UNITED NATIONS S Security Council Distr. GENERAL S/AC.26/2002/7 13 March 2002 Original: ENGLISH UNITED NATIONS COMPENSATION COMMISSION GOVERNING COUNCIL REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS MADE BY THE PANEL OF COMMISSIONERS CONCERNING THE THIRD INSTALMENT OF “F2” CLAIMS S/AC.26/2002/7 Page 2 CONTENTS Paragraphs Page Introduction .........................................................................................................1 - 2 7 I. PROCEDURAL HISTORY ..............................................................................3 - 12 11 II. COMMON CONSIDERATIONS....................................................................13 - 38 12 A. Military operations, military costs and the threat of military action..........17 - 20 13 B. Payment or relief to others ....................................................................... 21 14 C. Salary and labour-related benefits..........................................................22 - 28 14 D. Verification and valuation........................................................................ 29 15 E. Other issues..........................................................................................30 - 38 15 III. THE CLAIMS ............................................................................................. 39 - 669 17 A. Saudi Ports Authority ...........................................................................39 - 93 17 1. Business transaction or course of dealing (SAR 270,397,424) .........41 - 49 17 2. Real property (SAR 9,753,500) .....................................................50 - 56 19 3. Other tangible property (SAR 292,660) .........................................57 - 59 20 4. Payment or relief to others (SAR 2,088,081) ..................................60 - 64 20 5. Evacuation costs (SAR 7,516,781) ................................................65 - 72 21 6. Public service expenditures (SAR 13,914,036) ...............................73 - 92 22 7. Recommendation for Saudi Ports Authority...................................... 93 25 B. Ministry of Defence and Aviation/General Department of Military Works ................................................................................................ 94 - 113 27 1. Contract (SAR 22,712,149) ......................................................... 95 - 112 27 2. Recommendation for General Department of Military Works............ 113 30 C. Saline Water Conversion Corporation .................................................. 114 - 178 31 1. Real property (SAR 3,732,502) ................................................... 115 - 121 31 2. Other tangible property (SAR 1,789,179) .................................... 122 - 130 32 3. Income-producing property (SAR 18,000,929) ............................. 131 - 142 33 4. Evacuation costs (SAR 222,944) ................................................. 143 - 148 35 5. Public service expenditures (SAR 13,590,673) ............................. 149 - 175 35 6. Claim preparation costs (SAR 104,399) ....................................... 176 - 177 40 7. Recommendation for Saline Water Conversion Corporation ............. 178 40 D. Ministry of Defence and Aviation/Royal Saudi Air Force ..................... 179 - 193 41 1. Payment or relief to others (SAR 34,550,000) .............................. 180 - 182 41 2. Public service expenditures (SAR 14,312,881,900) ...................... 183 - 192 41 3. Recommendation for Royal Saudi Air Force.................................... 193 43 E. Ministry of Defence and Aviation/General Department of Medical Services............................................................................................. 194 - 208 44 S/AC.26/2002/7 Page 3 Paragraphs Page 1. Payment or relief to others (SAR 19,890,000) .............................. 195 - 198 44 2. Public service expenditures (SAR 2,237,549,063) ........................ 199 - 207 44 3. Recommendation for Ministry of Defence and Aviation/ General Department of Medical Services......................................... 208 46 F. Ministry of Defence and Aviation/Joint Forces Affairs.......................... 209 - 228 47 1. Payment or relief to others (SAR 2,455,213,767) ........................ 210 - 224 47 2. Public service expenditures (SAR 13,229,150,921) ...................... 225 - 227 50 3. Recommendation for Ministry of Defence and Aviation/ Joint Forces Affairs........................................................................ 228 50 G. Ministry of Agriculture and Water/Agricultural Affairs ........................ 229 - 234 51 1. Other tangible property (SAR 61,710) ......................................... 230 - 233 51 2. Recommendation for Ministry of Agriculture and Water/ Agricultural Affairs........................................................................ 