A MATTER OF PRIVILEGE: A DISCUSSION PAPER ON CANADIAN PARLIAMENTARY PRIVILEGE IN THE 21ST CENTURY Interim report of the Standing Committee on Rules, Procedures, and the Rights of Parliament Chair The Honourable Vernon White Deputy Chair The Honourable David P. Smith, PC. June 2015 MEMBERSHIP The Honourable Vernon White, Chair The Honourable David P. Smith, P.C., Deputy Chair The Honourable Denise Batters The Honourable Claude Carignan, P.C.* The Honourable Anne C. Cools The Honourable James S. Cowan* The Honourable Norman E. Doyle The Honourable Joan Fraser* The Honourable Linda Frum The Honourable George Furey The Honourable Leo Housakos The Honourable Mobina S.B. Jaffer The Honourable Serge Joyal, P.C. The Honourable Yonah Martin The Honourable Elaine McCoy The Honourable Paul E. McIntyre The Honourable David Tkachuk The Honourable David M. Wells *Ex officio members In addition, the Honourable Senators Selma Ataullahjan, Douglas Black, Suzanne Fortin-Duplessis, Nancy Ruth, Richard Neufeld and Pierre Claude Nolin were members of the committee or participated in its work on this report. Clerk of the Committee: Charles Robert Analyst from the Library of Parliament: Dara Lithwick TABLE OF CONTENTS INTRODUCTION: AN OPPORTUNITY TO REVIEW AND RENEW PARLIAMENTARY PRIVILEGE IN CANADA ...................................................................................................................................................... 1 A. Development of the Interim Report ................................................................................................. 4 PART I: PARLIAMENTARY PRIVILEGE: TRACING ITS HISTORY TOWARDS A CONTEMPORARY APPROACH ................................................................................................................................................. 5 A. Parliamentary Privilege: History ...................................................................................................... 5 B. Towards a contemporary approach: Evolution of parliamentary privilege in the UK, Australia, and New Zealand ................................................................................................................................... 7 1. The United Kingdom ..................................................................................................................... 7 2. Australia ...................................................................................................................................... 12 3. New Zealand .............................................................................................................................. 16 PART II: PARLIAMENTARY PRIVILEGE IN CANADA ............................................................................. 18 A. Privilege Since Confederation ....................................................................................................... 18 1. Privilege and the Constitution .................................................................................................... 18 2. Parliamentary Reviews of Rights, Immunities and Privileges .................................................... 20 B. The Courts, Parliamentary Privilege and the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms ........... 22 1. “Necessity” as the frame to interpret a privilege ........................................................................ 23 2. The Supreme Court of Canada, Parliamentary Privilege, and the Charter ............................... 25 C. Privilege in the provinces: Varying approaches to codification ..................................................... 32 D. Observations of the Rules Committee .......................................................................................... 36 PART III: FRAMEWORK TO ADAPT ELEMENTS OF PARLIAMENTARY PRIVILEGE IN CANADA TO CONTEMPORARY NORMS ...................................................................................................................... 38 A. From the Necessity Test to an Accountability Framework: A Canadian Approach to Renew Parliamentary Privilege ................................................................................................................. 38 B. Freedom of Speech ....................................................................................................................... 39 1. Should the scope of freedom of speech be modified? ............................................................... 40 2. Proceedings in Parliament ......................................................................................................... 46 3. Observations of the Rules Committee to Adapt the Privilege of Freedom of Speech to Contemporary Norms ................................................................................................................. 48 C. The Collective Rights of the Senate and House of Commons to Regulate their Internal Affairs/ Exclusive Cognizance ................................................................................................................... 51 1. Developments abroad ................................................................................................................ 52 2. Canadian developments: Parliament is not a “statute-free zone” .............................................. 53 3. Observations of the Rules Committee to Adapt the Collective Rights of the Senate and House of Commons to Regulate their Internal Affairs to Contemporary Norms ................................... 54 D. Disciplinary Powers ....................................................................................................................... 56 i 1. Procedural Fairness: Disciplining Individual Parliamentarians .................................................. 57 2. Procedural Fairness: Disciplining non-Parliamentarians ........................................................... 60 3. Observations of the Rules Committee to Adapt the Disciplinary Powers of the Senate and House of Commons to Contemporary Norms ............................................................................ 64 E. Freedom from Arrest in Civil Actions and Related Individual Privileges ....................................... 67 1. Freedom from arrest in civil actions ........................................................................................... 67 2. Freedom from being subpoenaed to attend court as a witness ................................................. 70 3. Freedom from jury service .......................................................................................................... 72 4. Freedom from obstruction, interference, intimidation and molestation ...................................... 75 CONCLUSION: LOOKING AHEAD ........................................................................................................... 77 BIBLIOGRAPHY ........................................................................................................................................ 79 A. Legislation ...................................................................................................................................... 79 1. Canadian – Constitutional and Federal ...................................................................................... 79 2. Canadian - Provincial ................................................................................................................. 79 3. International ................................................................................................................................ 80 B. Jurisprudence ................................................................................................................................ 80 1. Canadian .................................................................................................................................... 80 2. International ................................................................................................................................ 81 C. Parliamentary Materials and Government Reports ....................................................................... 82 1. Canada ....................................................................................................................................... 82 2. International ................................................................................................................................ 83 D. Secondary Materials ...................................................................................................................... 83 ii INTRODUCTION: AN OPPORTUNITY TO REVIEW AND RENEW PARLIAMENTARY PRIVILEGE IN CANADA Parliamentary privilege, an essential component of parliamentary democracy, exists to enable Parliament to function effectively and efficiently without undue impediment. Originally developed in Westminster as a means of preventing interference by the sovereign in the workings of Parliament,1 it has developed in parliaments throughout the British Commonwealth. In Canada, it is enshrined in the Constitution Act, 1867, at section 18 and through its preamble,2 and is further confirmed in section 4 of the Parliament of Canada Act.3 The rights and immunities associated with parliamentary privilege include the following4: The rights of individual parliamentarians (as well as witnesses at committees) and the collective rights of the Senate and House of Commons to freedom of speech from outside impeachment for things said in the course of parliamentary proceedings; The collective rights