From the SpaceX Starlink megaconstellation to the search for Type-I civilizations Osmanov Z.N. School of Physics, Free University of Tbilisi, 0183, Tbilisi, Georgia E. Kharadze Georgian National Astrophysical Observatory, Abastumani, 0301, Georgia ABSTRACT Here we extrapolate the idea of launching SpaceX’s Starlink satellites and study the possibility of building planetary megastructures (either designed as solid objects or as a web of satellites) by Type-I civilizations and the consequent detection of their techno-signatures. We have shown that the instruments of The Very Large Telescope Interferometer (VLTI) can potentially observe emission pattern of the huge constructions. Efficiency of the spectral variability method has been emphasized and the role of the FAST telescope was discussed. Subject headings: SpaceX Starlink; SETI; Techno-signatures; Extraterrestrial life; FAST telescope 1. Introduction civilization is harnessing the total energy coming from the sun to the Earth. Our society is con- Last year on May 24 the SpaceX launched the suming less than the mentioned energy, therefore, first set of 60 Starlink satellites and up to now the an index, K = log10 (P ) /10 − 0.6, introduced by total number is approximately 400 aiming to reach Shklovskii & Sagan (1966) for Earthlings is 0.7, at least 12000 (McDowell 2020) at the end of a where P denotes the average harnessed power in decade program announced by Elon Musk. Such a Watts. In the framework of the same classifica- huge number of satellites, distributed over almost tion Type-III is the alien high tech society which the whole surface of the Earth might be considered is able to use the total energy of the host galaxy. as the first prototype of a possible megastructure It is clear that detection of Type-II and Type- around the Earth, which in principal, might be III civilizations is much easier than Type-I be- visible from the cosmos. Similarly, one may search cause of the much higher total consumed ener- for techno-signatures of alien civilizations. gies. Therefore, a special interest in the Dyso- The discovery of the Tabby’s star (Boyajian et al. nian SETI projects deserve Type-II,III techno- 2016) and ”Oumuamua” (Bialy & Loeb 2018) signatures and a series of papers are dedicated to have provoked the revival of the search for ex- identification of DS candidates (Timofeev et al. traterrestrial intelligence (SETI). The idea to 2000; Carrigan 2009; Zackrisson et al. 2018). arXiv:2103.07227v1 [physics.pop-ph] 12 Mar 2021 search for techno-signatures of advanced alien so- Dyson’s original idea has been extended to hot cieties have been proposed by Dyson (1960). As- DSs (Osmanov & Berezhiani 2018, 2019) and the suming that a civilization is advanced enough to megastructures around pulsars (Osmanov 2016, build a megastructure around a host star to con- 2017). sume its whole energy, Dyson has concluded that Despite high radiation intensity of Type- such a huge (having the length-scale of the order II,III technologies compared to Type-I techno- of one AU) spherical construction - Dyson sphere signatures, the latter still can be considered (DS) - should be visible in the infrared (IR) spec- seriously in the SETI context. In particular, trum. Civilizations harnessing the host star’s total Kuhn & Berdyugina (2015) studied effects of energy belong to the Type-II societies according global warming as detectable biomarkers in Earth- to the classification by Kardashev (1964). Type-I like societies. 1 Our civilization consumes approximately 1.5 × that at geostationary orbit (R ≃ 36000km) the re- 1020 ergs s−1 (Kuhn & Berdyugina 2015), which quired mass becomes enormous compared to the is less than for Type-I society, 1.7 × 1024 ergs s−1. above considered. If one assumes 1% of an average growth rate of Another issue one should address, is to under- industry and the subsequent energy consumption, stand time scale required for launching such a huge one can straightforwardly show that our civiliza- mass of material. Roughly speaking, the civiliza- tion might reach Type-I in ∼ 1000yrs. It is quite tion can start launching material from the times probable that in 1000yrs the level of technology when its index was equal to ours, 0.7 (See the in- will differ from ours, likewise ours is different from troduction). Then, as we have already mentioned, the one of middle ages. Therefore, one can as- to reach the Type-I level, it needs 1000 yrs. The sume that Type-I alien society is able to cloak process will be feasible if the annual rate of growth their planet by a sphere-like (or ring-like) struc- of mass launching, µ, is a small parameter. If one ture to harness the total energy emitted from their assumes that the first year’s launched