Helmut Müller-Enbergs, dr.phil. Adj. Professor, Center for Cold War Studies, University of Southern Denmark Email: [email protected] Thomas Wegener Friis, ph.d. Associate Professor and Director, Center for Cold War Studies, University of Southern Denmark Email: [email protected] Research Paper Received: July 3, 2021 Accepted: July 28, 2021 Women Agents in the East German State Security Abstract: In the communist camp during the Cold War, exercising power was a male domain. The Ministry of State Security (MfS) of the former German Democratic Republic (GDR) was no exception. Within the organization, women were employed but they rarely made a career. In the bottom of the State Security hierarchy were the agents. This article examines who were the women agents in the rank of the MfS. Based on statistical materials, it gives an overview of women’s role and the character of their covert work. Inspired by Andrea Petö’s introduction of the concept of controlling images to intelligence studies, particular focus is devoted to the question whether the MfS agents complied to the stereotypes of women in intelligence work. Keywords: GDR, Ministry of State Security (MfS), domestic security, foreign Intelligence, Women agents 61 Introduction In 2020, the Hungarian professor for Gender Studies at the Central European University, Andrea Petö published an article on women in Hungarian Intelligence during the Cold War. She characterized the communist intelligence agencies not just as strict hierarchic but also as organizations with a gender- based hierarchy. On the bottom of the “pecking order” were the informants and the higher in the hierarchy one got, the lesser women were to be found.1 In the GDR, the overall impression was similar: Less than a fifth of the full-time employees of the East German State Security were women.2 This made it possible for wives and daughters to find suitable profession in the “family enterprise”. However, their chances to make a carrier were modest at best, and all higher manage positions were men. “Real chekist work” was male, and Women were primarily found in lower prestige parts of the security organization.3 Despite proclaimed gender equality in the socialist countries, exerting “the power of the working class” remained in the domain of men.4 Petö introduced into the intelligence equation the notion of controlling images as “an image that naturalizes and normalizes sexism and posits it as an unavoidable part of everyday life” used “in order to reinstate the traditional patriarchal rule”. In intelligence they boiled down to three stereotypes: the lustful, wanton dancer; the self-sacrificing, and the noble spirited woman patriot.5 This article focuses on the role of women bottom of the “pecking order”, the agents of the East German State Security. It offers a statistic overview of their functions as well as an insight into how women agents within foreign intelligence fitted into the stereotypes. In Germany, gender issues have not played a major role in the massive research of the former Ministry of State Security (MfS). Since the early 1990’s, “the Stasi”, it’s structures, and representatives have dominated both the public and academic discourse about the GDR. The State invested billions of marks and euros into a special Federal Commissioners Offices (BStU) for the safekeeping and interpretation of the files of the former MfS. For almost a generation, due to direct access to the files and a vast research budget, this organization which today is integrated into the German Federal 1 Andrea Petö: (2020) A gender history of Hungarian intelligence services during the Cold War, Journal of Intelligence History, 19:2, pp.197-212, here p. 207. 2 Mathias Finster, Philipp Reimann Anja Zschirpe: (2017): Im Dienst der Staatssicherheit. Eine soziologische Studie über die hauptamtlichen Mitarbeiter des DDR-Geheimdienstes. Frankfurt a.M.: Campusverlag. p. 119. 3 Jens Gieseke (2000): Die Hauptamtliche Mitarbeiter der Staatssicherheit. Personalstruktur und Lebenswelt 1950- 1989/90. Berlin: Chr. Links Verlag. p. 335, 394-395, 432. 4 A general analysis of women in the GDR can be found here: Anne Kaminsky (2016): Frauen in der DDR. Berlin: Links Verlag. 5 Petö (2020), p 1. 