234 51 H. Ministry of Agriculture and Water/Department of Water ...................... 235 - 261 53 1. Contract (SAR 63,768,539) ........................................................ 237 - 248 53 2. Payment or relief to others (SAR 38,330,720) .............................. 249 - 254 55 3. Public service expenditures (SAR 7,120,566) ............................... 255 - 260 56 4. Recommendation for Ministry of Agriculture and Water/ Department of Water...................................................................... 261 57 I. Royal Commission for Jubail and Yanbu............................................... 262 - 343 58 1. Payment or relief to others (SAR 33,122,585) .............................. 265 - 274 58 2. Public service expenditures (SAR 29,123,052) ............................. 275 - 342 60 3. Recommendation for Royal Commission for Jubail and Yanbu ......... 343 70 J. Ministry of Defence and Aviation/International Airports Project ............ 344 - 424 71 1. Contract (SAR 51,038,280) ........................................................ 347 - 355 71 2. Business transaction or course of dealing (SAR 307,286,450) ....... 356 - 380 72 3. Real property (SAR 74,379,727) ................................................. 381 - 387 76 4. Other tangible property (SAR 3,284,300) .................................... 388 - 390 77 5. Evacuation costs (SAR 12,589,164) ............................................ 391 - 407 78 6. Public service expenditures (SAR 36,297,875) ............................. 408 - 423 80 7. Recommendation for Ministry of Defence and Aviation/ International Airports Project ............................................................. 424 82 K. Ministry of Interior/Eastern Province Emirate ...................................... 425 - 488 83 1. Real property (SAR 504,710) ...................................................... 428 - 434 83 2. Other tangible property (SAR 95,000) ......................................... 435 - 439 84 3. Payment or relief to others (SAR 112,871,016) ............................ 440 - 456 85 4. Evacuation costs (SAR 3,480,460) .............................................. 457 - 461 87 S/AC.26/2002/7 Page 4 Paragraphs Page 5. Public service expenditures (SAR 50,709,087) ............................. 462 - 487 88 6. Recommendation for Ministry of Interior/Eastern Province Emirate ......................................................................................... 488 91 L. Ministry of Interior/General Passport Department................................. 489 - 516 93 1. Real property (SAR 650,000) ...................................................... 492 - 497 93 2. Other tangible property (403,650) ............................................... 498 - 501 94 3. Public service expenditures (SAR 77,779,713) ............................. 502 - 515 94 4. Recommendation for Ministry of Interior/General Passport Department.................................................................................... 516 96 M. Ministry of Interior/General Directorate of Frontier Forces................... 517 - 563 98 1. Real property (SAR 5,553,950) ................................................... 520 - 528 98 2. Public service expenditures (SAR 318,242,429) ........................... 529 - 562 99 3. Recommendation for Ministry of Interior/General Directorate of Frontier Forces .......................................................................... 563 104 N. Ministry of Interior/Public Security and General Department for Projects (UNCC claim No. 5000250) ................................................... 564 - 608 105 1. Real property (SAR 15,849,086) ................................................. 566 - 580 105 2. Other tangible property (SAR 1,829,979) .................................... 581 - 585 107 3. Income-producing property (SAR 186,705) ................................. 586 - 592 108 4. Public service expenditures (SAR 538,485,532) ........................... 593 - 607 109 5. Recommendation for Ministry of Interior/ Public Security and General Department for Projects........................ 608 111 O. Ministry of Interior/General Directorate of Investigations ..................... 609 - 617 113 1. Public service expenditures (SAR 228,637,892) ........................... 611 - 616 113 2. Recommendation for Ministry of Interior/General Directorate of Investigations ............................................................................ 617 114 P. Ministry of Interior/Department of Civil Affairs ................................... 618 - 625 115 1. Real property (SAR 38,826,969) ................................................. 619 - 624 115 2. Recommendation for Ministry of Interior/Department of Civil Affairs..........................................................................................