Scholarly Commons @ UNLV Boyd Law Scholarly Works Faculty Scholarship 2016 Policing and the Clash of Masculinities Ann C. McGinley University of Nevada, Las Vegas -- William S. Boyd School of Law Follow this and additional works at: https://scholars.law.unlv.edu/facpub Part of the Law and Gender Commons, and the Law and Society Commons Recommended Citation McGinley, Ann C., "Policing and the Clash of Masculinities" (2016). Scholarly Works. 1268. https://scholars.law.unlv.edu/facpub/1268 This Article is brought to you by the Scholarly Commons @ UNLV Boyd Law, an institutional repository administered by the Wiener-Rogers Law Library at the William S. Boyd School of Law. For more information, please contact [email protected]. 544-497,2016 mmx- Yt2? =arinnn2 mix-.rinn.-T, , 21, fIR mvllpmn, YnxR i!', 2015-1 2014 01=a ' w-'Tn 'nmn vnnpn , n mnrn- ?r ,znrT =ai , ' =a'' ,,pn wun ( rBy . 2a~g~l~ myv'n wimnt~ '-r'ntt 1 wmn~lrl'rlnZn w-nm t]'=ala VF',M20 15 =Vnp2 onuin-i 7,nt "nr ,=inirw Ernn~n tv nr:7-na vtv nr~ry , ma==m ",(avi ,=aumre)O=a .V'1rn = ,m xv .' ,m y , YT= n Irx M=a 'p 7,n a,m=,Y nm'in'tm mi,-in ,vwrin,= nia'np oan ,ny ninnna m'nmnnnn, -,n~n wnm mn ri t mu'l -'i?, nT0 =.-n t n(imenerR omr onun-i mn ni= m'm, nann nnn~n = ~a mn=a -mn uztina=' n:nrrin:wtvinn =apnn nl anxn ,'n naryn minnn in "xtm ,=1n, I=a'Yn wn =a, '' n , ' ; ,(Dan Hamilton) v r ,n-TV ; ynvn nv (Nettie Mann) ,tr?1 ,n tYv 1nrsn nn in (Jeff Stempel) 71t:m flIn-mri2 T tz X',(Frank Rudy Cooper) nnn pi tiuiv , .n-'i-nir n r'in ,2mpnv '~IN .m~~~~~n~21'1'T fl1Xi2)1 -7n~h1 ift in mmt - n n v- nn-ii nnn .2o ninn w3niv 5y1T~'1 tnnn .1 rimfl Ip'3fl nipi1 5w1T~'l ri-il-I .2 ~'rnn2''r~tl ~'X~W rri Po 1 . rl~rl- YM 2TI'flM lq; 3 nin''1 " '3112712n, 'Y=X 1l 2015-1 2014 01=7:1 .7-71 V U01Mj-11 252- 245-244 ,242-237 ,60-51 ,35-33 V ? I"1 1 Julia Craven, Here s How Many Black People Have : I .1 "71''71I' 0Iz'V Been Killed by Police This Year [Updated]. Too Many, THE HUFFINGTON POST (Jul. 7, 2016), http://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/black-people-killed-by-police-america_ M= 1:), )W, 7 ,I-Y V' 'T1?nMnn"r .us_577da633e4b0c590f7e7fb17 01tI/I, =1 1:1 0M:1 ': ,011UI 711-VIN 990 ' rlll'IM 2015 https://www.washingtonpost.com/n N .708 ]fln IM -1= ,2016 ]V/Z 7V Zl -, 11,1948 ,2015 ]=D mlll'? -L*X', 1n? .graphics/national/police-shootings-2016/ i11t- 1 , 172-1 01-11Mz 1- 258 0= 17,IWin 494,1n'1n .01m 42-1 01-1= http://www, Il') N ' ll, 25%-:) j?-I 11-IT11011,-I 012)0,-11 0111TIMV I 0,1TIrV , rnj'vp,iri, 7 , 7 , ,(infoplease.com/ipa/A0762156.html XI, 2015 Mt=" 11UV,1 1-11,-I11=11"I 1:117 9l01111= 71M .111=n x ,n 1no, 13% 171 0 rnn'011MVV 9K ,01-11MVz 1,-I 0'VV:)n 717 X'6rz 111=111 01N 7rnn 37%ZV .http://mappingpoliceviolence.org/unarmed/ 'i.r?', ,, http://www.cnn.com/2016/07/08/us/philando-castile-alton- lIW .t1, VY, Tx Inrz~nIrKV ,Nrl 71,-'Na , #BlackLivesMatter 0 1.sterling-protests/ Black Lives Matter Condemns Dallas, Pushes Forwardwith Protests, :RI., CBS NEws (Jul. 8, 2016), http://www.cbsnews.com/news/dallas-shooting-black-lives- .matter-leaders-respond/ n,-imni jp~r 1:) .