THE SENATE OF PAKISTAN DEBATES OFFICIAL REPORT Monday, September 27, 2010 (64 th Session) Volume VIII No. 06 (Nos. 01-10) CONTENTS Pages 1. Recitation from the Holy Quran ……………....……….. 1 2. Leave of Absence.……………………………………… 2-5 3. Presentation of the Reports ……………………………. 6 4. Discussion on Law and Order Situation in the country... 7-10 points of order: a) By Senator Zafar Ali Shah regarding territorial violation by the NATO Forces……. 11-12 b) By Senator Abdul Nabi Bangesh about official authentic report on Target Killing.----- 13-52 Printed and Published by the Senate Secretariat, Islamabad. Volume VIII SP. VIII ( 06 )/2010 No.06 130 SENATE OF PAKISTAN SENATE DEBATES Monday, September 27, 2010 The Senate of Pakistan met in the Senate Hall (Parliament House) Islamabad, at thirty minutes past four in the evening with Mr. Chairman (Mr. Farooq Hamid Naek) in the Chair. ---------------- Recitation from the Holy Quran -.. ! ª "#$% // - & ' (" ! () *#+$ $,% 0 ; 2( >? )% @ A - +"= ) 9:% - 123 45 %(6$% 78$ < ‹ G H( IJ 5% G 2(#$% >B$ CD EF$ ! / OPH 3 %6Q $, O#$% A - NK L 3 IM3 45 H( IJ A T R H S()$% >B$ 7*$ ! 7& - / G . 2 @$ N = ; ; :U ! / Q, 3 G ! / Q, ) =& :U% +ª $, G R=#A 8 D 8 R R 8 D 8 =3SH C )=KO 6J =C<;=?PI ;L=CB=B=M;=?E Q Q =4=NQ E;<= >FG = ?H = @;= ABI = B6 J C<; : 3567 4 9 8 O O X 9fg O kl e m R 8 =[bc =C<;=?\P L=4Q =] =BQ =^;=?_ dEP =VL=`hi =? =@;=V j =? C=aCB6 J =? Q (T69 ;UW ?E VYZ t 8 O 8 =n6J =o=@;=p?_d =;4=q69s6 =Ueu =?\ PQdI =? =^;=C<;=?_O =rPvI =4=^Bw 9EQxh ;=KhyZY =? E 4=LVz{ =K h y c 8 O 8 8 8O O 8 =C<;p?_d =VSh9 L=4Q =• S9 ( ?_d =VSdY Vw l =V j =n 6J)=C<;=?_d =VSh9 L=4Q =|;U=}CC=?_~ d =V Slj d Y Vw =V O OOOOD O 8 ƒQOOyZ ƒQ =? Q ) €4J •;=‚ >C=‚i =VhS9 L=C<;=Kh Y =?_d C=B=MBYd J =4=‚w 9 >C=‚ i =V h S 9 L=AB=UV I ~ j 1 O ŽPw9 8 X R 8 8 ( •=Œ 6 •5 h )=M;=3Š =KhyYZ =?Pˆm =U~ Vj =C<;=p?_ d =‰>V=;CBi ‹ et ( rˆ6t)=K hyc ( ?… „i V †‡ XXO O t O O D O =@;=3Š =<L=3 F m =p‚B=K“YdhyF =•CV=^Bih PQ =‚V ““ z E =‚B Q =?H =‘U ’ =‚ Q =CV ” LC<4=?w9 Q =M;=4 w 9 8 8 8 8 =BQ =M;=?_d =Vi BY d =—B6 J C ( ‘U’ = ‚Q =M; )=B=C<;?_6J d =V4=‰;UiQ –Yu ?_ d =V Sld V=?