USCA Case #20-1025 Document #1869759 Filed: 11/04/2020 Page 1 of 480 20-1025 (Lead); 20-1138 (Consolidated) UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA CIRCUIT ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH TRUST; CONSUMERS FOR SAFE CELL PHONES; ELIZABETH BARRIS; THEODORA SCARATO CHILDREN’S HEALTH DEFENSE; MICHELE HERTZ; PETRA BROKKEN; DR. DAVID O. CARPENTER; DR. PAUL DART; DR. TORIL H. JELTER; DR. ANN LEE; VIRGINIA FARVER, JENNIFER BARAN; PAUL STANLEY, M.Ed. Petitioners v. FEDERAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMISSION; UNITED STATES OF AMERICA Respondents Petition for Review of Order Issued by the Federal Communications Commission DEFERRED JOINT APPENDIX VOLUME 12 Edward B. Myers Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. Law Office of Edward B. Myers Children’s Health Defense 14613 Dehaven Court 1227 North Peachtree Pkwy #202 North Potomac, MD 20878 Peachtree City, GA 30269 Phone: 717-752-2032 Phone: 845-377-0211 [email protected] [email protected] Counsel for Petitioners 20-1025 W. Scott McCollough McCollough Law Firm, P.C. 2290 Gatlin Creek Rd. Dripping Springs, TX 78620 Phone: 512-888-1112 [email protected] Counsel for Petitioners 20-1138 USCA Case #20-1025 Document #1869759 Filed: 11/04/2020 Page 2 of 480 INDEX TO DEFERRED APPENDIX JA Tab Page Date Filer/Author Filing/Attachment Description No. Nos. VOLUME 1 – Tabs 1-2 COMMISSION ORDER AND NOTICE OF INQUIRY Dec. 4, 1 1-160 FCC Resolution of Notice of Inquiry Order 2019 Mar. 161- 2 29, FCC Notice of Inquiry 363 2013 VOLUME 2 – Tabs 3 – 7 Part 1 COMMENTS AND OTHER FILINGS CTIA-The FCC; Comments of the CTIA - The 364- Sep. 3, 3 Wireless Wireless Association, ET Docket No. 428 2013 Association 13-84 CTIA-The FCC; Reply Comments of the CTIA - 429- Nov 18, 4 Wireless The Wireless Association, ET Docket 467 2013 Association No. 13-84 Mobile 468- Sep. 3, FCC; Mobile Manufacturers Forum 5 Manufacturers 572 2013 Comments, ET Docket No. 13-84 Forum Mobile FCC; Mobile Manufacturers Forum 573- Nov. 18, 6 Manufacturers Reply Comments, ET Docket No. 13- 588 2013 Forum 84 -ii- USCA Case #20-1025 Document #1869759 Filed: 11/04/2020 Page 3 of 480 INDEX TO DEFERRED APPENDIX JA Tab Page Date Filer/Author Filing/Attachment Description No. Nos. Research Compilation; Abstracts of Joel M. 7 Part 589- Sep. 16, over 2,100 studies published between Moskowitz 1 764 2019 1990 - 2017; Prof. Henry Lai. (Tab 7 PhD Part 1) VOLUME 3 – Tab 7 Part 2 Research Compilation; Abstracts of Joel M. 7 Part 765- Sep. 16, over 2,100 studies published between Moskowitz 2 1164 2019 1990 - 2017; Prof. Henry Lai.(Tab 7 PhD Part 2) VOLUME 4 – Tab 7 Part 3 Research Compilation; Abstracts of Joel M. 7 Part 1165- Sep. 16, over 2,100 studies published between Moskowitz 3 1564 2019 1990 - 2017; Prof. Henry Lai.(Tab 7 PhD Part 3) VOLUME 5 – Tabs 7 Part 4 – 8 Part 1 Research Compilation; Abstracts of Joel M. 7 Part 1565- Sep. 16, over 2,100 studies published between Moskowitz 4 1602 2019 1990 - 2017; Prof. Henry Lai.