'l fOR RfFfRNCl: ONLY. Fourteenth Series, Vol. VIII, No. 16 Saturday, March 19, 2005 Phalguna 28, 1926 (Saka) LOK SABHA DEBATES (English Version) Fourth Session (Fourteenth Lok Sabha) I,.tic .. (Vol. VIII contains Nos. 11 to 20) Gazett~' £t Debeto, Unit Parliament Libl ary f3 u ilding Room No. FS-025 BIOM 'G' A()C. No ....••.•. 7 ............ O.. N ....... If/ofL4!S::::- LOK SABHA S{CAETARIAT NEW DELHI Price : Rs. 50.00 EDITORIAL BOARD G.C. Malhotra Secretary-General Lok Sabha Kifan Sahni Principal Chief Editor Harnam Oass Takker Chief Editor Parmesh Kumar Sharma Senior Editor S.S. Chauhan Assistant Editor (ORIGINAL ENGLISH PROCEEDINGS INCLUDED IN ENGLISH VERSION AND ORIGINAL HINDI PROCEEDINGS INCLUDED IN HINDI VERSION WILL BE TREATED AS AUTHORITATIVE AND NOT THE TRANSLATION THEREOF) CONTENTS (Fourteenth Series, Vol. VIII, Fourth Session, 200511926 (Saka) No. 18, Saturday, March 18, 2OO5IPhaiguna 28, 1928 (Satat) SUBJECT COLUMNS MESSAGE FROM THE PRESIDENT ....................................................................................................~ 1 STANDING COMMITTEE ON RURAL DEVELOPMENT Fifth to Eighth Reports .............. ................. ..................... ..... .................... ...................... .................... 1-2 BUSINESS OF THE HOUSE ....................... .............. ......... ........... ..................... .......... .......................... 3-4 ACTUARIES BILL. 2005 .......................................................................................................................... 5 STATUTORY RESOLUTION RE: APPROVAL OF PROCLAMATION BY THE PRESIDENT IN RELATION TO THE STATE OF BIHAR .............................................................. 12-142 Shri Shivraj V. Patil ..................................................................................................................,.... ........ 12-16. 130-142 Shri Nitish Kumar............................. ........... ............... ................................................ ..... ................... 16-41 Shir Nikhil Kumar ................................................................ ............................................................... 42-46 Shri Basu Deb Acharia................................................................................................................ ....... 46-51 Shri Devendra Prasad Yadav ......................................................................................._.... ............... 51-62 Shri Ramji Lal Suman ................... ......... ........ ...... ...................... ............ ........................................... 62-63 Shri llyes Azml................................................................................................................................... 63-65' Shri Ram Vilas Paswan........................ ............ .................... ........... ................ .................................. 65-67 Shri Sushi! Kumar Modi........ .............. ...... ....................... ......... ................... ....... ................... ............ 67-80 Shri Giridhar Garnang........ ................ ...................... .............. ............ ....... ....... .... .... ...... ... ... .............. 80-64 Shri Braja Kishor. Tripathy ...................................................................................................~............ 85-87 Shri Mohan Rawale ........................................................................................................................... 87-91 Shri C.K. Chandrappan....................................................................................................................... 91·92 Shri Prabhunath Singh .....................................................................................................................~ .. 92-98 Shri Klnjarapu Yerrannaldu ................................................................................................................ 98-101 SUBJECT COLUMNS Shri Lakshman Seth .......................................................................................................................... 101-102 Shri Sukdeo Paswan .... ............ ..... ..... ............................................................................................................... 102-1 04 Shrimati Tejaswini Seeramelh .......................................................... ;................................................................ 105-108 Shri Shailendra Kumar................................ ......... ........ ..................................................... ................................. 108-111 Shri Vijoy Krishna ......................................... ..................................................................................................... 111-115 Shrl Ravinder Naik Dharavath.............. ........................... ...... ....................... ..................................................... 115-117 Shri Nlkhil Kumar Choudhary ............................................................................................................................ 117-121 Shri B. Mahtab ................................................................................................................................................... 121-124 Shri AsacJ,Jt1dln Owalsl ...................................................................................................................................... 124-127 Prof. M. Ramadass........................................... .............. ....................................................................... ............ 127-130 BIHAR BUDGET, 2OO5-06-GENERAL DISCUSSION DEMANDS FOR GRANTS ON ACCOUNT (BIHAR)-2005-06 AND DEMANDS FOR SUPPLEMENTARY GRANTS (BIHAR)-2004-05......................................................................... 142-190 Shri Nitish Kumar................................................... ............................................................................................ 150-160 Shri Nlkhil Kumar............................................................................................................................................... '60-166 Shri Basu Deb Acharia ............................ ........................................................................................................ 166-170 Shri Raghunath Jha........................ .................... ............................................................................................... 170-177 Shrl Uday Singh................................................................................................................................................. 177-180 Shri Ram Kripal Yadav ....................................................................................................................................... 180" 183 Shri P. Chidambaram...................................................... ............. ...... .............. ................................................... 183-190 BIHAR APPROPRIATION (VOTE ON ACCOUNT) BILL. 2005 Motion to consider Shri P. Chidarnbaram......................................................................................................................................... 190 Clauses 2. 3 and 1 ............................................................................................................................................ 191 Motion to Pass ................................................................................................................................................... 191-192 BIHAR APPROPRIATION BILL, 2005 MotIon to conaider Shri P. Chldalnbaram ......................................................................................................................................... 192 Claueea 2. 3 and 1............................................................................................................................................ 193-194 Motion to Pea.. ....... ............... ............... ............ ..................... .................. .............. ........ ............. .......... ............ 194 OFFICERS OF LOK SABHA THE SPEAKER Shri Somnath Chatterjee THE DEPUTY·SPEAKER Shri Charnjit Singh Atwal PANEL OF CHAIRMEN Shri Pawan Kumar Bansal Shri Giridhar Garnang Shrirnati Sumitra Mahajan Shri Ajay Maken Dr. Laxminarayan Pandey Shri Balasaheb Vikhe Patil Shri Varkala Radhakrishnan Shri Arjun Sethi Lt. Col. (Retd.) Manabendra Shah Shri Devendra Prasad Yadav SECRETAR~GENERAL Shri G.C. Malhotra LOK SABHA DEBATES -.-----~==--.--====:=:=----.. -----:: .. --===============-========== LOK SABHA SHRI SANTOSH GANGWAR (Bareilly): I had already requested him that since his seat Is ahead. [English] Saturday, March, 19, 20051Phaiguna 28, 1926 (SUa) MR SPEAKER: Are you not happy with the company you have here? The Lok Sabha met at Eleven of the Clock [Translation] [MR. SPEAKER in the ChaiiJ SHRI KALYAN SINGH: Kindly allow me today. It (English] wUI correct it in future. MR. SPEAKER: We are coming out of the rigours {English] of the winter! I hope, it does not meet with your MR. SPEAKER: Okay. Today, it is an excuse. disapproval! [Translation] MESSAGE FROM THE PRESIDENT 1. SHRI KALYAN SINGH: Mr. Speaker, Sir. I beg MR. SPEAKER: Hon. MemberS, I have to inform to present a copy each of the following Reports (Hindi the House that I have received the following and English versions) of Standing Committee on message dated the 15th March, 2005 from the han. Rural Development:- President :- (1) Fifth