‘“Like a wail from the tomb, / But of world-waking power”: James Clarence Mangan’s “A Vision: A. D. 1848”, The Great Famine and the Young Ireland Rising’ Item Type Book chapter Authors Fegan, Melissa Citation In K. Boardman, & C. Kinealy (Eds.), 1848: The year the world turned? (pp. 210-224). Newcastle: Cambridge Scholars, 2007. Publisher Cambridge Scholars Download date 01/10/2021 05:52:15 Link to Item http://hdl.handle.net/10034/344444 This work has been submitted to ChesterRep – the University of Chester’s online research repository http://chesterrep.openrepository.com Author(s): Melissa Fegan Title: ‘“Like a wail from the tomb, / But of world-waking power”: James Clarence Mangan’s “A Vision: A. D. 1848”, The Great Famine and the Young Ireland Rising’. Date: 2007 Originally published in: 1848: The year the world turned? Example citation: Fegan, M. (2007). ‘“Like a wail from the tomb, / But of world- waking power”: James Clarence Mangan’s “A Vision: A. D. 1848”, The Great Famine and the Young Ireland Rising’. In In K. Boardman, & C. Kinealy (Eds.), 1848: The year the world turned? (pp. 210-224). Newcastle, United Kingdom: Cambridge Scholars. Version of item: Author’s accepted manuscript. Published with the permission of Cambridge Scholars Publishing. Available at: http://hdl.handle.net/10034/344444 1 “Like a wail from the tomb, / But of world-waking power”: James Clarence Mangan’s “A Vision: A. D. 1848”, the Great Famine, and the Young Ireland Rising On 1 January 1848, the Nation, the leading Dublin nationalist newspaper, reviewed the horrors of 1847, the second full year of the Great Famine, which was to kill more than a million people. The Nation spoke of “massacres”, “the temporary prostration of the Irish people before its executioner, like a victim on the scaffold”, and the Coercion Bill. The one bright light, it continued, had been the growth of national feeling, both among the higher classes, and among Young Irelanders, who had broken away from O’Connell’s Repeal movement and founded the Irish Confederation (9). The article was accompanied by a poem, “A Voice of Encouragement: A New Year’s Lay”, by one of the Nation’s stalwarts, James Clarence Mangan. It would be difficult to imagine a less encouraging poem, or indeed one less like a lay. The second stanza outlines the horrors of the present: Friends! the gloom in the land, in our once bright land, grows deeper. Suffering, even to Death in its horriblest form, aboundeth; Through our black harvestless fields the peasant’s faint wail resoundeth. Hark to it even now!... The nightmare-oppressèd sleeper Gasping and struggling for life beneath his hideous bestrider, Seeth not, dreeth not, sight or terror more fearful or ghastly Than that poor paralysed slave! (Mangan: 1999, 17, ll. 9-15) Even so, things are about to get worse; the Trustful and Firm, Sage and Saintly, Patriots, Orators and Prophets of Ireland have lost faith, and sunk into degradation and abasement. Denied progress by centuries of colonization, the Irish are in fact degenerating: 2 Slavery debases the soul, yea reverses its primal nature. Long were our fathers bowed to the earth by fetters of iron – And, alas! WE inherit the failings and ills that environ Slaves like a dungeon-wall, and dwarf their natural stature. (ll. 49-52) The speaker calls on his compatriots to reverse the backward slide: “Follow your destiny up!” (l. 41) By working, writing and preaching they can redeem their countrymen. But the final stanza is ominous and apocalyptic: Omen-full, arched with gloom, and laden with many a presage, Many a portent of woe, looms the Impending Era. Not, as of old, by Comet-sword, Gorgon, or ghastly Chimera, Scarcely by Lightning and Thunder, Heaven to-day sends its message. Into the secret heart – down through the caves of the spirit, Pierces the silent Shaft – sinks the invisible Token – Cloaked in the Hall the Envoy stands, his mission unspoken, While the pale banquetless guests await in trembling to hear it. (ll. 65-72) In many ways “A Voice of Encouragement” is typical of Mangan’s poems of exhortation in the Nation. He rarely foresees success for his friends and compatriots; instead, they must be prepared to fulfil their predestined role as sacrificial victims to pave the way for possible success in a future generation of Irish nationalists. In “The Warning Voice”, published in the Nation in February 1846, he forecasts a coming era of Knowledge and Peace, but warns the present generation: On you its beams glow not – For you its flowers blow not! You cannot rejoice in its light, But in darkness and suffering instead 3 You go down to the place of the Dead! To this generation, The stormy commotion, And