Canadian Military History Volume 19 Issue 4 Article 1 2010 Table of Contents Follow this and additional works at: https://scholars.wlu.ca/cmh Recommended Citation "Table of Contents." Canadian Military History 19, 4 (2010) This Table of Contents is brought to you for free and open access by Scholars Commons @ Laurier. It has been accepted for inclusion in Canadian Military History by an authorized editor of Scholars Commons @ Laurier. For more information, please contact [email protected]. et al.: Table of Contents CANADIAN MILITARY HISTORY Volume 19, Number 4 Autumn 2010 CANADIAN MILITARY HISTORY Articles Wilfrid Laurier University, Waterloo, Ontario, N2L 3C5, CANADA “But he has nothing on at all!”: Canada and the Phone: (519) 884-0710 ext.4594 5 Iraq War, 2003 Fax: (519) 886-5057 Timothy A. Sayle Email: [email protected] www.canadianmilitaryhistory.com Camaraderie, Morale and Material Culture: 20 Reflections on the Nose Art of No.6 ISSN 1195-8472 Group Royal Canadian Air Force Agreement No.0040064165 Publication mail registration no.08978 Caitlin McWilliams What was the point?: Raiding in the Summer 31 of 1917 Canadian Military History is published four times a year in the winter, spring, summer and autumn by the Laurier Geoffrey Jackson Centre for Military Strategic and Disarmament Studies, Wilfrid Laurier University. Editor-in-Chief Roger Sarty Managing Editor Mike Bechthold Book Review Supplement Editor Jonathan F. Vance Layout & Design Mike Bechthold Canada’s Work for Wounded Soldiers on Film CMH Editorial Board 41 Suzanne Evans David Bashow, Serge Bernier, Laura Brandon, Patrick Brennan, Isabel Campbell, Tim Cook, Donald Kenneth Anderson: Official War Artist Terry Copp, Serge Durflinger, Michel Fortmann, (1920-2009) Andrew Godefroy, John Grodzinski, David Hall, 50 Steve Harris, Geoffrey Hayes, Jack Hyatt, Whitney Hugh Halliday Lackenbauer, Marc Milner, Elinor Sloan, Jonathan F. Vance, Randy Wakelam, Lee Windsor. Printed in Canada by E GRAPHICS GROUP, Features Kitchener, Ontario A Loyalist’s War: Private Lewis Fisher in the 57 American Revolution, 1775-1783 Robert C. Fisher The Problem of Religion in Canadian Forces Subscription Information Canada: One year (4 issues): $40.00 68 Postings: Liebmann vs the Minister of International: One year (4 issues): US$55.00 National Defence et al. Subscriptions are handled by J.L. Granatstein Wilfrid Laurier University Press. Order or Renew online at: Admiral Kingsmill and the Early Years of the http://www.wlupress.wlu.ca/press/Journals/cmh/ 75 Royal Canadian Navy – Part III Order or Renew by phone at: (519) 884-0710 ext.6124 Roger Sarty We acknowledge the financial support of the Government of Canada, through the Publications Other Matters Assistance Program toward our mailing costs. 2 From the Editor-in-Chief Published by Scholars Commons @ Laurier, 2010 1 Contents - Autumn 2010.indd 1 1/28/2011 11:46:46 AM Canadian Military History, Vol. 19 [2010], Iss. 4, Art. 1 From the at the National Archives, as it then not converted capitalization and other Editor-in-Chief was. He has always cultivated a wide such details to the journal’s style.) range of interests, including family Suzanne Evans of the Canadian history, both as a professional pursuit War Museum continues her work on he articles and features in the in archival science and to investigate the rehabilitation of injured veterans Tpresent issue cover subjects from his own ancestry. Here he combines of the First World War with an the time of the American Revolution these interests with his training in investigation into a pioneering series to the US invasion of Iraq in 2003, treat military history to tell the story of of films produced by the Department naval, air, and ground forces, and one of his forebears who fought with of Soldiers Civil Re-establishment in probe the wider cultural dimensions the loyalist forces in the American 1918. Suzanne sets her research in the of armed conflict. Much as the Revolution, an aspect of that conflict context of the history of Canadian Laurier Centre is committed to this not well developed in the literature. film, and also the use of film by chronological breadth and diversity G e offrey Jackson, a PhD the Canadian, British and German of subjects, credit for the achievement candidate in Military and Strategic governments as a medium for public must go to the wide interests of our Studies at the University of Calgary, information. The Canadian War established and new contributors. joins in the debate about the purpose Museum section includes an obituary Timothy Sayle, a Canadian PhD and usefulness of trench raids during on Donald Kenneth Anderson, the candidate at Temple University the First World War with a study of Royal Canadian Air Force official war in Philadelphia, has produced a the extensive raiding program the 4th artist. The piece updates a substantial, revisionist account of Canada’s Canadian Division carried out before previously unpublished, biographical decision not to participate