -environmental Nothing Yes None conservation -employment creation
Evaluation of feedback/comments: A graphical evaluation of the comments and feedback received during the consultative feedback round meeting is found in the diagrams below:
1. What is your overall impression of the project
2. What do you like about the project?
17
GOLD STANDARD PASSPORT
3. Are there any issues that you think need to be addressed?
Conclusion Based on evaluation of the feedback given, it can be concluded that the stakeholders gave the project a go a head, no issues were raised that can affect either project design or implementation. It’s however important to note that the government through its officials present is keen on regular reporting on project progress and performance.
18
GOLD STANDARD PASSPORT
SECTION F. Outcome Sustainability assessment
F.1. ‘Do no harm’ Assessment
Safeguarding Description of relevance to my project Assessment of Mitigation principles my project risks measure breaching it (low/medium/high) Human Rights 1 • The project does not introduce an entirely new concept that is far off Low Not the local culture. Cooking on the efficient cook stove is not much needed different from cooking on traditional 3-stone fireplace. Thus, no significant change in cultural practice shall occur. Through the stakeholders forum is it evident that it doesn’t conflict the local communities values or practices. The United Nations INTERNATIONAL CONVENANT ON CIVIL AND POLITICAL RIGHTS has been signed and ratified by Kenya. (http://www.hrweb.org/legal/cprsigs.html) 2 • The project will not have any major impacts on the environment or Low Not land use patterns. needed • The project will not result in temporal or permanent displacement of the local community. 3 • The local community’s cultural set up will not be altered, damaged Low Not or removed/replaced as result of this project. needed • The project is to provide the efficient cook stoves to replace the inefficient three-stone fire. Labour standards 4 • The project will provide employment for the local youth who will be Low Not involved in constructing the cook stoves. They will be subject to the needed freedoms and rights as provided by for the constitution of Kenya and other pieces of legislation. The project will not curtail any of these rights. ILO convention 98 (right of collective bargaining) has been ratified by Kenya in 1964. (http://www.ilo.org/ilolex/english/convdisp1.htm)
5 • This project will not at any stage use force or use any other means Low Not that will be considered forceful to have people work in stove needed construction or buying. ILO convention 29 (forced labour) has been ratified by Kenya in 1964.
19
GOLD STANDARD PASSPORT
(http://www.ilo.org/ilolex/english/convdisp1.htm) ILO convention 105 (abolition of forced labour) has been ratified by Kenya in 1964. (http://www.ilo.org/ilolex/english/convdisp1.htm)
6 • All workers are adults. No child labour is engaged for the Low Not construction of the stoves or for the preparation of any construction needed material needed. ILO convention 138 (minimum age) has been ratified by Kenya in 1979. (http://www.ilo.org/ilolex/english/convdisp1.htm)
7 • The project will at no stage be biased either towards a particular Low Not gender, religion or race. This is expressly noted in the organization needed operational procedures. ILO convention 100 (equal remuneration) has been ratified by Kenya in 2001. (http://www.ilo.org/ilolex/english/convdisp1.htm) ILO convention 111 (employment & occupation) has been ratified by Kenya in 2001. (http://www.ilo.org/ilolex/english/convdisp1.htm)
8 • No hazardous materials are used for the construction of the Low Not improved stoves. All materials are locally available. The needed construction does not involve any dangerous processes. Environmental protection 9 • The project activity does not involve planting or agricultural activities Low Not or the use of hazardous materials, or invasive species. needed • The project promotes environmental protection. 10 • The project will not involve the conversion or degradation of natural Low Not habitats. The materials used for stove construction are locally needed available such as mud, burnt bricks; local people will be used to extract them. • The project promotes habitat conservation through reduced fuel wood use. The Convention on Biological Diversity has been ratified and signed by Kenya in 1992. (http://www.cbd.int/convention/parties/list/) The United Nations Convention to Combat Desertification has been signed by Kenya in 1997. (http://www.unccd.int/Lists/SiteDocumentLibrary/convention/ratification- eng.pdf) Anti- Corruption
20
GOLD STANDARD PASSPORT
11 • The project will not be involved and it is not complicit in corruption. Low Not • Tembea has procedures in place to report to the Ethic and Anti- needed Corruption Commission; Tembea is represented in Siaya Anti- Corruption Coalition (group of orgs. monitoring and following-up corruption incidents). The United Nations Convention against Corruption has been signed and ratified by Kenya in 2003. (http://www.unodc.org/unodc/en/treaties/CAC/signatories.html)
F.2. Sustainable Development matrix
Insert table in section C3 from your Stakeholder Consultation report (Sustainable Development matrix).
