Document generated on 09/25/2021 11 a.m. Journal of the Canadian Historical Association Revue de la Société historique du Canada The Whale and the Region: Orca Capture and Environmentalism in the New Pacific Northwest Jason Colby Volume 24, Number 2, 2013 Article abstract Although the orca is today widely recognized as a cultural and ecological icon URI: https://id.erudit.org/iderudit/1025084ar of the Pacific Northwest, historians have ignored the impact of killer whale DOI: https://doi.org/10.7202/1025084ar capture on the development of the region’s environmental values and identity. Between 1964 and 1976, the waters in southern British Columbia and See table of contents Washington State were the world’s principal source of captive killer whales. The display of orcas by the region’s aquariums transformed human perceptions of this marine predator, and soon aquariums around the world Publisher(s) were placing orders for Pacific Northwest killer whales. Yet the expanding capture and export of orcas in the late 1960s and early 1970s raised troubling The Canadian Historical Association / La Société historique du Canada ecological and moral questions for the region’s human residents. In the context of shifting attitudes toward cetaceans and rising environmental awareness ISSN throughout North America, Pacific Northwesters on both sides of the border increasingly viewed orcas as symbols of their region’s shared ecological 0847-4478 (print) concerns. The transnational nature of the region’s killer whale pods helped 1712-6274 (digital) spur not only ecological reflection but also transborder cooperation among activists, scientists, and government officials to study and eventually protect Explore this journal the species. In the process, the shifting human relations with orcas helped redefine the Pacific Northwest. Cite this article Colby, J. (2013). The Whale and the Region: Orca Capture and Environmentalism in the New Pacific Northwest. Journal of the Canadian Historical Association / Revue de la Société historique du Canada, 24(2), 425–454. https://doi.org/10.7202/1025084ar All Rights Reserved © The Canadian Historical Association / La Société This document is protected by copyright law. Use of the services of Érudit historique du Canada, 2013 (including reproduction) is subject to its terms and conditions, which can be viewed online. https://apropos.erudit.org/en/users/policy-on-use/ This article is disseminated and preserved by Érudit. Érudit is a non-profit inter-university consortium of the Université de Montréal, Université Laval, and the Université du Québec à Montréal. Its mission is to promote and disseminate research. https://www.erudit.org/en/ The Whale and the Region: Orca Capture and Environmentalism in the New Pacific Northwest* JASON COLBY Abstract Although the orca is today widely recognized as a cultural and ecological icon of the Pacific Northwest, historians have ignored the impact of killer whale capture on the development of the region’s environmental values and identity. Between 1964 and 1976, the waters in southern British Columbia and Washington State were the world’s principal source of captive killer whales. The display of orcas by the region’s aquariums transformed human perceptions of this marine predator, and soon aquariums around the world were placing orders for Pacific Northwest killer whales. Yet the expanding capture and export of orcas in the late 1960s and early 1970s raised troubling ecological and moral questions for the region’s human residents. In the context of shifting attitudes toward cetaceans and rising environmental awareness throughout North America, Pacific Northwesters on both sides of the border increasingly viewed orcas as symbols of their region’s shared ecological concerns. The transnational nature of the region’s killer whale pods helped spur not only ecological reflection but also transborder cooperation among activists, sci - entists, and government officials to study and eventually protect the species. In the process, the shifting human relations with orcas helped redefine the Pacific Northwest. Résumé Bien que l’épaulard soit aujourd’hui largement reconnu comme l’em - blème culturel et écologique du Pacifique Nord-Ouest, les historiens ont négligé l’incidence de la capture de ce mammifère sur le développement des valeurs environnementales et l’identité de cette région. De 1964 à * The author wishes to thank the editors and two anonymous readers for their suggested revisions to this article. JOURNAL OF THE CHA 2013 REVUE DE LA SHC 2013 New Series, Vol. 24, no. 2 Nouvelle série, vol. 24, n o 2 JOURNAL OF THE CHA 2013 / REVUE DE LA SHC 2013 1976, les eaux du sud de la Colombie-Britannique et de l’État de Washington étaient la principale source d’épaulards en captivité dans le monde. La présentation d’épaulards dans les aquariums de la région a changé le regard que portaient les humains sur ce prédateur marin, ce