PART I APPENDIX E: PUBLIC PARTICIPATION PART I APPENDIX E.1: I&AP DATABASE 1 APPENDIX E.2. CORRESPONDENCE TO I&APS RELATING TO FSR 10 LETTER 4 TO I&APS 10 PROOF OF CORRESPONDENCE WITH I&APS - REGISTERED MAIL RECEIPTS 13 PROOF OF CORRESPONDENCE WITH I&APS - COURIER WAYBILLS 28 EMAIL TO I&APS (RELEASE OF FSR) 30 APPENDIX E.3: CORRESPONDENCE FROM I&APS PRIOR TO RELEASE OF DRAFT EIA REPORT (AFTER RELEASE OF FSR) 43 APPENDIX E.4. CORRESPONDENCE TO I&APS – RELEASE OF DRAFT EIA REPORT 77 LETTER 5 TO I&APS 77 PROOF OF CORRESPONDENCE WITH I&APS - REGISTERED MAIL RECEIPTS 81 EMAIL TO I&APS 85 ADVERTISEMENTS 93 SITE NOTICES 99 APPENDIX E.5: CORRESPONDENCE FROM I&APS AFTER RELEASE OF DRAFT EIA REPORT 100 Copyright 2018 © CSIR – June 2018 Appendix E, Public Participation APPENDIX E.1: I&AP DATABASE Copyright 2018 © CSIR – June 2018 Appendix E, Public Participation, Page E-1 ORGANS OF STATE National Department of Environmental Affairs Ms Matlhodi Mogorosi National Department of Environmental Affairs Mr H Alberts Department of Environmental Affairs: Oceans and Coasts Mrs Nitasha Baijnath-Pillay Department of Environmental Affairs: Oceans and Coasts Mr Mulalo Tshikotshi Department of Energy Sandile Ntanzi Department of Mineral Resources KZN Ms N Khanyile Department of Public Works – KwaZulu-Natal Mr Nkosi Vilakazi Department of Transport Mrs J Reddy Department of Water Affairs and Sanitation Attention: Central Point Department of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries: Land Use and Soil Ms Anneliza Collet Management Department of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries Ms Mashudu Marubini Department of Land Affairs Ms Thembisile Mabaso KZN Department of Economic Development, Tourism and Ms Yugeshni Govender Environmental Affairs KZN Department of Economic Development, Tourism and Ms. Natasha Brijlal Environmental Affairs Dr. Siphiwe F. Mkhize KZN Department of Agriculture & Rural Development Head of Department Sub-directorate: Coastal and Biodiversity Management KZN Department of Economic Development, Tourism and Mr Omar Parak Environmental Affairs KZN Department of Economic Development, Tourism and Ms Liesel Beires Environmental Affairs KwaZulu-Natal Department of Water Affairs Ms Angela Masefield Department of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries Ms Mashudu Marubini Department of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries: Forestry Regulations Ms Karen Moodley and Support KZN Department of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries: Forestry Regulations Ms N Sontangane and Support KZN Department of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries: Forestry Regulations Mr Jeffrey Maivha and Support KwaZulu-Natal Department of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries Ms Thembile Dlungwana Department of Transport KZN Ms Michele Schmid KwaZulu-Natal Department of Co-operative Governance and Traditional Mrs Mandisa Zungu Affairs: Development Planning eThekwini Municipality: eThekwini Transport Authority Mr Logan Moodley eThekwini Municipality: Municipal Manager Mr Sibusiso Sithole eThekwini Municipality: Ward Councillor (Ward 58) Cllr Mxolisi Kenneth Ndzimbomvu eThekwini Municipality: Ward Councillor Cllr Jean Lindsay eThekwini Municipality: Ward Councillor Cllr Geoff Pullan eThekwini Municipality: Environmental Planning & Climate Protection Dr Debra Roberts eThekwini Municipality: Engineering Department Mr Adrian