-inxnn znn Txn ri!nr rwn im!n~n *i t)!)Vn pn w Carolyn Sung & Catherine E. Shoichet, Freddie Gray Case: :IX'I .01nIVNI i"TI Charges DroppedAgainstRemaining Officers, CNN (Jul. 27, 2016), http://www.cnn. ,M'M: Y1"1N '- fl V 7 .com/2016/07/27/us/freddie-gray-verdict-baltimore-officers/ J. David Goodman, Eric Garner Case Is Settled by New York City for :I'I .*I I 7ln $5.9 Million, N.Y. TIEs (Jul. 13, 2015), http://www.nytimes.com/2015/07/14/nyregion/ -'II 90nl .eric-gamer-case-is-settled-by-new-york-city-for-5-9-million.html? r-0 Timothy Williams & Mitch Smith, Cleveland Officer Will Not : IX .111: 0'TWly V1Ir) Face Charges in Tamir Rice Shooting Death, N.Y. TMES (Dec. 28, 2015), http://www. .nytime s.com/2015/12/29/us/tamir-rice -police -shootiing-cleveland. html?_r=0 '2mpn2'v IN rrn' mz O'nnz 7:)x ~ zmjp?: wrnriv 7:n-', rnvnn~ - rxnr i 'zfrix prv .(?r vz,5 niIV37n 32%)n Mriv pn 'n-ui1 -7~ '-'Y rnz 'rx "v nno'n " ltwZ' m*IT 29% . 1' .r91 VnrT i 102 ,rrimn 464 r"v r'" . 95% - n..1':"v.1 . .1x 50%"1n rf n".'t1 1%v ,v' T "n1n'1j? 25%T* 7xrnIy-i~n nnvn nri nm y -n- ..- noz'xn nr'',i z nrvnrn Charlotte Alter, Sandra Blands Not the FirstBlack Woman to Experience w mln Poice Tolence, TiM (Jul. 22, 2015), http://time.com/3965032/sandra-bland-arrest- ] D~ ], ,7flr ,T'7 #SayHerName 7i ]r .video-police-violence/ ~Police ~~~ ~ ~ tp//iecn3602snr-ln-ret~ ~ ~ ~Vilne4m(u.2,21) ~ ~~~~~.z Dara Lind, The FBI IsTrying to Get Better Data on Police Killings. Here s What We2 Know Now, Vox EXPLAINERS, http://www.vox.com/20 14/8/21/6051043/how-many- .people-killed-police-statistics-homicide-official-black (last updated Apr. 10, 2015) Jon Swaine, Oliver Laughland & Jamiles Lartey, Black Americans Killed by Police Twice as Likely to be Unarmed as White People, THE GUARDIAN (Jun. 1, 2015), https:// .www.theguardian.cdmlus-news 2015 jun1i/black-americans-killed-by-police-analysis 5 6 ,pZ- f VZ (War on Drugs) "Mlonrz' n nf",ni 'nn btz" .:'ntv rn-y'nTT, ,t' 7,(broken windows) "O'nlnZ *rir," tZ "-nuvim"ntuo ,,rnntvb xv , 7tmZ Nikole Hannah-Jones, Yes, Black America Fears the Police. Here s Wy., PROPUBLICA 5 (Mar. 4,2015), https ://www.propublica.org/article/yes-black-america-fears-the-police- .heres-why Andrew Glass, Reagan Declares 'War on Drugs, 'October 14, 1982, POLITICO (Oct. 6 XV'I, : r ,) 14, 2010), http://www.politico.com/news/stories/1010/43552.htl 7ZtV,TheAtlantic 11N-:11i Nnn'T1111MV "1111N11: Irin u triln 7 George L. :1XI ' m7 mV rT~?]1*'?11 rlMu plr 10i iriv- In Kelling & James Q. Wilson, Broken Windows: The Police andNeighborhood Safety, THE ATLANTIC (Mar. 1982), http://www.theatlantic.com/nagazine/archive/1 982/03/broken- 0,,n3 7 nutn rn, InZT0"11:wm', n'lvl, n ' ~ ,Rnwindows/304465/ BERNARD E. HARcouRT, :~111UUtV IU!)I ,111- n 1111rYvi 0-1min V1II'l]2 .ILLUSION OF ORDER: THE FALSE PROMISE OF BROKEN WINDOWS POLICING 1(2001) Bernard E. Harcourt & Jens Ludwig, Reefer Madness: Broken Windows Policing := and Misdemeanor MarijuanaArrests in New York City, 1989 2000, 6 CRIMINOLOGY tri'trZ 7'1= 0 711n 1onn '?rr'l :) Mj?