Mitigation Chosen parameter and Preliminary Indicator Relevance to achieving MDG measure explanation score Negative impact: score ‘-’ in case If relevant, negative copy impact is not mitigation fully Gold measure mitigated, Standard from ‘Do No Check www.undp.org/mdg and score ‘0’ in indicators Harm’ www.mdgmonitor.org case impact of assessment Defined by project is planned to sustainabl , and developer Describe how your indicator is be fully e include related to local MDG goals mitigated developm mitigation ent measure No change used to in impact: neutralise a score ‘0’ score of ‘-’
Positive impact: score ‘+’ MDG 4: Reduce child mortality Indoor air quality: Air quality n/a + MDG 5: Improve maternal health Number of positive
21
GOLD STANDARD PASSPORT
comments on indoor air Explanation quality improvement The efficient cook stove reduces from households using smoke emissions from fire through efficient cook stoves. cleaner burning process and This indicator will be decreased wood consumption monitored using through efficiency. Monitoring Surveys. The reduced indoor pollution will offer a chance to enhance the health of mothers and children who are mostly engaged in kitchen work. Thus promoting maternal health and reduced child mortality. MDG 7: Ensure environmental sustainability
Explanation Positive effect on water Water • Reduced tree cutting will have quality and quantity is quality positive impact on reducing difficult to attribute n/a surface run off and enhancing directly to project activity. 0 and the hydrological cycle of an This indicator is thus quantity area. scored “0” and will not be The reduced tree cutting will • monitored. mean reduced surface run off, which is important in enhancing underground water reserves by providing time for percolation. MDG 7: Ensure environmental sustainability MDG 1: Eradicate extreme poverty and hunger Improvement and conservation of soil Explanation condition is difficult to directly attribute to Soil • The reduced cutting of trees n/a project activity. 0 condition will lead to reduced surface run off which subsequently reduces This indicator is thus soil erosion, which robs off the scored “0” and will not be top and fertile soils, in monitored. extremes this, can reduce farm productivity. • This can enhance community well being due to reduced negative impacts on
22
GOLD STANDARD PASSPORT
agricultural productivity, thus surpluses will be sold to provide income.
No other pollutants are involved in project activity.
No hazardous materials are used in the production of efficient cook stoves. Stoves are MDG 7: Ensure environmental made with local bricks, Other n/a sustainability mud, water, and 0 pollutants sawdust. Construction is done onsite and the materials are sourced within the vicinity of the households/homes, with insignificant effect on the environment as these materials are drawn in small quantities. MDG 7: Ensure environmental sustainability MDG 1: Eradicate extreme poverty and hunger
Explanation Positive influence of • The reduced tree cutting and project activity on Biodiversi destruction of habitants will biodiversity is difficult to n/a 0 ty ensure minimum impacts on measure. Therefore, the species richness in the local area. The minimum indicator is kept neutral impacts on water quality and and is not monitored. quantity will reduce disturbance in water body habitats. • Maintain the species richness and natural environment of an area can be turned into income generation through the
23
GOLD STANDARD PASSPORT
blending of ecotourism around such areas.
MDG 1: Reduce poverty and hunger Explanation • The project seeks to offer Training of artisans: Quality of employment to the youth who - number of artisans employm n/a are marginalized from the trained for construction + mainstream employment. of efficient cook stoves ent • The project seeks to provide trainings to the youth that will improve their capacity as artisans. Skills that they can use later in life or elsewhere.
Time and money savings due to reduced fuel MDG 1: Eradicate extreme poverty consumption: and hunger Time and money spent Explanation on fuel per household • Households with improved per year compared to the cook stove will save time and baseline scenario. money spent on fuel wood. This indicator is This will relieve households’ monitored using the budgets. Monitoring Surveys and The livelihood of the locals will Livelihood is compared to the be greatly improved through, of the n/a values obtained in the + involvement in income earning baseline study poor activities (poultry keeping) initiated through the integrated Number of people in loaning and savings savings and loaning programme. This will provide groups: skills and financial resources - to acquire efficient cook that will enhance community stoves resilience to natural disasters - to access medical care, pay for school fees, and and poverty. other social services.
Records from the savings and loaning
24
GOLD STANDARD PASSPORT
groups are used to monitor these indicators.
MDG 7: Ensure environmental sustainability MDG 1: Eradicate extreme poverty and hunger
Explanation • Less resource consumption on Number of households buying energy sources for using efficient cook Access to cooking will provide for stoves: affordable savings, allowing people to This indicator is and clean n/a participate alternative + businesses thus reducing continuously monitored energy poverty. and is available from the services • The cook stoves that use less sales record. firewood will reduce the hardship put on women and young girls as they go fetching firewood long distances thus giving them chance to pursue education and others enhancing gender equity and empowerment.
