Table 1. NRHP-Listed Historic Districts in the APE. Period of Style and Type of Significance/ Date Listed/ NRHP No. Name of Resource Building or Dates of Criteria Structure Construction Residential, Commercial: Queen Listed 1983 Herron-Morton Place NR-0438 ca. 1880–1920 Anne, Classic Revival, (NR-0438), Historic District Tudor Revival, Criteria A and C American Foursquare Listed 1978 Residential: Italianate, (NR-0157) and NR-0157 and Old Northside Historic Second Empire, ca. 1850–1941 expanded 1984 NR-0716 District Queen Anne, Stick, (NR-0716), Colonial Revival Criteria A and C Saint Joseph Residential, Listed 1991 NR-0926 Neighborhood Historic ca. 1855–1930 Commercial, (NR-0926), District Industrial Criteria A and C Residential, Listed 1980 Chatham-Arch Historic NR-0327 1865–1941 Commercial, (NR-0327), District Industrial Criteria A and C Massachusetts Avenue Listed 1982 NR-0525 Commercial Historic 1865–1930 Commercial (NR-0525), District Criteria A and C Listed 1973 (NR-2030) and NR-0853 and Lockerbie Square Predominantly 1855–1930 expanded 1987 NR-2030 Historic District Residential (NR-0853), Criteria A and C Listed 1982 Fletcher Place Historic Predominantly NR-0355 1855–1924 (NR-0355), District Residential Criteria A and C Listed 1990 Cottage Home Historic Predominantly NR-0965 1870–1939 (NR-0965), District Residential Criterion C Listed 1976 Arsenal Technical High NR-0084 Various (NR-0084), School Historic District Criteria A and C Listed 2003 Indianapolis Park and NR-1711 1873–1952 Beaux Arts (NR-1711), Boulevard System Criteria A and C 12 Table 2. Individually Listed NRHP Resources in the APE. Name and Address of Date(s) of Style and Type of Date Listed/ NRHP No. Resource Construction Building or Structure Criteria Indianapolis Public Listed 2016, NR-2410 Library Branch No. 6, 1912 Craftsman Criteria A and C 1801 Nowland Avenue Prosser House, Listed 1975, NR-0090 1885 Cross gable house 1454 E. 10th Street Criterion C Bals-Wocher House, Listed 1979, NR-0146 1870 Italianate 951 N. Delaware Street Criteria B and C Wyndham, Tudor Revival Listed 1983, NR-0616.33 1929 1040 N. Delaware Street Apartment Building Criteria A and C Pierson-Griffiths House Italianate/Greek Listed 1978, NR-0203 (Kemper House), 1873 Revival House Criterion C 1028 N. Delaware Street Calvin I. Fletcher House, Listed 1984, NR-0694 1031 N. Pennsylvania 1895 Queen Anne House Criteria B and C Street Pennsylvania Apartments, Listed 1983, NR-0616.26 919 N. Pennsylvania 1906 Neoclassical Criteria A and C Street The Myrtle Fern, Twentieth Century Listed 1983, NR-0616.25 ca. 1925 221 E. 9th Street Functional Criteria A and C The Shelton, Twentieth Century Listed 1983, NR-0616.23 1925 825 N. Delaware Street Functional Criteria A and C Cathcart Apartments, Listed 1983, NR-0616.09 1909 Craftsman 103 E. 9th Street Criteria A and C Lodge Apartments, Listed 1983, NR-0616.19 829 N. Pennsylvania 1905 Neoclassical Criteria A and C Street Plaza Apartments, Listed 1983, NR-0616.27 902 N. Pennsylvania 1907 Neoclassical Criteria A and C Street The Ambassador, Mediterranean Listed 1983, NR-0616.03 1923 39 E. 9th Street Revival/Sullivanesque Criteria A and C Central Library of Listed 1975, NR-0085 Indianapolis-Marion 1914–1917 Neoclassical Criterion C County Public Library The Burton, Spanish Colonial Listed 1983, NR-0616.08 821–823 N. Pennsylvania ca. 1920 Revival Criteria A and C Street The Vera and The Olga, Twentieth Century Listed 1984, NR-0725 1440–1446 N. Illinois 1901 Functional Criterion C Street Independent Turnverein, Prairie/Renaissance Listed 1983, NR-0641 1914 902 N. Meridian Street Revival Criteria A and C Cole Motor Car Listed 1983, NR-0332 Company, 1904 The Commercial Style Criterion A 730 E. Washington Street Gaseteria, Inc., Listed 2013, NR-2266 ca. 1925 Art Moderne 1031 E. Washington St. Criteria B & C 13 Table 2. Individually Listed NRHP Resources in the APE. Name and Address of Date(s) of Style and Type of Date Listed/ NRHP No. Resource Construction Building or Structure Criteria Manchester Apartments, Listed 1998, NR-1406 960–962 N. Pennsylvania 1929 Tudor Revival Criterion C Street Sheffield Inn, Listed 1998, NR-1373 956–958 N. Pennsylvania 1927 Tudor Revival Criterion C Street Delaware Court, Tudor Revival Listed 1983, NR-0616.11 1917 1005 N. Delaware Street Apartment Building Criteria A and C The Spink (Renaissance Listed 1983, NR-0616.28 Tower Historic Inn), ca. 1922 Jacobethan Revival Criteria A and C 230 E. 9th Street William Buschman Block, Italianate Commercial Listed 1988, NR-0897 ca. 1879 968–972 Fort Wayne Building Criteria B and C Avenue Morris-Butler House, Listed 1973, NR-2027 1864 Second Empire 1204 N. Park Avenue Criterion C John W. Schmidt House Listed 1973, NR-2043 (The Propylaeum), 1875 Tudor Revival Criteria A and C 1410 N. Delaware St. Pearson Terrace, Listed 1984, NR-0695 928–940 N. Alabama 1902 Jacobethan