August 2014 DYNAMICS OF DIVERSITY: EVIDENCE FROM THE 2011 CENSUS ESRC Centre on Dynamics of Ethnicity (CoDE) Who feels Scottish? National identities and ethnicity in Scotland Summary • 83% of Scotland’s residents feel Scottish. • About 25% of Scotland’s residents born outside Scotland • 61% of Scotland’s residents identify as being of White do feel Scottish, and this is no less for those from South Scottish ethnicity and feel Scottish is their only national and East Asia, Africa and the Middle East, than it is for identity. A further 22% are from other ethnic groups and those born in England or other parts of Europe. About a feel they have a Scottish national identity, or are White third of Scotland’s residents born in North America, the Scottish whose Scottishness is combined with British or Old Commonwealth and Western Europe feel Scottish. other national identities. • The Polish ethnic group, who have recently had the • Catholics, Protestants and those of no religion share highest migration rates into Scotland, expressed most similar levels of commitment to a Scottish only national affiliation to a non-UK identity only (80%). identity, while two-thirds of Muslims in Scotland identify • For other groups, including Pakistanis, Bangladeshis, as Scottish or British. Africans, Indians and Chinese, British only was chosen • The ‘White: Other British’ are the largest ethnic minority in as frequently as Scottish only. This perhaps reflects the Scotland, and the ethnic group least likely to feel Scottish emphasis on Britishness in citizenship regulations, and national identity (11% feel Scottish, with or without other was also found in England where minorities identified identities). 78% were born in England. as British more often than English. • Being born in Scotland makes people feel Scottish: 94% • Almost all minority groups are more likely to claim of the Scotland-born choose Scottish as their national a Scottish identity in Scotland than an English identity identity alone or with other identities, but less than half of in England. those born outside Scotland do so. Figure 1. National identity and ethnic group, Scotland, 2011 0% 10%20% 30%40% 50%60% 70%80% 90%100% White: Scottish (4,445,700) 73% 21% 1% 5% White: Gypsy/Traveller (4,200) 66% 7% 3% 7% 6% 11% Mixed (19,800) 37% 11% 12% 16% 8% 16% Pakistani (49,400) 31% 13% 5% 34% 3% 13% Other Black (3,100) 27% 5% 4% 24% 10% 28% Black Caribbean (3,400) 27% 7% 5% 23% 14% 24% White: Irish (54,100) 22% 3% 7% 7% 22% 39% Bangladeshi (3,800) 19% 8% 4% 38% 4% 28% Arab (9,400) 18% 5% 8% 17% 5% 48% Indian (32,700) 17% 6% 7% 22% 5% 44% Other (5,000) 14% 3% 9% 16% 7% 50% Chinese (33,700) 14% 5% 5% 22% 4% 50% African (29,600) 12% 3% 6% 17% 5% 56% Other Asian (21,100) 10% 4% 7% 17% 6% 57% Other White (102,100) 7% 1% 11% 5% 4% 73% Polish (61,200) 5% 10% 2% 3% 80% White: Other British (417,100) 3%3% 5% 40% 48% 1% Scottish identity only Scottish and British identities only Scottish and any other identities British identity only All other involving UK identities Non-UK identity only Click here for data in Excel 1 www.ethnicity.ac.uk Who feels Scottish? Introduction From the first results of the 2011 Census, a flurry of What do you feel is your national identity? headlines declared that a majority of Scotland’s residents This was the question on national identity asked in 2011 had recorded their national identity as only Scottish. for the first time in the census in Scotland, as in other This Briefing examines what the public debates over parts of the UK. The instruction in Scotland was to ‘Tick independence have also made clear: that choices about ALL that apply’, with options of Scottish, English, Welsh, national identity are complicated ones, shaped by the Northern Irish, British, and Other. There was space to context in which they are made, by the different individual write in ‘Other’ national identities. The national identity and collective histories of those who make them and, no question preceded the ethnic group question. doubt, by different understandings about what is at issue in the idea of national identity itself. In the 2011 Censuses of the UK, the instructions were the same in each country except for a different ordering Because the Census asks its questions of everyone, it of categories, and ‘Irish’ was offered as a category in allows us to examine how Scottishness and other national Northern Ireland. The question allows more than one identities have been affected by the changing ethnic response but the use of the singular ‘identity’ in the title, diversity of Scotland.1 It also allows us to examine how and the fact that almost every other census question national identity relates to other characteristics such as allows only one response, may have encouraged people place of birth and religious affiliation, as well as to draw to tick one answer and move on to the next question. comparisons with the corresponding data from other parts Unlike the rest of the UK, the word ‘all’ was