MDG 1: Eradicate extreme poverty Number of women and hunger trained: MDG 3: Promote gender equity and - number of women trained for saving empowerment and loaning groups - number of Explanation animators (women) Human • The opportunity availed by the trained for and project for people to be trained awareness creation institution n/a on stoves construction and and education + al their subsequent involvement Participants list for capacity in stove development, will be a different trainings means of income generation, conducted (type of which will lead to poverty trainings, dates of eradication/reduction. training, the number of • The opportunity offered through trainees) are used for the trainings can contribute greatly monitoring. to communities appreciating the link or importance taking Number of people
25
GOLD STANDARD PASSPORT
children to schools as well as reached through source of income to be used to awareness creation on pay for fees and other efficient cook stoves and necessitates climate change. • The opportunities provided for training will offer equal opportunity for women and men thus giving women a chance to engage in income generation activities which is vital in achieving gender equity and empowerment. Number of people MDG 1: Eradicate extreme poverty receiving income from and hunger project activity: Number of people Explanation employed e.g. data • The project will offer clerks, accountant, employment to the youth and community mobilize, field sources of income, which will officers, loaning and be used to enhance the savings officers, quality economic well being of the assurance, monitors, community thus reducing stove construction. Quantitati incidences of poverty. The project coordination ve • The employment offered will be will keep a record of the employm both in the office and that for people directly employed artisans in the field. by the projects and ent and + • The indirect benefits from the copies of their contracts. income project can have a positive generatio impact on the HIV/AIDS Project will provide n prevalence rates in the region. employment to at least Some of the reasons for high 15 staff (project prevalence rates are poverty manager, loaning and but with employment then saving head, training incidences of sex for money coordinator and can be considerably reduced. environmental expert), 5 • Improve maternal health, due artisan per community to availability of income at the for 12 communities and community and household at least 2 sub contracts levels, money can be available awarded that will employ to support provision of medical not less than 5 people facilities and medicines. each.
Balance Project does not involve of n/a 0 this indicator payments
26
GOLD STANDARD PASSPORT and investmen t MDG 8: Develop a global partnership for development
Technolo Explanation gy • The efficient cook stove is an transfer improvement of an existing This indicator is kept and technology (biomass cook 0 neutral. technologi stove). Thus no real new technology is transferred to the cal self- project area. However, stoves reliance can locally be produced and local capacities are built for construction of stoves.
SECTION G. Sustainability Monitoring Plan
[See Toolkit 2.4.3 and Toolkit Annex I]
Copy Table for each indicator
Justification choices, data source and provision of references A justification paragraph and reference source is required for each indicator, regardless of score
Air quality Much of the world population, particularly in developing countries, still relies on firewood to meet basic energy needs. The resulting indoor air pollution can have severe health consequences, particularly for young children who spend considerable time in close proximity to the fire while their mothers cook.
“Lack of access to clean, efficient, modern energy in the home can impact health in many ways. The most important direct health effects result from the air pollution caused by burning solid fuels, often indoors on open fires and simple stoves. [...] There is good evidence linking smoke from solid fuel use in developing countries with three important diseases—child pneumonia, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), and lung cancer. Smoke from incomplete combustion of solid fuels contains many substances known to be toxic to human health through a variety of mechanisms. Among these pollutants, small particulate matter and carbon monoxide have been most commonly measured in homes using solid fuels.“ (WHO & UNDP 2009, page 22).
27
GOLD STANDARD PASSPORT
Sources: - World Bank report on the effects of indoor air pollution from cook stoves on health, 2003 http://siteresources.worldbank.org/INTPHAAG/Resources/AAGIAP9-03.pdf - The Energy Access Situation in Developing Countries. A Review Focusing on the Least Developed Countries and Sub-Saharan Africa. WHO & UNDP, November 2009: http://www.undp.org/energy/ - Gender and Equity in Bioenergy Access and Delivery in Kenya Study http://www.pisces.or.ke/pubs/pdfs/Gender%20and%20Equity%20in%20Bioenergy%20in%20Ken ya.pdf - “Smoke – the Killer in the Kitchen”: http://practicalaction.org/?id=smoke_report_home - General literature: http://www.hedon.info/category:improvedstoves - Specific on indoor air quality and health effects: http://www.hedon.info/1497/news.htm - Fuel Choice, Indoor Air Pollution, and Children's Health: http://econ.tulane.edu/RePEc/pdf/tul0803.pdf - Wood fuel: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wood_fuel - Indoor air pollution monitoring in Ghana: http://ceihd.org/images/stories/publications/Ghana%20final.pdf
Monitoring: • Indoor air quality: Number of positive comments on indoor air quality improvement from households using efficient cook stoves. This indicator will be monitored using Kitchen Surveys.
Water quality Forests, trees and vegetation play an important role as water buffer. Deforestation reduces water and quantity storage capacity of land and has a bad impact on the natural water cycle. Reducing the demand for wood fuel decreases deforestation. This has positive effects on the water cycle (availability and quality): An intact vegetation cover preserves water resources in the ground and prevents soil erosion, which would lead to silting of water courses and bodies and affects the water retention capacity of the soil. Inefficient use of fuel wood is considered one of the important causes of deforestation. Depending on location, tree cutting can have the following impacts on the water bodies around it 1. Increased sedimentation, nutrient loading 2. Increased stream temperature 3. Injury to fish, amphibian and other wildlife population 4. Water yield changes: 5. Increased high flows from storms and spring run-off 6. Decreased low flows in summer, negatively affecting riparian & aquatic habitat
Sources: - “State of the World's Forests 2009". United Nations Food and Agriculture Organization: http://www.fao.org/docrep/011/i0350e/i0350e00.HTM, p. 74 - “Adoption of biomass improved cook stoves in a patriarchal society: an example from Sudan”: http://sciencedirect.com4 - Water quality and quantity effects from clear cutting: http://www.stopclearcuttingcalifornia.org/library/reports/waterquality.html - Effects of plantation forest harvesting on water quality and quantity: Canobolas State forest, NSW:
4 http://www.sciencedirect.com/science?_ob=ArticleURL&_udi=B6V78-47GY924- B&_user=10&_coverDate=05%2F20%2F2003&_rdoc=1&_fmt=high&_orig=search&_origin=search&_sort=d&_docanchor=&view=c&_se archStrId=1475112800&_rerunOrigin=google&_acct=C000050221&_version=1&_urlVersion=0&_userid=10&md5=71a0edd37c81063e25 ce039c72385d3d&searchtype=a
28
GOLD STANDARD PASSPORT
http://www.csu.edu.au/research/ilws/news/events/5asm/docs/proceedings/Webb_Ashley_443.pdf - Water quality and quantity: http://www.extension.org/pages/Water_Quality_and_Quantity
Monitoring: • The project’s direct positive effect on this indicator is difficult to attribute. Thus, this indicator is not monitored.
