Port Authority of NY & NJ FINAL COPY Aviation Roundtable June 27, 2019 Page 1 PORT AUTHORITY OF NEW YORK & NEW JERSEY -------------------------------------------------- NEW YORK COMMUNITY AVIATION ROUNDTABLE June 27, 2019 Kew Gardens, New York BEFORE Barbara E. Brown and Warren Schreiber Co-Chairs JANE ROSE REPORTING Nicole Ellis, Court Reporting FINAL COPY JANE ROSE REPORTING 1-800-825-3341 JANE ROSE REPORTING National Court-Reporting Coverage 1-800-825-3341 [email protected] Port Authority of NY & NJ FINAL COPY Aviation Roundtable June 27, 2019 Page 2 A P P E A R A N C E S: FOR NYCAR JFK INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT COMMITTEE: Justin Connor for Congressman Tom Suozzi Joseph Edwards for Congressman Gregory Meeks Frieda Menos for Congressman Hakeem Jeffries Dennis Graham and Gloria Boyce-Charles for Queens Borough President Melinda Katz Leo Meyers for Senator Todd Kaminsky Rebecca Sheehan for Senator Anna Kaplan Barbara E. Brown, Co-Chair, for Assemblywoman Michele Titus Joshua Joseph for Assemblywoman Michaelle Solages Michael Matteo for Assemblywoman Stacey Pheffer-Amato Conner Dunleavy for Assemblyman Edward Ra Jared Fischedick for Nassau County Executive Laura Curran Fruize Ali, Community Board 9 Michelle Keller, Community Board 12 Clive Williams, Community Board 13 Dawn Roberts-Semple, Citizen Member Larry Hoppenhauer, Citizen Member (Appearances continue on following page.) JANE ROSE REPORTING National Court-Reporting Coverage 1-800-825-3341 [email protected] Port Authority of NY & NJ FINAL COPY Aviation Roundtable June 27, 2019 Page 3 A P P E A R A N C E S: (Cont'd.) For NYCAR LaGuardia Airport Committee: Christopher Boccia for Congressman Tom Suozzi Maria Becce for Congresswoman Grace Meng Michelle Hernandez for Congresswoman Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez Marie Figueroa for Congressman Hakeem Jeffries Lei Zhao and Allan Swisher for Queens Borough President Melinda Katz Akshor Patel for Senator John Liu Pema G. for Senator Jessica Ramos Assemblyman Edward Braunstein Sean Simmers for Assemblyman Brian Barnwell Tony Cao for Assemblyman Ron Kim Scott Sieber for Councilman Peter Koo Terence Cullen for Councilman Costa Constantinides Denise Keehan-Smith, Queens Community Board 2 Warren Schreiber, Co-Chair, Queens Community Board 7 Seymour Schwartz, Queens Community Board 8 Joan Garippa, Queens Community Board 11 Frank Taylor, Citizen Member (Appearances continue on following page.) JANE ROSE REPORTING National Court-Reporting Coverage 1-800-825-3341 [email protected] Port Authority of NY & NJ FINAL COPY Aviation Roundtable June 27, 2019 Page 4 A P P E A R A N C E S: (Cont'd.) FOR JFK/LAGUARDIA AIRPORT COMMITTEES: Bill Huisman, Facilitator, Aviation Development Council Kevin Costello, JetBlue FOR PORT AUTHORITY OF NEW YORK & NEW JERSEY: Adeel Yousuf XiaoBo Liu Nick Dmytryszyn Stacey Gilbert ALSO PRESENT: Steven Jones, FAA Veda L. Simmons, FAA Members of the Public JANE ROSE REPORTING National Court-Reporting Coverage 1-800-825-3341 [email protected] Port Authority of NY & NJ FINAL COPY Aviation Roundtable June 27, 2019 Page 5 A G E N D A ITEM PAGE 1. Welcome & Introductions................6 2. Minutes................................13 3. Understanding and Using the Monthly Noise Reports - PANYNJ.........15 4. PANYNJ Update on the Part 150 Study - PANYNJ................52 5. FAA Reauthorization Act of 2018 - Prioritizing our Requests for FAA Updates............................82 6. Airport Committee Sharing A. JFK Airport Committee..............90 B. LGA Airport Committee..............101 7. Public Comment.........................109 8. Adjournment............................115 JANE ROSE REPORTING National Court-Reporting Coverage 1-800-825-3341 [email protected] Port Authority of NY & NJ FINAL COPY Aviation Roundtable June 27, 2019 Page 6 1 * * * 7:18 PM * * * 2 CO-CHAIR WARREN: Good evening, 3 everyone. I want to thank everybody for 4 being here. We should have some more 5 people showing up, I know traffic is 6 really bad. It seems like traffic has 7 been bad forever, forever. This has been 8 the worst year for traffic. 9 But my name is Warren Schreiber, 10 I'm the co-chair of the New York Community 11 Aviation Roundtable, along with Barbara 12 Brown, and I represent Community Board 7. 13 And what I'd like to do, the first 14 thing, is just go around the room and have 15 everybody introduce themselves. 16 MR. HUISMAN: Good evening, 17 everybody. I'm Bill Huisman, I'm Aviation 18 Development counsel and I'm the 19 facilitator for NYCAR. 20 MR. MATTEO: Michael Matteo, I 21 work for Stacey Pheffer-Amato. 