Moaduy, Ottobar1,1 9 9 0 Nbilli Scries, Vol.X, No. 22 AsTin 9, 1912 LOK SABHA DEBATES (English Version) Third Session—Second Part (Ninth Lok Sabha) (Fo/. X containsMok 22 to 24) LOK SABHA SECRETARIAT NEW DELHI Price : Rs. 6^00 [ORIGINAL ENOUSH PROCaBEDlNOS INCLUDED IN ENOLmi VERSION AND ORIGINAL HINDI PROCEHDINOS INCLUDED IN HINDI VERSKW W ill, BE TREATED AS AUTHORITATIVE AND NOT THE TRANSpVTION THEREOF.] CONTENTS [Ninth Series, Vol. X, Third Session-Second Part, l990l1912{Saka) No. 22, Monday, October 1, 1990/Asvina 9, 1912 (Saka) COUTMNS Obituary References 1—4 Re. Adjournment Motion 19 -22, Police atrocities in dealing with students' agitation 135 against Government’s decision on Mandal Commission Report and resort to self-immolation by students against the decision Paper Laid on the Table 22 Assent to Bills 23 -24 Constitution (Seventy-Fifth Amendment) Bill 24 (Amendment of Article 356)—Introduced Matters under Rule 377 25—31 (i) Need to bring Kakinada town in East Godavari 25 District of Andhra Pradesh on the main railway line Shri M. M. Pallam Raju (ii) Need to give financial assistance to Uttar 27—28 Pradesh for construction of bridges over river Gomti between Shahjahanpur and Lucknow Shri Ram Lai Rahi (iii) Need to withdraw the orders regarding closure 28—29 of Supply Department of DGS&D and its. decentralisation Shri Basudeb Acharia (iv) Need to take steps to provide drinking water 29 in Jahanabad, Bihar Shri Ramashray Prasnd Smgh (v) Need to provide more L.P.G. connections and 29—'30 need to regulate the supply of gas cylinders in Jaipur, Riyasthan Shri Girdhari Lai Bhargava (vi) Need to provide compensation to workers 30—31 rendered jobless due to closure of 16 textile mills in Alunedabad Shri Prakabh Koko Brahmbhatt (0 (ii) COLUMKS Constitution (Seventy-Fifth Amendment) Bill 31-134 (Amendment of Article 356) Motion to consider Negatived Shri Mufti Mohammad Sayeed 31 -33, 100 107 Shri Kamal Chaudhry 34-41 Shri Yamuna Prasao Shastn 42 -47 Prof. Prem Kumai Dhumal 47 -51 Shri Saifuddin Choudhury 51 -56 Shri Indrajit Gupta 56 -62 Dr. Thambi Durai 62 -65 Shrimati Bimal Kaur Khalsa 6 6 -7 0 Shi i Kapil Dev Shastri 70 -73 Shrimati Sukhbuns Kaur 73-78 S. Atinder Pal Singh 7 9-82 Shri Inder Jit 82 84 Shri Kirpal Singh 84 87 Shri Nani Bhattacharya 87 88 Shri Harbhajan Lakha 88 90 Shri Rajdev Singh 90 93 Shri A. K. Roy 94- 96 Prof. Saif-ud-din Soz 96 100 Announcement by Deputy Speaker 136 Sitting for 3 October, 1990 cancelled on account of Prophet Mohammad Sahib’t. birthday LOK SABHA DEBATES LOK SABHA Chaudhary Multan Singh was elect­ ed to this House from Jalesar Coos* tituency of Uttar Pradesh in the Grae- ral Elections held In November. 1989, Monday, October 1, 19901Asvina 9, He had represented the same consti­ 1912 iSaka) tuency in the Sixth Lok Sabha (1977- 79) and Seventh Lok Sabha (1980-84K Earlier he had been a Member of The Lok Sabha met at Eleven of the Uttar Pradesh Vidhan Sabha contin­ Clock uously for four terms, during 1962-67, J 967-69, 1969-74 and 1974-77. [MR. SPEAKER in the Chair] He served on the Parliamentary OBITUARY REFERENCES Committee on Public Undertakings and [English] also Consultative Committee for the Ministry of Petroleum. Chemicals and MR. SPEAKER: Hon. Members, Fertiliser for about 2 years. As a as we meet today after an interval of Member of Uttar Pradesh Vidhan about three weeks, it is my sad duty Sabha also, he was assix;iatcd with to inform the House of the d^ise its various Committees, vi?. Estimates of two sitting Members, namely Shri Committee, Public Accounts Com­ Shashibhai Jamod and Chaudhary mittee etc. Therefore his services and Multan Sin^h and two of our former contribution as a legislator were enor­ colleagues, i.e., Sarvashri Raj Baha­ mous. dur and Prafulla Chandra Sen. Chaudhary Muhan Singh served the Shri Shashibhai Jamod was elected country in a multi-faceted capacity, as to this House from Bhavnagar Cons­ an agriculturist, political worker and tituency of Gujarat State in the Gene­ an able parliamentarian. He had ral Elections held in November, 1989- been actively involved in the Socialist Earlier, he had been a Member of Movement. the Gujarat Legislative Assembly during 1985-89 and also a Minister in the State Cabinet for a short peri<xi He relentles.sly worked for the up- between March and May, 1985. Uftment of agriculturists, villagers and depressed and the downtrodden and An engineer as well as lawyer by was instrumental in establishing ‘Kri- profession. Shri Jamod played signifi­ shak Manch’ for voicing the cause of cant role in the promotion of educa­ farmers. He worked hard for promo­ tion in the State of Gujarat. An ac­ tion of education among masses. Age tive, social and political worker, he and fragile health did not deter him served as a member of the Backward from undertaking the social and poli­ Oasses Commission in the State Gu­ tical activities even till the last mo­ jarat between 1987-89. ments of his life. He pas.sed away at Rewari on 23 September. 