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`aHM! "C^]D"C]bW"C]\DFGGb! bM!6NX.!*0(%/!X/03301:!! FGGbDFG"b! ! N1!3+1=! _M!A)R0%$!P)3+!.%101(43+!X/03301:!./)[%,$! "CcGD"C]C! \M!A03[+1!*01:!./)[%,$! "C]^D"C]c! ^M!PZ>!X%%'!X/03301:!./)[%,$! "CCGD"CC_! cM!6KX.! "CC^D! ! 6=%+(! ]M!A%35D(01801:!,+'(43%!0=%+(! ! *%,)/=(! X%%'%($!=/033!-)3%d!P)3+!AVDb!"FEF^F!&!L"CcGD"C]CM! X%%'%($!(,0%1$050,!-)3%!01!),%+1d!FE"""!&!I+($%/1!%e4+$)/0+3!.+,050,!LQ%:(!^CE!cGE!]bE! """E!"bcE!"_GE!"_]!Y)3%!\G_>E!XAX.WNX.E!"CcCD"CCbM! X%%'%($!S+$%/!=%'$-!=/033%=!5)/!(,0%1,%d!\EC^]H^!&!2+/0+1+!>+(01!LQ%:!"FC!Y)3%! ]GF#E!NX.E!"C]CDCGM! X%%'%($!)03!S%33!01!),%+1d!"GE^]\!&!L"EF\C!&!S+$%/!=%'$-M!X%%'S+$%/!Y)/0f)1!L>.M! X%%'%($!S+$%/!=%'$-!=/033%=!5)/!)03d!bEG\"!&!V435!)5!2%J0,)!LK-%R/)1M! ! ! ! F! !"+:3#*#5+()#(3#*#5+(!*-/+(;( ;/)&!>+(,)&!L"C^"M! !!!!!N1%!)5!$-%!%+/30%($!'/)')(+3(!5)/!+!'4/%3?!:%)3):0,+3!-)3%!S+(!&+=%!01!g)R%&B%/!"CGF!B?!VH!PH! V03B%/$E!=0/%,$)/!)5!$-%!K+/1%:0%!61($0$4$0)1!)5!7+(-01:$)1E!S-)!(4::%($%=!$)!$-%!$/4($%%(!$-+$!9+1! 01R%($0:+$0)1!)5!(4B$%//+1%+1!$%&'%/+$4/%!B%!&+=%!B?!&%+1(!)5!+!=%%'!B)/01:!01$)!$-%!'34$)10,! /),8H@!! !!!!!ZH!#H!h+::+/!L5)41=%/!+1=!=0/%,$)/!)5!Y+S+00!i)3,+1)!NB(%/R+$)/?M!'/)')(%=!9K)/%!=/03301:!41=%/! $-%!N,%+1@!01!"C_b!$)!6jVV!L61$%/1+$0)1+3!j10)1!)5!V%)=%(?!+1=!V%)'-?(0,(MH! ! '()*+,--)(./)01(%&".*)2(+/34+(*%2,.5)1(-/&),.)01/)*//4)(2/".)$(00(6&)/"21)(./)01(%&".*)7//0) *//4)".*)4+/&/+8/)01/)2(+/&)7(+)&4/2,"-,&0)&0%*#9):,01):(+-*:,*/)*+,--31(-/)*,&0+,$%0,(.;) !!!!!2+4/0,%!IS01:!L=0/%,$)/!)5!Q+&)1$!V%)3):0,+3!NB(%/R+$)/?Md!a'1/)/.0,+/)+/2(+*)(7)0/++/&0+,"-) 2(.*,0,(.&)7+(6)01/)$/5,..,.5)(7)01/)(2/".),&)01/+/),.)01/)6(&0)%.*,&0%+$/*)7(+6),0),&)4(&&,$-/)0()7,.*) ".#:1/+/<".*)01/)*+/"6)(7)6#)-,7/),&)0()4%.21)01"0)1(-/)=>>>)7//0)*//4)".*)$+,.5)01/)2(.0/.0&)$"2?)0() 01/)-"$)0()&0%*#)01/6H! ! <+#9*=/%2-5(4+/+-"2*(>*-?)(!;/+18!>H!I($+B/))8!LjHAH!#/&?M!A,0%1,%!