September 7, 2015 Superradiance Richard Brito,1 Vitor Cardoso,1;2;3 Paolo Pani,4;1 1 CENTRA, Departamento de F´ısica, Instituto Superior T´ecnico, Universidade de Lisboa, Av. Rovisco Pais 1, 1049 Lisboa, Portugal. 2 Perimeter Institute for Theoretical Physics, Waterloo, Ontario N2J 2W9, Canada. 3 Department of Physics and Astronomy, The University of Mississippi, University, MS 38677, USA. 4 Dipartimento di Fisica, \Sapienza" Universit`adi Roma & Sezione INFN Roma1, P.A. Moro 5, 00185, Roma, Italy [email protected], [email protected], [email protected] Abstract Superradiance is a radiation enhancement process that involves dissipative systems. With a 60 year-old history, superradiance has played a prominent role in optics, quantum mechanics and especially in relativity and astrophysics. In General Relativity, black-hole superradiance is permitted by dissipation at the event horizon, that allows for energy, charge and angular momentum extraction from the vacuum, even at the classical level. Black-hole superradiance is intimately connected to the black-hole area theorem, Penrose process, tidal forces and even Hawking radiation, which can be interpreted as a quantum version of black-hole super- radiance. Various mechanisms (as diverse as massive fields, magnetic fields, anti-de Sitter boundaries, nonlinear interactions, etc...) can confine the amplified radiation and give rise to strong instabilities. These \black-hole bombs" have applications in searches of dark matter arXiv:1501.06570v3 [gr-qc] 4 Sep 2015 and of physics beyond the Standard Model, are associated to the threshold of formation of new black hole solutions that evade the no-hair theorems, can be studied in the laboratory by devising analog models of gravity, and might even provide a holographic description of spontaneous symmetry breaking and superfluidity through the gauge-gravity duality. This work is meant to provide a unified picture of this multifaceted subject, which was missing in the literature. We focus on the recent developments in the field, and work out a number of novel examples and applications, ranging from fundamental physics to astrophysics. Contents 1 Prologue 7 2 Milestones 9 3 Superradiance in flat spacetime 13 3.1 Klein paradox: the first example of superradiance . 13 3.1.1 Bosonic scattering . 13 3.1.2 Fermionic scattering . 14 3.2 Superradiance and pair creation . 15 3.3 Superradiance and spontaneous emission by a moving object . 17 3.3.1 Cherenkov emission and superradiance . 18 3.3.2 Cherenkov radiation by neutral particles . 18 3.3.3 Superradiance in superfluids and superconductors . 20 3.4 Sound amplification by shock waves . 21 3.4.1 Sonic \booms" . 21 3.4.2 Superradiant amplification at discontinuities . 22 3.5 Rotational superradiance . 23 3.5.1 Example 1. Scalar waves . 24 3.5.2 Example 2. Sound and surface waves: a practical experimental setup? 25 3.6 Tidal acceleration . 29 4 Superradiance in black hole physics 31 4.1 Action, equations of motion and black hole spacetimes . 31 4.1.1 Static, charged backgrounds . 32 4.1.2 Spinning, neutral backgrounds . 33 4.1.3 Geodesics and frame dragging in the Kerr geometry . 33 4.1.4 The ergoregion . 34 4.1.5 Intermezzo: stationary and axisymmetric black holes have an ergoregion 36 4.2 Area theorem implies superradiance . 37 4.3 Energy extraction from black holes: the Penrose process . 38 4.3.1 The original Penrose process . 39 4.3.2 The Newtonian carousel analogy . 41 4.3.3 Penrose's process: energy limits . 42 4.3.4 The Penrose process in generic spacetimes . 44 4.3.5 The collisional Penrose process: ultra-high-energy debris . 46 4.4 The ABC of black hole superradiance . 48 4.5 Superradiance from charged static black holes . 49 4.5.1 Linearized analysis: amplification factors . 49 1 4.5.2 Backreaction on the geometry: mass and charge loss . 51 4.6 Superradiance from rotating black holes . 52 4.6.1 Bosonic and fermionic fields in the Kerr geometry . 53 4.6.2 Energy fluxes of bosonic fields at infinity and on the horizon . 54 4.6.3 Amplification factors . 56 4.6.4 Dirac fields on the Kerr geometry . 56 4.6.5 Linearized analysis: analytic vs numerics . 58 4.6.6 Scattering of plane waves . 61 4.6.7 Nonlinear superradiant scattering . 64 4.7 Boosted black strings: ergoregions without superradiance . 65 4.8 Superradiance in higher dimensional spacetimes . 67 4.9 Superradiance in analogue black hole geometries . 68 4.10 Superradiance in nonasymptotically flat spacetimes . 70 4.11 Superradiance from stars . 71 4.12 Superradiance beyond General Relativity . 72 4.13 Microscopic description of superradiance and the Kerr/CFT duality . 75 4.14 Open issues . 76 5 Black holes & superradiant instabilities 79 5.1 No black hole fission processes . 