1990 at An able parliamentarian, he made the age of 75 years while he was par­ valuable coctributioas to proceed­ ticipating in a social function. ings of the House. Shri Ra| Bahadur was a member of Shri Jamod passed away at Bhav­ th« Constituent Assembly and Provi­ nagar oa 19. September. 1990 at the sional Ptrliament from 1946-1952. La­ age of 52. ter he was elected to the First Lxdc 3 Obituary References OCTOBER 1, 1990 Obituary References 4 Sabha from Bharatpur coastituenc^ of A well-known sodal and political Rajasthan, which position he retained worker, he preferred constructive ru» in the Second. Third and Fifth Lok ral work and upliftment of depressed Sabha. and downtrodden classes in Arambagh which earned him the sobriquet of tJie He held with distinction various im­ ‘Gandhi of Arambagh’. portant portfolios in the Union Coun­ cil of Ministers during his long and An able administrator, Shri Sen illustrious parliamentary career. An held the portfolio of Food with dis­ able parliamentarian, he took keen in­ tinction in the State Cabinet headed terest in the proceedings of the House by Dr. B.C. Roy, right from 1948. and made significant contributions Subsequently on the demise of Dr. thereto. As a Minister of Parliamen­ Roy, Shri Sen succeeded him as Chief tary Affairs, his contribution for Minister of West Bengal in 1962 till smooth functioning of the House will the general election held in 1967. always be remembered. A well-known and soft-spoken par­ A veteran freedom fighter, he ac­ liamentarian, his contributions in the tively participated in the freedom proceedings of Lok Sabha, particularly stru^le from his college days and led in regard to ujpliftment of weaker sec­ the movement in erstwhile State of tions of thel society and spread of edu­ Bharatpur in 1940-41 to 1947 and cation amongst the masses, shall al­ suffered imprisonment. ways be remembered. An Advocate by profession, he was Shri Sen. despite having indifferent associated with several social and health over the last few years, took political organisations. He worked active part in the political affairs. He relentlessly for the social upliftment passed away at Calcutta on 25 Sep­ of the backward classes and vigorous­ tember. 1990 at the age of 94 years. ly camp.iigned for abolition of forced labour in the State of Bharatpur. We deeply mourn the loss of these friends and I am sure the House will A widely travelled person he took join me in conveying our condolences keen interest in sports too. to the bereaved families. The House may now stand in si­ Shri Raj Bahadur passed away at lence for a short while to express its Delhi on 22 September, 1990 at the sorrow. age of 78. The Members then stood ?«i silence Shri Prafulla Chandra Sen was a for a shcvt while member of the Constituent Assembly. He was elected to Sixth Lok Sabha from Arambagh constituency from [Translation] West Bengal in 1977. Earlier he had SHRI MADAN LAL KHURANA been a member of West Bengal As­ (South Delhi): Mr. Speak«, Sir, sembly. Shri Sen was one of the ol­ pie are committing self-immolation. dest living Gandhians and freedom {Interruptions) fighters in the country. [English] He suffered imprisonment for a to­ tal period of 11 years for participat­ MR. SPEAKER: Please take your ing in Non-Cooperation Movement, seats. Civil Disobedience Movement and the Quit India Movement. Even as a ilnterruptiam) student, he was attracted by the call MR. SPEAKER: Mr. Prime Minis­ of nationalist mov«nent. Later on. ter. he was drawn towards Gandhiji and his principles of non-violence. (Intarupttim) ASVINA 9, 1912 {SAKA) MR. SPEAKER; Please take your [Translation] seats. MR. SPEAKER: Shri Kalim th and I have called the hon. Prime Minis­ Shri Kumaramangalam, jdease tidce ter. your seats. (Interruptions) (Interrupticm) MR. SPEAKER: Will you please [English] / take your seats? SHRI AJIT PANJA: He has no (IrtterruptUms) right to speak. He must first visit the MR. SPEAKER: Mr. Rawat, please crying mothers whose children were take your seat. killed and visit the injured now in hospitals. (Interruptions) (Inierrupthm) MR. SPEAKER: I will allow you SHRI AJIT PANJA (Calcutta North after the Prime Minister. Now, will East): How can he speak Sir? He has you please take your scat? lorfeited his right to speak. (Intet- rupliom) (Interruptions) MR SPEAKER: Mrs Jamuna. [Trmstation] please go to your seat. MR. SPEAKER: Rawatji, please (Interruptions) take youi seat.