Volume 89 Number 3 September 2020 Historical Society of the Episcopal Church President Robyn M. Neville, St. Mark’s School, Fort Lauderdale, Florida 1st Vice President J. Michael Utzinger, Hampden-Sydney College 2nd Vice President Robert W. Prichard, Virginia Theological Seminary Secretary Pamela Cochran, Loyola University Maryland Treasurer Bob Panfil, Diocese of Virginia Director of Operations Matthew P. Payne, Diocese of Fond du Lac [email protected] Anglican and Episcopal History Editor-in-Chief Edward L. Bond, Natchez, Mississippi The John F. Woolverton Editor of Anglican and Episcopal History [email protected] Church Review Editor J. Barrington Bates, Diocese of Newark [email protected] Book Review Editor Sheryl A. Kujawa-Holbrook, Claremont School of Theology [email protected] Anglican and Episcopal History (ISSN 0896-8039) is published quarterly (March, June, September, and December) by the Historical Society of the Episcopal Church, PO Box 1301, Appleton, WI 54912-1301 (formerly the Church Historical Society). Information at hsec.us/aeh. Periodicals postage paid at Appleton, Wisconsin, and additional entry offices. A member of the Conference of Historical Journals Single print copies $10 including postage. Annual membership includes digital edition: $15 student, $30 retiree, $45 regular, $60 institution, $100 sustaining, $250 patron and $500 benefactor. Print edition $30 additional for student, retiree, regular and institutional members. Information at hsec.us/membership. Become a member at hsec.us/membership. Subscription without membership is available for institutions ($70 digital only, $100 print only, $150 digital & print, add $30 non-US print) or individuals ($30 digital only, $45 print only, $70 digital and print, add $30 non-US print). Subscription requests, orders for current and back issues, and information about advertising opportunities should be sent to Matthew P. Payne, Director of Operations, HSEC, PO Box 1301, Appleton, WI 54912-1301, (920) 383-1910, administration@ hsec.us. Checks payable to HSEC. Online payment available. Submissions: submissions for consideration should be typed, double-spaced, 12-point serif font, and conform to the Chicago Manual of Style (15th ed.). Electronic submission as Microsoft Word preferred to [email protected] or to Edward Bond, 902 State Street, Natchez, MS 39120. A physical manuscript not accepted for publication will only be returned if a self-addressed, stamped envelope is included with the submission. Books for review should be sent to Professor Sheryl A. Kujawa-Holbrook, Claremont School of Theology, 1325 North College Avenue, Claremont, CA 91711, [email protected]. Submissions for Church Reviews should follow direction found at hsec.us/church-reviews. Permission to photocopy articles and reviews for classroom use may be obtained from the Copyright Clearance Center, Inc., Academic Permissions Service, 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923. To request per- mission for other types of copying, such as general distribution, advertising or promotional purposes, creating new collective works, or resale, contact the Editorial Office, 902 State Street, Natchez, MS 39120, [email protected]. Editors are not responsible for the accuracy of the statements of con- tributors. The opinions expressed are solely those of contributors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the Historical Society of the Episcopal Church. Articles abstracted and indexed in HISTORICAL ABSTRACTS; AMERICA: HISTORY AND LIFE; and INDEX TO RELIGIOUS PERIODICAL LITERATURE. POSTMASTER: Please send address changes to Business Office, Historical Society of the Episcopal Church, PO Box 1301, Appleton, WI 54912-1301, [email protected], (920) 383-1910. The editors are not responsible for the accuracy of the statements of contributors. The opinions expressed are solely those of the contributors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the editors or of the Historical Society of the Episcopal Church. Articles in this journal are abstracted and indexed in HISTORICAL ABSTRACTS; AMERICA: HISTORY AND LIFE; and INDEX TO RELIGIOUS PERIODI- CAL LITERATURE. POSTMASTER: Please send address changes to Business Office, Historical Society of the Episcopal Church, PO Box 1301, Appleton, WI 54912-1301 (920) 383-1910. Copyright 2020. The Historical Society of the Episcopal Church Printed by Sheridan PA, Hanover, PA Volume 89 • September 2020 • Number 3 Contents Historical Revision in Church: Re-examining the “Saint” Edward Colston By Samuel J. Richards 225 The Elusive Goal: The Commitment to Indigenous Self-Determination in the Anglican Church of Canada, 1967–2019 By Alan L. Hayes 255 The Contentious Conferences of 1924: A Study of the Proceedings of the Anglo-Catholic