in the US the assault on Lens and Hill 70 in the study of Anderson by Hugh Halliday, led invasion of Iraq in 2003. The piece summer of 1917. Readers may recall former curator of war art at the traces the diplomatic action in Ottawa, Geoffrey’s article on the Canadian museum, a prominent historian of Section (CFSU (O)) SU2010-0533-01 Photo Support (Ottawa) Unit Canadian Forces New York, Washington and London Corps’s attack on Lens that appeared aviation and, more recently, honours on the basis of interviews with several in Vol.17, no.1 (Winter 2008). and awards in the Canadian forces, Clockwise from top left: of the key participants, and the Caitlin McWilliams, a graduate well known to readers of the journal. Admiral Kingsmill’s gravestone in the cemetery of recently published memoirs of others. student at Wilfrid Laurier, has been This issue also includes the Emmanuel Anglican Church; the honour guard from Of particular interest is material working on the cultural aspects of the third and final instalment of a series Naval League Cadet Corps Vice-Admiral Kingsmill and on the assessment by Canadian Canadian air effort during the Second of documents I selected to support Royal Canadian Sea Cadet Corps Falkland, both of Ottawa; the unveiling of the plaque while Vice-Admiral the Ontario government’s creation intelligence of privileged information World War. The article presented Dean McFadden, chief of the maritime staff looks from the US on Iraq’s possession here grew from a presentation on of a memorial plaque placed at on from the left; the history contingent (from left): of weapons of mass destruction. aircraft nose art in No.6 (RCAF) the grave of Admiral Sir Charles Richard Gimblett, command historian of the Canadian Rob Fisher, a previous contributor Group, Bomber Command, that was Kingsmill, the first professional head Navy, Michael Whitby, navy team leader Directorate of to this journal, started his career at well received at Carleton University, of the Canadian navy. The present History and Heritage, NDHQ, W.A.B. Douglas, former Director General History, NDHQ, Diana Kingsmill Flynn, the Directorate of History where he and then at the military history document is something of a sustained the admiral’s grand-daughter, Roger Sarty, Michael carried out the bulk of the research colloquium at Laurier last May. diatribe Kingsmill dispatched to the Kingsmill, the admiral’s grandson; Guests from the and analysis on convoy operations in R e gular contributor J.L. British Admiralty in November 1917. Portland area, who shared their memories of the 1942 for the new official history of the Granatstein has kindly allowed Here is a string of complaints about Kingsmill family at the admiral’s beloved summer navy. Important results of his work publication of his brief in support of the contradictory advice Canada had home, and the naval community in eastern Ontario. appeared in CMH (“Tactics, Training, Lieutenant (N) Andrew S. Liebmann’s received about the U-boat threat to Technology: The RCN’s Summer case against the Crown for the east coast and Newfoundland, of Success, July-September 1942,” discrimination on religious grounds. and the meagre assistance provided Vol.6, no.2 (Autumn 1997), pp.7-20), Lieutenant Liebmann’s appointment despite the fact Canada had devoted and feature prominently in No Higher to the staff of the commander of the the major share of its war effort Purpose: The Official Operational Canadian contingent in the Persian to the raising of land forces on History of the Royal Canadian Navy in Gulf War was cancelled because he the assurance the Royal Navy the Second World War, 1939-1943, Vol. was Jewish. In the brief Jack sets the could provide maritime protection. II, Part 1 (Vanwell Publications and case in the context of other instances the Department of National Defence, of discrimination in the history of the Roger Sarty 2003). With the deep cuts at the Canadian forces. (We have treated the November 2010 CFSU (O) SU2010-0533-17 directorate in 1996, he won a position brief as an historical document, and https://scholars.wlu.ca/cmh/vol19/iss4/12 2 Contents - Autumn 2010.indd 2 1/28/2011 11:46:47 AM et al.: Table of Contents Unveiling of Historical Plaque in Honour of Admiral Sir Charles Kingsmill, Portland, Ontario, 15 May 2010 CFSU (O) SU2010-0533-03 Canadian Forces Support Unit (Ottawa) Photo Section (CFSU (O)) SU2010-0533-01 Photo Support (Ottawa) Unit Canadian Forces Clockwise from top left: Admiral Kingsmill’s gravestone in the cemetery of Emmanuel Anglican Church; the honour guard from CFSU (O) SU2010-0533-24 Naval League Cadet Corps Vice-Admiral Kingsmill and Royal Canadian Sea Cadet Corps Falkland, both of Ottawa; the unveiling of the plaque while Vice-Admiral Dean McFadden, chief of the maritime staff looks on from the left; the history contingent (from left): Richard Gimblett, command historian of the Canadian Navy, Michael Whitby, navy team leader Directorate of History and Heritage, NDHQ, W.A.B.