IMAGINATIVE COSMOLOGY ROBERT H. BRANDENBERGER Physics Department, Brown University Providence, RI, 02912, USA AND JOAO˜ MAGUEIJO Theoretical Physics, The Blackett Laboratory, Imperial College Prince Consort Road, London SW7 2BZ, UK Abstract. We review1 a few off-the-beaten-track ideas in cosmology. They solve a variety of fundamental problems; also they are fun. We start with a description of non-singular dilaton cosmology. In these scenarios gravity is modified so that the Universe does not have a singular birth. We then present a variety of ideas mixing string theory and cosmology. These solve the cosmological problems usually solved by inflation, and furthermore shed light upon the issue of the number of dimensions of our Universe. We finally review several aspects of the varying speed of light theory. We show how the horizon, flatness, and cosmological constant problems may be solved in this scenario. We finally present a possible experimental test for a realization of this theory: a test in which the Supernovae results are to be combined with recent evidence for redshift dependence in the fine structure constant. arXiv:hep-ph/9912247v1 6 Dec 1999 1. Introduction In spite of their unprecedented success at providing causal theories for the origin of structure, our current models of the very early Universe, in partic- ular models of inflation and cosmic defect theories, leave several important issues unresolved and face crucial problems (see [1] for a more detailed dis- cussion). The purpose of this chapter is to present some imaginative and 1Brown preprint BROWN-HET-1198, invited lectures at the International School on Cosmology, Kish Island, Iran, Jan. 22 - Feb. 4 1999, to be publ. in Large Scale Structure Formation (Kluwer, Dordrecht, 2000) 2 ROBERT H. BRANDENBERGER AND JOAO˜ MAGUEIJO speculative ideas for early Universe cosmology which go beyond our present models and which address some of the puzzles unresolved by inflationary cosmology. Let us recall four of the key conceptual problems of inflationary cosmol- ogy. The first is the fluctuation problem: without finely adjusting param- eters in the particle physics model, the amplitude of the resulting cosmic microwave background (CMB) anisotropies is generically predicted to be far in excess of the measured values [2]. What is missing is an in-built suppression mechanism for scalar metric fluctuations. The second key problem of potential-driven inflation is the super-Planck scale physics problem: unless the period of inflation is very short, comoving length scales corresponding to today’s large scale structure had a physical wavelength much smaller than the Planck length in the early stages of inflation. In the absence of an implementation of inflation in the context of a unified theory of Planck-scale physics, it is not justified to blindly extrapolate the predictions of simple scalar field toy models to the required small length scales. Inflationary cosmology leaves the initial singularity problem of standard cosmology unresolved [3], and in this sense remains an incomplete theory of the early Universe without a consistent initial value formalation. This is a further problem of inflation. The Achilles heel of potential-driven inflationary cosmology is without doubt the cosmological constant problem. The mechanism of inflation relies on a transient cosmological constant generating the required exponential expansion of space, but can we trust this mechanism in the absence of an understanding of what sets the present value of the cosmological constant to (almost) zero? In the following, we summarize some imaginative but very speculative ideas which address one or more of the above problems. At the present time, none of the ideas is well enough developed to be able to solve all of the problems and none forms a complete well-developed theory. Our hope, however, is that the ultimate theory of the early Universe will contain cer- tain aspects of the mechanisms discussed below. As bi-products, these ideas point to the exciting possibility that the unified theory of all forces may explain the dimensionality of space [4], and yield an alternative to infla- tion for solving the flatness and horizon problems of standard cosmology without the need to invoke inflation [5, 6]. The outline of this chapter is as follows. In the next section, we show that adding a special class of higher derivative gravity terms to the usual low energy effective action for matter and gravity can lead to a nonsingu- lar Universe. Applied to dilaton gravity, this construction may lead to a graceful exit in “pre-big-bang” cosmology. IMAGINATIVE COSMOLOGY 3 Although higher derivative gravity corrections to the Einstein action are a generic feature of any lower energy limit of a unified thoery, the specific terms used in the nonsingular Universe construction of Section 2 are rather ad hoc and not at the present time motivated by any fundamental microscopic theory. In Section 3 we study a few cosmological aspects of the one well-motivated candidate for a