SPECIAL RELATIVITY Applications to astronomy and the accelerator physics Evgeny Saldin arXiv:2007.07780v4 [physics.class-ph] 2 Jul 2021 Preprint submitted to 5 July 2021 aFourth draft from July 2021 This is the fourth draft. New material has been added to the Chapter 6, Chapter 7. Current draft was also completed by a new section 6.6 where we analyze the potential for exploiting (vertically oriented STEM ) electron microscopes in order to confirm the predictions of the aberration of particle theory. A correct solution of this problem in the earth - based frame ( which rotates around the sun with velocity v ) requires the use of metric tensor even in experiments of first order in the parameter (v/c) since the crossed term in the Langevin metric plays a fundamental role in the non-inertial kinematics of a relativistic-charged-particle beam propagation. If you have any comments, please send an email to [email protected]. 2 *Preface There are many books on the classical subject of special relativity. However, after having spent a number of years, both in relativistic engineering and research with relativity, I have come to the conclusion that there exist a place for a new book. I do believe that the present book is not quite the same as the others, mainly due to attempt to cast light on dark corners. I should make it clear what this little book is not. It is not a textbook on relativity theory. What the book is about is the nature of special relativistic kinematics, its relation to space and time, and the operational interpretation of coordinate transformations. Every theory contains a number of quantities that can be measured by experiment and an expressions that cannot possibly be observed. Whenever we have a theory containing an arbitrary conven- tion, we should examine what parts of the theory depend on the choice of that convention and what parts do not. The distinction is not always made and many authors claim some data to be observable, according to arbitrary conventions, which do not correspond to any physical experiment. This leads to inconsistencies and paradoxes that should be avoided at all cost. The practical approach used in the book should be acceptable to astronomers, space engineers, accelerator engineers, and more generally, relativistic engi- neers. This approach, unusual in the relativistic literature, may be clarified by quoting one of the problems discussed in the text: the new light beam kinematics for rotating frame of references. Since we live on such a rotating (earth-based) frame of reference, difference in relativistic kinematics be- tween rotating and non-rotating frames of reference is of great practical as well as theoretical significance. A correct solution of this problem requires the use of relativistic principles even at low velocities since the first-order terms in (v=c) play a fundamental role in the non-inertial relativistic kine- matics of light propagation. All the results presented here are derived from the ”first principles”, and all steps involving physical principles are given. To preserve a self-consistent style, I place the derivation of auxiliary results in appendices. To help readers form their own opinion on the topics discussed, the end of each chapter has a suggested bibliography together with relevant remarks. The list of references includes only the papers I have consulted directly. A lot of papers remain unmentioned, and for this I apologize. I am grateful to my longtime friends Gianluca Geloni and Vitaly Kocharyan for discussions over many years about much of the material in this book. I should also like to express my thanks to DESY (Deutsches Electronen- Synchrotron) for enabling me to work in this interesting field. 3 Contents 1 Introduction 10 2 A Critical Survey of the Present Approaches to Special Relativity 21 2.1 What is Special Relativity? 21 2.2 Different Approaches to Special Relativity 22 2.3 Myth About the Incorrectness of Galilean Transformations 25 2.4 Myth About the Non-Relativistic Limit of the Lorentz Transformations 26 2.5 Myth about the Constancy of the Speed of Light 27 2.6 Convention-Dependent and Convention-Invariant Parts of the Theory 28 2.7 Myth about the Reality of Relativistic Time Dilation and Length Contraction 29 2.8 Relativistic Particle Dynamics 30 2.9 Mistake in Commonly Used Method of Coupling Fields and Particles 31 2.10 Clarification of the True Content of the ”Single Frame” Theory 33 2.11 Bibliography and Notes 35 3 Space-Time and Its Coordinatization 38 3.1 Introductory Remarks 38 3.2 Choice of Coordinates System in an Inertial Frame 38 3.3 Inertial Frame where a Source of Light is at Rest 39 3.4 Motion of a Light Source With Respect to the Inertial Frame 