Revival Criterion C Street Table 3. NRHP Determined Eligible Resource in the APE. Name and Address of Date(s) of Date NRHP No. Style(s) of Resource Resource Construction Listed/Criteria Martin Luther King, Jr. Park, Determined 17th Street to 21st Street N/A 1961 N/A Eligible 2017, (S to N) and Park Criteria A and B Avenue to Broadway Street (W to E) 14 Table 4. IRHSS Resources in the APE. Name and Address of Date(s) of Date NRHP No. Style(s) of Resource Resource Construction Listed/Criteria School #27 – Charity Dye Elementary Listed 2000, NR-1560* ca. 1882 Italianate School, Criteria A and C 545 E. 17th Street Anheuser Busch Saloon/Gally, Julius, Wines & Cigars, 942 Fort Wayne Listed 1980, NR-0422 ca. 1904 Neoclassical Avenue, Criteria A and C Saint Joseph Neighborhood NRHP District General Motors Buick Showroom Building, Listed 1989, NR-0956 1923 Neo-Classical Revival 1302 N. Meridian Criteria A and C Street Holy Cross/ Residential: Various Listed 1984 NR-0653* Westminster Historic 1860–1943 Styles Criteria A and C District *Properties listed in the IRHSS but not the NRHP are assigned NRHP numbers. Table 5. National Historic Landmarks in the APE. Name and Address of Date(s) of Date NRHP No. Style Resource Construction Listed/Criteria NHL Listed Benjamin Harrison 1964, NRHP NR-2066 Home/Presidential Site, 1874–1875 Italianate Listed 1966, 1230 N. Delaware Street Criteria A, B, and C NHL Listed James Whitcomb Riley 1962, NRHP NR-2067 House, 1872 Italianate Listed 1966, 528 Lockerbie Street Criteria A and B 15 Table 6. Previously Recorded Bridges in the APE. Name and Location of Date(s) of Style and Type of HB No. Status Resource Construction Building or Structure Contributing, Marion County Bridge Indianapolis B-25-18-L, HB-1071 ca. 1915 Plate Girder Park and Newman Street over Boulevard Pogue’s Run NRHP District Contributing, Marion County Bridge Indianapolis 2517, HB-2610 1911 Filled Spandrel Arch Park and Commerce Avenue Boulevard over Pogue’s Run NRHP District Contributing, Spades Place Indianapolis Footbridge, HB-2591 1907 Filled Spandrel Arch Park and Spades Place path over Boulevard Pogue’s Run NRHP District Marion County Bridge Recommended No. 2520L, N. Oriental Continuous Reinforced N/A pre-1940 Eligible, Street over Pogue’s Concrete Slab Criterion C Run Marion County Bridge 2521, HB-2611 1911 Concrete Slab Demolished E. North Street over Pogue’s Run Marion County Bridge 2511, HB-2189 1910 Concrete Slab Demolished Dorman Street over Pogue’s Run Marion County Bridge 2510, HB-2608 1917 Concrete Beam Demolished Michigan Street over Pogue’s Run Table 7. Recommended NRHP Eligible Resources in the APE. Name and Address of Date(s) of IHSSI # Style Rating Resource Construction John Hope School No. 26, 098-296-01212 1921 Neoclassical N; Criterion C 1301 E. 16th Street James E. Roberts School Art Moderne/Art Criteria A and 098-296-01220 No. 97, 1936 Deco C 1401 E. 10th Street School #27–Charity Dye N and 098-296-01309 Elementary School, 1882 Italianate IRHSS/Criteria and NR-1560 545 E. 17th Street A and C Knights of Pythias, 098-296-01378 1925 Gothic Revival O; Criterion C 941 N. Meridian Street 16 Table 7. Recommended NRHP Eligible Resources in the APE. Name and Address of Date(s) of IHSSI # Style Rating Resource Construction Fame Laundry, 098-296-01421 1929 Neoclassical N; Criterion C 1352 N. Illinois Street Stutz Motor Car Company, O; Criteria A 098-296-01426 1002–1008 N. Capital 1914 Commercial Style and C Avenue St. Rita’s Catholic Church Criterion A and Parish Complex, Mid-Century Criteria N/A 1959 1733 Dr. Andrew J. Brown Modern Consideration Avenue A Table 8. Recommended NRHP Eligible Historic Districts in the APE. Name and Address of Date(s) of NRHP No. Style Criteria Resource Construction Saints Peter and Paul Neoclassical, Italian N/A Cathedral Parish Historic 1891-1927 Criterion A Renaissance Revival District Windsor Park N/A 1880 – 1920 Folk Victorian Criterion C Neighborhood HISTORIC MAP ANALYSIS As a major urban area, the portion of Indianapolis within and adjacent to the project area has been thoroughly documented with historic map resources. As a sample, this HPR has included the Sanborn Map Company’s Fire Insurance Maps for Indianapolis for the years 1914–1915 with the project area overlain on the map (Sanborn Map Company 1914–1915). The map shows that most of the project area was thoroughly urbanized at that time. In the north and west portions of the project area, residential neighborhoods were continuous across what later became the route of the interstate. Only in the northeastern end of the project area, east of Roosevelt Avenue/Commerce Avenue, was there any significant area of vacant land. A railroad line along the east side of the project area had drawn a large amount of industrial development to that corridor, extending to and across the south end of the project area.