79 5.2 Spinning black holes in confining geometries are unstable . 80 5.3 Superradiant instabilities: time-domain evolutions versus an eigenvalue search 82 5.4 Black holes enclosed in a mirror . 83 5.4.1 Rotating black-hole bombs . 83 5.4.2 Charged black-hole bombs . 86 5.5 Black holes in AdS backgrounds . 86 5.5.1 Instability of small Kerr-AdS black holes and new BH solutions . 87 5.5.2 Charged AdS black holes: spontaneous symmetry breaking and holo- graphic superconductors . 91 5.6 Massive bosonic fields . 93 5.6.1 The zoo of light bosonic fields in extensions of the Standard Model . 94 5.6.2 Massive scalar fields . 95 5.6.3 Massive vector fields . 99 5.6.4 Massive tensor fields . 101 5.6.5 A unified picture of superradiant instabilities of massive bosonic fields 103 5.7 Black holes immersed in a magnetic field . 104 5.8 Superradiant instability of black holes surrounded by conducting rings . 105 5.9 Nonminimal interactions . 106 5.9.1 Plasma-triggered superradiant instabilities . 108 5.9.2 Spontaneous superradiant instabilities in scalar-tensor theories . 108 2 5.10 Kaluza-Klein mass: superradiant instabilities in higher dimensions . 110 5.11 Ergoregion instability . 110 5.11.1 Ergoregion instability of rotating objects: a consistent approach . 111 5.11.2 Ergoregion instability and long-lived modes . 115 5.11.3 Ergoregion instability in fluids . 118 5.11.4 Ergoregion instability and Hawking radiation . 121 5.12 Black-hole lasers and superluminal corrections to Hawking radiation . 122 5.13 Black holes in Lorentz-violating theories: nonlinear instabilities . 122 5.14 Open issues . 123 6 Black hole superradiance in astrophysics 126 6.1 Superradiance & relativistic jets . 126 6.1.1 Blandford-Znajek process . 127 6.1.2 Blandford-Znajek process and the membrane paradigm . 129 6.2 Superradiance, CFS instability, and r-modes of spinning stars . 133 6.3 Evolution of superradiant instabilities: gravitational-wave emission and accretion135 6.3.1 Scalar clouds around spinning black holes . 136 6.3.2 Gravitational-wave emission from the bosonic condensate . 137 6.3.3 Gas accretion . 138 6.3.4 Growth and decay of bosonic condensates around spinning black holes 139 6.3.5 Superradiant instabilities imply no highly-spinning black holes . 141 6.3.6 Summary of the evolution of superradiant instabilities . 143 6.4 Astrophysical black holes as particle detectors . 144 6.4.1 Bounds on the mass of bosonic fields from gaps in the Regge plane . 144 6.4.2 Gravitational-wave signatures and bosenova . 148 6.4.3 Floating orbits . 151 6.5 Are black holes in the universe of the Kerr family? . 154 6.5.1 Circumventing the no-hair theorem with complex scalars . 154 6.5.2 Other hairy solutions and the role of tidal dissipation . 157 6.5.3 Formation of hairy solutions and bounds on bosonic fields . 158 6.6 Plasma interactions . 159 6.7 Intrinsic limits on magnetic fields . 161 6.8 Phenomenology of the ergoregion instability . 163 6.8.1 Ergoregion instability of ultracompact stars . 163 6.8.2 Supporting the black-hole paradigm: instabilities of black-hole mimickers164 6.9 Open issues . 168 7 Conclusions & Outlook 170 A List of publicly available codes 172 3 B Analytic computation of the amplification coefficients 172 C Angular momentum and energy 174 C.1 Energy and angular momentum fluxes at the horizon . 175 D Electromagnetic fluctuations around a rotating black hole enclosed in a mirror 175 E Hartle-Thorne formalism for slowly-rotating spacetimes and perturbations179 E.1 Background . 179 E.2 Perturbations of a slowly-rotating object . 180 E.2.1 Scalar perturbations of a slowly-rotating star . 181 F WKB analysis of long-lived and unstable modes of ultracompact objects 182 4 Notation and conventions Unless otherwise and explicitly stated, we use geometrized units where G = c = 1, so that energy and time have units of length. We also adopt the (− + + + ::: ) convention for the metric. For reference, the following is a list of symbols that are used often throughout the text. ' Azimuthal coordinate. # Angular coordinate. m Azimuthal number with respect to the axis of rotation, jmj ≤ l. l Integer angular number, related to the eigenvalue Alm = l(l + 1) in four spacetime dimensions. s Spin of the field. ! Fourier transform variable. The time dependence of any field is ∼ e−i!t. For stable spacetimes, Im(!) < 0. !R;!I Real and imaginary part of the QNM frequencies. R; I Amplitude of reflected and incident waves, which characterize a wavefunction Φ. Zslm Amplification factor of fluxes for a wave with spin s and harmonic indices (l; m). For scalar fields, 2 2 i!t −i!t Z0lm = jRj =jIj − 1 with the asymptotic expansion at spatial infinity, Φ ∼ Re + Ie . Occasionally, when clear from the context, we will omit the indices s and l and simply write Zm.