(Tab 7 PhD Part 4) Research Compilation; Abstracts of Joel M. 8 Part 1603- Sep. 13, Over 600 Studies Published Between Moskowitz 1 1964 2019 August 2016- August 2019, Dr. Joel PhD Moskowitz; 2019 (Tab 8 Part 1) -iii- USCA Case #20-1025 Document #1869759 Filed: 11/04/2020 Page 4 of 480 INDEX TO DEFERRED APPENDIX VOLUME 6 – Tabs 8 Part 2 - 10 Research Compilation; Abstracts of Joel M. 8 Part 1965- Sep. 13, Over 600 Studies Published Between Moskowitz 2 2130 2019 August 2016- August 2019, Dr. Joel PhD Moskowitz; 2019 (Tab 8 Part 2) Research Compilation; Abstracts of 2131- Sep. 28, Gary C. 9 15 New Studies, Dr. Joel Moskowitz 2142 2016 Vesperman PhD, 2016 2143- Jul. 7, Environmental Research Compilation; Studies and 10 2378 2016 Health Trust Documents; City of Pinole, CA VOLUME 7 – Tabs 11 – 13 Part 1 US Exposures Limits - A History of 2379- Jul. 7, Environmental 11 Their Creation, Comments and 2389 2016 Health Trust Explanations; Eng. Lloyd Morgan Biosystem & Ecosystem; Birds, Bees and Mankind: Destroying Nature by 2390- Aug. 26, Heidi M. 12 ‘Electrosmog’: Effects of Mobile 2439 2016 Lumpkin Radio and Wireless Communication. Dr. Ulrich Warnke, Ph.D., 2007 Parents for Cancer; IARC Monograph: Non- 13 2440- Jul. 13, Safe Ionizing Radiation Part 2: RF EMFs, Part 1 2778 2016 Technology 2013 (Tab 13 Part 1) VOLUME 8 – Tabs 13 Part 2 - 23 Parents for Cancer; IARC Monograph: Non- 13 2779- Jul. 13, Safe Ionizing Radiation Part 2: RF EMFs, Part 2 2920 2016 Technology 2013 (Tab 13 Part 2) -iv- USCA Case #20-1025 Document #1869759 Filed: 11/04/2020 Page 5 of 480 INDEX TO DEFERRED APPENDIX Cancer; IARC Press Release: IARC 2921- Nov. 18, 14 Kevin Mottus Classifies RF EMFs As Possibly 2927 2013 Carcinogenic to Humans, 2011 NTP; Report of Partial Findings from the National Toxicology Program 2928- Jul. 11, Environmental Carcinogenesis Studies of Cell Phone 15 3002 2016 Health Trust Radiofrequency Radiation in Hsd: Sprague Dawley® SD rats (Whole Body Exposures); Draft 5-19-2016 NTP; Commentary on the utility of the National Toxicology Program study on cell phone radiofrequency radiation data for assessing human 3003- Oct. 1, Environmental 16 health risks despite unfounded 3009 2018 Health Trust criticisms aimed at minimizing the findings of adverse health effects. Environmental Research. Dr. Ron Melnick; 2019 NTP; Dr. Hardell and Dr. Carlsberg letter to the NTP, NIH, DHHS, NTP 3010- Apr. 16, Theodora 17 Technical Report On The Toxicology 3036 2018 Scarato And Carcinogenesis Studies; Mar. 12, 2018 Cancer-NTP; Cancer epidemiology update, following the 2011 IARC 3037- Oct. 1, Environmental 18 evaluation of radiofrequency 3048 2018 Health Trust electromagnetic fields; (Miller et al); 2018 Cancer-NTP; The Significance of Joel M. Primary Tumors in the NTP Study of 3049- Oct. 18, 19 Moskowitz, Chronic Rat Exposure to Cell Phone 3055 2018 Ph.D. Radiation. IEEE Microwave Magazine. Prof. James C. Lin; 2019 -v- USCA Case #20-1025 Document #1869759 Filed: 11/04/2020 Page 6 of 480 INDEX TO DEFERRED APPENDIX Cindy Sage 3056- Aug. 27, 20 and David O. BioInitiative Comments 3065 2013 Carpenter 3066- Nov. 18, 21 Kevin Mottus BioInitiative; 2012 Conclusions 3080 2013 BioInitiative; Section 24: Key 3081- Nov. 18, 22 Kevin Mottus Scientific Evidence and Public Health 3126 2013 Policy Recommendations; 2012 3127- Jul. 11, Cecelia BioInitiative; Section 1: Summary for 23 3146 2016 Doucette the Public (2014 Supplement) VOLUME 9 – Tabs 24-27 BioInitiative-Modulation; Section 15: Evidence for Disruption by Modulation Role of Physical and 3147- Sep. 30, Catherine 24 Biological Variables in Bioeffects of 