Soil condition Harvesting wood and development and use of infrastructure (roads, skid trails, and landings) can expose soil, leading to soil erosion and runoff that can affect water quality and hydrological processes. Removing vegetation and litter during biomass harvesting for bioenergy can increase the risk of higher peak flows. It also allows more water to fall directly on the soil surface and infiltrate to groundwater, resulting in a higher water table that could lead to soil saturation and a loss of productivity. Reducing deforestation as a result of fuel wood savings prevents soil erosion and leaching. This ensures the fertility of the soil. The severity of human induced soil degradation in the Nyanza Province, Kenya is considered to be very severe:
Sources: - Forest Resources in Eritrea: http://www.fao.org/docrep/003/x6782E/X6782E02.htm - Wood Energy and Soil Productivity: http://www.extension.org/pages/Wood_Energy_and_Soil_Productivity - "State of the World's Forests 2009". United Nations Food and Agriculture: Organization: http://www.fao.org/docrep/011/i0350e/i0350e00.HTM. - http://www.fao.org/landandwater/agll/glasod/glasodmaps.jsp?search=Display+map+!&country=K EN
Monitoring: • The project’s direct positive effect on this indicator is difficult to attribute. Thus, this indicator is not monitored.
Other No other pollutants are involved in project activity. pollutants No hazardous materials are used in the production of efficient cook stoves. Stoves are made with local bricks, mud, water, and sawdust. Construction is done onsite and the materials are sourced within the vicinity of the households/homes, with insignificant effect on the environment as these materials are drawn in small quantities.
Sources: N.A.
Monitoring: N.A. Biodiversity Deforestation results in declines in biodiversity. The removal or destruction of areas of forest cover has resulted in a degraded environment with reduced biodiversity. Forests support biodiversity, providing habitat for wildlife; moreover, forests foster conservation. With forest biotopes being irreplaceable source of new drugs (such as taxol), deforestation can destroy genetic variations (such as crop resistance) irretrievably.
Sources:
29
GOLD STANDARD PASSPORT
- Tropical timber harvesting, biodiversity loss and environmental change: http://www.thedailystar.net/story.php?nid=18676 - "State of the World's Forests 2009". United Nations Food and Agriculture: Organization: http://www.fao.org/docrep/011/i0350e/i0350e00.HTM - Fuelwood/Building Material: http://rainforests.mongabay.com/0814.htm
Monitoring: • The project’s direct positive effect on this indicator is difficult to attribute. Thus, this indicator is not monitored.
Quality of Kenya has an unemployment rate of 40%. The implementation of efficient cookstoves in the Siaya employment County in Nyanza Province will provide new jobs for the inhabitants. The project seeks to provide trainings to the youth and others that will improve their capacity as artisans. Skills that they can use later in life or elsewhere.
Sources: - Kenya economic overview: https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world- factbook/geos/ke.html - Copy of certification document for artisans trained will be provided. - Copies of contracts with artisans employed by the project.
Monitoring: • Number of artisans trained and certified: Copy of certification document for artisans trained. • Number of artisans practicing: Copies of contracts with artisans employed by the project.
Livelihood of In Siaya County over 90% of rural households and over 80% of urban households use wood the poor fuel as a source of energy and the demand of wood is high and continues to rise (SDDP 2008-2012, p. 25). The reduction in firewood required for cooking will result in less expenditure on cooking fuel. As a result of providing fuel efficient stoves access to clean and affordable energy services will be improved considerably. Overall poverty level of the district stands at 40%, however with great geographical differences; in some areas there are poverty indices of more than 70% (SDDP 2008-2012, p. 54). The causes of poverty in this area are diverse and include among others low income among households to afford farm inputs, over-reliance on traditional methods of farming and lack of alternative sources of income. Almost 90% of the population are engaged in agricultural activities or are self-engaged (SDDP 2008-2012, p. 37). Siaya County has a very high incidence of HIV/AIDS estimated at 24%. The doctor/population ration is at 1:52,000 and high cost of health care services and health care financing is mentioned among major concerns in the health sector (SDDP 2008-2012, p. 28 & 54). The livelihood of the locals will be greatly improved through the involvement in income earning activities and the integrated loaning and savings programme, which will provide skills and financial resources that will enhance community resilience to natural disasters and poverty.