„w x J =‚VI • E 8 O O O J O ™vhE 8 8 ™9 =@;=LVhi =•L=?Q =K6 =C<;=? E š=^V 5 ht ;=ABI =B 6 J ( q ) p?_d =VVi ˜m L=3S H C=V=‘U=q j ’ w ; 8 8 8 yZ œ Q I m O H yZ pKh Y =?E V=›;C•;=•L=qwiY =? H =LV=‚h i =o‚V • E =@;=3Š =Be C=K =pKh Y =?E V=›;C•;=?wi H 8 8 8 ( ( 28 Vi25 Th9 •; )=>• 4I ;=‰CBž = 8 ™J 7 ¡ 6E X O pKhyZY =?\Py£ =? I =Leave Applications =?…F ¤t p`h 4;=KIO o ¢ 4;=3 I b£ ;=` =:KO hyc Œ•Sh wJ =€V6 S6J LEAVE of ABSENCE 8 O 8 O OOQ8 ‡ “ R « ” O X J O ¬®= =Vi =¬• =3CB=4=Vl ‡ w9 SS69 =‚ =€Vh { <Œ© =‚;L=r6J V ¨ =€š=> 5 ª =§=€V6 S 6J =:Khyc Œ•Sh w =€V6 S6J O O 8 O D 8 8 O t 8 O t t 8 ™H =r°J C=?H =^;B;=?\OOhE PQI =? =^B ²h CV=^;=?i E =^B ˆ t ;=?\ P I =M;=p? e± =?³ 4=KQ hyF =TŒ=KQ ´ h y c =M¯6l;==Œ 6 •5 ¶ O O O 8 ‡ 8QOO Q 8 Q ˚?_d =VVUCBi c~ f P =r°J C==‚ =^;==^;B;=3=Vh Eh i h S Q =p?_ d =‚ =r H ;B J CL=‚ X ¶ O 8 O ( ( =q™ƒ =‚Q =CBfP‡ =r °J )C 8 O Q8 ‡ “ O OO ™dY « y ‹ O X J O =4=Vw9S69 =‚=€Vh S { <Œ© =‚;L=rV6J ¨l =^V=`h ;4;=>6 9h9 5 ª =Œ · <4=w :Khyc Œ•Sh w = €V6 S6J O 8 O D 8 O t 8 O t t 8 ™H O =^B²h CV=^;=?i O E =^B ˆt ;=?\ PI =M;=p? e± =?³ 4=KQ hyF =TŒQ ´ =K h y c =M¯;=B=Œ6l Q 6 •5 ¬® =C<;=¬¬ ¬¸˘ 3l CB ‡ ¶ O OOO 8 ‡ 8QOOO Q 8 Q 8 I ˚?_dP =VVUCBi c~ f =r°J C==‚ =^;==^;B;=3=Vh Eh i h S Q =p?_ d =‚ =r H ;B J CL=‚ =r ° J C=? HPQ =^;B h E ;=?\ =? X ¶ O 8 O ( ( =q™ƒ =‚Q =CBfP‡ =r °J )C 8 O 8 O OOQ8 ‡ “ O « O X J O ¬®= =Vi =¬» =3CB=4=Vl ‡ w9 SS69 =‚=€Vh { <Œ© =‚;L=rV6J ¨FS C>=Œ6 ih •ºi V6 7 => 5 ª =€V6 6J =:Khyc Œ•Sh w =€V6 S6J O O 8 O D 8 8 O t 8 O t t 8 ™H =r°J C=?H =^;B;=?\OOhE PQI =? =^B ²h CV=^;=?i E =^B ˆ t ;=?\ P I =M;=p? e± =?³ 4=KQ hyF =TŒ=KQ ´ h y c =M¯6l;Œ 6 •5 ¶ O O O 8 ‡ 8QOO Q 8 Q ˚?_d =VVUCBi c~ f P =r°J C==‚ =^;==^;B;=3=Vh Eh i h S Q =p?_ d =‚ =r H ;B J CL=‚ X ¶ O 8 O ( ( =q ™ƒ=‚Q =CBfP‡ =r°J C ) 8 O ¶ O OOQ8 ‡ “ ²¼ « O X J O ¬»= =3CB=4=Vl‡ w9 SS69 =‚=€Vh { <Œ© =‚;L=rV6J ¨ =N;=U½’ => 5 ª =3;C==€V6 l 6 S 6J = :Khyc Œ•Sh w =€V6 S6J = O OOO 8 O D 8 8 O t 8 t yt 8 y ™H =r°J C=?H =^;B;=?\hE PQI =? =¾CV=M;=?h i E =^B ˆt ;=?\ P I =M;=p? e± =?³ 4=KQ hF =TŒ=KQ ´ h c =M¯;6l =B Q ==Œ 6 •5 ¶ O O O 8 ‡ 8QOO Q 8 Q ˚?_d =VVUCBi c~ f P =r°J C==‚ =^;==^;B;=3=Vh Eh i h S Q =p?