View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by Oxford Brookes University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tate Department report, for instance, highlighted that ‘ISIL showed a particular capability in the use of media and online products to address a wide spectrum of potential audiences … . [Its] use of social and new media also facilitated its efforts to attract new recruits to the battlefields in Syria and Iraq, as ISIL facilitators answered in real time would-be members’ questions about how to travel to join the group’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`$CN4':!#'--&;$!9$:!&%F(4'%3&$((?!$-G4';J!G(,/$(!3'--,-!.,/&(&:':!39'!$==$-$34:!,F! G(,/$(&]$3&,%!$G$&%:3!&3:'(F!(&D'!$%!$43,&..4%'!;&:,-;'-Y!%$.'(?J!M39$3!:3-$%G'! /'9$>&,4-!@9'-'!$!(&>&%G!/'&%GJ!&%!N4$:&H:4&C&;$(!F$:9&,%J!a&3:'(Fb!@,-D:!3,!;':3-,?!&3:! ,@%!=-,3'C3&,%J!3,!&..4%&]'!&3:'(F!$1$&0"*(&3:!,@%!&..4%&3?*EW!! 5F!G(,/$(!3'--,-!&:!C(,:'(?!'%3@&%';!@&39!39'!%'3@,-D:!,F!G(,/$(&]$3&,%!&3:'(FJ! G(,/$(!(&3'-$-?!3'<3:!:4C9!$:!39,:'!$%$(?]';!&%!39&:!C9$=3'-!9'(=!3,!.$D'!:4C9! %'3@,-D:!c!$%;!39'!=,:&3&,%&%G!,F!3'--,-!@&39&%!39'.!c!>&:&/('E!Q,@'>'-J!39'?!;,! 39&:!@9&('!:&.4(3$%',4:(?!,FF'-&%G!$!C,(('C3&>'!-':&:3$%C'!3,!39'!-';4C3&>'!M4:!>:E! 39'.*!&;'%3&3?!/&%$-&':!39$3J!$:!=,(&3&C$(!:C&'%3&:3!d&C9$-;!`$CD:,%!=43:!&3J!9$>'!M/''%! ;&:C4-:&>'(?!C,%:3-4C3';!39-,4G9!39'!,FF&C&$(!($%G4$G'!,F!C,4%3'-H3'--,-&:.*Ee!O%! &%C-'$:&%G!%4./'-!,F!(&3'-$-?!3'<3:!F$((!&%3,!39&:!C$3'G,-?J!$%;!39&:!C9$=3'-!/?!%,! ! U! .'$%:!$&.:!3,!,FF'-!$%!'<9$4:3&>'!(&:3J!/43!39,:'!39$3!&:!;&:C4::':!$-'!'<'.=($-?!,F! 39'!$./&3&,%:!,F!$%!&%C-'$:&%G!/,;?!,F!:&.&($-(?!G(,/$((?H,-&'%3';!3'<3:!/?!$439,-:! F-,.!$-,4%;!39'!@,-(;E!! 09'!C9$=3'-!@&((!,FF'-!$!:4->'?!,F!39&:!'.'-G&%G!C,%3'.=,-$-?!G'%-'J! $%$(?]&%G!=,'3-?!/?!L49'&-!Q$..$;J!5.3&$]!#9$-D'-!$%;!f$-:$%!L9&-'J!39'$3-'!/?! +',-G'!P-$%3J!f$R$9$3!O(&!$%;!O?$;!OD93$-J!$%;!%,>'(:!/?!0'R4!g,('J!`E_E!g,'3]''! $%;!h&$!Q$&;'-!d$9.$%J!/'F,-'!F&%&:9&%G!@&39!$!C$:'!:34;?!,F!i$-$%!_$9$R$%*:! C-&3&C$((?!$CC($&.';!-'C'%3!%,>'(J!=2+(>"".'&$*&.0(.;()%$##(7.%/"(V67"WXE!53!@&((! &;'%3&F?!39-''!D'?!3-'%;:!39$3!4%;'-=&%!39':'!