Sources:
30
GOLD STANDARD PASSPORT
- Siaya District Development Plan (SDDP) 2008-2012, OFFICE OF THE PRIME MINISTER MINISTRY OF STATE FOR PLANNING, NATIONAL DEVELOPMENT AND VISION 2030, pp. 25, 28, 34-42, 54. - New Global Alliance Embraces Efficient Cooking Stoves: http://www.wfp.org/stories/new-global- alliance-embraces-clean-cooking-stoves - Gender and Equity in Bioenergy Access and Delivery in Kenya: http://www.pisces.or.ke/pubs/pdfs/Gender%20and%20Equity%20in%20Bioenergy%20in%20Ken ya.pdf - UNDP joins major Africa drive: http://www.capitalfm.co.ke/news/Kenyanews/UNEP-joins-major-Africa-drive- 9882.html
Monitoring: • Time and money savings due to reduced fuel consumption: Time and money spent on fuel per household per year compared to the baseline scenario. • Number of people in savings and loaning groups: - to acquire efficient cook stoves - to access medical care, pay for school fees, and other social services.
Access to The reduction in firewood required for cooking will result in cleaner combustion and in less affordable and expenditure on cooking fuel. As a result of providing fuel efficient stoves access to clean and clean energy affordable energy services will be improved considerably. services Sources: - Ingwe A (2007) Rocket Mud Stoves in Kenya. Boiling Point No 53, 2007. http://www.hedon.info/docs/BP53-Ingwe-3.pdf
Monitoring: • Number of households using efficient cook stoves. • This indicator is continuously monitored and is available from the sales record.
Human and The opportunity availed by the project for people to be trained on stoves construction and institutional their subsequent involvement in stove development, will be a means of income generation, capacity which will lead to poverty eradication/reduction. The opportunity offered through trainings can contribute greatly to communities appreciating the link or importance of taking children to schools as well as source of income to be used to pay for fees and other necessitates. The opportunities provided for training will offer equal opportunity for women and men thus giving women a chance to engage in income generation activities which is vital in achieving gender equity and empowerment. Environmental training, knowledge dissemination, stove building process will include teaching families about the benefits of the fuel efficiency and how to make the most of the technology in their homes, as well as raising environmental awareness on issues to do with deforestation, climate change, respiratory health.
Sources: - Records from different types of trainings.
31
GOLD STANDARD PASSPORT
Monitoring: • Number of people trained: - number of women and men trained for saving and loaning groups - number of animators (women and men) trained for awareness creation and education • Number of people reached through awareness creation on efficient cook stoves and climate change.
Quantitative The project will provide employment to the locals in different activities such as efficient stove employment construction, raw material production, maintenance, data clerks, accountant, community and income mobilize, field officers, loaning and savings officers, quality assurance. generation Project will provide employment to at least 15 staff (project manager, loaning and saving head, training coordinator and environmental expert), 5 artisan per community for 12 communities and at least 2 sub contracts awarded that will employ not less than 5 people each.
Sources: - The project coordination will keep a record of the people directly employed by the projects and copies of their contracts.
Monitoring: • Number of people receiving income from project activity.
Balance of The project will utilize locally available materials and skills as well as lead to the development payments and of that expertise locally. This will reduce dependence on foreign or outside acquired materials investment or skills.
Sources: N.A.
Monitoring: N.A.
Technology The use of the traditional three stones cooking stoves is widespread in the project area. The transfer and traditional three stone cooking stoves are considered cheap and easy to assemble and that technological for a long time has made it common despite of its inefficiency. The proposed project stoves self-reliance are new and blend both indigenous and modern technology. The new modern technology is borrowed; it is adoption will lead to technology transfer and domestication. The training and employment in the efficient stove development will lead to a level of self reliance in the community which contributes to sustainable development.
Sources: - Household Energy Network, Boiling Point No 17, http://www.hedon.info/BP17:SupplyOfMetalForJikos - Ingwe A (2007) Rocket Mud Stoves in Kenya. Boiling Point No 53, 2007. http://www.hedon.info/docs/BP53-Ingwe-3.pdf
32
GOLD STANDARD PASSPORT
Monitoring: N.A.
No 1 Indicator Air quality Mitigation measure N.A. Repeat for each parameter Chosen parameter # of positive comments from stove users Current situation of parameter Energy efficient cook stoves will reduce fuel wood smoke through cleaner burning and decreased fuel wood burning through efficiency. This should lead to positive comments by stove owners about indoor air quality and perhaps fewer cases of respiratory-related problems at local dispensaries. Estimation of baseline situation of N.A. parameter Future target for parameter All new stove users give positive comments about indoor air quality from those who cook with Tembea stove over baseline stove. Way of monitoring How Household interviews for Monitoring Survey When Annually 1 year after registration By who Research/Monitoring Coordinator Tembea
No 2 Indicator Quality of Employment Mitigation measure N.A. Repeat for each parameter Chosen parameter Number of artisans trained Current situation of parameter N.A. Estimation of baseline situation of Number of artisans trained: parameter None Future target for parameter Number of artisans trained: It is expected to train at least 60 artisans
Way of monitoring How Training records When Annually By who Research/Monitoring Coordinator Tembea
No 3 Indicator Livelihood of the poor Mitigation measure N.A. Repeat for each parameter
33
GOLD STANDARD PASSPORT
Chosen parameter - Time and money savings due to reduced fuel consumption: Time and money spent on fuel per household per year compared to the baseline scenario. - Number of people in savings and loaning groups: - to acquire efficient cook stoves - to access medical care, pay for school fees, and other social services.