Priests’ Convention and the 38th Episcopal Church Congress By Jesse J. Lee 281 Church Reviews Pandemical Context, Second Report By J. Barrington Bates 302 Online Worship in Waco During a Season of Pandemic By Joel W. West 305 Contents continues Contents (continued) Book Reviews DORRIEN, GARY, Breaking White Supremacy: Martin Luther King Jr. and the Black Social Gospel; KHYATI Y. JOSHI, White Christian Privilege: The Illusion of Religious Equality in America, by Sheryl A. Kujawa-Holbrook 310 GERBNER, KATHERINE, Christian Slavery: Conversion and Race in the Protestant Atlantic World, by Jennifer Snow 313 BYRD, BRANDON, The Black Republic: African Americans and the Fate of Haiti, by Kevin M. Lowe 315 HORN, HUSTON, Leonidas Polk: Warrior Bishop of the Confederacy, by Gardiner H. Shattuck Jr. 317 GAMBLE, RICHARD M., A Fiery Gospel: The Battle Hymn of the Republic and the Road to Righteous War, by Nancy Saultz Radloff 319 KIDD, THOMAS S., America's Religious History: Faith, Politics, and the Shaping of a Nation, by Kevin M. Lowe 321 BELLOWS, BARBARA L., Two Charlestonians at War: The Civil War Odysseys of a Low Country Aristocrat and a Black Abolitionist, by Glem Bowman 323 DOWNS, MATTHEW L. and M. RYAN FLOYD, eds., The American South and the Great War 1914-1924, by Christopher Webber 325 BUGGELN, GRETCHEN and BARBARA FRANCO, Interpreting Religion at Museums and Historic Sites, by Geoffrey Brown 326 MITCHELL, KERRY, Spirituality and the State: Managing Nature and Experience in America’s National Parks, by Harvey Hill 328 HERNANDEZ, JILL GRAPER, Early Modern Women and the Problem of Evil: Atrocity & Theodicy; JEANNE ABRAMS, First Ladies of the Republic:Martha Washington, Abigail Adams, Dolley Madison, and the Creation of an Iconic American Role: LISA PLACE VETTER, The Political Thought of America’s Founding Feminists, by Molly James 330 GREM, DARREN E., TED OWNBY, JAMES THOMAS, JR., eds., Southern Religion, Southern Culture: Essays Honoring Charles Reagan Wilson, by Nicholas M. Beasley 333 DANIELSON, LEILAH, MARIAN MOLLIN, DOUG ROSSINOW, The Religious Left in Modern America: Doorkeepers of a Radical Faith, by Justus D. Doenecke 335 Contents (continued) PHAN, PETER C., Asian Christianities: History, Theology, Practice, by Anglea M. Tankersley 336 BROWNE, RANDY M., Surviving Slavery in the British Caribbean, by Kyle Welty 338 CAÑIZARES-ESGUERRA, JORGE, ed., Entangled Empires: The Anglo-Iberian Atlantic, 1500-1830, by Carla E. Roland Guzmán 340 BLOCK, SHARON, Colonial Complexions: Race and Bodies in Eighteenth Century America, by Joan A. Gundersen 342 HUDNUT-BEUMLER, JAMES, Strangers and Friends at the Welcome Table: Contemporary Christianities in the American South, by Justus D. Doencke 343 WOODS, ERIC TAYLOR, A Cultural Sociology of Anglican Mission and the Indian Residential Schools: The Long Road to Apology, by Jesse Link 345 WILLIAMS, DUNCAN RYUKEN, American Sutra: A Story of Faith and Freedom in the Second World War, by Kathryn Nishibayashi 347 WEBBER, CHRISTOPHER L. Christian Psalms for Worship and Prayer, by Sheryl A. Kujawa-Holbrook 349 CATRON, JOHN W., Embracing Protestantism: Black Identities in the Atlantic World; STEFAN WHEELOCK, Barbaric Culture and Black Critique, by Kyle Bulthuis 350 RESÉNDEZ, ANDRÉS, The Other Slavery: The Uncovered Story of Indian Enslavement in America, by Matthew P. Payne 354 Society Announcements 356 Editorial Board Nicholas Beasley Robert Bruce Mullin Greenwood, General Theological Seminary South Carolina Robert W. Prichard Mary S. Donovan Virginia Theological Seminary Hunter College, City University of New York Jane Shaw Grace Cathedral, Joan R. Gundersen San Francisco University of Pittsburgh Kevin R. Hardwick Peter Sherlock James Madison University Melbourne College of Divinity Robert G. Ingram Victor Stater Ohio University Louisiana State University Benjamin J. King John N. Wall University of the South North Carolina State University Advisory Editors Phyllis D. Airhart, Emmanuel College, Stanford E. Lehmberg University of Toronto Mei-Mei Lin, National Dong Hwa C. FitzSimons Allison, Diocese of University South Carolina Paul Victor Marshall S. Charles Bolton, University of Arkansas at Little Rock Frederick V. Mills, LaGrange College Henry W. Bowden, Rutgers University Alfred A. Moss, University of Maryland Robert G. Carroon, Diocese of Connecticut John K. Nelson, University of Craig D’Alton, University Church North Carolina of St. Mary the Virgin Lesley A. Northup, Florida Justus D. Doenecke, New College of Florida International University R. William Franklin, Bishop of Western William L. Sachs, Diocese of Virginia New York Gardiner H. Shattuck, Diocese of Allen C. Guelzo, Gettysburg College Rhode Island Miranda K. Hassett, Episcopal Divinity School William S. Stafford,