Rinzai Zen Hakuin (1685-1768) Shidō Munan's Dharma grandson, Hakuin Ekaku, had enough talent for three people—three rather different people—and he exercised it with an abandon that seems reckless, sometimes damaging his own health. Above all, he was a follower, lover, teacher and protector of the Way, blazing with ardor, demanding that fellow monks and masters pursue the Dharma strictly, purely to the limit. To the folk of his province, he presented another face: warm brimming with humor, to minister to their needs with great empathy and flexibility. The rich and powerful experienced a third Hakuin, a man with deep concern, more typically Confucian than Buddhist, for peaceful maintenance of the social order. In all three roles he displayed a sharp intelligence, a sensitive and passionate nature, and a wild streak of creative genius that lent sparkle to his teachings and made him a brilliant calligrapher, painter, and writer. Like Munan's, Hakuin's family operated a post station on the Tōkaidō highway, theirs being located near Mt. Fuji, about halfway between the capitals of Kyoto and Edo. Accounts of his early years depict a boy struck by the Daruma (Bodhidarma) by Hakuin ephemerality of clouds, terrified of falling into hell, wondrous in his powers of recall, and much taken with religious ritual. At fourteen, he began reading Buddhist texts at a Zen temple that his family had long helped support and there received, as his first Zen book, an anthology of capping phrases still used today in Rinzai koan study. His long and eventful career formally commenced some months later, when his head was shaved in a ceremony at this same temple, Shōin-ji. For most of the ensuing eighteen years, he would be occupied elsewhere—training in other temples, on pilgrimage, studying Chinese literature, in seclusion—but he always returned to Shōin-ji. It was his home temple and, quite exceptionally, remained so; he did most of his teaching at this rural site and died there, the most famous master of his day and the greatest in modern Rinzai history. Hakuin's biography abounds with dramatic episodes, a fact attributable probably in equal parts to the headlong, do-or-die quality of his practice and to the uses he made of his story, citing it for inspirational value in his writings and lectures. We have little information from other sources about his first fifty years and thus have little choice but to accept Hakuin's, judiciously. He describes an initial breakthrough at age twenty-three, after two lesser openings and several days of such profound absorption in the koan mu that he "forgot both to eat and rest." Thus immersed, he felt sometimes as though he "were frozen solid in the midst of an ice sheet extending tens of thousands of miles," other times as though he "were floating through the air." Suddenly the booming of the temple bell brought him to, "as if a sheet of ice had been smashed or a jade tower had fallen with a crash." But with the dissolution of his doubt came another challenge, recognized on reflection: "my pride soared up like a majestic mountain, my arrogance surged forward like the tide. Smugly I thought to myself: "in the past two or three hundred years no one could have accomplished such a marvelous breakthrough as this." Philosophy of Zen Rinzai Zen—2 At this juncture, "shouldering my glorious enlightenment," he went off to meet a master of whom he had heard great things—Munan's lone heir, Dōkyō Etan (1642-1721), better known as Shōju Rōjin, the old man of Shōju. This eccentric teacher, who lived in the mountains with his aged mother and a few dedicated students, swiftly that the air out of Hakuin's balloon: "How do you understand Chao-chou's mu? the master asked him. "Where is mu such that one could put arms and legs on it?" he replied. The Old Man abruptly twisted Hakuin's nose, declaring, "Here's somewhere to put arms and legs!" Getting no response, he guffawed and exclaimed, "You poor, pit-dwelling devil! Do you suppose somehow you have sufficient understanding?" From that time on, Shōju Rōjin hounded Hakuin, calling him a pit-dwelling devil whenever they met, much as T'ou-tzu had berated Hsüeh-feng for being a black lacquer bucket almost a millennium before. Hakuin redoubled his efforts, and one day, as he sought alms in a nearby town, and attack by a broom-wielding madman precipitated a realization that the Old Man found persuasive. The two continued rigorous studies together for another six months or so, and though no ceremony of transmission is recorded, Hakuin has always been counted as Shōju Rōjin's heir. In later years, Hakuin quoted his master's counsel on many things, among them the necessity for stringent, extended post-enlightenment