62 Archives set the agenda for GDR research. Among the BStU research prioritizing gender did not rank first. Nonetheless, a handful of researchers were able to establish the field as a niche within MfS- studies which has predominantly been published in German. One of the few BStU researchers who dealt with women in the MfS is Angela Schmole who since the 1990’s has published on the subject.6 Important independent research contributions were the work of the journalist Annette Maennel and the Thuringian historian Renate Ellmenreich. Both took up the subject on women in East German state security and put a particular emphasis on the domestic apparatus of the MfS.7 Individual stories have been presented by for instance the journalist Gerald Praschl.8 Women in foreign intelligence have primarily been described in the popular scientific publication by the journalist Wilhelm Dietl and Marianne Quorin.9 From a scholarly perspective, the subject has been dealt with by the historian Katja Augustin.10 Both the journalist and scholars have displayed prominent interest to seduction, thus to some extent abiding to the controlling image of women roles in intelligence. Who and how many? Due to the mass of documents released upon the dissolution of the GDR quantitative methodology has played a prominent role in understanding the State Security structures, which left 111 running kilometers of archive, documenting the work of its 91.015 employees and 189.00 agents.11 The administrative mass of the former ministry’s 209 municipal offices, 15 district offices, and 40 central departments and main departments in Berlin made this approach rational. However, because of the large structure, it is not easy to give an unambiguous impression of the share and character of women participation in the covert operation of the MfS. 6Angela Schmole (1996): Frauen und MfS, in: Deutschland Archiv 29, 4, pp. 512–525; Angela Schmole (2001): Frauen im Ministerium für Staatssicherheit, in: Horch und Guck 10, 34, pp. 15–19: Angela Schmole (2005): Die Spitzenfrauen des MfS. Bei der Staatssicherheit diente das weibliche Personal nur selten in gehobenen Stellungen. in: Zeitschrift des Forschungsverbundes SED-Staat 18, pp. 107–114. 7 Annette Maennel (1995): Frauen zwischen Alltag und Konspiration. Zur IM-Problematik, in: Horch und Guck 4,14; Renate Ellmenreich (1994): Frauenbild im Ministerium für Staatssicherheit der DDR – Mein Einblick, in: Unabhängiger Frauenverband (ed.): Weibblick 16, pp. 14–16, hier 14; Renate Ellmenreich (1999): Frauen bei der Stasi. Am Beispiel der MfS-Bezirksverwaltung Gera. Erfurt: "Der Landesbeauftragte des Freistaates Thüringen für die Unterlagen des Staatssicherheitsdienstes der ehemaligen DDR informiert. 8 Gerald Praschl (1999): Zwei Frauen und das MfS. Gleichberechtigung bei Mielke. Auch Frauen durften mitmachen, in: Horch und Guck 8, 26, pp. 46–67. 9 Marianne Quorin (1999): Agentinnen aus Liebe. Warum Frauen für den Osten spionierten. Frankfurt (Main): Edition Berolina; Wilhelm Dietl (2006): Spy ladies. Frauen im Geheimdienst. Berlin: Ullstein. 10 Katja Augustin (2002): Verführerinnen und Verführte. Frauen und die Staatssicherheit In: Haus der Geschichte der Bundesrepublik Deutschland (Ed.): Duell im Dunkel. Spionage im geteilten Deutschland. Cologne: Böhlau Verlag. pp. 99–109 11 Numbers are from 1989. 63 Renate Ellmenreich examined the files of the district office of the MfS in the Gera region in Eastern Thuringia and proposed a women agent share of 16,7 percent in the municipal offices.12 Numbers from other municipal offices show that this was likely even to be in the high end of the spectrum. Other municipal offices in today’s Thuringia like Bad Salzungen (1988) and Weimar (1984) had a women agent share of selectively 12% and 13,5%; in Wenigerode (1984) and Stendal (1989) in Saxony-Anhalt it were 12,2% and 15,8%, whereas in Sternberg (1974) and Bützow (1978) in Mecklenburg-Western Pomerania it were only 4,9% and 8,1%.13 On the middle administrative level of the district (Bezirke), the number proved to be slightly higher. In the district administration Gera, the MfS recruited 22,3 percent women (1989). This was a bit higher than some of the others of the MfS regional branches. In the Karl-Marx-Stadt region in Saxony, it was 14 percent (1989), in Rostock in Mecklenburg-Western Pomerania 10 percent (1989), in the district of Magdeburg in Saxony-Anhalt 12 percent, and in Frankfurt/ Oder 14,9 percent.14 On a national level, the estimates slightly vary. Annette Maennel estimated the share to be between ten and 15 percent, and Angela Schmole almost agreed with ten and 16 percent.15 In his analysis of denunciation, the Polish researcher Karol Sauerland assessed women´s share only at ten percent.16 The overall picture of the women participation within the GDR showed that the agent business was predominantly male. Even on this level in the pecking order, gender equality was far from being achieved in the socialist German state. This of course raises the question whether the low women´s share of agents was isolated to the GDR. Though, exact statistics are not available for any other part of history, the state of art suggests that other German agencies had been equally reluctant to involve women in the covert sphere of men.17 East German estimates of their Western opponent the 12 Ellmenreich (1994), p. 14. 13 Bundesarchiv (BA): MfS, BV Schwerin, KD Bützow Nr. 10164, Bl. 12; BKG Nr. 646b, p. 53, 55, 58, 76, 92; MfS, BV Magdeburg, AKG Nr. 199, p. 331; MfS, BV Erfurt, KD Weimar Nr. 14, Bl. 4; MfS, BV Magdeburg, KD Stendal Nr. 16, p. 5; MfS, BV Suhl, BdL Nr.