FINAL EVALUATION REPORT BERLIN Authors: Name Partner Institution Elisabeth Kracker Integrated Transport Planning TU Berlin Hans-Joachim Becker Integrated Transport Planning TU Berlin Diana Runge Integrated Transport Planning TU Berlin Astrid Karl Social Science Research Centre Berlin (WZB) Wiebke Zimmer Öko-Institut e.V. Martin Schmied Öko-Institut e.V. Martin Schönberg Centre for Technology and Society (CTS) TU Berlin Peer review: Friedemann Kunst Senate Department of Urban Development Issued in November 2005 Table of Contents Table of Contents A INTRODUCTION ................................................................................1 A.1 General Remarks .....................................................................................................1 A.2 TELLUS landscape in Berlin.....................................................................................2 1 Demonstration measures...........................................................................................2 2 Thematic clusters.......................................................................................................3 3 Integration into local transport policy .........................................................................4 4 Actors of evaluation ...................................................................................................5 B EVALUATION ON DEMONSTRATION MEASURE LEVEL..............7 B.1 Approach ..................................................................................................................7 1 Overview ....................................................................................................................7 2 Types of evaluation....................................................................................................8 3 Objectives ..................................................................................................................9 4 Scenarios.................................................................................................................10 B.2 Demonstration Measure 6.4 – Tele-Parking System/Mobile Parking .....................13 1 Introduction ..............................................................................................................13 2 Description of demonstration measure ....................................................................13 3 Implementation process...........................................................................................17 4 Results.....................................................................................................................20 5 Conclusions .............................................................................................................29 6 Scenario...................................................................................................................33 B.3 Demonstration Measure 6.5 – Road Pricing...........................................................43 1 Introduction ..............................................................................................................43 2 Description of demonstration measure ....................................................................43 3 Implementation process...........................................................................................45 4 Results.....................................................................................................................46 5 Conclusions .............................................................................................................48 6 Scenario...................................................................................................................49 Issued in November 2005 I Final Evaluation Report - Berlin B.4 Demonstration Measure 7.5 – Future Management of Urban Public Transport.....51 1 Introduction ..............................................................................................................51 2 Description of demonstration measure ....................................................................51 3 Implementation process...........................................................................................53 4 Results.....................................................................................................................56 5 Conclusions .............................................................................................................59 6 Scenario...................................................................................................................63 B.5 Demonstration Measure 8.4 – Metropolitan Fleet Car............................................65 1 Introduction ..............................................................................................................65 2 Description of demonstration measure ....................................................................65 3 Implementation process...........................................................................................67 4 Results.....................................................................................................................70 5 Conclusions .............................................................................................................72 6 Scenario...................................................................................................................75 B.6 Demonstration Measure 8.5 - Car Modal................................................................85 1 Introduction ..............................................................................................................85 2 Description of demonstration measure ....................................................................85 3 Implementation process...........................................................................................87 4 Results.....................................................................................................................90 5 Conclusions .............................................................................................................93 6 Scenario...................................................................................................................97 B.7 Demonstration Measure 9.3 – Inner City Logistics Centre ...................................105 1 Introduction ............................................................................................................105 2 Description of demonstration measure ..................................................................105 3 Implementation Process ........................................................................................108 4 Results...................................................................................................................112 5 Conclusions ...........................................................................................................113 6 Scenario.................................................................................................................116 II Issued in November 2005 Table of Contents B.8 Demonstration Measure 9.4 – Financing Contracts for NG Vehicles ...................127 1 Introduction ............................................................................................................127 2 Description of demonstration measure ..................................................................127 3 Implementation process.........................................................................................129 4 Results...................................................................................................................130 5 Conclusions ...........................................................................................................133 6 Scenario.................................................................................................................135 B.9 Demonstration Measure 10.4 – Customer and User Participation .......................137 1 Introduction ............................................................................................................137 2 Description of demonstration measure ..................................................................137 3 Evaluation methods ...............................................................................................139 4 Implementation process.........................................................................................139 5 Conclusions ...........................................................................................................145 6 Scenario.................................................................................................................147 B.10 Demonstration Measure 11.6 – Dynamic Real-Time Passenger Information.......149 1 Introduction ............................................................................................................149 2 Description of demonstration measure ..................................................................149 3 Implementation process.........................................................................................152 4 Results...................................................................................................................153 5 Conclusions ...........................................................................................................158 6 Scenario.................................................................................................................161