capitalised of the UK in order to explore what may be distinctive and emboldened in the Scottish census, and this may be about national identification in the Scottish context. partly responsible for the higher proportion of multiple identities chosen in Scotland than other parts of the UK. While the 2011 Census reveals that 62% of the population felt only Scottish, and a further 20% felt Scottish alongside See also the Briefings How has ethnic diversity changed other national identities, these figures represent a mix of in Scotland?, and Who Feels British?. different forms of allegiances to Scotland. National identity is more nuanced than may be evident in the exclusionary view of either Scottishness or Britishness that is often 39% choose only a non-UK national identity, presumably canvassed in political debates. Irish, compared to 60% in England. The difference is accounted for by those who choose other UK national National identity and ethnicity in Scotland identities – presumably Northern Irish – rather than British. In all, 3.2m or 61% of all Scotland’s residents claim White This picture varies from Edinburgh where only 11% of the Scottish ethnicity as well as Scottish as their only national ethnic Irish feel a Scottish national identity, to Glasgow identity. 22% more either feel only Scottish although they where over 40% feel Scottish. are not of White Scottish ethnicity, or feel Scottish as well For other ethnic groups, many chose a non-UK national as British or another national identity. Thus in total, 83% identity only, rising to 80% of the Polish ethnic group which included Scottish in their national identity. has had the highest migration rates into Scotland recently. As one might expect, those who declare their ethnicity to Those groups with longer-established populations in Scotland be White Scottish are more likely than others to also claim are more likely to choose Scottish as a national identity: for a national identity of Scottish. Figure 1 (on page 1) shows example 49% of Pakistanis chose some degree of Scottish the different ethnic groups identified in the census, in national identity, including 31% who choose only a Scottish decreasing order of claiming Scottish as a national identity. national identity. In England, by contrast, 15% of Pakistanis chose only English as their national identity. Within the White Scottish population, there was a strong difference between Edinburgh where two-thirds of this Similar numbers among established minorities choose group identified as only Scottish, compared to 74% in ‘British’ as their only national identity – 34% of all Glasgow and 73% in the rest of Scotland. Gypsy/Travellers Pakistanis, 38% of Bangladeshis, and 22% of both were the second most likely ethnic group, after White Chinese and Indians. These are lower percentages than in Scottish, to select Scottish as their national identity, 76% England (63%, 72%, 38% and 57% respectively). doing so and 66% choosing only Scottish. In Scotland, more of each Black and Asian minority claimed Among the remainder who did not express any Scottish a Scottish-only national identity than claimed an English national identity were 26% of ‘White: Other British’ who identity in England, while fewer claimed a British-only claimed only English national identity. 78% of the ‘White: national identity than in England. The census results clearly Other British’ were born in England (not shown in the Figure). suggest that Scottish national identity is currently more ethnically inclusive in Scotland than is English in England. Those who identify as White Irish are 1% of Scotland’s A fuller analysis of the results in England is provided in population; it is the same proportion as in England, but the Briefing Who feels British? The relationship between with a different composition regarding national identity. ethnicity, religion and national identity in England. 2 www.ethnicity.ac.uk Who feels Scottish? Figure 2. National identity and country of birth, Scotland, 2011 0% 10%20% 30%40% 50%60% 70%80% 90%100% Scotland 72% 21% 1% 5% Channel &IoM 22% 7% 4% 41% 12% 15% South and East Africa 22% 9% 7% 24% 6% 32% North America 20% 6% 11% 8% 5% 49% Australia, NZ & Other 20% 6% 11% 10% 48% 5% EU March2001 19% 5% 8% 11% 5% 53% North Africa 16% 7% 7% 22% 7% 42% Caribbean 15% 8% 7% 28% 8% 33% South-East Asia 14% 7% 6% 17% 6% 50% Middle East 14% 6% 6% 22% 6% 46% England 14% 6% 6% 33% 40% 1% Other Europe 13% 4% 8% 16% 7% 51% South America 13% 5% 9% 15% 7% 51% Southern Asia 12% 7% 6% 26% 4% 44% Republic of Ireland 10% 2% 5% 10% 3% 70% Wales 10% 4% 8% 20% 58% 1% Eastern Asia 8% 3% 4% 19% 5% 61% Northern Ireland 8% 2% 6% 17% 62% 6% Central & West Africa 6% 3% 6% 14% 4% 68% EU from Apr2001 4% 8% 2%2% 83% Scottish identity only Scottish and British identities only Scottish and any other identities British identity only All other involving UK identities Non-UK identity only Click here for data in Excel The Scottishness of the Mixed ethnic group sits between Table 1.