=l Z & PUB. POL'Y 165, 171 (2007) Loic Wacquant, RacialStigma in the Making ofAmerica s Punitive State, in RACE, :X-1 8 INCARCERATION, AND AMERICAN VALUES 57, 59, 63 (Glenn C. Loury et al. eds., 2008) (mass "",l, ,'1Or"l ?1 ,(hyper incarceration) "MV'n', =" Mn3, IWn,) Frank Rudy ;( , , , 7'1 Wl ,incarceration) Cooper, Hyper-incarcerationas a MultidimensionalAttack:Replying to Angela Harris -1111-N" :) fl71,) Through The Wire, 37 WASH. U. J.L. & POL'Y 67, 70-71 (2011) CriminalJustice Fact Sheet, NAACP, http://www.naacp.org/pages/criminal-justice- :IN' 9 ,1 np,- r i 7 1 't:=M) "V1YIV fact-sheet (last visited Jul. 6,2015) ,2mpn2'v IN 01-1= 5tz 1"N.-M r l't.3-i 11 "°,(The New Jim Crow) "tZ1r i T'WV.3 -rrzl37- 12,19 70 rut72 ? rl'.3 'l 3z rl~:z2 rr37T'I1 -r.3z -i' ' f 5nz2 ] .,= -nir- wr-im , n r, inn ,rrv nin-nn mr-In 'o-in7 n or iirwi ,in1Y.- "'~,97 =V 2m r7 7.3nn m== n,7n -i,.3n -n, rinv IN72 1I1IUnm,i 111ri,-il 'n-.,7- .-i vi rrrn 57 ..7Y mnltv ,,rn, nni. nI 3t ntV nn,;ynn ,niy, n nnn - n*,ni tinrinn nxm pn,;n trnn tinuln-i .Tma3= a.= MICHELLE ALEXANDER, THE NEW JIM CROW: MASS INCARCERATION IN THlE AGE OF 10 .CoLORBLINDNESS (2010) Nadra Kareem Nittle, What Is the Definition of Jim Crow Laws, ABouT NEWS, http:// 11 wtvn ln- I n ' , ri ,lr:) ,inn:mol ,nny/ tv nrimnp' .7 '1v "/TD:7- 14 racerelations .about.com/od/historyofracerelations/g/jimcrow. htm (last visited Jul. 6, wri.99wi"n y1 -I,7 rn-7 '? iir xI,AEANE 15 .(lnnt' vxn Edward Glaeser & Jacob Vigdor, The End of the Segregated Century. Racial :3 '1 12 Separation in America s Neighborhoods, 1890-201 0 (Civic Report No. 66, Manhattan Institute for Policy Research. 2012), http ://www.manhattan-institute.org/pdf/cr66.pdf .126-1 210~ 14 '?y~ ,10 I", Tj Y ,AEADRl1 I'M rII=tvn m"I'Mrini'l ri x -mmn m-nrltv z,= .-i-= tv 7-:Y w xvi riv-rn mw z m-n;yn %mvivrnwniz y inn-Inj? mp-m tv wmztv m=-ni? on ninimin mvinm-n n wnimtv m,-= M, -Ilntv mx -T,- Y -7ynl M-lultv.-I -7yn ril-l= riln .mrin ri=n M= M,-= -mn uyn: 18 - .. j yn. j rix vnrln I= rinivi rix rm: -T:) mn-= tv ri-iwri: trnmn ra -inxn 1-7,12nrl rix J-Iyn rivri-Irin I: -Itm -7nynl M,: uyn 19.mri-myn wnultvn tv mm rwnnl =lwyn tv Y-Iznn morl, y rntvn -Invy wnirltv wn= tv m-i=n rinnn -7= ri xtvn w jmv Nin rinnn 7,n w-nmv.-I wn=n tv rii-i=n mmri 7,n tmnn -wzi mn, x wnuwn tv -71w n ril:nlritv -In, on r= 'InNnn jnn, *Y wnultvn tv mwi jim tv mvirm wnwrl mn-m -vtv mn-rl mn-i=n mn ri xtvn tv ri-Inn-rily-INn z -7,- Y vmn rviyn i w-imv ri-itm-n Y-O ninvy m,:,-7nn ril-linn my :1*vn ril:nlri wn= InIn pl-m 1,.wwnri ri=mj? -7n ri ymnn nwimn.-I mw xn tv nrin-irln riynnn MIMN -IYYn V r11r1-IUVn,-1 -MVIUOX MM-1 KI,-1 ("VIDIMI "Stop and Frisk" 17 Orl :)x -Iyyn rm,:)o rl 'Y rx mnultv -Itvx:) trm-Irm "trivM1 M-lultn-1 ON :1-ilyn 0-m-ar -1,:It) -7tvm y 0-pim I!m y trivM1 -mm-1 :11:),y 'TN IT ri-m-rinx:1 Terry v.