View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by MURAL - Maynooth University Research Archive Library Wert, Rechtheit and Gut. Adolf Reinach’s Contribution to Early Phenomenological Ethics by James H. Smith, M.Litt. Submitted in fulfilment of the requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy Presented to: The Department of Philosophy National University of Ireland, Maynooth 28th February, 2013 Head of Department of Philosophy: Dr Michael Dunne Supervisors: Dr Mette Lebech & Dr Cyril McDonnell Dedicated to the memory of Dr Thomas A. F. Kelly, who taught me what philosophy is and why it is so very important. i C O N T E N T S Preface vii Acknowledgements viii Abbreviations ix INTRODUCTION 1 Section One: Reinach’s Life and Legacy 3 Section Two: Ethics in Reinach’s Philosophy 7 Section Three: The Significance of the Concept of ‘Contribution’ 10 Section Four: Methodology 12 Section Five: Structure 13 CHAPTER I Primary Sources and a Review of 16 Literature on Reinach’s Philosophy Section One: Timeline of Reinach’s Known Works 17 1.1.1 1904–1905 17 1.1.2 1906–1909 18 1.1.3 1910–1911 19 1.1.4 1912–1913 21 1.1.5 1914–1917 24 Section Two: Selected Sources for Reinach’s Work on Ethics 25 1.2.1 ‘Die Grundbegriffe der Ethik’ 25 1.2.2 ‘Die Überlegung: ihre ethische und rechtliche Bedeutung 29 1.2.3 ‘Grundzüge der Ethik’ 35 1.2.4 ‘Die apriorischen Grundlagen des bürgerlichen Rechtes’ 39 Section Three: Editions, Biographical Sources and Translations 45 1.3.1 Compiled Editions of Reinach’s Work 46 1.3.2 Biographical Sources 47 1.3.3 English-Language Translations 48 Section Four: Secondary Literature 49 1.4.1 Critical Studies 49 1.4.2 Works Dealing with Reinach’s Ethics 53 1.4.2.1 The Phenomenology of Adolf Reinach 54 1.4.2.2 ‘Verpflichtung und Verbindlichkeit. Ethische 55 Aspekte in der Rechtsphilosophie Adolf Reinachs’ 1.4.2.3 ‘Adolf Reinach: Metaethics and the Philosophy of 57 Law’ Section Five: Concluding Remarks 59 ii CHAPTER II The Philosophical Background to Reinach’s Ethics 60 Section One: What is Early Phenomenology? 61 2.1.1 Origins of Early Phenomenology 63 2.1.2 The Transcendental Turn and Later Phenomenology 68 2.1.3 Characteristics of Early Phenomenology 71 Section Two: Early Influences 72 2.2.1 Aristotle 73 2.2.1.1 Aristotelianism and Phenomenology 73 2.2.1.2 Aristotelian Ethics 74 2.2.1.3 Aristotle and Reinach 77 2.2.2 Kantian Philosophy 78 2.2.2.1 Kantian Philosophy and Phenomenology 79 2.2.2.2 Kant’s Ethics 81 2.2.2.3 Kant and Reinach 83 2.2.3 Franz Brentano 85 2.2.3.1 Brentano and Phenomenology 86 2.2.3.2 Brentano’s Ethics 88 2.2.3.3 Brentano and Reinach 92 2.2.4 Theodor Lipps 92 2.2.4.1 Lipps and Phenomenology 93 2.2.4.2 Lipps’s Ethics 93 2.2.4.3 Lipps and Reinach 96 Section Three: The Phenomenological Movement 97 2.3.1 Early Phenomenological Ethics 98 2.3.2 The Munich Circle 99 2.3.2.1 Johannes Daubert 100 2.3.2.2 Alexander Pfänder 101 2.3.3 Edmund Husserl 102 2.3.3.1 Husserl’s Ethics 103 2.3.3.2 Husserl and Reinach 105 2.3.4 Max Scheler 106 2.2.4.1 Scheler’s Ethics: Christian Values and Ethical 108 Personalism 2.2.4.2 Scheler and Ressentiment 109 2.2.4.3 The Axioms of Scheler’s Ethics 110 2.2.4.4 Scheler’s Value Theory 111 2.2.4.5 Scheler’s Theory of the Person 114 2.2.4.6 Scheler on Good and Evil 115 2.2.4.7 Religion and Scheler’s Ethics 116 2.2.4.8 Scheler and Reinach 117 iii 2.3.5 Dietrich von Hildebrand 118 2.3.5.1 Von Hildebrand’s Ethics 119 2.3.5.2 Von Hildebrand and Reinach 123 Section Four: Concluding Remarks 124 CHAPTER III Critical Discussion of Reinach’s Works on Ethics 125 Section One: The Foundations of Reinach’s Ethics 127 3.1.1 The Meaning of Ethics 128 3.1.2 The Objective Attitude 130 3.1.3 Object and Objectivity 131 Section Two: The Structure of Reinach’s Ethics: The Three Spheres 135 3.2.1 The Sphere of Moral Values 138 3.2.1.1 The Meaning of Value 139 3.2.1.2 The Experiencing of Values 140 3.2.1.3 Value and Demand 141 3.2.1.4 Moral Values and their Bearers 143 3.2.1.5 The Role of Values in Ethics 144 3.2.1.6 Critique 147 3.2.2 The Sphere of Moral Rightness 150 3.2.2.1 The Meaning of Moral Rightness and the Formal 153 Moral Law 3.2.2.2 The Role of the Sphere of Rightness in Ethics 