@=AE!F_CE!"C\^H! (((#!5+/D/%+,-01:!&)=%&!(),0+3!=%R%3)'&%1$!0(!$-%!&+((0R%!501+1,0+3!B+,801:!S-0,-!,+1E!S0$-! 01,/%+(01:!%+(%E!B%!)B$+01%=!5)/!)/:+10f%=!:/)4'!+$$+,8(!)1!1%S!+/%+(!)5!B+(0,!81)S3%=:%H!N1%! $-018(!0&&%=0+$%3?!)5!$-%!3+/:%!+,,%3%/+$)/(!)5!$-%!#IKE!)5!$-%!4''%/D+0/!%J'3)/+$0)1!'/):/+&(E!)5! $-%!6VkE!+1=!)5!$-%!+/$050,0+3!(+$%330$%H!61!:%1%/+3E!1)1%!)5!$-%(%!'/):/+&(!-+(!0&&%=0+$%!%,)1)&0,! )/!1+$0)1+3!=%5%1(%!'4/')(%(<!/+$-%/E!$-%0/!(4'')/$!B?!R+/0)4(!:)R%/1&%1$+3!+1=!'/0R+$%! +:%1,0%(!/%53%,$(!+!:%1%/+3!41=%/($+1=01:!)5!$-%!43$0&+$%!4$030$?!)5!+33!'-?(0,+3!81)S3%=:%H! #3$-)4:-!&+((0R%!'4B30,!(4'')/$!)5!(,0%1,%!41=)4B$%=3?!%1$+03(!()&%!41=%(0/+B3%!,)1(%e4%1,%(E! $-%!R%/?!$%,-1)3):0,!/%()4/,%(!$-4(!&+=%!+R+03+B3%!5)/!(,0%1$050,!'4/')(%(!&%+1!$-%!)'%101:!4'! )5!/%(%+/,-!+/%+(!)$-%/S0(%!01+,,%((0B3%H!A,0%1$0($(!01!+33!50%3=(!(-)43=!B%!+S+/%!)5!$-0(! )'')/$410$?H!! !!!!Z-%!'4/')(%!)5!$-0(!1)$%!0(!$)!(4::%($!)1%!(4,-!')((0B030$?d!+!:%)'-?(0,+3!'%1%$/+$0)1!)5!$-%! %+/$-l(!,/4($H!6!+&!1)$!+!:%)'-?(0,0($E!1)/!+&!6!e4+3050%=!%J'%/$3?!$)!=0(,4((!$-%!1)R%3!%1:01%%/01:! '/)B3%&(!01R)3R%=H!g%R%/$-%3%((E!+!,)&'+/0()1!)5!(4,-!+1!%J'3)/+$0)1!S0$-E!(+?E!$-%!+/$050,0+3! (+$%330$%!'/)[%,$!LS0$-!/%:+/=!$)!B+(0,!(,0%1$050,!S)/$-E!$)!')((0B3%!'/+,$0,+3!4(%(E!+1=!$)!$-%! %J'%1(%!)5!=%R%3)'01:!$-%!$%,-1)3):?!01R)3R%=M!S)43=!(%%&!0&&%=0+$%3?!$)!,)150/&!$-%! (4::%($0)1!$-+$!,/4($+3!'%1%$/+$0)1!(-)43=!B%!$-)4:-$!+B)4$E!=0(,4((%=E!+1=!%R+34+$%=!B?!$-%! (,0%1$050,!,)&&410$?H!65!$-%!,)1(%1(4(!0(!$-%1!$-+$!(4,-!+!'/)[%,$!S)43=!B%!R+34+B3%!+1=!5%+(0B3%E! S%!&0:-$!%J'%,$!)1!$-%!+5)/%D&%1$0)1%=!:%1%/+3!:/)41=(!$)!501=!(4'')/$!5)/$-,)&01:H!! !!!Z-%/%!+''%+/!$)!B%!&+1?!:%)'-?(0,+3!'/)B3%&(!$-+$!,)43=!B%!'/)50$+B3?!01R%($0:+$%=!B?!+! '-?(0,+3!'%1%$/+$0)1!)5!$-%!%+/$-l(!,/4($!+1=!B?!+1!%J+&01+$0)1!)5!$-%!,)&')(0$0)1E!'/)'%/$0%(E! +1=!'-?(0,+3!,)1=0$0)1!)5!$-%!&+1$3%!B%3)S!$-%!2)-)/)R0T0U!X0(,)1$0140$?H!