Peters eThekwini Municipality: Water & Sanitation Mr Ednick Msweli eThekwini Municipality Mr Kuben Samie eThekwini Municipality: EIA Hub Ms Diane Van Rensburg OTHER KEY STAKEHOLDERS KZN Conservation Association Mr Rob Crankshaw South African Heritage Resources Agency Tara Van Niekerk Amafa aKwaZulu-Natali Ms Weziwe Tsabalala Copyright 2018 © CSIR – June 2018 Appendix E, Public Participation, Page E-2 Amafa aKwaZulu-Natali Ms Bernadet Pawandiwa BirdLife South Africa Mr Simon Gear South African National Roads Agency Ltd: Eastern Region Mr Casper Landman Ezemvelo KwaZulu-Natal Wildlife Ms Nerissa Pillay Ezemvelo KwaZulu-Natal Wildlife Ms Dinesree Thambu Ingonyama Trust Mr Pravesh Manipersadh Eskom Mr John Geeringh Eskom Ms Michelle Nicol Eskom: Land Development Manager Mr Neil Purdon Tongaat Hulett Properties Ms Tina Hattingh Tongaat Hulett Properties Mr Greg Veerasamy Tongaat Hulett Properties Mr Paul Rusell Tongaat Hulett Properties Mr Mohsin Shaik Tongaat Hulett Properties Mr Beki Hlatshwayo Transnet Ms Xoliswa Nhlozi SA Cane Growers Association Mr Aubrey Gabriel WESSA Ms Bianca McKelvey WESSA Ms Jenny Duvenage SA Navy Mr Edwin Dwyer Endangered Wildlife Trust Ms Yolan Friedmann Biota Southern Africa Ms Gerda Kriel South African National Parks Lize McCourt- Chief Operating Officer Ms Simphiwe Mazibuko Transnet National Ports Authority Mr Desmond D’Sa South Durban Community Environment Alliance (SDCEA) Mr Tony Carnie Independent Newspapers – The Mercury Ms Nokuthula Ntuli Independent Newspapers Mr Bryan Ashe Private - GeaSphere and the KZN Water Caucus Mr Anthony Botha Durban Chamber of Commerce and Industry Mr Siva Narainsamy Tongaat Ratepayers/East Civic Association Mr Zama Dlamini Dube Tradeport Corporation Mr Daniel Smith Dube Tradeport Corporation Ms Mpume Myeni Dube Tradeport Corporation Mr Owen Mungwe Dube Tradeport Corporation Mr Anthony Gould Dube Tradeport Corporation Ms Nokuthula Mcinga ACSA Ms Nora Choveaux Private Mr Allan Childs Private Copyright 2018 © CSIR – June 2018 Appendix E, Public Participation, Page E-3 Mr Nick Singh Tekeweni Civils CC Ms Bianca Torre Leads 2 Business Mr Prenol Girdharie Compressed Air Driers & Filters cc Mr Murray Jackson Private Mr George Oliver Vision Data Services cc Mr Neal Naidoo Transnet National Ports Authority Ms Sharmla Ramharry Private Michael Jamieson Wakefields Property Management Ms Lynndene Martin Private Shaylin Shunmugam Private Mr Davashkar Virasamy Private Ms Carolyn Schwegman Coastwatch KZN Ms Di Jones Coastwatch KZN Mr Brendon Bosworth Independent Journalist Ms Judy Marx/Ms Stacey Canham National Roads Agency (NRA) Mr Jeeva Pillay Tongaat Civic Association Ms Betty Rawheath La Mercy Residents Action Group Mr Solly Dodabhay La Mercy Residents Action Group Mr Kam Singh La Mercy Residents Action Group Ms Sharon Shunmugan La Mercy Residents Action Group Mr Wade Holland La Mercy Residents Action Group/ Coastwatch Mr Roy Rawheath La Mercy Residents Action Group Mr Les March Private Ms Tashya Giyapersad Private Mr Keagan Allan Private Mr Devan Singh SRACA Mr Harendra Jogi Divine Life Society Mr Dennis Kullen TCA Ms Andisha Maharaj Ottawa Environmental Forum Copyright 2018 © CSIR – June 2018 Appendix E, Public Participation, Page E-4 Mr Vilasen Govender CCS-UKZN Mr P Singh Seatides Ratepayers and Civic Association Mr B Naidoo Westbrook Development Mr Damir Percaic Private Mr Riyashan Owen Pather Private Mr Lee Govender Private Mr Amal Ramharry Private Mr Seelan Govender Private Mr Shaylin Shunmugam Private Ms Dolly Shunmugam Private Ms Marlene Naidoo Private Private Ms Alice Thomson Community Policing Forum (Coastal Sector) Mr Nazir Sadack Wakefields Ballito Mrs. Cindy Bogan Private Revd Peter Houston Parish of Umhlali Diocese of Natal (Anglican) Departments of housing settlements KZN Mr Ravi Pillay Seatides Rate payers association Mr Devan Singh Private – Activist Mr Allimuthu Perumal Lasec SA Renata Narain KSE Mr Ashon Naidoo Private Mrs Claire Lilford PRASA Mr Paul Motsoaledi Local Farmer Mrs Krish Naidu Private Mr Mike Wilson Private Mrs Veena Rajyah East Coast Mail Mrs Keshni Ramsamy Tonver (NPO) Mr S. Sunthkenar Private Mr and Mrs Lucille and Justin Wendler Copyright 2018 © CSIR – June 2018 Appendix E, Public Participation, Page E-5 Private Mrs Ilona Gounder CPF South Mr Paul Gounder Private Naren Mahara SDCEA Mr Patrick Laplace Archilever Mr Ken & Frances Lever Student Biotech Mr Rivaaj Rai Bhunprakash ANC Ward Cllr 61 Dr Michael Abraham Tongaat Civic Mrs Rebecca Abraham CMA Mr Benjamin Coston eThekwini Mr Niren Appalsamy North Coast Courier Mrs Jacqueline Herbst Private Mr P. Govender Private Mr Alven Pillay Activist Mr Roy Singh Private Mr D D Jeeawon Private Mr Ashon Naidou DxxP Mr C Govender Hatch Mr Vignesh Naidoo MOSA Mr Mervin Pillay Divine Life Society of SA Mrs Jogie Naidoo DPG Property Mrs Kogila Cooper Belveden Civic Association Mr Ruban Govender AFFECTED LANDOWNERS Rem of La Mercy Reservoir N0. 15692 Umgeni Water Portion 2456, 2558, 2464, 2465 of Cotton Lands No 1575 South African National Roads Agency Portion 4 of Lot 77 No 1523 LTD (SANRAL) Rem of Erf 662 RSA (Dept of Public Works) Portion 3, 47 (39), 48(40), 49, 50 of Erf 662 Portion 6 of Erf 922 RSA (Dept of Public Works) eThekwini Roads and Storm water Portion 23 of Lot 42 No 1114 Portion 34 of Lot 42 No 1114 - Mdloti substation eThekwini Municipality – Electricity eThekwini Municipality – Coastal Portion 17 of Erf 662 Management & Environmental planning Copyright 2018 © CSIR – June 2018 Appendix E, Public Participation, Page E-6 Portion 6 of Erf 662 Mr Naidoo Bala Kantha Portion 14 of Erf 662 Mr P Govender Dhavagee Family Trust Portion 15 of Erf 662 Trustees: Seelan Govender and Colin Govender Portion 18 and 19 of Erf 662 Mr V Govender Portion 34 of Erf 662 Mr Govender, Marimuthu Vadivalu Moodley Family Trust – Portion 41 of Erf 662 Trustees Portion 42 of Erf 662 Mr Moodley, Pragalathan Meadow Brook Properties 8 CC Portion 11 of Erf 662 Mrs Riaz Meer Portion 12 of Erf 662 Ikhwaan Trust Trustee Rem of Portion 13 of Erf 662 ( Portion 13 of Erf 662) Mr G Nadasen Rem of Lot 77 No 1523 Tongaat Hulett/IFA Resort Dev. Joint Portion 3 of Lot 77 No 1523 Venture Partner Unregistered – falls under parent property- Rem of Farm No. 1523 Portion 10 of Lot 77 No. 1523 Tongaat-Hulett- Zimbali Resorts Pty Ltd Rem of Portion 7, 13, 30 of Lot 42 No 1114 Portion 1, 6 of Lot 42 No 1114 Portion 1 of Lot 77 No 1523 Rem of Portion 2 of Lot 77 No 1523 Portion 20, 23, 236 of Lot 44 No 1570 Tongaat-Hulett Group LTD Rem of Portion 67, 68, 69, 70, 71, 72, 167, 178, 189, 192, 196, 199, 200, 204, 212, 245,262, 1779, 436 of Cotton Lands No 1575 Portion 67, 244, 263 of Cotton Lands No 1575. Rem of Portion 1 of Lot 44 No. 1570 Tongaat-Hulett Group LTD Rem of Cotton Lands No. 157 Tongaat-Hulett Group LTD Portion 2457 of Cotton Lands No. 1575 Tongaat-Hulett Group LTD Portion 175 of Cotton Lands No.