Deliberative Document - For Discussion Purposes Only - Do Not Release Under FOIA DCN: 10783 THE UNDER SECRETARY OF DEFENSE 30 10 DEFENSE PENTAGON WASHINGTON, DC 2030 1-3010 ACQUISITION. TECHNOLOGY AND LOGISTICS NOV 3 0 2904 MEMORANDUM FOR INFRASTRUCTURE STEERING GROUP (ISG) MEMBERS SUBJECT: Coordination on Scenario Conflicts Proposed Resolutions As agreed at the October 15,2004, Infrastructure Steering Group meeting, the DASs were to brief only those scenarios for which they could not agree on a proposed resolution. Because the DAS's review of the seventh batch of scenarios indicated there were no issues for in-person ISG deliberations, we will obtain your concurrence on the DAS's newly proposed resolutions via paper. The attached package includes all 5 18 scenarios registered in the tracking tool as of November 12,2004. A summary of these scenarios, broken out by category (Independent, Enabling, Conflicting, Deleted, and Not Ready for Categorization) can be found at TAB 1. The section titled "New Conflicts Settled" includes new scenario conflicts on which the DASs and affected JCSGs agree regarding the proposed resolution (TAB 2). TAB 3 represents the one contested conflict resolution for an E&T and Air Force scenario. Discussions regarding this issue are scheduled for the December 3,2004, ISG meeting. Details of the remaining scenarios, by category (Old Conflicts Settled, Independent, Enabling, Deleted, and Not Ready for Categorization), are provided on a disc at TAB 4-8. Request your written concurrence on the proposed resolutions (TAB 2) by close of business on Fridav. December 3.2004. (~ctin~~~~/(Ac~uisition, Technology & Logistics) Chairman, Infrastructure Steering Group Attachment: As stated cc: Joint Cross-Service Groups Chairs Deliberative Document - For DiscussionCj Purp ses Only - Do Not Release Under FOIA INDEX Tab 1 – Summary of Scenarios Registered Tab 2 – New Conflicts Settled Tab 3 – Not Resolved Tab 4 – Old Conflicts Settled - disc Tab 5 – Independent - disc Tab 6 – Enabling - disc Tab 7 – Deleted - disc Tab 8 – Not ready for Categorization - disc Scenarios Registered (Scenarios as of 12Nov 04) DAS Review 24 Nov 04 Total Not Ready for Independent Enabling Conflicting Deleted Categorization 119 20 44 47 8: USA-0005, 0025,0037, Army 0042, 0043, 0052, 0071, 0079 69 28 32 5 4: DoN-0027, 0028, 0029, DoN 0030 15: USAF-0001, 0002, 0004, 0005, 29 11 2 1 ooo9, 0019, 0020, 0021,0022, 0023, Air Force 0024, 0025, 0026, 0028, 0029 36 1 17 16 2: E&T-0011, 0019 Ed & Training 109 1 74 25 9: H&SA-0023, 0037, 0038, 0039, 0052, 0054, 0066, 0073, H&SA 0091 53 6 7 19 16 5: IND-0002, 0005, 0007, Industrial 0010, 0011 11 0 3 5 3: INTEL-0001, 0002, 0008 Intelligence 32 0 28 4 Medical 26 9 9 6 2: S&S-0001, 0002 Supply & Storage 34 7 8 11 8: TECH-0011, 0015, 0016, Technical 0021, 0022, 0023, 0024, 0025 TOTAL 518 83 224 19 136 56 Draft Deliberative Document –For Discussion Purposes Only – Do Not Release Under FOIA 1 New Conflicts Settled Deliberative Document –For Discussion Purposes Only – Do Not Release Under FOIA 1 Redacted E&T-0031, H&SA-0045, 0048, 0071, 0072, 0076, 0099 & 0100, & INT-0005 – Ft Meade Conflicts New n Facilities (E&T-0031, H&SA-0045, 0048, 0071, 0072, 0076, 0099, & 0100, & INT-0005) Previous n Facilities (H&SA-0045, 0048, 0071, 0072, 0076, 0099, & 0100, & INT-0005) Proposed Resolution New n Continue with original scenario (E&T-0031) n E&T already has a scenario (E&T-0030) that does not use Ft Meade (E&T-0031) Previous n Continue with original scenario(s) (H&SA-0045, 0048, 0071, 0072, 0076, 0099, & 0100 & INT-0005) n INT already has scenarios (INT-0003 & 0004) that use other locations. (INT-0005). n Direct H&SA to develop and analyze scenario(s) that do not use Ft Meade (H&SA-0045, 0048, 0071, 0072, & 0076) •Note: H&SA has developed scenarios (H&SA-0046, 0047, 0049, & 0072) that use other locations (H&SA-0045, 0048, 0072, 0076, & 0100) n H&SA already has a scenario (H&SA-0098) that uses other locations (H&SA-0099) Deliberative Document –For Discussion Purposes Only – Do Not Release Under FOIA 3 E&T-0028, 0034, & 0036, H&SA-0055, 0057, & 0063, & MED-0013 – Fort Eustis Scenarios Involved Conflicts n Consolidate senior service colleges, national war colleges New and industrial college as a single school under the n Facilities – (E&T-0028, 0034, & 0036, & H&SA- National Defense University at Ft Eustis. (E&T-0028) 0055, 0057 & 0063) n Realign senior service colleges under the National n Doctrinal – Senior Service colleges under NDU Defense University with the national war colleges and (E&T-0028, 0034, & 0036) industrial colleges co-located but under their chain of command. (E&T-0034) Previous n Realign senior service colleges under the National Defense University and relocate to