unified theory of all forces, string theory. In particular, we explore the role of target space duality in resolving cosmological singularities and in determining a preferential dimensionality of space. Perhaps the craziest attempt to bypass inflation is the varying speed of light cosmology [5, 6]. In its current formulation the theory allows for violations of Lorentz invariance. These are shown to lead to a solution of the problems usually solved by inflation, even if the matter content of the Universe satisfies the strong energy condition. We outline some aspects of this theory in Section 4, and in Section 5 we show how solutions to the cosmological problems emerge in these theories. In Section 6 we then show how such a theory may be confronted with experiment. In a concluding section we digress on the future of imaginative cosmol- ogy (as opposed to mainstream, “boring”, cosmology). 2. Nonsingular Dilaton Cosmology 2.1. MOTIVATION The initial singularity is one of the outstanding problems of current cosmo- logical models. In standard big bang cosmology, the existence of the initial singularity is an inevitable consequence of the Penrose-Hawking theorems [7, 8]. While potential-driven inflationary models such as chaotic inflation [9] resolve many of the problems faced by conventional cosmology, initial singularities are still generic, even when stochastic effects are included [3]. It is generally hoped that string theory will lead to a resolution of the singularity problem. A key feature of string theory is that the low energy degrees of freedom include besides the graviton the dilaton and an antisym- metric tensor field. Gasperini and Veneziano initiated a program known as “pre-big-bang cosmology” [10] aimed at studying the cosmological conse- quences of the low energy effective action of string theory. To lowest order, and neglecting the antisymmetric tensor field, the action is given by 1 1 S = d4x√ g R ( φ)2 + , (1) −2κ2 − − 2 ∇ · · · Z 2 −2 where φ is the dilaton, κ = 8πG = 8πmpl , with G being the (4 dimen- sional) gravitational coupling, and mpl the Planck mass. The field equations of pre-big-bang cosmology exhibit a new symmetry, scale factor duality, 4 ROBERT H. BRANDENBERGER AND JOAO˜ MAGUEIJO which (in the Einstein frame) maps an expanding Friedmann-Robertson- Walker (FRW) cosmology to a dilaton-dominated contracting inflationary phase. This raises the hope that it is possible to realize a nonsingular cos- mology in which the Universe starts out in a cold dilaton-dominated con- tracting phase, goes through a bounce and then emerges as an expanding FRW Universe (see Ref. [11] for a recent review of pre-big-bang cosmology. Unfortunately, it has been shown that the two branches of pre-big-bang cos- mology cannot be smoothly connected within the above tree-level action [12, 13, 14, 15]. The contracting dilaton-dominated branch has a future singularity, whereas the expanding branch emerges from a past singularity. A natural approach to resolving the singularity problem of general rel- ativity is to consider an effective theory of gravity which contains higher order terms, in addition to the Ricci scalar of the Einstein action. This approach is well motivated, since we expect that any effective action for classical gravity obtained from string theory, quantum gravity, or by inte- grating out matter fields, will contain higher derivative terms. Thus, it is quite natural to consider higher derivative effective gravity theories when studying the properties of space-time at large curvatures. Most higher derivative gravity theories have much worse singularity problems than Einstein’s theory. However, it is not unreasonable to expect that in the fundamental theory of nature, be it string theory or some other theory, the curvature of space-time is limited. In Ref. [16] the hypothe- sis was made that when the limiting curvature is reached, the geometry must approach that of a maximally symmetric space-time, namely de Sit- ter space. The question now becomes whether it is possible to find a class of higher derivative effective actions for gravity which have the property that at large curvatures the solutions approach de Sitter space. A nonsin- gular Universe construction which achieves this goal was proposed in Refs. [17, 18]. It is based on adding to the Einstein action a particular com- bination of quadratic invariants of the Riemann tensor chosen such that the invariant vanishes only in de Sitter space-times. This invariant is cou- pled to the Einstein action via a Lagrange multiplier field in a way that the Lagrange multiplier constraint equation forces the invariant to zero at high curvatures. Thus, the metric becomes de Sitter and hence explicitly nonsingular. If successful, the above construction will have some very appealing con- sequences. Consider, for example, a collapsing spatially homogeneous Uni- verse. According to Einstein’s theory, this Universe will collapse in a finite proper time to a final “big crunch” singularity (top left Penrose diagram of Figure 1).