qui fait qu’en peu de temps les aquariums du monde se sont mis à en commander. Or, la capture et l’exportation croissantes de cet animal, à la fin des années 1960 et au début des années 1970, a soulevé des ques - tions écologiques et morales troublantes chez les résidents de la région. Vu le changement de mentalité à l’égard des cétacés et la sensibilisation crois - sante à l’écologie dans toute l’Amérique du Nord, les habitants du Pacifique Nord-Ouest des deux côtés de la frontière se sont mis à voir de plus en plus l’épaulard comme un symbole des préoccupations environ - nementales de leur région. La nature transnationale des troupeaux d’épaulards de cette région a permis de susciter non seulement une réflexion sur l’écologie, mais aussi la collaboration transfrontalière des activistes, des scientifiques et des représentants du gouvernement pour étudier et finalement protéger cette espèce. Ce faisant, les relations entre - tenues par les humains avec les épaulards ont contribué à redéfinir le Pacifique Nord-Ouest. On Saturday, 16 August 1975, Sealand of the Pacific, an entertain - ment-oriented aquarium in Victoria, B.C., captured a pod of six killer whales in Pedder Bay off southern Vancouver Island. Sealand’s owner, Bob Wright, was well aware of the controversy orca capture could stir, having organized two similar operations in 1970 and 1973. Yet he was unprepared for the furor unleashed by this latest capture. The event made national news, with distant newspapers such as the Saskatoon Star-Phoenix printing front-page photos of the “trapped killer whales” at Pedder Bay. 1 The most visible reaction, however, was local. Protests appeared almost immediately, some of them organized by Vancouver-based Greenpeace, which had recently turned its focus to whales and other marine mammals. Over the fol - lowing weeks, officers of the Royal Canadian Mounted Police guarded Sealand’s nets and prevented at least one attempt to cut the orcas free. Eventually, federal size regulations forced Wright to release four of the whales. Of the remaining two, Sealand kept a young ORCA CAPTURE AND ENVIRONMENTALISM IN THE NEW PACIFIC NORTHWEST female and earmarked the other, a 15-foot male soon to be named “Kanduke,” for Marineland of Niagara Falls to replace another young orca that had died in November 1973, shortly after shipment. But exporting killer whales from the Pacific Northwest was not as simple as it used to be. Since the late 1960s, opposition to the cap - ture, sale, and public display of orcas had been growing as part of a larger environmentalist movement on both sides of the border. Responding to the public outcry at this most recent capture, the B.C. government attempted to intervene, despite the fact that juris - diction lay with the federal government, which had issued Wright his capture permits. On 12 September 1975, the B.C. Department of Recreation and Conservation declared a ban on orca capture in provincial waters, and soon after the B.C. government announced it would not allow B.C. Ferries to carry the whale, thereby preventing the planned transport to Ontario via the Vancouver Airport. The provincial government’s actions annoyed federal officials and forced Marineland’s owner, John Holer, to charter a private plane directly from Victoria. The full extent of local opposition became apparent only on 19 September, however, when hundreds of protestors con - fronted the truck carrying the whale on the way to the Victoria Airport. 2 Just six months later, a similar episode occurred across the border in Washington State, when an operation funded by Sea World and based out of the Seattle Marine Aquarium netted a pod of orcas in southern Puget Sound. As in B.C., the local reaction was visceral, with activists protesting and attempting to free the whales. For its part, the state government sued Sea World in federal court, chal - lenging the right of both the company and the federal government to remove a species that was quickly becoming a regional icon. These two events highlight the critical importance of killer whales in the changing environmental politics of the Pacific Northwest. On the surface, these were simply disputes over the fate of a few captive orcas. On a deeper level, however, they crystalized a broader debate over the growing influence of environmental values in the region. Killer whales became symbolic of this debate because they played a highly visible and influential role in this cultural shift. To be sure, most people today associate orca captivity with the multi - billion-dollar business of San Diego-based Sea World, particularly JOURNAL OF THE CHA 2013 / REVUE DE LA SHC 2013 following the release of Gabriela Cowperthwaite’s influential docu - mentary, Blackfish (2013). As such, it is easy to forget that the business of orca capture and display began in the Pacific Northwest and played a key part in transforming its regional values and identity.