Ft Eustis. (E&T- n Cultural – AF patients at Army facility (MED- 0036) 0013) n Realign Ft McPherson, GA by co-locating FORSCOM and USARC at Ft Eustis, VA. (H&SA-0055) Proposed Resolution n Realign Ft Monroe, VA, Naval Station Norfolk, and New JFCOM leased facilities in Suffolk, VA by co-locating n Continue with original scenarios (E&T-0028, TRADOC (minus Army Accessions Command and 0034, & 0036, & H&SA-0055, 0057 & 0063) Cadet Command), JFCOM HQ, and JFCOM leased n Direct H&SA to develop scenarios that do not use facilities in Suffolk, VA to Ft. Eustis, VA. (H&SA-0057 Ft Eustis (H&SA-0063) n Realign Washington Navy Yard and 1 leased location in Alexandria, Virginia by co-locating USN Military Sealift n E&T and H&SA already have scenarios (E&T- Command (COMSC) and USA Surface Deployment and 0025, 0026 & 0027, & H&SA-0060 & 0083) that Distribution Command (SDDC) with existing SDDC use other locations (E&T-0028, 0034, & 0036, & offices at Ft. Eustis. (H&SA-0063) H&SA-0055, & 0057) n Disestablish Langley AFB Medical Facility and move patient workload to expanded Fort Eustis Medical Facility. Previous (MED-0013) n Continue with original scenario. (MED-0013) Deliberative Document –For Discussion Purposes Only – Do Not Release Under FOIA 4 DoN 0033 & MED-0023 – SUBASE New London Scenarios Involved Conflicts n Close SUBASE New London, CT n Force Structure – (DoN-0004, & (D0N-0033) 0033, IND-0003 & 0026, & MED-0023) n Create Tri-service Biomedical research centers of excellence at four sites by relocating hyperbaric Proposed Resolution medicine department, NMRC to n Continue with Original Scenarios SUBASE New London. (MED- (DoN-0033 & MED-0023) 0023) n Direct MED to develop and analyze a scenario that does not use SUBASE New London. (MED-0023) Deliberative Document –For Discussion Purposes Only – Do Not Release Under FOIA 5 E&T-0027, 0033, & 0035, H&SA-0041, 0094, & 0108 – MCB Quantico Scenarios Involved Scenarios Involved n Consolidate the United States Army War College, Air n Realign NSA New Orleans, LA by co-locating Marine War College, College of Naval Warfare, Marine Corps Corps Recruiting Command with HQ Marine Corps War College, National War College, and the Industrial and Marine Corps Recruiting Command at MCB College of the Armed Forces as a single school under Quantico, VA. (H&SA-0041) the National Defense University at MCB Quantico. n Relocate Marine Corps Reserve Command by (E&T-0027) realigning NSA New Orleans, LA by relocating with n Consolidate the United States Army War College, Air HQ Marine Corps and Marine Corps Recruiting War College, College of Naval Warfare, and the Command at MCB Quantico, VA. (H&SA-0094) Marine Corps War College as a single school under the n Realign Washington Navy Yard, Andrews AFB, and National Defense University at MCB Quantico. The Ft. Belvoir by co-locating Navy Criminal Investigation National War College, and the Industrial College of the Service, AF Office of Special Investigation, and USA Armed Forces will co-locate at MCB Quantico, but Criminal Investigation Command at MCB Quantico. with retention of the current chain of command. (E&T- (H&SA-0108) 0033) n Consolidate the United States Army War College, Air War College, College of Naval Warfare, and the Marine Corps War College under the National Defense University at MCB Quantico. (E&T-0035) Deliberative Document –For Discussion Purposes Only – Do Not Release Under FOIA 6 E&T-0027, 0033, & 0035, H&SA-0041, 0094, & 0108 – MCB Quantico Conflicts n Facilities – (E&T-0027, 0033, & 0035, H&SA-0041, 0094, & 0108) n Doctrinal – (E&T-0027, 0033, & 0035) Proposed Resolution n Continue with original scenarios (E&T-0027, 0033, & 0035, H&SA-0041, 0094, 0108) n Direct H&SA to develop and analyze scenarios that do not use MCB Quantico facilities. (H&SA-0041, 0094 ) n E&T and H&SA already have scenarios (E&T-0028, 0032, & 0036 and H&SA-0076) that use other locations (E&T-0027, 0033, & 0035 and H&SA-0108) Deliberative Document –For Discussion Purposes Only – Do Not Release Under FOIA 7 H&SA-0070 & 0106 & MED-0023 & 0024 – Walter Reed Army Medical Center Scenarios Involved Conflicts n Close 1 and realign 5 leased locations in the n Facilities – (H&SA-0070 & 0106 NCR, Bolling AFB and Potomac Medical Annex by relocating medical activities to & MED-0023 & 0024) Walter Reed Medical Center (H&SA-0070) n Close 9 and realign 26 leased locations by relocating OSD components to Walter Proposed Resolution Reed Medical Center (H&SA-0106) n Continue with original scenarios n Create Tri-Service Biomedical/Research Centers at 4 locations by relocating Division (H&SA-0070 & 0106 & MED-0023 & of Retrovirology, WRAIR, and the Vacuum 0024) Research Program NMRC to Walter Reed n Direct H&SA and MED to develop and Medical Center.