practice. He went about this period of maturation with his customary zeal and, in the process, fell into an illness that one Rinzai authority termed "a severe nervous breakdown." Hakuin later described acute burning sensations in his head and chest, chills in his legs, and in his ears "a rushing sound as of a stream in a valley. My courage failed and I was in an attitude of constant fear. I felt spiritually exhausted, night and day seeing dreams, my armpits always wet with sweat and my eyes full of tears." When conventional remedies proved fruitless, he consulted a cave dwelling practitioner of Chinese medicine (formerly a disciple of Ishikawa Jōzan), who taught him meditative techniques by which he eventually cured himself of this "Zen sickness." Further pilgrimage and a nearly two-year seclusion ended in 1717, when Hakuin's father called him home, urging that he restore now-deserted Shōin-ji. He accepted this request in the spirit of filial piety, installing himself as the temple's abbot and fixing it up with the help of a few disciples. Yet he pushed himself as relentlessly as ever in his practice: When darkness fell he would climb inside a derelict old palanquin and seat himself on a cushion he placed on the floorboard. One of the young boys studying at the temple would come, wrap the master's body in a futon, and cinch him up tightly into this position with ropes. There he would remain motionless . until the following day when the boy would come to untie him so that he could relieve his bowels and take some food. The same routine was repeated nightly. In 1726, these draconian measures paid off in an experience, triggered by the hum of a cricket, that caused tears to spill down his cheeks "like beans pouring from a ruptured sack." This time Hakuin found lasting peace and turned his energies to teaching for the next forty years. Not long after reopening Shōin-ji, Hakuin had been honored with a three-month appointment as head monk at Myōshin-ji, but his reputation took time to develop, even when teaching became his first priority. As late as 1736, records show, only eight resident monks and twenty-two visitors attended a series of talks he delivered at Shōin-ji. The following year, for the first time, he was invited to speak elsewhere—at a temple in a neighboring province—and the curve of his fame steeped thereafter. A turning point appears to have come in 1740, when four Philosophy of Zen Rinzai Zen—3 hundred monks from all across Japan congregated at Shōin-ji to hear such blistering lectures as "Licking up Hsi-keng's Fox Slobber" and "The True and Untransmittable Dharma." During this special gathering of 1740 and in his subsequent work, Hakuin fulminated against the laxity in Zen training that he had witnessed in his years of roaming and inveighed against specific errors that he found evident in latter-day Ch'an writings as well as in Japanese monasteries. Integration of the Pure Land nembutsu practice into Zen training, as promoted by the Obaku sect, came in for especially scathing criticism. Quoting texts and naming names, Hakuin excoriated teachers who expressed a literalistic understanding of rebirth in the Pure Land, likening them to "a troop of blind Persian who stumble upon a parchment leaf inscribed with Sanskrit letters . and attempt to decipher the meaning of the text, but not having the faintest idea what it says, they fail to even get a single word right, and turn themselves into laughingstocks in the bargain." Adopting Pure Land recitation, he warned, would sap the vitality of their already imperiled tradition, producing even the most promising Zen students to "sitting in the shade next to the pond with listless old grannies, dropping their heads and closing their eyes in broad daylight and intoning endless choruses of nembutsu." Contradictory as it may seem, Hakuin elsewhere recommended nembutsu practice. He viewed it as good and useful in its own right for those who lack the aspiration or the ability to undertake Zen training. In making his criticisms of Pure Land Buddhism, he said, "I am not referring to those wise saints, motivated by the working of the universal vow of great compassion, who wish to extend the benefits of salvation to people of lesser capabilities." He enthusiastically quotes Tenkei Denson, a highly regarded Sōtō master of the previous generation, on undesirability of crossing the sects: "Adding Pure Land to Zen is like depriving a cat of its eyes. Adding Zen to Pure Land is like raising a sail on the back of a cow." Hakuin also revived Ta-hui's old campaign against the evils of "silent elimination," which he considered less a matter of adherence to a specific method than a crucial and common failure of insight.