1 of 63 ABA.314.2019.doc IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION CRIMINAL ANTICIPATORY BAIL APPLICATION NO.314 OF 2019 Anand T !"#$%d & Age () *ear,& Occ.Seni/+ P+/0 ,,/+ C1ai+& B.g Data Ana!*".-,& G/a Inst."#" /0 Manage$ent& R2/.G/a Inst."#"e /0 Manage$ent& Sanque!.$& G/a-403 505. A66!.cant 7 +,#, T1e S"at /0 Maharash"+a and /"1 +, R ,6/ndent, 8ITH INTERIM APPLICATION NO.1 OF 2019 IN CRIMINAL ANTICIPATORY BAIL APPLICATION NO.314 OF 2019 T1e S"at /0 Maharash"+a A66!.cant 7 +,#, Anand Ba6#+ao T !"#$%d R ,6/ndent M+.M.1.+ Desai& Seni/+ Ad7/cat & .2%* D 7*ani 9#!:a+ni 0/+ ap6!.cant .n ABA N/.24(1 /0 2019 and 0/+ R ,6/ndent .n I.A. N/.122019. S$".A+una S. Pa.& S6 -.al P#%!.c P+/, -#"/+ 0/+ S"a" 2R ,6/ndent. D+.S1.7aj. Pawar& ACP and Inv ,".gat.ng Of0.- +. CORAM = PRA9ASH D. NAI9& J. Date /0 R , +7.ng "1e Ord + = 1)"1 D - $% + 2019 Date /0 P+/nouncing "1e Ord + = 14"1 F %+ua+* 2020 PC = 1. T1., .s an ap6!.cat./n 0/+ ant.-.6at/+* %ai! #nd + S -"./n 43) /0 C/d /0 C+.$.nal P+/-ed#+ & 19)3 >`C+.P.C@A. T1 ap6!.cant ., ::: Uploaded on - 14/02/2020 ::: Downloaded on - 14/02/2020 15:20:15 ::: 2 of 63 ABA.314.2019.doc a66+ 1end.ng a++ ," .n -/nnect./n <."1 CR N/.4 /0 201) + '.," +ed <."1 B.,1+a$%agh P/!.- S"a"./n, Pune. T1 0.+," .nf/+$at./n + 6/+" >`FIR@A <as !/dged /n )"1 Januar* 201). T1 /00ences < + + '.," +ed und + S -"./ns 1534A& 505>1A>%A& 11C& 34 /0 Ind.an Penal C/de. 2. T1 FIR <as !/dged %* /ne T#,1ar Ram ,1 Da$ugade. I" <as a!!eged "1at "1 + <as a 6+/'+a$$ at S1an.<ar 8ada, at Pune /n 31," D - $% + 201C /+ganized %* El'ar Par.,1ad. T1e 0.+," .nf/+$ant at"ended "1 6+/'+a$$ at ab/#" 2 6$ /n 31," D - $% + 201C. T1 + < + 0 < ,6eak +,& -/$6 + ,& ,.nger, and /"1 + 6 +0/+$ +, 6+esent /n "1 ,"age. T1 .nf/+$ant <as :no<.ng 9ab.+ 9ala Manch and .", $ $% +s. He 1ad +ead ab/#" "1 $ /n ,/-.al $ed.a and .n "1 n <,6ap +s. S/$ /0 "1 6 +0/+$ +, enacted ,1/+" 6!ay,& 6 +0/+$ed dances and sang ,/ngs. A--/+d.ng "/ "1 0.+," .nf/+$ant& "1 6 +0/+$ances < + 6+/7/cat.7 .n nat#+ and 1ad 00 -" /0 -+eat.ng -/$$una! d.,1ar$/ny. P+/7/cat.7 ,6 -1 , < + d !.7 +ed. F < /%; -"./nab! and 6+/7/cat.7 %//:, < + : 6" 0/+ sa! at "1 7enue. T1 %anned /+ganizat./n C/$$#ni," Par"* /0 Ind.a >Mao.,"A >0/+ ,1/+" `CPI >MA@A <as .nsi'1".ng 7./!ence %* -+eat.ng -/$$unal d.,1ar$/ny. T1 $ $% +, /0 9ab.+ 9ala Mah-1 ,6+ead 1a"+ed "1+/#'1 "1 .+ ,/ngs, 6!ay, and ,6 -1 , causing ::: Uploaded on - 14/02/2020 ::: Downloaded on - 14/02/2020 15:20:15 ::: 3 of 63 ABA.314.2019.doc nm."