_ d =‚ =r H ;B J CL=‚ X ¶ O 8 O ( ( =q™ƒ =‚=CBQ fP‡ =r°J C ) 2 8 O 8 O OOQ8 ‡ “O “ À « O X J O ¬»= =Vi =¬¬ =3CB=4=Vl ‡ w9 SS69 =‚ =€Vh { <Œ© =‚;L=r6J V ¨ =‚;CL=q• => 5 ª ==€V6 S 6J =:Khyc Œ •Sh w =€V6 S6J O O 8 O D 8 8 O t 8 O t t 8 ™H =r°J C=?H =^;B;=?\OOhE PQI =? =^B ²h CV=^;=?i E =^B ˆ t ;=?\ P I =M;=p? e± =?³ 4=KQ hyF =TŒ=KQ ´ h y c =M¯6l;==Œ 6 •5 ¶ O O O 8 ‡ 8QOO Q 8 Q ˚?_d =VVUCBi c~ f P =r°J C==‚ =^;==^;B;=3=Vh Eh i h S Q =p?_ d =‚ =r H ;B J CL=‚ X ¶ O 8 O ( ( =q™ƒ =‚=CBQ fP‡ =r°J C ) O O khi 8 O O Q 6 P’ O O O X J O =` =Vi =¬® =3l CB‡ =4w9 =V S69=‚ ==] =ÁCV³i V===?E =r6J V ¨ ==CB…6i => 5 7 ;=MVh SSI ;=€V6 6J=:Khyc Œ•Sh w =€V6 S6J ¶ O OOO 8 ‡ 8QOOO Q 8 Q 8 8 ˚?_dP =VVUCBi c~ f =r°J C==‚ =^;==^;B;=3=Vh Eh i h S Q =p?_ d =‚ =r H ;B J CL=‚ =r ° J C=? H =^;B h E ;===469 BPQ ; X ¶ O 8 O ( ( =q™ƒ =‚=CBQ fP‡ =r°J C ) 8 8 ™H O O Q8 ‡ “ O X O 8 « O X J O ==BQ =Œ6 •5 = ¬¸ =3CB=4=Vl‡ w9 S69 =‚=€Vh S { <Œ© =‚;L==36 SSÂJ V ¨ =‘<C=3h y 6S H =3Œ •Ã = :Khyc Œ•Sh w =€V6 S6J O OOO 8 O D Q 8 O t 8 y³yt k t 8 y =‚ =r°J C=?H =^;B;=?\hE PQI =? =¾CV=M;=?h i E =^B ˆ t ;=?\ P I =M;= pKh˜ =q 4=KQ h F =TŒ=K=M¯Q ´ h c 6l; ¶ O O O 8 ‡ 8QOO Q 8 ˚?_d =VVUCBi c~ f P =r°J C==‚ =^;==^;B;=3=Vh Eh i h S Q =p?_ d =‚ =r H ;B J CL X ¶ O 8 O ( ( =q™ƒ =‚=CBQ fP‡ =r°J C ) O X O ! ! r6 J V¨ =ÁCV à 6t =q=67:KO hyc Œ•Sh wJ =€V6 S6J Would you like to start item No.2 or move some motion? O O O O X O O y J R y H 4w9 =M;=€V6 S6J :( ^;BhE ;=>i V Ç ) ÁCVÃ6t =K h z =Œh •i =>hSH =Œ •Sh hS in fact in the last Business Advisory meeting this was the decision over there that we will be taking up the Flood situation as the first instant, that would be discussed in the House and then the other issue was the Law and Order situation. This was the consensus between the members of the Committee. 8 8 8 yO m 7 yR t t y wl X J O =pKhZYY =?_Pd V=VwlSˆm =Èw² =€•;=rVw 6 J ¨É =}CV=q=pK6 h Z =?\ P y £ 4=3=;CBQ h i e =? … F ¤=K h b =:KO hyc Œ•Sh w =€V6 S6J O 8 O 8 t t y t y t R =[=¾V=?i w wiH =<L? …F ¤=pKh ZY =? E V=•;=4=6 l w9motion =Uew =^B=?I I =formal business =Kh c =?…F ¤ ! =rP‡ =[;h i 8 pKhyZY =?P \y£=? I Senator Col Senator Syed Tahir Husssain Mashhadi may move item No.2.