3218 2016 Kleiber Non-Thermal Microwaves for Reproducibility, Cancer Risk and Safety Standards, (2012 Supplement) BioInitiative; Section 20, Findings in Autism, Consistent with 3219- Sep. 3, 25 Kevin Mottus Electromagnetic Fields (EMF) and 3319 2013 Radiofrequency Radiation (RFR); 2012 Joel BioInitiative-Neurological; Percent 3320- Sep. 16, 26 Moskowitz Comparison, Effect vs No Effect in 3321 2019 PhD. Neurological Effect Studies; 2019 Joel BioInitiative-Neurological; Research 3322- Sep. 16, 27 Moskowitz Summaries, RFR Neurological 3559 2019 PhD. Effects (Section 8), 2007-2017; 2017 -vi- USCA Case #20-1025 Document #1869759 Filed: 11/04/2020 Page 7 of 480 INDEX TO DEFERRED APPENDIX VOLUME 10 – Tabs 28-41 BioInitiative-Mechanisms of Harm; Joel M. Percent Comparison Showing Effect 3560- Sep. 16, 28 Moskowitz vs No Effect, DNA (Comet Assay), 3561 2019 PhD. 2017 and Free Radical (Oxidative Stress), 2019 Joel M. BioInitiative-Mechanisms of Harm; 3562- Sep. 16, 29 Moskowitz Research Summaries, DNA (Comet 3602 2019 PhD. Assay) Studies; 76 Studies, 2017 BioInitiative-Mechanisms of Harm; Joel M. 3603- Sep. 16, Research Summaries, Free Radicals 30 Moskowitz 3721 2019 (Oxidative Stress Effects), 225 PhD. studies, 2019 BioInitiative Working Group; Preliminary Opinion on Potential 3722- Apr. 11, Cindy Sage, 31 Health Effects of Exposure to 3749 2014 MA Electromagnetic Fields (EMF); 2014 BioInitiative Working Group; Bioinitiative 3750- Sep. 16, Consistent Failure to Identify the 32 Working 3755 2019 Potential for Health Effects (Exhibit Group A); 2014 BioInitiative Working Group; Biointiative 3756- Sep. 14, Reference List for Important Fertility 33 Working 3766 2019 and Reproduction Papers (Exhibit C); Group 2014 BioInitiative Working Group; 3767- Apr. 14, Mitochondrial Dysfunction and 34 Cindy Sage 3771 2019 Disruption of Electrophysiology (Exhibit G); 2014 -vii- USCA Case #20-1025 Document #1869759 Filed: 11/04/2020 Page 8 of 480 INDEX TO DEFERRED APPENDIX BioInitiative Working Group; Epidemiological Studies, RF fields epidemiology, Comments by Drs. 3772- Apr. 14, Cindy Sage, 35 Lennart Hardell, Fredrik Soderqvist 3779 2019 MA PhD. and Michael Carlberg, MSc. Section 3.5.1.1 Epidemiological Studies (Exhibit B); 2014 BioInitiative Working Group; An Update on the Genetic Effects of 3780- Apr 11, Cindy Sage, 36 Nonionizing Electromagnetic Fields 3874 2014 MA by Prof. Henry Lai PhD; (Exhibit E); 2014 BioInitiative Working Group; An Update on Physical and Biological 3875- Apr. 11, Cindy Sage, 37 Variables, Cancer and Safety 3896 2014 MA Standards by Prof. Igor Belyaev Dr. Sc., (Exhibit F); 2014 BioInitiative Co-Editor; Human 3897- Sep. 30, Health Effects of EMFs: The Cost of 38 Maria Powell 3904 2016 Doing Nothing. IOPScience. (Prof. David Carpenter MD.); 2010 3905- Sep. 28, BioInitiative Author; Statement of 39 Kevin Mottus 3919 2016 Prof. Martin Blank PhD., PhD.; 2016 BioInitiative Authors; Prof. Lennart 3920- Aug 27, Sage Hardell Hardell MD. PhD., Prof. Martha 40 3945 2013 Herbert Herbert MD. PhD. and Cindy Sage Comments B. Blake 3946- Aug. 26, BioInitiatiive Author; Prof. Henry Lai 41 Levitt & 3984 2013 PhD, and Blake Levitt Comments Henry Lai -viii- USCA Case #20-1025 Document #1869759 Filed: 11/04/2020 Page 9 of 480 INDEX TO DEFERRED APPENDIX VOLUME 11 – Tabs 42-59 3985- Sep.