STEP Arbeidsnotat ISSN 1501-0066 $UQH,VDNVHQ A-02 1LOV+HQULN6ROXP • ,QQRYDVMRQVVWUDWHJLHUIRU $XVW$JGHU,QQVSLOOWLO 1998 6WUDWHJLVN1 ULQJVSODQ $UQH,VDNVHQ 1LOV+HQULN6ROXP 67(3 6WRUJDWHQ 12VOR 1RUZD\ 2VORDXJXVW 6WRUJDWHQ12VOR1RUZD\ 7HOHSKRQH )D[ :HEKWWSZZZVROQRVWHS 67(3 SXEOLVHUHU WR XOLNH VHULHU DY VNULIWHU 5DSSRUWHURJ$UEHLGVQRWDWHU 67(3$UEHLGVQRWDWHU , GHQQH VHULHQ SUHVHQWHUHU YL YLNWLJH IRUVNQLQJVUHVXOWDWHU VRP YL ¡QVNHU n JM¡UH WLOJMHQJHOLJH IRU DQGUH PHQ VRP LNNH KDU HQ IRUP VRP JM¡U GHP HJQHW WLO SXEOLVHULQJ L 5DSSRUWVHULHQ $UEHLGVQRWDWHQH NDQ Y UH VHOYVWHQGLJH DUEHLGHU IRUDUEHLGHU WLO VW¡UUH SURVMHNWHUHOOHUVSHVLHOOHDQDO\VHUXWDUEHLGHWIRU RSSGUDJVJLYHUH 'HLQQHKROGHU GDWD RJ DQDO\VHU VRP EHO\VHU YLNWLJH SUREOHPVWLOOLQJHU UHODWHUW WLO LQQRYDVMRQ WHNQRORJLVN ¡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¡ULQJDYKHOHHOOHUGHOHUDYGHQQHSXEOLNDVMRQHQVNDO UHWWHVWLO $SSOLFDWLRQVIRUSHUPLVVLRQWRWUDQVODWHFRS\RULQRWKHUZD\V UHSURGXFHDOORUSDUWVRIWKLVSXEOLFDWLRQVKRXOGEHPDGHWR 67(36WRUJDWHQ12VOR )RURUG 'HWWHQRWDWHWRPIDWWHUHQVDPOLQJDYILUHQRWDWHUXWDUEHLGHWIRU1 ULQJVHWDWHQ L$XVW$JGHUI\ONHVNRPPXQHLIRUELQGHOVHPHGLQQVSLOOWLODUEHLGHWPHGQ\VWUD WHJLVNQ ULQJVSODQIRUI\ONHW,QQVSLOOHWVNXOOHWDXWJDQJVSXQNWLHWLQQRYD VMRQVSHUVSHNWLYVLGHQ1 ULQJVHWDWHQ¡QVNHWnInXWUHGHWQ UPHUHRPHWVOLNW SHUVSHNWLYNXQQHY UHIUXNWEDUWIRUQ ULQJVSROLWLNNHQRJWLOWDNVDUEHLGHWLI\O NHWVDPWKYDHWVOLNSHUVSHNWLYEHW\UQnUGHWJMHOGHUWLOQ UPLQJVPnWHUWLOUH JLRQDOQ ULQJVSROLWLNNVnYHOVRPPHUNRQNUHWHVWUDWHJLHURJYLUNHPLGOHU 1RWDWHQHHUXWDUEHLGHWLSHULRGHQGHVHPEHUWLODXJXVW1RWDWHQHHU XQGHUYHLVGLVNXWHUWLXOLNHVDPPHQKHQJHUPHG1 ULQJVHWDWHQRJYLKDUInWW Q\WWLJHNRPPHQWDUHUWLOYLGHUHEHDUEHLGLQJDYQRWDWHQHLGLVVHP¡WHQH-¡UQ 5DQJQHVYHG1 ULQJVVHQWHUHWL9HVWIROGRJ-DPHV.DUOVHQYHG$JGHUIRUVNQLQJ KDURJVnJLWWQ\WWLJHLQQVSLOOWLOHQNHOWHDYQRWDWHQH 'HWI¡UVWHQRWDWHWRP·,QQRYDWLYDNWLYLWHWRJUHJLRQDOHLQQRYDVMRQVVWUDWHJLHU² 3ULQVLSLHOOHEHWUDNWQLQJHU·HUHWUHQW·WHRULQRWDW·)RUPnOHWPHGGHWWHQRWDWHWHU nEHVNULYHKYDVRPPHQHVPHGEHJUHSHWLQQRYDVMRQUHGHJM¡UHIRUKYRUGDQLQQR YDVMRQIRUHJnULQ ULQJVOLYHWVDPWGLVNXWHUHKYDVRPXWIUDWHRUHWLVNHEHWUDNW QLQJHUNDQY UHUHOHYDQWHLQQRYDVMRQVSROLWLVNHYLUNHPLGOHURYHUIRUXOLNHW\SHU DYEHGULIWHU1RWDWHWHURJVnPHQWVRPHQIRUKROGVYLV·SRSXO U·LQQI¡ULQJRYHUIRU RSSGUDJVJLYHULWHPDHWIRU67(3JUXSSHQVSURVMHNWRJRJVnVRPHQEDNJUXQQ IRUGHUHVWHUHQGHQRWDWHQH 1RWDWRJDQDO\VHUHUXOLNHVLGHUYHGLQQRYDVMRQVDNWLYLWHWL$XVW$JGHUVQ ULQJVOLY²RJPHGEUXNDYXOLNHW\SHUGDWDRJPHWRGH'HWDQGUHQRWDWHWRP ·1 ULQJVVWUXNWXURJLQQRYDVMRQL$XVW$JGHU²6WDWLVWLVNDQDO\VH·JLUHQEUHG RYHUVLNWRYHUYLNWLJHIRUKROGYHGQ ULQJVOLYHWL$XVW$JGHURJLI\ONHWVILUHUHJL RQHU'DWDNLOGHQHHURIIHQWOLJVWDWLVWLNNRJRIIHQWOLJHGDWDUHJLVWUHRJGHWHUWLO GHOVVQDNNRPQ\HGDWDNLOGHUVRPKLWWLOKDUY UWOLWHEHQ\WWHWWLODQDO\VHUDY UHJLRQDOQ ULQJVXWYLNOLQJ1RWDWHWVDPPHQOLNQHUIRUKROGYHGQ ULQJVVWUXNWXU XWGDQQLQJVQLYnIRUVNQLQJRJXWYLNOLQJ )R8 RJLQQRYDWLYDNWLYLWHWL$XVW $JGHUPHGWLOVYDUHQGHWDOOIRUODQGVJMHQQRPVQLWWHW 0HQVQRWDWDOWVnJLUHQEUHGRYHUVLNWRYHUYLNWLJHIRUKROGYHGLQQRYDWLYDNWLYL WHWL$XVW$JGHUVQ ULQJVOLYHUIRUPnOHWPHGQRWDWnIRUHWDJUXQGLJHVWXGLHUL QRHQXWYDOJWHEHGULIWHURJQ ULQJVVHNWRUHU1RWDWRP·,QQRYDWLYDNWLYLWHWRJ LQQRYDVMRQVXWIRUGULQJHUL$XVW$JGHUVQ ULQJVOLY²FDVHVWXGLHU·VNDOV UOLJ VNDIIHIUDPNXQQVNDSRPKYRUGDQEHGULIWHUL$XVW$JGHULQQRYHUHURJRPKYD VRPHUYLNWLJHXWIRUGULQJHURJIODVNHKDOVHUYHGEHGULIWHQHVLQQRYDWLYHDNWLYLWHW 'HWHUNXQQVNDSVRPLNNHNDQIUDPVNDIIHVYLDRIIHQWOLJVWDWLVWLNNPHQVRP NUHYHUHJQHJUXQGLJHVWXGLHU1RWDWEDVHUHVVnOHGHVSnSHUVRQOLJLQWHUYMXPHG OHGHUHLXWYDOJWHEHGULIWHUVDPWSnDOOHUHGHJMHQQRPI¡UWHLQQRYDVMRQVDQDO\ VHULILUHUHJLRQDOHQ ULQJVNO\QJHULI\ONHWQHPOLJLSODVWEnWLQGXVWUL,7 Q ULQJHQPDULWLPVHNWRURJWXULVWQ ULQJHQ'HEHGULIWHQHEOHYDOJWXWL LLL LY VDPUnPHGRSSGUDJVJLYHURJGHWRPIDWWHUEHGULIWHULXOLNHGHOHUDYI\ONHWLXOL NHEUDQVMHULXOLNHVW¡UUHOVHVJUXSSHURJVnYLGHUH 'HWVLVWHQRWDWHW·2SSVXPPHULQJRJIRUVODJWLOLQQRYDVMRQVVWUDWHJLHUIRU$XVW $JGHU·RSSVXPPHUHUYLNWLJO UGRPIUDGHWUHI¡UVWHQRWDWHQHEnGHQnUGHW JMHOGHUJHQHUHOOO UGRPRPUHJLRQDOLQQRYDVMRQVSROLWLNNRJVLWXDVMRQHQL$XVW $JGHUVQ ULQJVOLY3nEDNJUXQQDYNXQQVNDSHQHUYHUYHWLSURVMHNWHWKDUYLVn IRUVODJWLOLQQRYDVMRQVUHWWHWHVWUDWHJLHURJYLUNHPLGOHUIRUXOLNHGHOHUDYQ ULQJVOLYHWL$XVW$JGHU 6HOYRPQRWDWHQHE\JJHUSnKYHUDQGUHKDUYLRJVnSU¡YGnVNULYHKYHUWQRWDW VOLNDWGHNDQOHVHVXDYKHQJLJDYKYHUDQGUH'HUPHGYLOGHWY UHOLWWRYHUODS SLQJPHOORPQRWDWHQHYHGDWGHQRYHURUGQHGHKHQVLNWHQPHGSURVMHNWHWHUEH VNUHYHWNRUWIDWWHWI¡UVWLKYHUWQRWDW ,QQKROG )2525' ,,, ,11+2/' 9 127$7,1129$7,9$.7,9,7(72*5(*,21$/(,1129$6-216675$7(*,(5 35,16,3,(//(%(75$.71,1*(5 ,QQOHGQLQJ 8WIRUGULQJ*OREDOLVHULQJDYQ ULQJVOLYHW 8WIRUGULQJ1\GRPLQHUHQGHSURGXNVMRQVPnWH 2SSVXPPHULQJRPXWIRUGULQJHU 6YDU8WQ\WWJOREDOLVHULQJHQWLOnVNDIIHDUEHLGVSODVVHUXWHQIUD 6YDU%\JJVWHUNHORNDOHQ ULQJVPLOM¡HU (WIHOOHVVYDU6WLPXOHULQQRYDWLYHPLOM¡HU ,QQRYDVMRQHUVRPHQGULYNUDIWLQ ULQJVXWYLNOLQJHQ ,QQRYDVMRQHUHUVDPDUEHLGRJJMHQVLGLJO ULQJ 5HJLRQDOHIDNWRUHUNDQVWLPXOHUHLQQRYDWLYDNWLYLWHW 8OLNHYLUNHPLGOHUIRUXOLNHGHOHUDYQ ULQJVOLYHW 6WUDWHJL/RNDOIRUDQNULQJDYILOLDOEHGULIWHU 6WUDWHJL7LOI¡UHORNDOHQ ULQJVPLOM¡HUVWUDWHJLVNNRPSHWDQVH 6WUDWHJL.Q\WWH¶HQVOLJH·EHGULIWHUWLOQDVMRQDOHNRPSHWDQVHPLOM¡HU 6WUDWHJL6NDS¶VW¡WWHPLOM¡·UXQGWQ\HWDEOHUH 2SSVXPPHULQJ(QPXOLJLQQRYDVMRQVVWUDWHJLIRU$XVW$JGHU +YDQn" 127$715,1*66758.7852*,1129$6-21,$867$*'(5²67$7,67,6. $1$/<6( ,QQOHGQLQJ 'DWDPDWHULDOHW 9LNWLJHQ ULQJHUL$XVW$JGHU ,QQOHGQLQJ 1 