22 CO-CHAIR WARREN: If everybody can 23 speak up. I'm sorry about the mic, but we 24 don't have a wireless mic and it's a short 25 cord. JANE ROSE REPORTING National Court-Reporting Coverage 1-800-825-3341 [email protected] Port Authority of NY & NJ FINAL COPY Aviation Roundtable June 27, 2019 Page 7 1 MS. SMITH: Denise Smith, chair of 2 Community Board 2. 3 MR. ALI: Mr. Ali, chair of the 4 Transportation Committee and CB9. 5 MS. SHEEHAN: Rebecca Sheehan, 6 chief of staff and counsel for Senator 7 Anna Kaplan. 8 MR. DUNLEAVY: Conner Dunleavy, 9 Assemblyman Edward Ra's office. 10 MR. ZHAO: Lei Zhao, I'm 11 representing Queens Borough President 12 Melinda Katz. I'm also the recording 13 secretary for the LaGuardia Committee. 14 MS. MENOS: Frieda Menos for 15 Congressman Hakeem Jeffries. 16 MR. MEYERS: I'm Leo Meyers with 17 Senator Todd Kaminsky's office. 18 MS. BOYCE-CHARLES: Gloria 19 Boyce-Charles for Borough President Katz. 20 MR. LIU: John Liu, I work for 21 Assemblyman Ed Braunstein. 22 MR. JONES: Steven Jones, FAA. 23 MS. SIMMONS: Veda Simmons, FAA. 24 MS. JEOFF: I'm Noemi Jeoff and 25 I'm an intern for Assemblyman Brian JANE ROSE REPORTING National Court-Reporting Coverage 1-800-825-3341 [email protected] Port Authority of NY & NJ FINAL COPY Aviation Roundtable June 27, 2019 Page 8 1 Barnwell. 2 MR. SELLINGER: Jesse Sellinger, 3 Assemblyman Brian Barnwell. 4 MR. ALAM: Muhoma Alam, 5 Assemblyman Brian Barnwell. 6 ASSEMBLYMAN BRAUNSTEIN: 7 Assemblyman Edward Braunstein. 8 MS. HERNANDEZ: Michelle Hernandez 9 from Congresswoman Ocasio-Cortez's office. 10 MR. PATEL: Akshor Patel for John 11 Liu's office. 12 MR. CULLEN: Terence Cullen with 13 Councilman Costa Constantinides' office. 14 MS. BECCE: Maria Becce, first 15 vice chair of the LaGuardia Committee and 16 I represent Congresswoman Grace Meng. 17 MR. SCHWARTZ: Seymour Schwartz 18 representing Community Board 8. 19 MR. EDWARDS: Joseph Edwards 20 representing Congressman Meeks. 21 MR. BOCCIA: Chris Boccia 22 representing Congressman Suozzi's office. 23 MR. GRAHAM: Dennis Graham, 24 Melinda Katz JFK Airport Committee. 25 MR. DMYTRYSZYN: Nick Dmytryszyn, JANE ROSE REPORTING National Court-Reporting Coverage 1-800-825-3341 [email protected] Port Authority of NY & NJ FINAL COPY Aviation Roundtable June 27, 2019 Page 9 1 Port Authority. 2 MS. PEMA: I'm Pema from the 3 office of Senator Ramos. 4 CO-CHAIR WARREN: Are you 5 representing the senator? 6 MS. PEMA: No, I'm here to attend. 7 MR. FISCHEDICK: Jared Fischedick 8 representing County Executive Laura 9 Curran. 10 MR. HOPPENHAUER: Larry 11 Hoppenhauer, citizen member of this group. 12 MR. COSTELLO: Kevin Costello, 13 JetBlue Airways. 14 MS. BROWN: Beverly Brown. 15 Springfield Rosedale. 16 MS. GARIPPA: Joan Garippa, 17 Community Board 11. 18 MR. CONNOR: Justin Connor from 19 Congressman Tom Suozzi's office. 20 CO-CHAIR WARREN: So before we 21 start here, I know that State Senator John 22 Liu has asked to say a few words and I 23 wasn't going to tell him no because he's 24 also my state senator, so John. 25 SENATOR LIU: Good evening. Thank JANE ROSE REPORTING National Court-Reporting Coverage 1-800-825-3341 [email protected] Port Authority of NY & NJ FINAL COPY Aviation Roundtable June 27, 2019 Page 10 1 you, Mr. Chair. 2 I just wanted to say hello to 3 everybody. And I didn't have a chance to 4 attend many of these meetings. The last 5 time I attended this was last December, 6 which I think we had the meeting over at 7 Bayside, but this is a very important 8 roundtable of representatives of elected 9 officials, as well as industry groups, 10 civic associations. 11 And we all care very much about 12 what's happening in our skies and how that 13 translates into what's happening in our 14 ears. And so we want to make sure that we 15 allow the skies to be friendly to 16 everybody, including residents in our 17 communities, the people that we all 18 represent. 19 So I'm here to lend you support. 20 Akshor Patel, my deputy chief of staff, is 21 going to be here for the whole meeting I 22 have a lot of things to get to tonight. 23 So I want to wish you a great 24 meeting, and keep up the great work that 25 you're doing. Chairperson Warren JANE ROSE REPORTING National Court-Reporting Coverage 1-800-825-3341 [email protected] Port Authority of NY & NJ FINAL COPY Aviation Roundtable June 27, 2019 Page 11 1 Schreiber has been heading this for some 2 time now and we put it all in your good 3 hands, Warren. 4 CO-CHAIR WARREN: And Barbara. 5 CO-CHAIR BROWN: I'm Barbara 6 Brown, I'm co-chair of NYCAR, chairperson 7 of JFK Airport Committee, and I represent 8 Assemblywoman Titus. 9 CO-CHAIR WARREN: Frank, would you 10 like to introduce yourself. 11 MR. TAYLOR: Frank Taylor. I 12 guess I'm the civilian -- whatever you 13 call it -- citizen member.