Document No: STM_ID5.3.4. Title: STM Validation Use Cases Results (final information report from test beds) Date: 2019-06-30 DOCUMENT STATUS Authors Name Organisation Lucía Calabria Tasa Fundación Valenciaport Jorge Lara López Fundación Valenciaport Jose Andrés Giménez Maldonado Fundación Valenciaport Jordi Arjona Aroca Fundación Valenciaport Núria Alonso I García Fundación Valenciaport Review Name Organisation Approval Name Organisation Signature Date Document History Version Date Status Initials Description TEN-T PROJECT NO: 2014-EU-TM-0206-S The sole responsibility of this publication lies with the author. The European Union is not responsible for any use that may be made of the information contained therein. STM VALIDATION 5.3.4 – STM VALIDATION USE CASES 1 ANALYSIS Table of contents 1 ABSTRACT .................................................................................................................... 5 2 INITIAL PROJECT HYPOTHESES VALIDATION .......................................................... 5 3 USE CASES STUDY METHODOLOGY ......................................................................... 7 1.1 Selection of Use Cases ........................................................................................... 7 1.1.1 STM Fleet ........................................................................................................ 7 1.1.2 Use Cases and ships selection criteria ............................................................11 1.1.3 Use Case specific motivations .........................................................................12 1.2 Data used in the analysis .......................................................................................21 1.3 Data processing .....................................................................................................22 1.3.1 Baseline static data: VESSL Database Sources ..............................................22 1.3.2 Initial data processing ......................................................................................23 1.4 Efficiency analysis: demonstrating the need for STM .............................................28 1.4.1 Speed variation ...............................................................................................28 1.4.2 ETA / ATA Deviation .......................................................................................30 1.4.3 Anchoring time ................................................................................................32 1.5 Environmental Sustainability Analysis ....................................................................33 1.5.1 Scenario 1: An improved synchronization between ships and ports ................33 1.5.2 Scenario 2: An advanced PortCDM deployment ..............................................34 1.5.3 Scenario 3: STM in operation. Adapting the ship cruising speeds. ..................35 1.5.4 Fuel consumption and GHG emissions analysis ..............................................36 1.5.5 Impact on navigation time ...............................................................................38 4 STM MACRO EVALUATION METHODOLOGY ............................................................38 5 USE CASES RESULTS ................................................................................................45 5.1 Use Case CS1 .......................................................................................................45 5.1.1 Abstract ...........................................................................................................45 5.1.2 Use Case Data ................................................................................................45 5.1.3 Use Case Analysis ..........................................................................................45 5.1.4 Use Case Evaluation .......................................................................................53 9.2 Use Case CS2 .......................................................................................................55 9.2.1 Abstract ...........................................................................................................55 9.2.2 Use Case Data ................................................................................................55 9.2.3 Use Case Analysis ..........................................................................................55 9.2.4 Use Case Evaluation .......................................................................................65 9.3 Use Case CS3 .......................................................................................................67 9.3.1 Abstract ...........................................................................................................67 STM VALIDATION 5.3.4 – STM VALIDATION USE CASES 2 ANALYSIS 9.3.2 Use Case Data ................................................................................................67 9.3.3 Use Case Analysis ..........................................................................................68 9.3.4 Use Case Evaluation .......................................................................................75 9.4 Containerships Use Cases Comparison .................................................................79 9.5 Use Case PAX1 .....................................................................................................81 9.5.1 Abstract ...........................................................................................................81 9.5.2 Use Case Data ................................................................................................81 9.5.3 Use Case Analysis ..........................................................................................82 9.5.4 Use Case Evaluation .......................................................................................88 9.6 Use Case RPX1 .....................................................................................................89 9.6.1 Abstract ...........................................................................................................89 9.6.2 Use Case Data ................................................................................................89 9.6.3 Use Case Analysis ..........................................................................................89 9.6.4 Use Case Evaluation .......................................................................................97 9.7 Use Case RPX2 .....................................................................................................99 9.7.1 Abstract ...........................................................................................................99 9.7.2 Use Case Data ................................................................................................99 9.7.3 Use Case Analysis ..........................................................................................99 9.7.4 Use Case Evaluation ..................................................................................... 106 9.8 Use Case RPX3 ................................................................................................... 108 9.8.1 Abstract ......................................................................................................... 108 9.8.2 Use Case Data .............................................................................................. 108 9.8.3 Use Case Analysis ........................................................................................ 108 9.8.4 Use Case Evaluation ..................................................................................... 115 9.9 Ro-Pax Use Case Comparison ............................................................................ 117 9.10 Use Case RO1 ..................................................................................................... 118 9.10.1 Abstract ......................................................................................................... 118 9.10.2 Use Case Data .............................................................................................. 118 9.10.3 Use Case Analysis ........................................................................................ 118 9.10.4 Use Case Evaluation ..................................................................................... 126 9.11 Use Case RO2 ..................................................................................................... 128 9.11.1 Abstract ......................................................................................................... 128 9.11.2 Use Case Data .............................................................................................. 128 9.11.3 Use Case Analysis ........................................................................................ 128 9.11.4 Use Case Evaluation ..................................................................................... 138 9.12 Use Case RO3 ..................................................................................................... 140 9.12.1 Abstract ......................................................................................................... 140 9.12.2 Use Case Data .............................................................................................. 140 9.12.3 Use Case Analysis ........................................................................................ 140 STM VALIDATION 5.3.4 – STM VALIDATION USE CASES 3 ANALYSIS 9.12.4 Use Case Evaluation