41 3.5 Discussion 42 3.6 A Clock Resynchronization Procedure 43 3.7 Bibliography and Notes 45 4 Aberration of Light Phenomenon. Inertial Frame of Reference 47 4 4.1 Introductory Remarks 47 4.2 The ”Plane Wave” Emitter 47 4.3 A Moving Emitter. The ”Single Frame” Description 48 4.4 A Moving Emitter. Explanation on the Basis of the Lorentz Transformations 52 4.5 Reflection from a Mirror Moving Transversely. Mistake in Existing Theory 53 4.6 Way to Solve the Emitter-Mirror Problem in the (3+1) Space and Time 56 4.7 Covariant Way to Solve the Emitter-Mirror Problem 59 4.8 Discussion 61 4.9 Large Aperture Mirror 63 4.10 Analysis of Transmission through a Hole in a Opaque Screen 64 4.11 Spatiotemporal Transformation of the Transmitted Light Beam 65 4.12 Applicability of the Ray Optics 66 4.13 Measure of Aberration 68 4.14 Moving Large Aperture Emitter 69 4.15 Bibliography and Notes 72 5 Aberration of Light Phenomenon. Noninertial Frame of Reference 74 5.1 Introductory Remarks 74 5.2 Absolute Time Coordinatization in the Accelerated Systems 75 5.3 The Asymmetry between the Inertial and Accelerated Frames 76 5.4 A Resynchronization of the Accelerated Clocks 79 5.5 A Single Moving Emitter in a Noninertial Frame of Reference 80 5.6 A Useful Analogy 83 5.7 A Point Source in a Nonertial Frame of Reference 85 5.8 Concept of Reciprocity in the Aberration of Light Theory 87 5 5.9 Explanation of the Aberration on the Basis of Electrodynamics 89 5.10 Explanation of the Aberration on the Basis of the Ether Theory 91 5.11 Bibliography and Notes 94 6 Notion of Ordinary Space in Special Relativity 95 6.1 Inertial Frame View of Observations of the Noninertial Observer 95 6.2 The Non-Existence of an Instantaneous 3-Space 100 6.3 Acceleration of a Rigid Body and Special Relativity 102 6.4 Discussion 105 6.5 Aberration of Relativistic Particles 106 6.6 Explanation of the Aberration of Electrons on the Basis of Electrodynamics 109 6.7 Bibliography and Notes 112 7 Special Relativity. Absence of Reciprocity 113 7.1 Time Dilation 113 7.2 Light-Clock. Observations of the Noninertial Observer 114 7.3 Experimental Evidence for the Absence of Reciprocity 117 7.4 Pseudo-gravitation Field and the Langevin Metric 118 7.5 Bibliography and Notes 122 8 Space and Time Coordinates in an Inertial Frame 123 8.1 Active and Passive Transformations 123 8.2 Two Metrics 126 8.3 Metrics Connected with Optics of Moving Media and Light Sources 126 8.4 Bibliography and Notes 130 9 Stellar Aberration 131 9.1 A New Approach to the Stellar Aberration 131 9.2 Heliocentric Inertial Frame of Reference 134 6 9.3 Earth-Based Non-Inertial Frame of Reference 135 9.4 Region of Applicability 137 9.5 Bibliography and Notes 138 10 Relativistic Particle Dynamics 140 10.1 Manifestly Covariant Particle Dynamics 140 10.2 Conventional Particle Tracking. Hidden Absolute Time Coordinatization 141 10.3 Incorrect Expansion of the Relation dτ = dt/γ to an Arbitrary Motion 144 10.4 The Usual Integration of the 4D Covariant Equation of Motion 145 10.5 Covariant Particle Tracking 147 10.6 Convention-Invariant Particle Tracking 149 10.7 The Nature of Mass 151 10.8 Bibliography and Notes 154 11 Relativity and Electrodynamics 156 11.1 Why did the Error in Radiation Theory Remain so Long Undetected? 157 11.2 An Illustrative Example 159 11.3 Bibliography and Notes 171 12 Synchrotron Radiation 172 12.1 Introductory Remarks 172 12.2 Paraxial Approximation for the Radiation Field 173 12.3 Undulator Radiation 174 12.4 Synchrotron Radiation from Bending Magnets 185 12.5 How to Solve Problems Involving Many Trajectory Kicks 193 12.6 Synchrotron Radiation in the Case of Particle Motion on a Helix 197 12.7 Bibliography and Notes 203 7 13 Relativity and X-Ray Free Electron Lasers 205 13.1 Introductory Remarks 205 13.2 Modulation Wavefront Orientation 208 13.3 XFEL Radiation Setup 210 13.4 Modulation Wavefront Tilt in Maxwell’s Theory. Logical Inconsistency 216 13.5 Bibliography and Notes 219 14 Kinematics of the Wigner Rotation 222 14.1 Introductory Remarks 222 14.2 The Commutativity of Collinear Lorentz Boosts 222 14.3 The Noncommutativity of Two Lorentz Boosts in Nonparallel Directions 223 14.4 Wigner Rotation 224 14.5 How to Measure a Wigner rotation? 225 14.6 Wigner Rotation and the Reciprocity 227 14.7 Bibliography and Notes 229 15 Relativistic Spin Dynamics 230 15.1 Introductory Remarks 230 15.2 Magnetic Dipole at Rest in an Electromagnetic Field 230 15.3 Derivation of the Covariant (BMT) Equation of Motion of Spin 231 15.4 Change Spin Variables 233 15.5 An Alternative Approach to the BMT Theory 234 15.6 Spin Tracking 236 15.7 Spin Rotation in the Limit g 0 as Dynamics Effect 239 ! 15.8 Incorrect Expression for Wigner Rotation.