* % "<een d.00 +ent -/$$uni".es. A, a + ,#!"& "1 + < + .nstances /0 7./!ence, ar,/n and ,"/ne 6 !".ng near B1.$a-9/+egaon. 3. T1 FIR <as + '.," +ed against Sud1.+ D1aval & Sagar G/+:1 & Ha+,1al. P/"dar& D.6ak D1enga! & J*/". Jagtap& Ra$ ,1 Gay-1/+ and /"1 +s. T1 .nv ,".gat./n 6+/ceeded. S -"./n 1204B /0 IPC <as added /n ("1 Mar-1 201). T1 .nv ,".ga"./n <as "+ans0 ++ed "/ C+.$e B+anch& Pune. 4. A--/+d.ng "/ 6+/, -#"./n, d#+.ng "1 -/#+, /0 .nv ,".gat./n, sea+-1 <as -/nd#-" d /n 1C"1 A6+.! 201) at "1 + ,.dent.al 6+ $., , and </+: 6!aces /0 R/na 8.!,/n >R//.D !1.A& S#+end+a Gad!.ng >R//.Nagp#+A& Sud1.+ D1aval >R2/.M#$%aiA& Ha+,1al. P/"dar >R//.M#$%aiA& Sagar G/+:1 >R//.Pune)& D.6ak D1enga! >R//.Pune)& Ram ,1 Gay-1/+ >R//.P#ne)& J*/". Jagtap >R//.Pune). I" ., al!eged "1at d#+.ng "1 sea+-1 d/-#$ent, < + + -/7 +ed 0+/$ "1 .+ + ,6 -".7 -/$6#" +,2!ap"/6,26en d+.7 ,2$ $/+* card, "c.. D.00 +ent d/-#$ent, < + 0/und "/ 1av %een -+eated /+ : 6" .n "1 + ,6 -".7 -/$6#" +,2!a6"/6,26 n d+.7 ,2$ $/+* ca+d,2d 7.- , /n d.00 +ent da"es. T1 , .zed a+".-! , < + , nt "/ F/+ nsi- S-.ence Lab/+at/+* 0/+ anal*,.s. T1 -!/ned -/6. , < + + - .7 d %* "1 .nv ,".ga".ng agency. A--/+d.ng "/ 6+/, -#"./n, 0+/$ "1 , .zed and ::: Uploaded on - 14/02/2020 ::: Downloaded on - 14/02/2020 15:20:15 ::: 4 of 63 ABA.314.2019.doc + -/7 +ed $at +.al& ." <as + 7ealed "1at /"1 + 6 +,/ns ar al,/ 6ar" /0 -+.$.nal -/nsp.+acy. Based /n .nv ,".gat./n "1 6+/7.,./ns /0 S -"./ns 13& 1(& 1C& 1)& 1)4B& 20& 3) 39 and 40 /0 Unlaw0#! A-".7.". , >P+ 7ent./n A A-"& 19(C >`UAPA A-"@ 0/+ ,1/+"A < + ap6!.ed /n 1C"1 May 201) against S#+end+a Gad!.ng, R/na 8.!,/n, S1/$a Sen, Mah ,1 Raut& C/$+ad M E M.!.nd T !"#$%d & C/$+ad P+akash E Nav.n E Ri"#6an G/,<am.& C/$+ad Mangal# and C/$+ad D.6u. Sea+-1 <as -/nd#-"ed at "1 + ,.dence /0 S1/$a Sen and Mah ,1 Raut /n ("1 Jun 201). Sear-1 <as -ar+.ed /#" at "1 6!ace /0 + ,.dence /+ </+: 6!ace /0 a66!.cant& P.Barava+a Rao >R2/. Hyd +abadA& A+un F ++ .+a >R2/.T1ane)& Sud1a B1a+ad<aj >R//.Far.dabadA& B +non G/nsa!7es >R2/.M#$%aiA. 5. T1 accused S#+end+a Gad!.ng, R/na 8.!,/n and Sud1.+ D1aval < + a++ ,"ed /n ("1 June 201). A--/+d.ng "/ "1 6+/, -#"./n, %ased /n .ncr.$.nat.ng $at +.al& /"1 + 6 +,/ns < + added as accused& 7.z.P.Barava+a Rao& A+#n F ++ .+a, B +non G/nsal7 ,& Sud1a B1a+ad<aj& a66!.cant& Anand T !"