156 3.2.2.3 Moral Obligation and Duty 158 3.2.2.4 Critique: The Inaccessibility of the Formal 161 Moral Law 3.2.2.5 Burkhardt’s Criticism 166 3.2.3 The Sphere of Goods 170 3.2.3.1 The Role of the Sphere of Goods in Ethics 173 3.2.3.2 The Potential of the Sphere of Goods 174 Section Three: The Mechanics of Reinach’s Ethics: 178 Motivation, Reflection and Freedom 3.3.1 Autonomy and the Personal Structure 179 3.3.2 Action versus Project 181 3.3.3 Consequences and Value-Modification 182 3.3.4 Moral Value and Personal Interest 184 3.3.5 The Structure of Willing 186 3.3.6 The Ethical Significance of Reflection 188 Section Four: Analysing Reinach’s Work on Ethics 194 3.4.1 The Question of Objectivity 196 3.4.2 The Question of Fallibility 198 Section Five: Concluding Remarks 200 iv CHAPTER IV Assessing Reinach’s Contribution to Early 201 Phenomenological Ethics Section One: Preparing for the Assessment 202 4.1.1 The Meaning of a Contribution 202 4.1.2 Ethics and Meta-Ethics 203 4.1.3 Reinach’s Ethics as a Phenomenological Ethics 206 Section Two: The Originality of Reinach’s Work 207 4.2.1 Reinach and Scheler: Comparative Discussion 209 4.2.2 Values and Their Role in Ethics 213 4.2.3 The Sphere of Rightness and the Formal Moral Law 214 4.2.4 The Sphere of Goods 216 4.2.5 Meta-Ethics 217 4.2.6 The Theory of Social Acts 220 4.2.7 The Concerns of Ethics and Those of the Philosophy of Law 222 Section Three: The Influence of Reinach’s Ethics 225 4.3.1 Dietrich von Hildebrand 226 4.3.2 Edith Stein 229 4.3.2.1 Stein and Ethics 230 4.3.2.2 Stein’s Value Theory 231 4.3.2.3 Community Ethics 234 4.3.2.4 The State and Law 235 4.3.2.5 Stein and Reinach 236 4.3.2.6 The Influence of Reinach’s Ethics on Stein’s 237 Philosophy 4.3.3 The Wider Field of Phenomenological Ethics 239 Section Four: Towards Assessing Reinach’s Contribution to Ethics in General 242 4.4.1 Criteria for Assessment of an Ethics 243 4.4.2 Questions Facing a Reinachian Ethics 247 4.4.2.1 Does Reinach plausibly answer the questions of 247 ethics? 4.4.2.2 Does a Reinachian ethics provide a basis for 248 making normative statements? 4.4.2.3 Does a Reinachian ethics provide a means of 249 resolving moral dilemmas? 4.4.2.4 Is a Reinachian ethics capable of accounting for 250 ethical disputes? 4.4.2.5 What do Reinach’s comments on ethics have to 252 offer the wider field? Section Five: Concluding Remarks 253 Conclusion 254 Bibliography 259 v A P P E N D I C E S Appendix (I) Preface to the Translations 270 Glossary of Terms 271 Appendix (II) ‘Grundbegriffe der Ethik’/ ‘The Basic Concepts of Ethics’ 276 Appendix (III) ‘Die Überlegung: ihre ethische und rechtliche Bedeutung’/ 284 ‘Reflection: Its Ethical and Legal Significance’ Appendix (IV) ‘Grundzüge der Ethik’/ ‘Basic Features of Ethics’ 375 vi PREFACE This thesis contains references from sources in both English and German. Where titles or quotations from German texts are given in English, the translation is my own unless otherwise indicated. I have also quoted from existing translations of Reinach’s works where it is possible and appropriate to do so. The thesis also contains quotations of passages from the works translated in the appendices. These are referenced to the relevant page and paragraph of the source text in volume I of Reinach’s Sämtliche Werke (S.W.). These page numbers are reproduced in line with the text of the translations in the appendix indicated. Some passages quoted from the Sämtliche Werke contain notes inserted by the editors. Likewise, some quotations from existing translations contain notes inserted by the translator. For clarity, these notes have been left in the original square brackets, i.e. [], while my own editorial notes are indicated with braces, i.e. {}. Italic text in quotations from appendices (II) and (IV) does not indicate emphasis, but instead distinguishes between the transcripts used to reconstruct the texts in Sämtliche Werke. The precise meanings of these typefaces and other formatting details in the translations can be found in appendix (I). vii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS I would like to thank, first of all, my co-supervisors, Dr Mette Lebech and Dr Cyril McDonnell.