Current situation of parameter N.A. Estimation of baseline situation of Time and money spent on fuel: parameter The BS estimated an expenditure of KES 10972 on fuel per year and 431 hours used in fuel gathering per year for the baseline scenario.
Number of people in savings and loaning groups: None Future target for parameter Time and money spent on fuel: Based on PS expenditure on fuel are estimated at KES 5486 per year and time used in fuel gathering is estimated to be 215 hours for the project scenario.
Number of people in savings and loaning groups: Per year approximately 300 CSL groups established with 4,500 persons targeted.
Way of monitoring How Household interviews for Monitoring Survey Record keeping of savings and loaning groups When Annually By who Research/Monitoring Coordinator Tembea
No 4 Indicator Access to affordable and clean energy services Mitigation measure N.A. Repeat for each parameter Chosen parameter - Number of households using efficient cook stoves.
Current situation of parameter Households use 3-stone fire for cooking Estimation of baseline situation of N.A. parameter Future target for parameter See A.2. for forecasted number of efficient stoves constructed over a period of 7 years. Way of monitoring How Sales record When Annually By who Research/Monitoring Coordinator and Project Manager Tembea
34
GOLD STANDARD PASSPORT
No 5 Indicator Human/institutional capacity Mitigation measure N.A. Repeat for each parameter Chosen parameter - Number of women trained: - number of women trained for saving and loaning groups (CSL) - number of animators (women) trained for awareness creation and education - Number of people reached through awareness creation on efficient cook stoves and climate change.
Current situation of parameter N.A. Estimation of baseline situation of N.A. parameter Future target for parameter Approx. 3,000 women trained for CSL Approx. 9 animators trained Approx. 4,500 people reached through awareness creation per year.
Way of monitoring How Training records and record from awareness creation activities When Annually By who Research/Monitoring Coordinator
No 6 Indicator Quantitative employment and income generation Mitigation measure N.A. Repeat for each parameter Chosen parameter Number of people receiving income from project activity.
Current situation of parameter N.A Estimation of baseline situation of N.A parameter Future target for parameter Project will provide employment to approximately 75 persons: - Approx. 15 staff (project manager, loaning and saving head, training coordinator and environmental expert) - Approx. 5 artisan per community for 12 communities (totaling 60)
It is expected that 100% of employees are locals. Way of monitoring How Employment records and financial records When Annually By who Monitoring/Research Coordinator
Additional remarks monitoring
35
GOLD STANDARD PASSPORT
SECTION H. Additionality and conservativeness
This section is only applicable if the section on additionality and/or your choice of baseline does not follow Gold Standard guidance
H.1. Additionality
N.A.
36
GOLD STANDARD PASSPORT
H.2. Conservativeness
[See Toolkit 2.2]
N.A.
37
GOLD STANDARD PASSPORT
ANNEX 1 ODA declaration
38
GOLD STANDARD PASSPORT
ANNEX 2 Supporting documentation for feedback round
Invitation tracking table for stakeholder feedback round
Category Organisation (if Name of invitee Means of invitation Date of Feedback Code relevant) invitation received? (see list Y/N above) E Gold Standard: Nahla Sabet [email protected] 12.10.2011 N Local Gold reminder Standard Expert, sent Africa & Middle 12.12.2011 East F Renewable Energy Ndhlukula [email protected] 12.10.2011 N & Energy Efficiency Kudakwashe reminder Institute, Namibia sent 12.12.2011 F WWF South Africa Worthington [email protected] 12.10.2011 N Richard (office: +27 11 262 9460, mobile: +27 (0)82 reminder 44 66 392) sent 12.12.2011 F (SACAN Facilitator) Dora Ledello 185 Smit Street, Braamfontein, 8000 South 12.10.2011 N EarthLife Africa Africa reminder Johannesburg Telephone: +27 (0)730357208 sent [email protected] 12.12.2011 F SouthSouthNorth, Raubenheimer [email protected] 12.10.2011 N South Africa Stefan reminder sent 12.12.2011 F Zero: Regional Chigwada [email protected] 12.10.2011 N Environment Johannes reminder Organisation, sent Zimbabwe 12.12.2011 F WWF International Bella Roscher [email protected] 12.10.2011 N reminder sent 12.12.2011 F Greenpeace Steve Sawyer [email protected] 12.10.2011 N International -> Failed delivery. reminder Thus, sent to: sent [email protected] 12.12.2011 F Mercy Corps Dorothy [email protected] 12.10.2011 N International McIntosh reminder
