Relaxation dynamics of non-Brownian spheres below jamming Yoshihiko Nishikawa,1 Atsushi Ikeda,2 and Ludovic Berthier1, 3 1Laboratoire Charles Coulomb (L2C), Universit´ede Montpellier, CNRS, 34095 Montpellier, France 2Graduate School of Arts and Sciences, University of Tokyo, Komaba, Tokyo 153-8902, Japan 3Department of Chemistry, University of Cambridge, Lensfield Road, Cambridge CB2 1EW, United Kingdom (Dated: February 11, 2021) We numerically study the relaxation dynamics and associated criticality of non-Brownian fric- tionless soft spheres below jamming in spatial dimensions d = 2, 3, 4, and 8, and in the mean-field Mari-Kurchan model. We discover non-trivial finite-size and volume fraction dependences of the relaxation time associated to the relaxation of unjammed packings. In particular, the relaxation time is shown to diverge logarithmically with system size at any density below jamming, and no critical exponent can characterise its behaviour approaching jamming. In mean-field, the relaxation time is instead well-defined: it diverges at jamming with a critical exponent that we determine numerically and differs from an earlier mean-field prediction. We rationalise the finite d logarithmic divergence using an extreme-value statistics argument in which the relaxation time is dominated by the most connected region of the system. The same argument shows that the earlier proposition that relaxation dynamics and shear viscosity are directly related breaks down in large systems. The shear viscosity of non-Brownian packings is well-defined in all d in the thermodynamic limit, but large finite-size effects plague its measurement close to jamming. I. INTRODUCTION diverging relaxation time, thus connecting the viscosity divergence to some form of dynamic slowing down. Fur- The jamming transition is an athermal critical phase ther, the connection with the slowest mode of the vi- transition between a fluid at low density and a disor- brational density of states would then finally relate two dered solid at large density [1{3]. Exactly at jamming, macroscopic quantities (the relaxation time and the vis- particles form a rigid network and the number of con- cosity) to the detailed microstructure of unjammed pack- ings, whose geometry controls the vibrational density of tacts z between particles is equal to zc = 2d, where d is the spatial dimension [3,4]. The contact forces and dis- states [27, 35]. Physically, Eq. (1) follows from the nu- tances between particles follow power-law distributions merical observation that the field of particle displace- with non-trivial exponents [5{8]. Above jamming, the ments under shear or during relaxational dynamics both excess contact number z − 2d, mechanical modulus, and have a very strong overlap with the spatial structure of vibrational properties also exhibit non-trivial critical be- the slowest vibrational mode [27, 35]. havior [3,4,8,9]. The measured critical exponents agree Despite these recent developments, both the valid- with predictions from mean-field theories [9{11] down to ity and physical content of Eq. (1) remain open issues. d = 2, suggested to be the upper critical dimension for There is no consensus yet on the value of the exponent β jamming. and its physical origin. Theoretical arguments developed By contrast to these well-understood results, the crit- in Refs. [27, 37{39] result in a quantitative prediction, icality of systems approaching jamming from the un- β ' 3:41, which is directly linked to the values of known jammed phase is still under intense scrutiny [12{22]. critical exponents for the jamming transition. This sug- When jamming is approached from below, the shear vis- gests that β should also be independent of the spatial cosity exhibits a critical divergence [14, 23{30]. Similarly, dimension for d ≥ 2. Recently, a mean-field study anal- in both sheared and isotropic systems, the relaxation dy- ysed the exponent β using the perceptron model of jam- namics slows down approaching jamming [31{37]. In ad- ming, with a different prediction, β ' 2:55 [40], again dition, both quantities have been linked to the frequency expected to hold in any d ≥ 2. However, several simu- ! of the softest vibrational mode characterising the arXiv:2007.09418v2 [cond-mat.soft] 9 Feb 2021 min lations showed that the exponent β depends on d in a structure of unjammed packings [27]. Recent numerical surprising manner. The relaxation time in d = 2 and simulations and theoretical arguments suggested that the d = 3 models has β ' 2:7 and β ' 3:3, respectively. relaxation time τ, the viscosity η, and the inverse squared 2 These values were measured from the relaxation dynam- frequency 1=!min, all follow the same critical behavior ics starting from steady shear trajectories [34]. The value η ∼ τ ∼ 1=!2 ∼ (∆z)−β; (1) β ' 3:2 is reported in both sheared and isotropic cases min for d = 3 [35], from relaxation dynamics as well. More with ∆z ≡ 2d − z > 0 now defining the shortage of diverse values β 2 [2:0 − 2:8] are obtained by direct mea- contacts from the isostatic limit. surements of the shear viscosity, which is notoriously dif- If correct, the physical content of Eq. (1) is remark- ficult to determine [14, 23, 29, 30, 41]. Therefore, the able since it connects an important physical quantity, determination of a precise value, the dimensional depen- the shear viscosity of non-Brownian suspensions, to a dence, the mean-field theoretical value of the dynamical 2 exponent β, and its dependence on the chosen observable II. MODELS AND METHODS for its measurement, are all unresolved issues. We study harmonic spheres defined by the following pair interactions In this paper, we numerically study the dynamics of 2 unjammed packings with three main goals. (i) We anal- X rij rij yse the relaxation dynamics over a broad range of spatial E = 1 − Θ 1 − ; (2) 2 σij σij dimensions, d = 2, 3, 4 and 8 to assess its dimensional- i<j ity dependence. (ii) We analyse the mean-field Mari- Kurchan (MK) model in order to resolve the conflict be- where rij = jri − rj − Aijj with ri the position of par- tween current simulations and the mean-field prediction ticle i, σij = σi + σj with σi the radius of particle i, from the perceptron model, and also in order to com- and Θ (x) is the Heaviside step function. We choose plete the understanding of the dimensional dependence (Aij) = unif(0;L) with L the linear length of the system of the relaxation dynamics by including the mean-field to analyse the mean-field Mari-Kurchan (MK) model [42{ limit. (iii) We perform a careful analysis of finite-size 45], while Aij = 0 for finite dimensional models in d di- effects for the relaxation dynamics and the shear viscos- mensions. The physical idea behind the long-range ran- ity to directly assess the validity of Eq. (1) over a broad dom shifts in the MK model is that particles live in a range of conditions. finite-dimensional space, but interact with each other as if they were on a random graph with only a very small number of local loops and thus a tree-like structure, sim- ilar to the Bethe lattice [42]. This geometry decreases We find that the relaxation time τ seems to behave the role of long-range, multi-body correlations and this differently in d = 2 (β ' 2:8) and in d = 3, 4 and 8 makes the MK model behave as a particle model in the (β ' 3:3), and find that β ' 3:3 also holds in the mean- large dimensional limit with mean-field behaviour. The field MK model, which would indicate that only d = 2 mean-field MK model may thus be closer to physical par- is distinct from all d ≥ 3 up to the mean-field d ! 1 ticle models than the perceptron analysed in Ref. [40]. limit. However, we also find that strong finite-size ef- We study the MK model in three dimensions throughout fects affect the relaxation dynamics, and offer numeri- this paper. cal and theoretical evidences that in the thermodynamic We use a 50 : 50 binary mixture for the two dimen- limit N ! 1, the relaxation time diverges logarithmi- sional case with σ /σ = 1:4, and monodisperse cally, τ(N) ∼ log N. This finite-size effect is at play in large small models for the other cases including the MK model. The finite dimensional models d < 1, but not in the mean- boundary conditions are periodic in all directions for the field MK model. We conclude that β cannot be obtained isotropic case, and Lees-Edwards conditions [46] are used from the relaxation time τ in finite dimensions, and that when simple shear is applied. We denote N the number τ ∼ (∆z)−β in Eq. (1) is in fact incorrect. We finally of particles, which we vary systematically in our simu- demonstrate that the shear viscosity η is finite and de- lations. The simulations are performed in a hypercubic coupled from τ as N ! 1, meaning that η ∼ τ in Eq. (1) box of linear size L ∼ N 1=d. We denote φ the volume is also incorrect, but that its determination is affected by fraction of the system, which corresponds to the volume large finite-size effects. We identify the length scale that occupied by the particles divided by V = Ld. controls this finite-size effect and find that it diverges so In the isotropic case, we study the relaxation dynamics rapidly near jamming that viscosity measurements free of the model by studying overdamped Langevin dynamics from finite-size effects are extremely difficult. Our re- at zero-temperature: sults establish that β ' 3:3 in the mean-field limit on the one hand, and identify a serious difficulty in the de- @ri @E termination of β in finite dimensions on the other hand.