• Arthur Goldberg (acclimation) (appointed by John F. Kennedy in 1962) replaced Felix Frankfurter (who replaced Benjamin Cardozo) • Abe Fortas (acclimation) (appointed by Lyndon B. Johnson in 1965) replaced Arthur Goldberg (who replaced Felix Frankfurter who replaced Benjamin Cardozo) • Thurgood Marshall (69-11) (appointed by Lyndon B. Johnson in 1967) replaced Tom Clark • Warren Burger (74-3) (appointed by Ricard M. Nixon in 1969) replaced Earl Warren • Harry Blackmun (94-0) (appointed by Richard M. Nixon in 1970) replaced Abe Fortas who replaced Arthur Goldberg who replaced Felix Frankfurter who replaced Benjamin Cardozo) • Lewis Powell (89-1) (appointed by Richard M. Nixon in 1972) replaced Hugo Black • William Rehnquist (68-26) (appointed by Richard M. Nixon in 1972) replaced John Harlan • John Paul Stevens (98-0) (appointed by Gerald Ford in 1975) replaced William O. Douglas • Sandra Day O’Connor (99-0) (appointed by Ronald Reagan in 1981) replaced Potter Stewart • Antonin Scalia (98-0)(appointed by Ronald Reagan in 1986) replaced William Rehnquist who was elevated to Chief Justice (65-33) replacing Warren Burger • Anthony Kennedy (97-0) (appointed by Ronald Reagan in 1988) replaced Lewis Powell • David Souter (90-9) (appointed by George H.W. Bush in 1990) replaced William Brennan • Clarence Thomas (52-48) (appointed by George H.W. Bush in 1991) replaced Thurgood Marshall • Ruth Bader Ginsburg (96-3) (appointed by Bill Clinton in 1993) replaced Byron White • Stephen Breyer 87-9) (appointed by Bill Clinton in 1994) replaced Harry Blackmun (who replaced Abe Fortas who replaced Arthur Goldberg who replaced Felix Frankfurter who replaced Benjamin Cardozo) • John Roberts (78-22) (appointed by George W. Bush in 2005) replaced William Rehnquist • Samuel Alito (58-42) (appointed by George W. Bush in 2006) replaced Sandra Day O’Connor • Sonia Sotomayor (68-31) (appointed by Barack Obama in 2009) replaced David Souter • Elena Kagan (63-37) (appointed by Barack Obama in 2010) replaced John Paul Stevens (who replaced William O. Douglas who replaced Louis D. Brandeis) • Neil Gorsuch (54-45) (appointed by Donald J. Trump in 2017) replaced Antonin Scalia • Bret Kavanaugh (50-48) (appointed by Donald J. Trump in 2018) replaced Anthony Kennedy .