39
GOLD STANDARD PASSPORT
sent 12.12.2011 F Helio International Helene [email protected] 12.10.2011 N O'Connor- reminder Lajambe sent 12.12.2011 F REEEP Marianne [email protected] 12.10.2011 N Osterkorn reminder sent 12.12.2011 C National Dr. Ayub [email protected], 25th October N Environment Macharia 2011 Management Authority, (NEMA)Kenya (DNA) C NEMA - District Ms. Anne [email protected], 25th October N environment AnyangoOwino [email protected] 2011 D Green Belt Executive [email protected] 25th October N Movement director Website contact form 2011 F Sustainable Table Hayley Giachin [email protected] 25th October N (Formerly – 2011 Yaubula) F African Wildlife Ms. Isabella A. [email protected] 25th October N Foundation Masinde 2011 F IUCN Grace Mwaura [email protected] 25th October N 2011 D Rural Water and Mr. Francis [email protected], 25th October N Sanitation Asuna [email protected] 2011 Organization (WATERSAN) D Nature Kenya Emily Mbenge [email protected] 25th October N 2011 D UCRC Mr. [email protected], 25th October N AggreyOmondi [email protected] 2011 F ILRI Philip Osano [email protected] 25th October N ,[email protected] 2011 D KENVO David Kuria [email protected] 25th October N 2011 D KEFRI Mr. Mukolwe [email protected], 25th October N Michael [email protected] 2011 D WKCDD/FMP Ms. Rose [email protected] 25th October N Koboge 2011
40
GOLD STANDARD PASSPORT
D KARI/WKIEMP Wilson Aore [email protected], 25th October N [email protected] 2011 D UCAHA Mr. Bernard [email protected], 25th October N Adalla [email protected] 2011 D UNDP/DBSC Siaya Ms. Bianca [email protected] , 18th October Y Ocholla [email protected] 2011 D National Mr. [email protected] 25th October Y Coordinating OduorOnyango +254722790457 2011 Agency on Population and Development – (NCAPD) F Artist Project Earth Ms. Lorna [email protected] 25th October N - UK Horwath 2011 B Member of Hon. James [email protected] 25th October N Parliament, Ugenya AggreyOrengo Letter 2011 Constituency B Siaya county Town Clerk, Letter 18th October Y Council 2011 B Town Council of Town Clerk Letter 18th October Y Ugunja 2011 B Town Council of Town Clerk Letter 18th October Y Ukwala 2011 B Kisumu Medical Ms. Monica [email protected] 25th October N Education Trust Oguttu 2011 (KMET) D OSIENALA Dr. Obiero [email protected] 25th October N Ong’anga 2011 D ECOFINDER Mr. Leonard [email protected] 25th October Y Akwany 2011 D Community Mr. Chris Owala [email protected] 25th October Y Initiative Action 2011 Group (CIAG – Kenya) D Matibabu Mr. Dan Ogolla [email protected] 25th October N Foundation 2011 D AYICC-KENYA George Auko [email protected] 25th October N 2011 D AYICC Ms. Sylvia [email protected], 25th October N Wachira [email protected] 2011
F WWF-Kenya KimunyaMugo [email protected] 25th October N 2011
41
GOLD STANDARD PASSPORT
F ACTIS Dr. Roger Baud [email protected] 25th October N 2011 F Sustainability Ms. Jess [email protected] 25th October N Institute Schulschenk 2011 D Youth Alive! Kenya Mr. James [email protected] 25th October N Muraguri 2011 D KENTEL Mr. Cleopa [email protected] 25th October N Otieno 2011 B DC Ugenya Ms. Caroline Letter/Telephone 18th Y Onchoka October 2011 B DC Siaya Mr. Boaz Letter/Telephone 18th Y Cherutich October 2011 D Africa Now Mr. Haron [email protected], 18th N Emukhule [email protected] October 2011 D EU/GTZ Ecological Mr. Johaness [email protected], 25th October Y Sanitation Orodi [email protected] 2011 promotion D Eco Sanity Watako David [email protected], 25th October Y Services 2011 D Kenya Land Ms. Rose [email protected], 25th October N Alliance Ong’ech 2011 D RECONCILE Mr. Ken Peter [email protected], 25th October Y Otieno [email protected], 2011 [email protected] F CARE International Mr. Joseph [email protected], 25th October N in Kenya Makanda [email protected] 2011 D KWAHO Mr. Arysterico E. [email protected], 25th October N Mahinda [email protected] 2011 D CMEDA Ms. Annemarie [email protected], 25th October N Ojung’a - [email protected] 2011 Ochieng F PACJA Mr. Mwenda [email protected], [email protected] 25th October N Mithika 2011 D Kenya Young Philip Otieno [email protected], 25th October N Greens [email protected], 2011 [email protected] D Kenya Community Mr. Peter [email protected], 25th October N Development Wechuli 2011 Foundation D Youth Employment Emmanuel [email protected] 25th October N
42
GOLD STANDARD PASSPORT
