New solutions of the Dirac, Maxwell and Weyl equations from the fractional Fourier transform Iwo Bialynicki-Birula∗ Center for Theoretical Physics, Polish Academy of Sciences Aleja Lotnik´ow 32/46, 02-668 Warsaw, Poland New solutions of relativistic wave equations are obtained in a unified manner from generating functions of spinorial variables. The choice of generating functions as Gaussians leads to representa- tions in the form of generalized fractional Fourier transforms. Wave functions satisfying the Dirac, Maxwell, and Weyl equations are constructed by simple differentiations with respect to spinorial arguments. In the simplest case, one obtains Maxwell and Dirac hopfion solutions. PACS numbers: 03.65.Pm, 03.65.Db I. INTRODUCTION spinors and their complex conjugates. These generating functions have interesting properties on their own be- The aim of this work is to describe a new universal cause they form a representations of the full 15 parame- tool in the study of the solutions of Weyl, Maxwell and ter conformal group for Weyl and Maxwell equations and Dirac equations. This tool is used here to derive a large of the inhomogeneous Poincar´egroup for the Dirac equa- family of solutions of these equations. The essential role tion. Our method of generating solutions is particularly is played by the generating function Υ(η, η∗ x) which in useful for the construction of knotted solutions with intri- a simple form encodes the information about| the solu- cate topological properties. As special cases one obtains tions of Weyl and Maxwell equations and by the function the solutions describing the Dirac [4] and Maxwell [5–7] Υ(η, η∗,ζ,ζ∗ x) which encodes the information about the hopfions. solutions of| the Dirac equation. Solutions of relativis- The main mathematical ingredients in this work are tic wave equations are obtained by the differentiation of two-component spinors and four component bispinors ap- generating functions with respect to their spinorial argu- pearing as arguments of the functions that generate so- ments η and ζ. lutions of Weyl, Maxwell and Dirac equations. These The generating functions have the form of generalized solutions are obtained as the derivatives of the generat- fractional Fourier transforms. Fractional Fourier trans- ing functions with respect to their spinorial arguments. form (sometimes also called the Fresnel transform) was Of course, spinors and bispinors also appear as the wave introduced long time ago by Condon [1]. However, its functions in spacetime. Our notation is a slight modifi- numerous applications in optics, in signal processing, in cation of that used in [8–10] and it is summarized in the image compression, in computed tomography, and other Appendix A. fields began after the work of Namias [2]. The gener- The formalism based on spinors is particularly well alization of the fractional Fourier transform to spinorial suited to describe the solutions of relativistic wave equa- variables extends its range of applications. It enables tions because it is often directly connected with topo- one to obtain analytic localized solutions of relativistic logical properties of these solutions. These properties wave equations with ever increasing degree of complex- in many cases [6, 7] involve Hopf fibration [11]. This ity. The term localized has here the following meaning. subject in the case of the electromagnetic field has been The probability to find the particle outside the sphere thoroughly studied (see a recent review [12]). The spino- of a fixed radius tends to zero when the scaling param- arXiv:2101.03325v1 [quant-ph] 9 Jan 2021 rial representation introduced in the present work gives a eter a tends to zero. Of course, the localization can be unified framework to describe also the solutions of other achieved only around t = 0 because all solutions of wave relativistic wave equations. functions describing particles evolving in free space un- dergo dispersion. As a result, the mean square radius is a quadratic function of time [3, 4], II. MASSLESS PARTICLES: WEYL AND 2 2 r t = A + Bt . (1) MAXWELL EQUATIONS h i Therefore, in the remote past and future the extension ∗ of every wave packet is arbitrarily large. Let us consider an arbitrary complex function Υ(η, η ) A The generating functions introduced here depend on of a two-component spinor η and its complex conjugate ˙ complex parameters: the components of the relativistic ηA. The space of these functions becomes a representa- tion of the conformal group after the introduction of the 15 group generators. The generators of translations Pµ, rotations and special Lorentz transformations