#$%ad and S"an S<am*. C1ar' ,1 " <as 0.!ed against ar+ ,"ed accused und + S -"./ns 121& 1214A& 1244A& 1534A& 505>1A>%A& 11C& 1204B +2< 34 /0 Ind.an Penal C/d and und + S -"./ns 13& 1(& 1C& 1)& 1)4B& 20& 3)& 39 and 40 /0 UAPA A-". ::: Uploaded on - 14/02/2020 ::: Downloaded on - 14/02/2020 15:20:15 ::: 5 of 63 ABA.314.2019.doc (. T1 ap6!.cant@, .nv/!7 $ent <as d.,-!/sed and 1 <as a++aigned as accused /n 22nd A#'#," 201). C. On 29"1 A#'#," 201) 8+." P "."./n N/.2(0 /0 201) >R/$.!a T1a6ar and /"1 +, Bs. Uni/n /0 Ind.a and /"1 +, 4 >201)A104SCC4 C53A <as 6+ 0 ++ed % 0/+ "1 Hon’%! S#6+ $ C/#+" %* 0.7 $.nent 1.,"/+.ans and acad $.-, -1a!!enging "1 act./n /0 Maharash"+a P/!.- .n +aid.ng 1/$ , and ar+ ,".ng 1#$an +.'1", act.7.,",& ;/#+na!.,",& ad7/cat , and 6/!.".cal </+: +s. T1 '+. 7ance /0 "1 6 "."./ner, <as "1at "1 act.7.,", nam !* Gautam Nav!ak1a, Sud1a B1arad<aj& Ba+avara Rao& A+un F ++ .+a and B +non G/nsal7 , < + ar+ ,"ed /n 2)"1 A#'#," 201) 0+/$ "1 .+ 1/$ , at N < D !1.& Far.dabad& M#$%ai& T1ane and Hyd +abad <."1/#" any -+ed.%! $at +.al and 7.dence .n -/nnect./n <."1 FIR N/.4 /0 201) + '.," +ed <."1 B.,1+a$%agh P/!.- S"at./n, Pune. T1 6+/, -#"./n- + ,6/ndent /66/sed "1 6 "."./n %* 0.!.ng + 6!*. D#+.ng "1 -/#+, /0 1ear.ng /0 "1 said 6 "."./n, 0/+$a! a66!.cat./ns < + 0.!ed /n % 1al0 /0 Sud1a B1a+ad<aj& A+un F ++ .+a and B +non G/nsal7 ,& <1/ < + und + 1/#, ar+ ,"& ,"at.ng "1a" "1 * $ay % 6 +$.""ed "/ 6#+,# "1 <+." 6 "."./n 0.!ed %* "1 $. T1 Hon’%! S#6+ $ C/#+" 1ad F"ended 6+/" -"./n /0 1/#, ar+ ," '+anted "/ "1 ap6!.cant and /"1 +s. T1 6 "."./ner, 1ad 6+ayed "1a" "1 .nv ,".gat./n % ::: Uploaded on - 14/02/2020 ::: Downloaded on - 14/02/2020 15:20:15 ::: 6 of 63 ABA.314.2019.doc $/ni"/+ed "1+/#'1 SIT. T1 Hon’%! S#6+ $ C/#+" 7.d ;ud'$ nt and /+d + dated 2)"1 S 6" $% + 201) %* $aj/+."* /0 2=1 d -!.ned "/ /+d + a C/#+" $/ni"/+ed SIT. T1 accused < + 6 +$.""ed "/ , : /"1 + + $ed. , .nclud.ng quash.ng/%ai! "c. T1 .nt +.$ 6+/" -"./n <as F"end d 0/+ a 0#+"1 + 0/#+ < :, "/ nab! "1 accused "/ 6#+sue ap6+/6+.a"e + $ed.es. ). T1 a66!.cant 6+ 0 ++ed C+.$.nal 8+." P "."./n N/.459( /0 201) % 0/+ "1., C/#+" %* .nv/:.ng <+." ;#+.,d.-"./n /0 "1., C/#+" und + A+".-! 22( /0 C/nst."#"./n /0 Ind.a , :.ng quash.ng /0 CR N/.4 /0 201). T1 ,aid 6 "."./n <as d.,$.,, d 7.d ;ud'$ent and /+d + dat d 21," D - $% + 201). T1 /6 +at./n /0 "1 /+d + <as, 1/< 7 +& ,"a*ed /n "1 + 3# ," /0 a66!.cant 0/+ a 6 +./d /0 "1+ < :s. T1 a66!.cant 6+ 0 ++ed 6 "."./n 0/+ S6 -.al Leav "/ A66ea! >C+..A N/.59 /0 2019 % 0/+ Hon’%! S#6+ $ C/#+" -1al!enging "1 ;ud'$ent and /+d + dated 21," D - $% + 201) 6assed %* D.7.,./n Bench /0 "1., C/#+".