foam of the Popular Ocean, The struggle of class against class; The Dearth and the Sadness, The Sword and the War-vest; To the next, the Repose and the Gladness, “The sea of clear glass,” And the rich Golden Harvest! (Mangan: 1997, 134, ll. 61-75) The next generation will achieve the “sea of clear glass” of the Book of Revelation: “and I saw as it were a sea of glass mingled with fire: and them that had gotten the victory over the beast, and over his image, and over his mark, and over the number of his name, stand on the sea of glass” (Rev. 15:2). But this generation must accept merely the “foam of the Popular Ocean”, do their duty and die. “A Voice of Encouragement” also acknowledges Mangan’s own position on the periphery of the struggle for liberty. In the first stanza he admits his unfitness for the role of rebel: You, young men, would a man unworthy to rank in your number, Yet with a heart that bleeds for his country’s wrongs and affliction, Fain raise a Voice to in Song, albeit his music and diction Rather be fitted, alas! to lull to, than startle from, slumber. (ll. 5-8) His desire to play a part, and very real sense of pain at the horrors he had witnessed over the years of famine, are balanced against the realisation that the “young men” of Young Ireland outrank him. In the autobiographical “The Nameless One”, published 4 posthumously but written in 1848, Mangan describes himself as “Old and hoary / At thirty-nine” (Mangan, 1999, 224, ll. 49-50); he was in fact 45, reflecting his consistent excision of 6 years from his age. Three years earlier he wrote to James McGlashan, editor of the Dublin University Magazine: “I suppose, en passant, that you imagine me an old man. I am 36 years of age in point of time” (Mangan, 2002b, 277). Mangan’s biographer, Ellen Shannon-Mangan, has argued that the loss of six years from his age was due to a suppressed childhood trauma (12), but it is clearly also related to the uncomfortable proximity of the virile youths of Young Ireland. His own physical weakness is often foregrounded in poems in which he calls on the Youth of Ireland to rise: in “For Soul and Country”, published in 1849, he cries: My countrymen! my words are weak, My health is gone, my soul is dark, My heart is chill – (Mangan: 1999, 123, ll. 49-51). Any role he could play was going to be limited. Mangan knew he was an unlikely rebel. While some of his earliest poems were published in the Comet, founded as part of the nationalist anti-tithe campaign, this was in part a matter of necessity, given how few publishing opportunities were available, and Mangan’s contributions tended to be comic charades and enigmas. In the 1830s and 1840s he worked for some of the bastions of the Union in Ireland: the Dublin University Magazine, Trinity College Dublin, and the Ordnance Survey. In 1832 the 29-year-old Mangan wrote a long letter to his friend Tynan, meditating on his political apathy: [M]y conclusion is this: that political liberty is not worth a bag of chaff. […] If I were to-morrow to enter into possession of all the advantages that the best of good governments have been able to bestow, I would feel precisely as an 5 individual would, who, suffering under a complication of maladies, gout, palsy, stone, phythisis, scrofula, cancer, dropsy, cholic, catarrh, epilepsy, erysipelas, &c. &c. should find himself one morning freed from a little wen upon his thumb. […] I should myself like a revolution better than you think, especially if it produced a general transfer of property and I had any prospect of robbing somebody, for my finances are too low for my ideas, which are of the princeliest. A revolution, besides, creates an extensive hubbub, a thing I am occasionally partial to, and exceedingly so whenever I see any likelihood of making anything by it. (Mangan: 2002b, 246-8) At this stage he can see nothing altruistic in revolution; it is merely another form of self-absorption: “I think the man who labours to earn the price of a pair of boots for himself proportionably entitled to as many encomiums as the man who kills other people that he may procure freedom for himself. Depend upon it that Self is at the bottom of every struggle” (245). In 1840 he wrote to Charles Gavan Duffy, then editor of the Belfast Vindicator, later editor of The Nation and one of the leaders of Young Ireland: “Don’t ask me for political articles just now. I have had no experience in that genre d’écrire and I should infallibly blunder” (258). Duffy later commented: “At this time he knew nothing of politics and cared nothing for them, and he averted his eyes from Irish history as from a painful and humiliating spectacle” (“Personal Memories” 286).