@-&3'-:*!C,(('C3&>'!-':=,%:':!3,!G(,/$(! 3'--,-Y!F&-:3J!$!;-&>'!3,@$-;:!=,'3&C!9+*+88&*.8&$#&?$*&.0(&%!=,'3-?!39$3!-':=,%;:!3,! 3'--,-j!:'C,%;J!$!='-F,-.$%C'!,F!39&:!;'3'--&3,-&$(&]$3&,%!39-,4G9!$!F,C4:!,%!39'! .&C-,C,:.!,F!39'!9.%+"*&'(&%!C,%3'.=,-$-?!39'$3-'j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f':3J!&%!(&%'!@&39!@9$3!L$-$9!P-,4&('33'!9$:!&;'%3&F&';! $:!$%!&%C-'$:&%G!.$-D'3$/&(&3?!,F!G(,/$(!@-&3&%GJ!@9&C9!k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l-':&;'%3!#,%$(;!0-4.=*:! $33'.=3';!M_4:(&.!/$%*!&%!39'!K%&3';!L3$3':XJ!39'?!;,!%,3!-'3-'$3!&%3,!-'$C3&,%$-?!M4:! >:E!39'.*!/&%$-&':Em!5%:3'$;J!39'?!-'$C9!,43@$-;:J!'.=9$:&]&%G!39'!C,%%'C3&,%:!$%;! &%3'--'($3&,%:!/'3@''%!$((!=$-3&C&=$%3:!c!@9'39'-!$GG-'::,-!,-!>&C3&.!c!&%!39'!:,H C$((';!M@$-!,%!3'--,-*E!O:!$!-':4(3J!39'?!@,-D!3,!&%>,D'!&%!39'&-!-'$;'-!:,.'39&%G! $D&%!3,!@9$3!@9$3!P-4C'!d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d$39'-J! &3!&:!$%!'<3'%:&,%!,43@$-;!,F!39'!:$.'!:,-3:!,F!=,3'%3!$%;!;$%G'-,4:! :,(&;$-&3?E!VWX!! ! d,//&%:!&%>,D':!39'!MF''(&%G*!,F!G(,/$(&3?!9'-'!$:!$!.'$%:!,F!=-$G.$3&C$((?!.$==&%G! C,:.,=,(&3$%!&;'$(:!,%3,!39'!C,.=('<!.$3'-&$(!-'$(&3?!,F!39'!C,%3'.=,-$-?!@,-(;E! Q'!&:!,F!C,4-:'!%,3!$(,%'!&%!39&:!$33'.=3Y!i@$.'!O%39,%?!O==&$9J!F,-!&%:3$%C'J! =-,.&%'%3(?!:4..$-&]':!C,:.,=,(&3$%&:.!$:!M4%&>'-:$(&3?!=(4:!;&FF'-'%C'*J!@9&('! +$?$3-&!g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k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j!$%!$@$-'%'::!39$3!&:! %'C'::$-?!A8&.8!3,!39'!;&FF&C4(3!@,-D!,F!=-,G-'::&>'(?!-'C$(&/-$3&%G!39':'!:3-4C34-':E! 09&:!&:!%,3!3,!:$?!39'!3'<3:!;,!%,3!$#".!$;>,C$3'!C,:.,=,(&3$%!=,(&3&C:J!/43!:&.=(?! 39$3!MG(,/$(!F''(&%G*J!$:!$!('::!,>'-3(?!=,(&3&C$(!3'-.J!9'(=:!3,!F,-'G-,4%;!39'!.,.'%3:! ,F!=$&%J!C,%F4:&,%!,-!C,%3-$;&C3&,%!&%!39'!3'<3:J!@9&C9!=-'C';'!39'!M[C,%C'=3&,%\!,F! -'$(!C,:.,=,(&3&C:*!39$3!LC9,'%'!;':C-&/':!$/,>'E!! 5%!9'-!$-3&C('J!MbQ,@!#,!f'!f-&3'!$/,43!09&:nb!09'!#,.':3&C!$%;!39'!+(,/$(! &%!39'!l,:3Hmo""!p,>'(*J!g$39'-&%'!_,-('?!9$:!-&G93(?!'<=-'::';!C$43&,%!$/,43!@9$3! :9'!>&'@:!$:!$!3-'%;J!&%!3-$%:%$3&,%$((?H,-&'%3';!=,:3Hmo""!(&3'-$-?!:34;&':J!3,!!