Forget secular stagnation, Jan von Gerich the bond market is pricing in secular stagflation Nordea Research, 21 February 2017 Everybody seems to be talking about secular stagnation, or the prospect of low or no growth for the foreseeable future. However, what the bond market is currently pricing in is even more frightening: inflation without growth. Does the recent rise in yields really signal expectations of a brighter future? The current low level of nominal interest rates is often taken as a testament that the bond market has lost all hope that the economy would ever rebound. Correspondingly, the recent rise in US bond yields, partly driven by the election of Donald Trump, is generally seen as signalling increased confidence of faster economic growth. This is by far not the whole story. While there are many factors driving the level of long yields, which is ultimately determined by the laws of supply and demand, the economic interpretation of long nominal interest rates is that their level illustrates expectations of real economic growth added with inflation. As a result, higher rates usually indicate brighter growth prospects and vice versa. However, merely looking at nominal rates makes it impossible to conclude, whether higher rates are driven by higher inflation or real growth expectations. A decomposition of long nominal yields into so called real yields and inflation expectations gives a better picture of what the bond market is actually pricing in. Such decomposition reveals some startling findings. First, the level of long nominal yields is mostly accounted for by inflation expectations, while real yields are low or even negative. Second, the rise in nominal yields has been driven by higher inflation expectation, not so much by higher real yields. The current level of nominal yields explained almost fully by inflation expectations nexus.nordea.com/research Current real yields illustrate more than just weak growth prospects… Real yields are what drive the economy and are a major determinant of how easy monetary policy is. From that perspective, the current low real yields can be seen as welcome in trying to bring life into the economy. Apart from weak economic performance, the low real yields illustrate the exceptional central bank stimulus measures, including the massive bond purchase programmes. …but the picture longer out very grim However, the outlook appears much gloomier, when one looks at how the bond market expects real yields to develop going forward. In the US, the 5-year real yield is priced to top at just above 0.5% in the 2030s and start to fall again after that. The economic interpretation of this is that the bond market does not expect US real growth to be much higher than 0.5% annually on average over any 5-year period going forward. Even in the past 10 years, which incorporates the Great Recession, average annual growth has been around 1.3%. The picture for the Euro area is even gloomier. Forward 5-year EUR real rates reach their highs of -0.10% in the 2020s and start to fall again longer out – in other words, an outlook of no economic growth whatsoever. By comparison, the past 10 years has seen growth average some 0.8% despite the financial crisis and the sovereign debt crisis. nexus.nordea.com/research Long real forward rates do not illustrate really any growth expectations It gets worse – the market is pricing in inflation without growth Could the market just be pricing in a scenario, where the central banks are forced to continue ultra-easy monetary policy and keep real yields at artificially low levels over an extended period of time in a desperate attempt to try to lift inflation towards the target? The pricing of inflation expectations overrules such interpretation. Implied 5-year US inflation expectations are expected to be close to 2.5% over the next 25 years. Even in the Euro area, implied 5-year inflation expectations rise above 2% in around ten years’ time and stay there. Central banks are thus expected to reach their inflation targets, and should not have a reason to continue exceptionally accommodative monetary policies. The inflation picture is priced to normalize nexus.nordea.com/research In conclusion, the bond market is pricing in a scenario of very low or no growth even in the longer run – something one might call secular stagnation. However, as the market is pricing in inflation at the same time, secular stagflation is a more appropriate term, an even grimmer prospect. President Trump has not done really anything to change that picture. The bond market pricing illustrates that what the economy really needs is longer-term reforms to lift production capacity. The US economy certainly does not need short-term fiscal stimulus to push inflation expectations even higher. nexus.nordea.com/research Disclaimer and legal disclosures Origin of the publication or report The perception of opinions or recommendations such as Buy or Sell or This publication or report originates from: Nordea Bank AB (publ), including similar expressions may vary and the definition is therefore shown in the its branches Nordea Danmark, filial af Nordea Bank AB (publ), Sverige, research material or on the website of each named source. Nordea Bank AB (publ), filial i Finland and Nordea Bank AB (publ), filial i Norge (together “Nordea”) acting through their unit Nordea Markets. Limitation of liability Nordea or other associated and affiliated companies assume no liability as Nordea Bank AB (publ) is supervised by the Swedish Financial Supervisory regards to any investment, divestment or retention decision taken by the Authority and the branches are supervised by the Swedish Financial investor on the basis of this publication or report. In no event will Nordea or Supervisory Authority and the Financial Supervisory Authorities in their other associated and affiliated companies be liable for direct, indirect or respective countries. incidental, special or consequential damages resulting from the information in this publication or report. Content of the publication or report This publication or report has been prepared solely by Nordea Markets. Risk information The risk of investing in certain financial instruments, including those Opinions or suggestions from Nordea Markets may deviate from mentioned in this document, is generally high, as their market value is recommendations or opinions presented by other departments in Nordea. exposed to a lot of different factors such as the operational and financial The reason may typically be the result of differing time horizons, conditions of the relevant company, growth prospects, change in interest methodologies, contexts or other factors. rates, the economic and political environment, foreign exchange rates, shifts in market sentiments etc. Where an investment or security is denominated in Opinions and price targets are based on one or more methods of valuation, a different currency to the investor’s currency of reference, changes in rates for instance cash flow analysis, use of multiples, behavioural technical of exchange may have an adverse effect on the value, price or income of or analyses of underlying market movements in combination with from that investment to the investor. Past performance is not a guide to considerations of the market situation and the time horizon. Key future performance. Estimates of future performance are based on assumptions of forecasts, price targets and projections in research cited or assumptions that may not be realized. When investing in individual shares, reproduced appear in the research material from the named sources. The the investor may lose all or part of the investments. date of publication appears from the research material cited or reproduced. Opinions and estimates may be updated in subsequent versions of the Conflicts of interest publication or report, provided that the relevant company/issuer is treated Nordea, affiliates or staff in Nordea, may perform services for, solicit anew in such later versions of the publication or report. business from, hold long or short positions in, or otherwise be interested in the investments (including derivatives) of any company mentioned in the Validity of the publication or report publication or report. All opinions and estimates in this publication or report are, regardless of source, given in good faith, and may only be valid as of the stated date of To limit possible conflicts of interest and counter the abuse of inside this publication or report and are subject to change without notice. knowledge, the analysts of Nordea Markets are subject to internal rules on sound ethical conduct, the management of inside information, handling of No individual investment or tax advice unpublished research material, contact with other units of Nordea and The publication or report is intended only to provide general and preliminary personal account dealing. The internal rules have been prepared in information to investors and shall not be construed as the basis for any accordance with applicable legislation and relevant industry standards. The investment decision. This publication or report has been prepared by Nordea object of the internal rules is for example to ensure that no analyst will Markets as general information for private use of investors to whom the abuse or cause others to abuse confidential information. It is the policy of publication or report has been distributed, but it is not intended as a Nordea Markets that no link exists between revenues from capital markets personal recommendation of particular financial instruments or strategies activities and individual analyst remuneration. Nordea and the branches are and thus it does not provide individually tailored investment advice, and members of national stockbrokers’ associations in each of the countries in does not take into account the individual investor’s particular financial which Nordea has head offices. Internal rules have been developed in situation, existing holdings or liabilities, investment knowledge and accordance with recommendations issued by the stockbrokers associations.