Systems Denis Ngongo 2011 D Ujamaa Centre Patrick Ochieng [email protected], 25th October N [email protected] 2011 D ILEG Mr. Makoloo [email protected] 25th October N 2011 D SOPA International Ambrose [email protected] 25th October N Ong’wen 2011 D Allavida Clement K. [email protected] 25th October N Nganga 2011 D Resource Prof. Chris [email protected] 25th October N Management and Ackello-Ogutu 2011 Policy Analysis Institute D Organization for Charles Odiero [email protected] 18th October Y Transformation of 2011 Initiated Technologies
43
GOLD STANDARD PASSPORT
Copies of emails sent to Gold Standard Supporters:
44
GOLD STANDARD PASSPORT
45
GOLD STANDARD PASSPORT
46
GOLD STANDARD PASSPORT
47
GOLD STANDARD PASSPORT
Copies of the participants’ list of the feedback round meeting:
48
GOLD STANDARD PASSPORT
Copies of feedback received filled and in feedback forms:
49
GOLD STANDARD PASSPORT
50
GOLD STANDARD PASSPORT
51
GOLD STANDARD PASSPORT
52
GOLD STANDARD PASSPORT
53
GOLD STANDARD PASSPORT
54
GOLD STANDARD PASSPORT
55
GOLD STANDARD PASSPORT
56
GOLD STANDARD PASSPORT
57
GOLD STANDARD PASSPORT
58
GOLD STANDARD PASSPORT
59
GOLD STANDARD PASSPORT
60
GOLD STANDARD PASSPORT
61
GOLD STANDARD PASSPORT
62
GOLD STANDARD PASSPORT
Re: Call for Stakeholder Feedback Round http://www.tembeayouth.org:2095/3rdparty/squirrelmail/src/printer_frien...
From: "ANDREW ADALLAH"
Dear Jared, We are impressed with the work you do in this project that brings special focus on climate change, which of course need to be considered by other development partners as of urgent need. I see your project to bring in a new paradigm shift that will be significant in shaping "our perception" of sustainable development. We will give quality feed back in due course of the month. Keep up the good work.
Regards,
Andrew Adallah,
UCAHA Youth Group.
--- On Tue, 10/25/11, Buoga, Jared Omondi
From: Buoga, Jared Omondi
Dear Stakeholders,
We would like to invite you to participate in the stakeholder feedback round for the project activity "GS 879 Energy Efficient Cook Stoves for Siaya Communities, Kenya".
Please find attached the call for the stakeholder feedback round including a non-technical summary of the project activity as well as the stakeholder report summarizing the outcome of the local stakeholder consultation meeting held on 05 May 2010 in Ugunja, Kenya.
The project documentation (PDD, GS Passport, Stakeholder Report) is available at myclimate's website:http://www.myclimate.org/carbon-offset-projects/international-projects/detail/mycproject/169/95.html We are looking forward to receiving your comments on this project activity (e.g. by filling in the attached feedback form). Thank you very much! Cordially Yours, Buoga Jared Omondi Director, Tembea Youth Centre for Sustainable Development, P.O. Box 313 - 40606 UGUNJA, Kenya Tel: +254722588675 Skype: buoga.jared Webpage: www.tembeayouth.org Go confidently in the direction of your dreams! Live the life you ve imagined. As you simplify your life, the laws of the universe will be simpler; solitude will not be solitude, poverty will not be poverty, nor weakness weakness. --Henry David Thoreau (American author, poet and philosopher) Attachments: untitled-[2].html Size:3.7 k Type:text/html 1 of 1 1/26/2012 9:17 PM 63 GOLD STANDARD PASSPORT Re: Call for Stakeholder Feedback Round http://www.tembeayouth.org:2095/3rdparty/squirrelmail/src/printer_frien... From: "nyanzanorth" Dear Jarred Buoga, Thank you for involving us in this feed back. We are giving it the necessary attention! Onyango, RPC Nyanza -----Original Message----- From: "Buoga, Jared Omondi" > Dear Stakeholders, > > We would like to invite you to participate in the stakeholder feedback > round for the project activity "GS 879 Energy Efficient Cook Stoves for > Siaya Communities, Kenya". > > Please find attached the call for the stakeholder feedback round > including a > non-technical summary of the project activity as well as the > stakeholder > report summarizing the outcome of the local stakeholder consultation > meeting held on 05 May 2010 in Ugunja, Kenya. > > The project documentation (PDD, GS Passport, Stakeholder Report) is > available at myclimate's 1 of 2 1/26/2012 8:54 PM 64 GOLD STANDARD PASSPORT Gmail - 1109_feedback_form_tembea https://mail.google.com/mail/?ui=2&ik=8730a093ed&view=pt&q=feedba... Jared Buoga 1109_feedback_form_tembea Ken Otieno Dear Jared, Attached find my feedback. It is such a great work. I have put some points for reflection. Ken 1109_feedback_form_tembea.docx 78K 1 of 1 1/26/2012 9:14 PM 65 GOLD STANDARD PASSPORT Call for Stakeholder Feedback Round sent out to stakeholders: 66 GOLD STANDARD PASSPORT 67 GOLD STANDARD PASSPORT 68