#&)1:!$-%(%!+/%!$-%! 5)33)S01:H!L0M!P1)S3%=:%!)5!$-%!R+/0+$0)1!)5!$-%!%+/$-l(!&+:1%$0,!50%3=!B%3)S!$-%!(4/5+,%!,)43=! (-)S!S-%$-%/!0$(!)/0:01!0(!01!$-%!,/4($!)/E!+3$%/1+$0R%3?E!0(!$-%!/%(43$!)5!&+:1%$)-?=/)=?1+&0,! &%,-+10(&(!01!$-%!,)/%H!L00M!P1)S3%=:%!)5!$-%!$%&'%/+$4/%!R+/0+$0)1!B%3)S!$-%!(4/5+,%!0(! 0&')/$+1$!5)/!=0(,4((0)1(!)5!$-%!%+/$-l(!-%+$!B+3+1,%E!/+=0)+,$0R0$?E!+1=!%R)34$0)1H!L000M! P1)S3%=:%!)5!'/%((4/%E!$%&'%/+$4/%E!+1=!=%1(0$?!,)1=0$0)1(!+$!$-%!)4$%/!B)41=+/?!)5!$-%!&+1$3%! +/%!/%e40/%=!5)/!$-%!14&%/0,+3!01$%:/+$0)1(!01!:%)'-?(0,+3!$-%)/0%(!)5!I+/$-E!i%14(E!+1=!2+/(H! L0RM!V%)'-?(0,+3!$-%)/0%(!)5!,)1$01%1$!B403=01:!/%e40/%!81)S3%=:%!)5!$-%!43$/+B+(0,!&+1$3%! &+$%/0+3!+1=!)5!0$(!/%3+$0)1!$)!$-%!B+(+3$!3+?%/!+1=!$)!$-%!:/+10$0,!,)1$01%1$+3!B+(%&%1$H!LRM! .%1%$/+$0)1!)5!$-%!,/4($!,)43=!(-%=!30:-$!)1!$-%!R+30=0$?!)5!$-%!0()($+(?!,)1,%'$<!$-0(!01!$4/1!-+(! 0&')/$+1$!+1=!'/+,$0,+3!:%)=%$0,!,)1(%e4%1,%(H!LR0M!Z-%!%+/$-l(!,/4($!+''+/%1$3?!-+(!+1! 414(4+33?!-0:-!/+=0)+,$0R%!,)1$%1$<!0$!0(!0&')/$+1$!$)!=%$%/&01%!S-%$-%/!$-0(!0(!+,$4+33?!()E!+1=! S-%$-%/!$-%!/+=0)+,$0R%!%3%&%1$(!-+R%!B%%1!5/+,$0)1+$%=!)4$!)5!$-%!&+1$3%H!LR00M!P1)S3%=:%!)5! $-%!,)&')(0$0)1!)5!$-%!&+1$3%!+1=E!-%1,%E!)5!B?!5+/!$-%!3+/:%($!'+/$!)5!$-%!%+/$-l(!&+((!0(!)5!:/%+$! 01$%/%($!5)/!+($/)'-?(0,+3!=0(,4((0)1(!)5!,)(&0,!+B41=+1,%(H!;4/$-%/&)/%E!+(!01!+1?!(,0%1$050,! %J'3)/+$0)1E!)1%!,+11)$!%($0&+$%!01!+=R+1,%!$-%!0&')/$+1,%!)5!$-%!1%S!+1=!41%J'%,$%=! '-%1)&%1+!+1=!,)1=0$0)1(!$-+$!S)43=!B%!%1,)41$%/%=<!5)/!%J+&'3%E!0$!S+(!(4::%($%=!$)!&%E!1)$! 1%,%((+/03?!01![%($E!$-+$!$-%!&+1$3%!&0:-$!'/)R%!=0+&)1=05%/)4(H!! ! b! !!!Z-%!(0$%!)5!$-%!/%(%+/,-!(-+5$!S)43=!B%!,-)(%1!()!$-+$!$-%!=%'$-!)5!$-%!2)-)/)R0T0U! X0(,)1$0140$?!S+(!$-%/%!+!&010&4&H!7-03%!$-0(!01=0,+$%(!=/03301:!5/)&!+1!),%+10,!0(3+1=E!$-%! 3):0($0,!,)1R%10%1,%!)5!+!,)1$01%1$+3!3),+$0)1!S)43=!+3()!B%!+!5+,$)/H!./%(4&+B3?!(%0(&0,!