ULQJVVWUXNWXUL1RUJHRJ$XVW$JGHU 1 ULQJVVWUXNWXUL$XVW$JGHUVUHJLRQHU %HGULIWVVW¡UUHOVH %RVWHGRJDUEHLGVVWHG 2SSVXPPHULQJQ ULQJVVWUXNWXU 8WGDQQLQJ ,QQOHGQLQJ Y YL 1 ULQJVYLVIRUGHOLQJDYXWGDQQLQJ 5HJLRQDOHXWGDQQLQJVP¡QVWUH 9LNWLJHXWGDQQLQJVUHWQLQJHUL$XVW$JGHU 2SSVXPPHULQJ8WGDQQLQJ )RUVNQLQJRJXWYLNOLQJ )R8 RJLQQRYDVMRQ )R8DNWLYLWHWLQRUVNHEHGULIWHU ,QQRYDVMRQVDNWLYLWHW 2SSVXPPHULQJ)R8RJLQQRYDVMRQVDNWLYLWHW .RQNOXVMRQ 127$7,1129$7,9$.7,9,7(72*,1129$6-21687)25'5,1*(5,$867 $*'(5615,1*6/,9²&$6(678',(5 ,QQOHGQLQJ %DNJUXQQLQQRYDVMRQHUVRPGULYNUDIWIRUQ ULQJVXWYLNOLQJHQ 3UREOHPVWLOOLQJHURJPHWRGH 8OLNHW\SHUEHGULIWHU²PHGXOLNHLQQRYDVMRQVXWIRUGULQJHU ·'HWHUQ¡GYHQGLJnY UHSnKXJJHWKHOHWLGHQ· ,QQRYDVMRQHUHUODQJVLNWLJHSURVHVVHU ,QWHUQNRPSHWDQVHRJKROGQLQJHUHUDYJM¡UHQGHYHGLQQRYDWLYDNWLYLWHW ,QQRYDVMRQVSURVMHNWHUHU·WRSSVW\UWH· ·/HYHUDQG¡UHQHHUHQGHODYEHGULIWHQ· 0DUNHGVRULHQWHUWSURGXNWXWYLNOLQJ ,QQRYDVMRQ VDPDUEHLG 2SSVXPPHULQJRPLQQRYDVMRQVXWIRUGULQJHULGHEHGULIWHQH /RNDOHEUDQVMHNRQVHQWUDVMRQHU 3ODVWEnWLQGXVWULHQ ,7Q ULQJHQ 0DULWLPVHNWRU 5HLVHOLYVQ ULQJHQ 2SSVXPPHULQJDYEUDQVMHDQDO\VHQH +YDVnQnUGHWJMHOGHUVWUDWHJLHURJYLUNHPLGOHU" 6DPPHQGUDJ 9HGOHJJ2YHUVLNWRYHUEHGULIWHUVRPHUPHGLLQWHUYMXXQGHUV¡NHOVHQ 127$72336800(5,1*2*)256/$*7,/,1129$6-216675$7(*,(5 ,QQOHGQLQJ (Q·EUHG·IRUVWnHOVHDYLQQRYDVMRQHU 5HODWLYWODYLQQRYDWLYDNWLYWHWL$XVW$JGHU ,QQRYDVMRQVXWIRUGULQJHUL$XVW$JGHU ,QQRYDVMRQVV\VWHPHU 6NUHGGHUV¡PDYYLUNHPLGOHU YLL %HW\GQLQJHQDYGHWUHJLRQDOHQLYnHW ¶6\VWHPRULHQWHUWH·YLUNHPLGOHU )RNXVSnPHUHQQWHNQRORJLXWYLNOLQJ 2JVnO ULQJLYLUNHPLGGHODSSDUDWHW NWIRNXVSnLQQRYDVMRQHU 6LNUHNRPSHWHQWDUEHLGVNUDIW %LGUDWLOVDPDUEHLGRJQHWWYHUNVE\JJLQJ ,QVWLWXVMRQVE\JJLQJLUHJLRQDOHQ ULQJVNO\QJHU 8OLNHWLOWDNLQ ULQJVNO\QJHQH 0HOORPPHQQIRU·HQVOLJHVYDOHU· 5HJLRQDOIRUDQNULQJDYILOLDOEHGULIWHU .