mass equals host star toward the planet. M0, then in 1000 yrs the total mass will be given In this paper we consider the possible obser- by 1000 vational characteristics of a planetary megastruc- M = M0 (1 + µ) . (2) ture partially or completely covering an Earth-like After taking into account Eq. (1) and the fact that planet located in the habitable zone. up to date there are 895 satellites each with the The paper is organized in the following way: in mass 260 kg (McDowell 2020), one can straight- Sec. 2, we introduce main theory and study the forwardly show that µ ≃ 0.021. techno-signatures of Type-I megaconstructions, Generally speaking, the megastructure might obtaining major results and in Sec. 3 we outline be constructed by advanced Type-I civilization them. from extraterrestrial resources without launch costs (Haliki 2020), but let us consider the worst 2. Discussion and results case: the Solar energy is stored and then utilized At first we consider the question: energetically to launch material on the orbit. how feasible is launching material to cover an area In this case energy required to launch material comparable to the Earth’s surface. As an example on the altitude H ∼ 500km is as follows we examine the construction designed by means GMM H of Graphene as up to now the strongest material, E ≃ p ≃ 5.7κ × 1027 ergs, (3) R2 our civilization is able to produce. Then, for the ⊕ total mass of the megastructure we obtain where Mp = ME is Earth-like planet’s mass and 27 2 ME ≃ 6 × 10 g is the Earth’s mass. M ≃ 4κπRpρ∆r ≃ On the other hand, power from the host star 17 ρ ∆r toward the planet is given by ≃ 2κ × 10 × 3 × g, (1) 0.4g/cm 1mm 2 L Rp 24 −1 ≤ P ≃ × ≃ 1.7κ × 10 ergs s , (4) where κ 1 is a dimensionless geometric fac- 4 r tor, Rp is the Earth-like planet’s radius (R⊕ ≃ 6400 km) density, ρ, is normalised by the Graphene where L ≃ 3.8 × 1033ergs s−1 is the solar-type density and it is assumed that since the Graphene star’s luminosity and r ≃ 1.5 × 1013 cm is the ra- is 10 times stronger than steel the effective thick- dius of the habitable zone. Whatever the propul- ness of the construction, ∆r, is normalised by sion mechanism (electromagnetic launch or some 1mm value. As it clear from here, the total mass other mechanisms), it is evident from Eq. (4) that is less than the total storage of Earth’s Carbon, 24 the energy required to launch a thin shell around 1.85 × 10 by seven orders of magnitude and thus a planet can be extracted in approximately ten one can find enough material to build a construc- hours with 10% of efficiency of energy conversion. tion. Here we assume that the altitude is much If the megastructure is a web of many satellites or- less than R⊕. One can straightforwardly check biting the planet, then the kinetic energy should 2 be added to the aforementioned value, leading to VLTI instruments2 in 1 hour is of the order of ten times more total energy, which, energetically 2.3 × 10−18ergs s−1cm−2. Therefore, potentially is quite feasible for Type-I alien societies. one can monitor the spherical volume with radius For a uniformly distributed spherical mass such of the order of R0 = 260 ly. In the Solar neigh- a construction will not require any energy to sta- bourhood the stellar number density, n, is of the −3 bilise it. Unlike this scenario, if instead of the order of 0.138 star pc (Latyshev 1978), which sphere one uses a ring, the planet will be charac- means that the total number of stars could be terised by the out of plane stability, whereas for 3 4πR0 5 in-plane displacements the dynamics is unstable N ≃ n ≃ 3 × 10 , (9) 3 (Osmanov 2016). In this work we have discussed that such rings may have sense only if the power with approximately 1000 G-type (Solar-type) required to maintain stability is small compared to stars. Although the flux method cannot distin- the total received power, leading to the following guish emission from the planet and the megas- condition for maximum displacement from equi- tructure, it allows to find objects in the habitable librium zone. For identifying the candidates of megacon- 3 4 struction one can use the spatial resolution of the 1/2 3 / 0.37 P 2Rp telescopes. ξ << ≃ 0.07, (5) R M GM p p ! The VLTI telescope has the maximum angular resolution, θm, of the order of 0.001 mas (milliarc- where ξ ≡ d/Rp and d denotes the displacement of second - please see the technical characteristics of the ring from the equilibrium position. We would the VLTI instruments. By taking into account this like to emphasise that such a precision is not diffi- value, one can obtain the maximum resolving dis- cult to achieve: in the Lunar laser ranging experi- tance ment1 the distance is measured with the precision 2R −10 Dm = ≃ 280 ly.