Mµν , spe- ∗ [email protected] cial conformal transformations Kµ, and dilation D are 2 (~ =1,c = 1): cance because with their help one can construct from the function Υ(η, η∗) a complete field defined at all space- time points xµ. To this end, Υ(η, η∗) is represented as a AB˙ P = ∂ ˙ g ∂ , (2a) µ − A µ B four-dimensional Fourier integral over the spinorial vari- i A B A˙ B˙ ables, M = η S ∂ η S ˙ ∂ ˙ , (2b) µν 2 µνA B − µνA B ˙ A B˙ ∗ 2 2 ∗ A A ˜ ∗ K = η g ˙ η , (2c) Υ(η, η )= d κd κ exp i(κAη + η κ ˙ ) Υ(κ,κ ). µ µAB − A Z 1 A A˙ h i (3) D = η ∂ + η ∂ ˙ , (2d) 2i A A The integration variables are the real and imaginary A A˙ parts of both components of the spinor κ. The trans- where ∂A = ∂/∂η and ∂A˙ = ∂/∂η . This representa- lation operators acting on the spinorial integral (3) pro- tion has a close connection with twistors [13–15] but this duce an integral in the form of a multidimensional frac- line of investigation will not be pursued here. tional Fourier transform since the exponent has both the The generators of translations are of special signifi- quadratic and the linear part in the integration variables, ∗ µ ∗ 2 2 ∗ AB˙ µ A A˙ ∗ Υ(η, η x) = exp( iP x )Υ(η, η )= d κd κ exp iκ ˙ g κ x exp i(κ η + η κ ˙ ) Υ(˜ κ,κ ). (4) | − µ − A µ B − A A Z h i h i This function satisfies four Schr¨odinger-like equations, The second derivative is a solution of the Maxwell equa- ∗ ∗ tions, i∂µΥ(η, η x)= PµΥ(η, η x). (5) | | ˙ φ (x)= ∂ ∂ Υ(η, η∗ x), gµEC ∂ φ (x)=0. ˜ ∗ CD C D µ CD For every choice of Υ(κ,κ ) which guarantees the con- − | (8) vergence of the integral and for all values of the spinorial ∗ ∗ parameters η and η , the generating function Υ(η, η x) Both equations follow from the algebraic relation: satisfies the d’Alembert equation, | µEC˙ AB˙ A˙E˙ BC g κ ˙ gµ κBκC =2κ ˙ ǫ ǫ κBκC =0, (9) (∂2 ∆)Υ(η, η∗ x)=0, (6) A A t − | applied to the derivatives of the spinorial transform (4). AB˙ because the derivative ∂µ produces κA˙ gµ κB under the The wave equation (8) is equivalent to Maxwell equations integral and this is a lightlike vector. Negative energy so- upon the following identification of the components of µ lutions are obtained by the translation exp(iPµx ). The φCD(x) with the components of the Riemann-Silberstein general solution is a superposition of positive and nega- (RS) vector [3]: tive energy contributions but choosing only one sign at a time simplifies the formulas. Fx = φ11 φ00, Fy = i(φ11 + φ00), Fz =2φ01 =2φ10. − − The generation of the solutions of Maxwell equations (10) from a solution of the d’Alembert equation has been It follows from these relations that positive/negative fre- known already to Whittaker [16]. This method was for- ± mulated in the spinorial framework by Penrose [17]. In quency solutions of Maxwell equations F (x) have the both these constructions, the Maxwell field is built from following spinorial representation: second derivatives with respect to spacetime variables. 2 2 κ1 κ0 Therefore, these methods are closely related to Hertz po- ± 2 2 ∗ F (r,t)= d κd κ iκ2− iκ2 tentials. In contrast, the generation of the solutions of − 1 − 0 2κ0κ1 Weyl and Maxwell equations from our spinorial gener- Z ating function Υ(η, η∗ x) is quite different because it in- AB˙ µ ˜± ∗ exp iκA˙ gµ κBx Υ (κ,κ ). (11) volves the derivatives with| respect to the auxiliary spino- × ∓ A h i rial argument η . Derivatives with respect to the com- General solutions are sums of positive and negative fre- ponents of spinors also appear but in an entirely different quency solutions. It is shown in the next Section that role in the solutions of the massless wave equations ex- the spinorial representation through the Hopf fibration pressed in terms of Penrose transforms [18]. is directly related to the Fourier representation that is The first derivative is a solution of the Weyl equation, commonly used in physical applications. The alternative ˙ representation based on the Penrose transform [18] does φ (x)= i∂ Υ(η, η∗ x), gµEC ∂ φ (x)=0. (7) C C | µ C not have this property. 3 III. SPINORIAL REPRESENTATION AND ξi kx, ky, kz, ϕ is equal to 1/8k and the integral (11) THE HOPF FIBRATION expressed→{ in terms} of new variables coincides with (14) provided we make the following identification: The Hopf fibration [11] is a decomposition of the three- 2π 2 + dimensional sphere into linked circles: the fibers. Every π 3/2 e iϕΥ˜ (k, ϕ) f+(k)= dϕ , (15a) fiber corresponds to one point on the two-dimensional 2 0 k(k ik ) Z x − y sphere. In the Hopf construction the spheres are 3 2 2π 2iϕ − ∗ π / e Υ˜ (k, ϕ) parametrized in terms of the Cartesian coordinates sub- f−(k)= dϕ .