+1=! R)3,+10,!,)&'30,+$0)1(!(-)43=!B%!R)0=%=H!A%=0&%1$+/?!)R%/3+?!'%/!(%!0(!4101$%/%($01:E!+1=! :/)41=!S+$%/!+1=!)$-%/!(%%'+:%(!,)43=!B%!+R)0=%=!B?!(%%801:!%J')(%=!#/,-%+1!/),8H!6!,+11)$! +=%e4+$%3?![4=:%!$-%!/%3+$0R%!0&')/$+1,%!)5!$-%(%!5+,$)/(H!! !!!6$!0(E!-)S%R%/E!,3%+/!$-+$!'/%(%1$!S%33D=/03301:!$%,-1)3):?!S)43=!B%!01+=%e4+$%!$)!+,-0%R%!$-%! R%/$0,+3!=%'$-!/%e40/%=D!'%/-+'(!"G!&03%(H!N1%!&0:-$E!01($%+=E!0&+:01%!+!(&+33DB)/%!L'%/-+'(!"F! 01,-%(!01!=0+&%$%/E!bGG!=)S1D(3+1$M!(-+5$E!=/033%=!01$)!$-%!:/+10$0,!+1=!B+(+3$0,!/),8!B?!/%&)$%D ,)1$/)33%=!%e40'&%1$H!Z-%!')S%/!$/+1(&0((0)1!5/)&!(4/5+,%!$)!=/033!,)43=!B%!B?!%3%,$/0,!,+B3%<! /),8!/%&)R+3E!B?!B%3$!)/!-?=/+430,!&%+1(H!Z-%!$%&'%/+$4/%(!%1,)41$%/%=!(-)43=!1)$!B%! %J,%((0R%!L'%/-+'(!+!5%S!-41=/%=!=%:/%%(!,%1$0:/+=%M<!$-%!%J$/%&%!'/%((4/%(!S)43=!'/)B+B3?! /%e40/%!$-%!4(%!)5!-%+R?!=/03301:!&4=(!5)/!-?=/)($+$0,!,)&'%1(+$0)1H!! !!!#3$-)4:-!%($0&+$0)1!)5!,)($(!5)/!(4,-!+!'/)[%,$!0(!%J$/%&%3?!=0550,43$!41$03!'/%30&01+/?!(0$%! (4/R%?(!+1=!+!$%,-1)3):0,!5%+(0B030$?!($4=?!-+R%!B%%1!&+=%E!6!&0:-$!')01$!)4$!$-+$!$-%!3+/:%D(,+3%! /),8!$411%301:!)1!$-%!(4/5+,%!,)($(!'%/-+'(!m"!&0330)1!'%/!&03%H!7%!&0:-$!%J'%,$!$-+$!$-%! '/)')(%=!(&+33!B)/%E!$-%!4(%!)5!&)=%/1!/%&)$%D,)1$/)33%=!01($/4&%1$+$0)1E!+1=!%('%,0+33?!$-%! +B(%1,%!)5!,)&'30,+$01:!(%%'+:%!+1=!R%1$03+$0)1!'/)B3%&(!S)43=!:/%+$3?!/%=4,%!$-%!,)($!5/)&! $-+$!)5!,)1R%1$0)1+3!$411%301:H!A)!$-0(!,)($!&0:-$!S%33!B%!,)&&%1(4/+$%!S0$-!$-+$!)5!&+1?! &)=%&!:/)4'!+$$+,8(!)1!)$-%/!B+(0,!+/%+(!)5!(,0%1,%E!+(!0(!01=0,+$%=!01!$-%!50/($!'+/+:/+'-H!6! (-)43=!308%!$)!$-+18!h+&%(!V+/R%?!5)/!&+1?!=0(,4((0)1(E!+1=!5)/!%1,)4/+:%&%1$!01!$-0(!&+$$%/H!! 1957: Harry Hess and Walter Munk asked themselves, “How could the earth sciences take a great stride forward?” Munk suggested that they should consider what project, regardless of cost, would do the most to open up new avenues of thought and research.